188 karma · joined March 12, 2017
"Alex, I'll take circular saws for $500"
Perspective people, perspective.
All I'll say is if I was the head of the programming committee for the air transport association conference, I would invite the designer to keynote, as comic relief.
What you describe needlessly adds complication to the approach, which adds risk, which will certainly result in accidents and fatalities. It's just a bad idea, and there is a reason airport designers never considered this (it is not as if the idea of banked curved roadways is new).
Sorry as a pilot, I can say this is not just a bad idea, it is a lethally bad idea. A fun simulator challenge, but not something that will work in the real world. If you are doubtful, I would suggest you try circling around a point in IFR conditions within 50' lateral tolerance above a circular runway. Be sure to add zero visibility and a 10-20 knot cross wind to simulate doing so in the clouds above the runway as you descend.
This product is solving what problem exactly? I had to ask if this was satire, but sadly it is an example of how some people in the tech industry are so helpless they can't even seem to manage feeding themselves.
The #1 reason this is a very bad idea is it is not compatible with flying what's called a stabilized approach, which is fundamental to safe landings. What this means simply is you fly your last (final) leg of approach on a straight line aligned with the centerline at a shallow glide angle. The moment before touch down you reduce engine power and flare (bring the nose up) and stall the wings just above the runway. If you are flying into a crosswind, you crab (fly with the nose angled into the wind to stay on centerline), then kick out of the crab angle just prior to touchdown (you control the rudder with foot pedals). A banked circular runway is totally incompatible with this. If you misjudge your approach a bit and land long, you miss the runway. You have to go from wings level to a banked turn at exactly the right moment. Lots of potential for things to go wrong. It's just a bad, unsafe idea.
Another reason this is bad, higher landing speeds. If you are flying in a banked turn, your wing will stall at a higher airspeed. Heavy aircraft already land fast, and anything that adds to that creates problems, wear on tires and brakes, etc.
These people also seem to be unfamiliar with basic geometry. A "circle-ish" runway configuration would do the job while retaining long straight runways. For example, just arrange eight runways in an octagon configuration, with the airport terminal etc in the center. If you have enough land area to work with, this is easy. The problem, of course, is that land in large metro areas is expensive, so you end up with compromises such as intersecting runways as you see at airports like San Francisco (SFO).
So while this may be fun as a flight simulator challenge, it is a bad, unsafe idea for the real world.
For most people, what does work well is a split office/remote schedule. Some do a couple days a week from offsite. Some will work onsite 3 weeks, offsite 1 week. This sort of arrangement yields the benefits of being in a common location (face time, boss time, etc), while giving workers the option to work offsite part-time so they are not chained to the same desk all of the time.
If you absolutely need to get there on time, or need flexibility, buy a non-discounted fare. Yes, it costs more, but you will be at the head of the line if there is a mechanical problem, weather cancelation, equipment replacement, etc, all of which the airline has limited control over.
Also, a bit of perspective, the last US commercial airline accident with fatalities was in 2009, and tens of millions of people have traveled safely to their destination since then, not so with any other mode of transportation.
I think Ford, GM, etc are right in the long run. There are so many edge cases in driving a car (blown tire, hydroplaning, uncertain intention of an oncoming driver), I would not trust a fully driverless car. That said, there is a lot of room for innovation with automatic braking and collision avoidance that will reduce accident rates and severity, maybe dramatically.
Once most cars are networked and semi-autonomous, lots of things become possible. Example, cars that automatically observe speed limits (which can be dialed down during bad weather). No single measure like this will eliminate all accidents, but each will add to safety.
The problem with too much automation is people become dependent on it and lose skills. This was a critical factor in the Air France flight that stalled and crashed off the coast of Brazil. I'd rather see them focus on helping people be better drivers than taking humans completely out of the loop except on protected roadways.
Nowadays I only look at companies that can offer RSUs. Until the re-write the tax code to stop taxing people on fictional gains, options are crap, especially with companies remaining private far longer than you are likely to remain working there.
I am skeptical of unmanned taxis for reasons having nothing to do with autonomous driving. What do you do if a passenger gets sick, passes out, starts acting violently, has a heart attack, all things regular taxis encounter. Basically, you need a person to monitor the vehicle, passenger and contents even if the car is driving much of the time. Plus also, pleasant conversation if desired.
What happens when you get in a situation like this? Every dirtbag on the planet who has an idea about how to profit off it will appear. This was especially true of real estate agents, as well as people peddling legit sounding loan restructuring programs. It is a huge pile on and it really wears you down (besides the stress of not knowing from week to week if you home is going to be auctioned off at the courthouse, not being able to pay for luxuries like basic dental care, and so on).
If you have not been there, you have no idea at all how difficult it is to get out of that trap once you are in it.
It does however force business travelers to rethink flying Emirates, Etihad, etc and fly United, etc instead. I'll be interested to see if these airlines sue.
- Clean running water - Electricity - Heat - Phone, now plus internet access - Paved roads - Access to basic health care (for now, thanks Obama!)
Disclosure: I went through bankruptcy and foreclosure, so I know exactly how much not having money sucks in this country, but I would take being broke in the US over being broke almost anywhere else, with one important caveat, if you have a long term physical or mental disability and do not have family to support you, then you are truly fucked (but that would be true anywhere outside of northern Europe or Canada as well).