HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

romesc

71 karma · joined October 18, 2016

submissionscomments
romesc··on AlphaNIST
Well that settles it! They'll just have to hire us. Then the universe will be back in order XD!
romesc··on AlphaNIST
If you're interested in some more details, take a look at this post I made (and am admittedly still polishing) that discusses the method in a low-dimensional space. I am trying to make it more accessible to the community since explaining it for higher-dimensional robot control / hybrid-contact dynamical systems is a whole other thing :)

https://rosarioscalise.com/garage-success-guided-sampling

romesc··on AlphaNIST
Thank you so much for your kind words!

Ensuring the assets are "CAD-level accurate" has a huge impact on making this work in practice. So much so, that our collaborators Yash Narang [1] and Iretiayo Akinola [2] have spent a number of years on just this - we are standing on the shoulders of giants!

Additionally, understanding the hardware well (including things like motor and controller dynamics) is non-negotiable. We learned the hard way that there is, in fact, no free lunch. You really have to get the deep understanding of physics and engineering right.

[1] https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=M3NuG7AAAAAJ&hl=en [2] https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=e1zesfMAAAAJ&hl=en

romesc··on AlphaNIST
We use sim2real with distillation-based transfer :)

This means no need to do the rollouts on real robots first! Please check out https://sgs-rl.github.io for some transfer examples (albeit a simpler setting then the multi-part NIST board we examine in AlphaNIST).

romesc··on AlphaNIST
The mechanism is loosely related to curriculum learning, though we argue there are some distinctions. In the methodological companion paper (https://sgs-rl.github.io), we try to get into more details in the related work and baselines including comparison to methods like PLR (also from Deepmind), SFL, and linear handcrafted curriculums over states.

You are giving me some inspiration, though, that it might be good to try to explain the related techniques in a lower-dimensional setting to help teach the concept more effectively! brb

romesc··on AlphaNIST
Point received! We wonder what a better way to pay that same homage would be, since we followed the similar philosophy, but with considerations for our contact-rich robotic control setting.
romesc··on AlphaNIST
Hi, one of the authors here!

We can answer questions! But also, I want to highlight that the "AlphaNIST" name is an homage to the very well known work from David Silver's research group @ Deepmind circa 2016->2018. This was when we were coming up very early in our research careers and their work obviously had a big impact on us!

It has taken longer to make some of those ideas work for areas as challenging as robotics where there are physical constraints to deal with (and admittedly in this paper, we do not show the transfer to real hardware quite yet). But, we have some glimmer of evidence it is looking possible here (in another recent paper) that we cranked on for the last 6 months and will be featured at CoRL: https://x.com/octi_zhang/status/2108583315544682914

We are also all mega-lurkers here so we were honored to be featured on the front page!

romesc··on SANA-WM, a 2.6B open-source world model for 1-minute 720p video
We are seeing increasing evidence that these sort of video world models are terrible options for useful rollouts of the physical dynamics of the environment. It is hypothesized that you can get them to be better than simulators by training on physics simulation data, but then the question becomes, why not use the simulator directly?

There are a lot of areas where predictive models make sense in the robotics stack, but doing it with "video world models" as is trendy this year is likely a bet in the wrong direction according to the evidence we have been amassing in the last 6 months.

romesc··on Show HN: Talk to Me Human – my game about social persuasion
I had a lot of fun playing this! It's definitely the quirkiness that sets it apart from the typical "GenAI" content. Highly recommend other hackernews readers check it out.
romesc··on An electric new era for Atlas
thats just not in the BDs ethos. They have been the only company really trying to physically build these kinds of robust, dynamic systems for the last 3 decades (almost to a fault).
romesc··on Show HN: Suno AI Download – Download Suno AI Music Song MP3
Thank you for thinking of this and implementing it!

But, I'm wondering is there any major difference between just clicking the "..." next to the song in the default interface and selecting "Download->Audio"?

romesc··on Sequential modeling enables scalable learning for large vision models
Or prediction is intelligence.

I think we need a more rigorous definition to go beyond tautology

romesc··on Lessons from AlphaZero: Part 1 of blog post series
Wow, some actual legit content on HN!
romesc··on Cicero: The first AI to play at a human level in Diplomacy (2022)
Congrats to Noam (and the whole team)!
romesc··on Q* Hypothesis: Enhancing Reasoning, Rewards, and Synthetic Data
Sure A* is awesome, but taking the "star" and immediately attributing it to A* is probably a bridge too far.

