HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

rprasad

2,691 karma · joined June 28, 2010

...
submissionscomments
rprasad··on Aaron Swartz v. United States (2011)
I don't know how much more simply to state this:

As a consequence of prosecutorial "discretion" exercised during the jim crow days of the segregated South, federal prosecutors do not have discretion about which laws to prosecute. Once they have been presented a case, they are required to prosecute if the presentation of evidence is sufficient to suggest that a crime has been committed.

Only upper management of the DOJ (i.e., above Ms. Ortiz) or the president can issue orders not to enforce certain laws.

Thus, this does excuse Ms. Ortiz. She's just doing her job. If you don't like that, change the scope of her job by getting her superiors to end enforcement of the laws at issue.

rprasad··on Aaron Swartz v. United States (2011)
I don't have time to go over the several dozen Aaron-related posts or HN threads from today until tomorrow to provide cites, but many of Aaron's posts linked to on HN (including, especially the Batman post) display many signs of severe clinical depression. I'm not a doctor, so I'm not saying that he did kill himself as a result of a medical illness with any degree of certainty. But I am saying, based on my past experience representing defendants with mental illness, that it probably played a role in his suicide.

Also, the family does not say anything that disagrees with what I said. They state merely that the criminal case "contributed to" Aaron's death. That is an actual quote from [1].

rprasad··on Philip Greenspun: Aaron Swartz
Robbery is not a federal crime.

Train robbery and bank robbery, on the other hand...

rprasad··on Posthumously pardon Aaron Swartz
Nixon was still alive at the time of his pardon and thus was still in a position to be convicted.

There is no precedent for pardoning a dead person who was not convicted of a crime because it is a legal impossibility as described above.

rprasad··on JSTOR torrent
JSTOR does not have the power to direct what others do. If the publisher chooses to restrict a document, JSTOR has no say in that decision--JSTOR is merely a repository. JSTOR has access to essentially every academic article in existence precisely because it does not attempt to enforce any political goal on contributors.

If you want to change what publishers do with articles which should be in the public domain, get the law changed. But don't hold JSTOR responsible for something outside of their control.

rprasad··on JSTOR torrent
Recent change, after the downvote wars this past fall in which Microsoft articles would get unceremoniously downvoted to oblivion the instant they hit the front page.

The idea is that articles should rise to the top on their own merits, but not be pushed to the bottom simply by people disagreeing with their content.

rprasad··on JSTOR torrent
Underground Railroad: people risking their lives to help slaves fleeing slavery, rape, beatings, murder, and the wholesale destruction of their families.

Aaron Swartz: releasing academic articles that are already available for free or a low cost simply by visiting your local university and acquiring a guest access card.

Not even remotely comparable.

rprasad··on I propose an Aaron Swartz act.
Prosecutors will always include all possible charges; they have to because of double jeopardy (gross but generally accurate simplification: if they only charge you with one crime for an act and you immediately plead guilty, they cannot charge you with more crimes for that act).

* If I kill you via your heart implant I get a murder charge. You can tack on a computer trespass charge if you like but it seems a little extraneous now doesn't it?*

Special circumstances charges always play a role in determining sentencing. By adding in the computer hacking charge, that murder sentence could go from 25 years with the possibility of parole to life without.

For example: I once had a client who had a simple gun possession charge attached to an attempted murder/robbery charge. By itself, the gun possession charge would normally have only been a 1-3 year sentence (he was a convicted felon), but attached to a violent crime, even though the gun was not used in the crime it automatically added 15 years to the end of any sentence imposed by the judge, with no room for discretionary adjustment.

Well, I'd rather have 1 year than 35, wouldn't you? This proposal is still loads better than the status quo.

I would rather pay a small fine than go to prison at all for something like what Aaron did. As I said, it overpenalizes what he did but vastly underpenalizes far more serious crimes.

Hold on, if I disrupt a power grid or steal your identity, I am already violating a slew of other laws. The prosecutor should, rightfully, be using those laws to charge me If I kill you via your heart implant I get a murder charge. You can tack on a computer trespass charge if you like but it seems a little extraneous now doesn't it?

Yes, they should, but they would still need to actually convict you in court (or get you to plead). There may not be sufficient evidence of those other crimes to convict on those other charges, but that would not ameleriorate the seriousness of, say, hacking the power grid.

rprasad··on I propose an Aaron Swartz act.
This proposal is a really bad idea.

It over-penalizes acts like Aaron's but underpenalizes heinous acts such as hacking power grids or heart implants.

rprasad··on I propose an Aaron Swartz act.
Text:

Propose an Aaron Swartz Act: The purpose of which to limit all computer crime sentences to 1 year maximum and $100,000.

This act would provide a sensible maximum penalty for what the government deems "computer crimes." As a society, we all agree that proportionality is important for non-violent crimes, especially those who we typically prosecute young people with. Many times these crimes are prosecuted under laws that aren't well defined and leave a great deal of the implementation and sentencing to politics, not justice.