Q* or any X* for that matter is extremely common for referring to the optimal function under certain assumptions. (usually cost / reward structure).

romesc··on Ask HN: Any alternatives to Duolingo without gamification?
I really have to plug the method of Comprehensible Input (CI) [0].

Specifically, Pablo Román's effort to make this viable for Spanish [1]. I started before there was a website or anything, just watching free youtube videos. Now I'm definitely B2 or C1. I subscribe partially just to show my support even though I mostly consume native-level media now.

Similar and helpful along he lines of CI are [2] and [3].

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Input_hypothesis [1] https://dreamingspanish.com [2] https://refold.la/ [3] https://www.alljapaneseallthetime.com/

romesc··on John Carmack and Rich Sutton partner to accelerate development of AGI
For what it's worth, this was a paper I was exposed to during grad school for robotics/CS. I'm not saying one has to go to school to get good curation of content, but it is certainly one way to be exposed to a well structured foundation of knowledge in your field.
romesc··on Bluesky Exploits
Thank you kind soul! Unfortunately, I found out that mailbox is full. Thanks microsoft...

If you happen to see this, please check my profile for a working email!

romesc··on Bluesky Exploits
If you send me an invite, I pinky promise I will post something interesting and we can have a HN clique of at least 2. =D Email: {HNusername}@live.com
romesc··on Obsidian 1.4.10 Desktop (Public)
I am approaching 3 years with Obsidian!

What I have found works best is to basically forget about putting strong priors on the structure of your notes. Just let everything be flat - or at most, create one level of hierarchy for a specific project.

When you have a new thought, use search. I have a command that pulls up the advanced search tool plugin and fuzzy searches my term. I then quickly scan (visually as cards) the notes I created already. If there is something related to my idea I open that note and continue that thread. If it's new, I create a new note.

This can be improved even more by using tags liberally, but I find that just having a powerful search and taking the time to "check" before creating a new note works very well for my style of note taking!

romesc··on On Robots Killing People
You're right about AI capabilities being much better in the "ungrounded" realm (like writing sonnets), but I would revise the statement a little to be more accurate.

AI systems are quite good at perception in a traditional sense (e.g. determining a red ball is in the sensor receptive field), but once actual cognition about how the red ball relates to the world around it becomes important, current approaches are limited.

I would argue that the first wave of perception is solved much more completely than the ability to reason about complex interactions of objects grounded in the physical world.

Disclaimer: I am a robotics research scientist

romesc··on Social media decline: Users are shifting to messaging apps and group chats
I also love it and am interested in hearing more about how you approach syndication!
romesc··on Artificial General Intelligence – A gentle introduction
In my opinion, this is the crux.

Think about it for a moment. Can you define human intelligence? Have you ever gotten in a debate with someone about this? Is there a commonly accepted way to designate intelligence that isn't somewhat controversial?

How will we ever define AGI if we still haven't even defined RoHI (Regular ol' Human Intelligence) sufficiently?

romesc··on Noclip – A digital museum of video game levels
This hits me hard.

Somehow, this has a perfect selection of games that formed a great portion of my childhood (some of which I was too young to play myself, but I watched my cousin or dad play).

Amazing to teleport into these worlds through the browser only 15 years later.

romesc··on Remembering the Slip: the Manhattan street that birthed a generation of artists
I've definitely seen this in other parts of NYC, but generally those instances have the IYKYK angle to them, ostensibly to protect their existence.
romesc··on Cities with their own psychological disorders
Can't forget "The Danbury Shakes" [1] (clinically known as Erethism).

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Danbury_shakes&re...

romesc··on Threads users down by more than a half
I'm very curious about Bluesky, still. If anyone's got an invite to kick around, romescpro@gmail.com =].

I am earnestly trying to go all in on ActivityPub these days.

romesc··on AI•ON: Artificial Intelligence Open Network
Ah, that makes more sense. I should have read the full comment XD.
romesc··on AI•ON: Artificial Intelligence Open Network
Out of curiosity, which mailing lists did you check? I am wondering what others consider the 'standards'. Thanks!