Considering it takes at least $1.5 million dollars to attempt to defend oneself from a federal prosecutor, we can at least try to make sentencing sane as most federal indictments go into plea bargaining as no one other than the super-rich can attempt to defend themselves.

rprasad··on Aaron Swartz v. United States (2011)
Aaron appears to have committed suicide as a result of a mental illness (i.e., clinical depression) which was exacerbated by the criminal case against him. It wasn't the criminal case that killed him; it was his mental illness.

The fact that he has a mentally ill mother is strong evidence of this, since mental illness has a genetic component (especially depression and schizophrenia).

rprasad··on Why 2013 May Be The Year You Quit Your Job
It was a typo. They meant to say that "People read TechCrunch because they [don't] want to create something."
rprasad··on Why 2013 May Be The Year You Quit Your Job
Until late in 2012, I came out ahead far more by paying down my graduate student loan debt than I did by contributing to my 401(k). However, that is because my graduate student loans are statutorily fixed at 6.5% or higher, whereas market returns have been close to zero or negative.
rprasad··on Ask HN: Why was Aaron Swartz so special?
Basically, he fought for freedom of information to an extent that most other people would not, i.e., he risked committing (what is currently considered) a felony to uphold his principles.

In this sense, he was a martyr who didn't just talk about ideals like so many other internet commenters do, he actually acted on his ideals.

rprasad··on Aaron Swartz v. United States (2011)
. The United States never should have been a party to this -- it should have been a civil issue between JSTOR, MIT, and Aaron.

Except, you know...the fact that Congress passed a law a while ago that made this a crime.

This should come up in Congress because what Aaron did should not be a felonious act. At best, it should be an infraction (i.e., the lowest type of civil misconduct, like jaywalking).

But the fault lies with Congress for making this a crime, not Ms. Ortiz for enforcing the laws is ethically and legally bound to enforce.

rprasad··on Ask HN: Why was Aaron Swartz so special?
It depends very strongly on your point of view and the context.

I do not consider Aaron Swartz to be very special in the legal sense. His case was a simple hacking case (as the crime is defined in federal statutes). There was nothing special about it politically or technologically or procedurally. There was nothing special about the "victim" (JSTOR) or the victim choosing not to press charges. Indeed, even the fact that he killed himself is not unique because the incidence of suicide is higher with white collar crimes.

I am aware that my viewpoints on this differ strongly from most of HN, but if you read the comments by the other lawyers on HN, most of them generally agree with my sentiments in this regard.

Aaron was apparently very gifted technically (RSS spec, reddit co-founder, etc.), but as I know little about him in this regard, I cannot intelligently discuss this aspect of his person further.

rprasad··on Posthumously pardon Aaron Swartz
Pardon = the defendant is forgiven his crime and released from prison, but the fact of being guilty of the crime remains, i.e., the defendant is forgiven for his bad acts.

Amnesty = the defendant is cleared of legal guilt for the crime and the fact of having committed the crime is also cleared, i.e., it is as if the defendant never committed a crime at all.

Pre-emptive amnesty is more simply referred to as "immunity."

rprasad··on Posthumously pardon Aaron Swartz
That Slate article doesn't say what you think it says.

A pre-emptive pardon can only be issued for someone in danger of being convicted of a crime; it is essentially a grant of immunity. A dead defendant who was merely charged with a crime can never be convicted of the crime, so a dead defendant cannot be pre-emptively pardoned.

rprasad··on The Truth About Aaron Swartz's "Crime"
No conspiracy, guys.

The prosecutor was just doing her job. A simple case like Aaron's probably took up less than 1% of her week. It may have been a big case to Aaron, but compared to their normal cases, it was a relative vacation for the prosecutors working on it.

The problem was not that Aaron "upset someone deeply entranched." The problem is that Aaron's activities fall into the definition of a particular form of electronic crime which may be overbroad. Federal prosecutors don't get to decide if laws are overbroad or unconstitutional and choose not to enforce the law (because this discretion was historically used to excuse many white defendants accused of lynching black men in the South). They enforce all of the laws on the books unless someone with legal discretion (i.e. ,the head of the DOJ or the president) issues an order telling them not to enforce a particular (set of) law(s).

rprasad··on Posthumously pardon Aaron Swartz
Zero percent change of happening: you cannot pardon someone who was not adjudicated guilty of a crime (by conviction or by a guilty plea).

Aaron died before his case was finally adjudicated (i.e, until all appeals were exhausted), so like the Enron guy, in the eyes of the law, he is not and never can be guilty of the crimes he was charged with.

Again, for emphasis: you cannot pardon someone without a conviction.

rprasad··on Petition the Whitehouse to remove Carmen Ortiz from office
Zero percent chance of this happening:

- She did her job, which is to enforce the laws as they are written.

- She is very good at doing that job.

- You will not get her fired on the basis of enforcing a law on the books where the law has not been found unconstitutional nor even had its constitutionality seriously questioned.

You want a petition that might have some value? Petition the white house to change the laws or to direct the DOJ not to enforce the law. Until either of those happens, federal prosecutors are ethically bound to continue prosecuting these cases.

rprasad··on Prosecutor as bully
Whether Aaron is a "sympathetic" defendant depends strongly on your point of view. All the laws named after little white girls are named after dead little white girls who were the victims of brutal crimes.

Aaron is the alleged perpetrator of a potentially serious felony. Moreover, he is the perpetrator of a crime that most people cannot distinguish from hacking (because unlike the HN crowd, most people are not technology literate beyond knowing how to download apps). Aaron would not be a sympathetic defendant to most of America; he would be just another one of the same hackers who try to steal money from their bank accounts.

rprasad··on Prosecutor as bully
I don't know how much more clearly I can state this:

Most criminal defendants do not kill themselves. It was Aaron's choice to take his life, not hers. Her professional and personal contacts will never agree with you that she hounded someone to suicide. Telling them "she did wrong" when it is not clear that she did anything out of the ordinary in this case will have zero effect on getting her "shamed" and will have no effect on ending her career.

The internet does not determine whether these people get jobs. People in the legal industry and in the federal government determine that. And right now as a member of the legal industry, I can tell you that despite my extreme distaste for prosecutors, based on all publicly available facts about this case she did not do anything wrong. She did her job, pursuant to the laws as they are written. You don't like that? Change the laws.

Going after her without changing the laws will not work.

rprasad··on Prosecutor as bully
Federal courts vs normal courts are like the difference between the NBA and high school basketball, or the NFL and college football.

Most of the rules are the same, but the game is played at a much higher level and the stakes are higher.

rprasad··on Prosecutor as bully
The sole purpose of a grand jury is to determine if there is sufficient evidence that a crime may have been commited to justify an expensive investigation, filing charges, or proceeding to trial (depends on the jurisdiction).

The grand jury hearings have no bearing on the determination of guilt, much less on the adequacy of the prosecution's case.

rprasad··on Prosecutor as bully
All prosecution is political and white collar crimes doubly so.

No, all laws are political. Enforcement of the law, especiallly at the federal level, is apolitical. White collar crimes are not special; indeed, white collar crimes are by far the worst types of crimes because they strike directly at the foundation of the system itself (i.e., trust).

There's no politically neutral AI calling the shots.

Exactly. Letting prosecutors pick and choose which statutes they enforce would make prosecution political. This is what happened in the South for 100 years when blacks were prosecuted aggressively and white defendants were not (especially in cases with black victims). It's also the reason why prosecutors at the federal level generally do not have discretionary authority to decide what crimes they will enforce absent a presidential directive or a directive from the head of their agency.

rprasad··on Prosecutor as bully
That's not how politics works. It's never been how politics works. This is why most people simply ignore Silicon Valley and the Internet when it comes to political issues.

If the likes of 4chan or reddit attack a federal prosecutor personally, all they will do is spur political action against reddit and 4chan. The underlying cause of their action will be ignored and forgotten.

(Note: SOPA is not an exception; major Silicon Valley companies spent serious amounts on lobbying to get that bill dropped. The internet opposition had exactly zero impact on its political fate.)

rprasad··on Prosecutor as bully
The second petition will never be granted. I can say this with certainty because it is legally impossible to grant a pardon when someone has not been convicted (or plead guilty to) a crime to finality (i.e., the exhaustion of appeals).

As with the Enron fellow who died during his appeals, Aaron will never legally be guilty of whatever it was he was specifically charged with because his case was never adjudicated to finality.

rprasad··on Prosecutor as bully
That's about as realistic as expecting people to dump Aaron by telling them he downloaded a bunch of files without paying for them. It made him a hero.

You talk to her friends and family about her, and you'll just make her a hero in their eyes, the same way Aaron's actions made him a hero to reddit and 4chan.

rprasad··on Prosecutor as bully
Or, you know, you could just call your local Congressperson and complain. This is far more likely to have a direct impact on her job (performance of, or continued employment) than some random internet "naming and shaming." It is also far more likely to bring about the structural changes necessary to prevent this from happening again.

...as they have disabled the voice of the people by routing around jury trials.

Aaron had the option of going to trial. It was his constitutional right. He chose to kill himself instead.

...and they are appointed rather than subject to elections

The history of the South should provide enough justification for why federal prosecutors are never elected. You do not want enforcement of federal crimes subject to popular whims or to political pressures. Too often, political pressure leads to overzealous enforcement of criminal statutes, not reasoned enforcement (see, e.g., Maricopa County).

← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →