HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

rtwrtwer54

7 karma · joined September 1, 2022

submissionscomments
rtwrtwer54··on Russia's Only “Winning Move”
I think "NATO" will be rapidly be re-evaluated after the first nuke goes off in EU.

Think it; US won't directly attack Russia mainland, neither Russia will attack US mainland. But EU continental territories will probably be fair game for NATO.

So if a nuclear war begins nukes will only be deployed inside EU countries, that will probably lead a NATO disband and / or some countries with nukes or even conventional kinetic weaponry, just starting to directly attack Russia somehow, without US "ok".

You can't predict at this point how it is going to be played, but almost certainly, EU elites won't be happy knowing / discovering their land / cities / territories are going to be - nuclearly - taken to tabula rasa once again, and that would lead to decisions.

rtwrtwer54··on The Age of Predatory Nuclear-Weapon States Has Arrived
I think tacticals will work surprisingly well, just the opposite of using tanks without air support.

The world maybe horrified at seeing a couple nukes blowing in the middle of a field, but tactics could end using very effectively a bomb that can clean a couple of square km. in one sweep. The low-yield thing just add an icing to the cake; you can swifly move ahead your own army almost just after the nuke has went off, without waiting for a deadly fallout ends in a couple of days.

And think about this: the enemy has no nukes and there's no way to stop the nukes. The battlefield has not seen this kind of radical strategic advantage since the invention of the tank.

rtwrtwer54··on Russia's Only “Winning Move”
I think the article is naive in the sense that NATO has done everything in its hands to steer and asure everyone in the world that this is absolutely a regional conflict, nothing to be worry about, nobody is going to globally deploy any force to handle anything, because you don't need to mobilize a dozen of armies resources for a fairly local conflict, even if the conflict involves a potencially hostile - to NATO - nuclear power.

Hence, MAD is not present in most of the scenarios probably evaluated in some tables around the globe. Even here, I think nobody is even mentioning great chances of a massive nuclear confrontation.

So, Russia has the upper hand in the game, and there's no MAD as a variable. So perspectives look awry from going towards a clean exit from the conflict. Nuclear options, are just of the several bad outcomes for EU.

I think by now NATO has lost the war and Ukraine is by itself, most probably any further military, intelligence assistant directly regarding about regaining control of the south of their country is being re-assesed right now.

They probably know they will have the lines of cooperation open just a couple more of hours till they fall to silence, and they will try to exact the most advances possible in this grim situation, for those lines would probably be stable for years, as it happened with Crimea.

rtwrtwer54··on Nuclear strike odds moved from “single” to “double digits” in past week
I think is no corner by now, NATO has lost the war.

The question is if they will admit it or if they will try to restart the war looking for a different outcome.

Ukraine is alone right now regarding to their attempts to recover the south of their country, it's now a matter of time till Russia to resort to a heavy handed response based in its territorial claim.

rtwrtwer54··on Vladimir Putin's Speech, English Sub [video]
I guess there's something to be heard in there.

Here we go.

rtwrtwer54··on 4th leak reported on Nord Stream pipelines in Baltic Sea
mmm, it's a bit more crude than just sign a deal with Russia and just go and make happen not one, but two Nordstreams, not precisely backstabbing those two, but you see the point: Everyone out there is at end looking for themselves.

Hence, there's no guarantee whatsoever than if EU begins to crunch under the winter, it wouln't just call it a day and request please open ND 1 + 2, we just need to refill reserves, then little more, and then they're back to full operational status.

So, it could weaken NATO just if it can be fully demonstrated, no doubt at all, that it was them. If you can't, it is just twitter and inet noise, nobody can base politics over rumors.

I said in another comment, this is war - kinetic, hybrid, cyber -, quite a difference with the usual geopolitical game. Some stuff you just can bet, you need to be sure.

At the end, if Germany or EU as whole steps back from its current status (re-opening ND1+2, or other actions), it could equally desastrous from NATO. Now you have no good choices, just bads ones and worst ones.

rtwrtwer54··on 4th leak reported on Nord Stream pipelines in Baltic Sea
It is one straight benefit: now UE hasn't any other option but to relay on US + allies, to be gas providers.

This was not the case with Nordstream 1 + 2 in operational state.

Again, US + allies as much as the russian folks, aren't playing any games, this is war for resources (the whole bunch of gas under south Ukraine), you have to win, there's no other acceptable outcome.

rtwrtwer54··on 4th leak reported on Nord Stream pipelines in Baltic Sea
Actually...

so, the giant elephant in the room: this works just fine if it was done by US and/or allies. It is even a quite valid geopolitic strategic move - tough a bit crude, but hey this is war -, even risking the EU to discover it.

But then, the russians are the only other ones that actually know they didn't dit it. Hence, an automatic license to answer was granted. They know the other side won't answer to their answer, because of escalation to kinetic or worse, nuclear.

So, one possible, even the most feasible to be done without serious risk of escalation, would be to just go and sever some transatlantic cables. It's all the way international waters, it's accesible for underwater cover ops, it's not like messing with a nuclear reactor inside a state-nation, or cyber-trashing someones mainland infrastructure.

So, if the russians didn't did it, they have now some "credit" to spend. You can just wonder where and when they will do this.

rtwrtwer54··on Is Germany in danger of repeating its Nazi past? (2020)
It was another time, with another set of memes running into society, like software daemons setting stuff to work in a fascist way. Think about a pair of the Linux desktop GUIs, Gnome and KDE.

Gnome gives you a set of rules for using the desktop, you can't modify, except by going around the set of rules. You can run a computer with this GUI, you have set of constrains and a set of benefits.

KDE chooses a diffent path, you have freedom, lots of it, you can do almost whatever you want with the GUI, change its rules, how it behaves. You also can run a computer with this GUI, and also it has a set of constrains, and a set of benefits.

But who decides which one is better? You decide, you choose, you have the freedom to choose whatever GUI suits you better.

But in the real world, things got really messy, awfully.

Sometime around the 30s the fascist movement took a stronger way of forcing society to play by its rules, then it resorted to violence to expand its influence, ultimately - ten years later - leading to the WWII.

But the grave failure of the fascist movement to the societies it ruled was published by western victorious elites later as a complete, absolut failure in every aspect, but the history actually show a different picture: the violence and the war took the victory out of the hands of the fascist movement.

When the WWII exploded, the fascist movement was already established and ruling most of the super-powers of the 30's, and it actually didn't went away after the Axis defeat. Another kind of fascist movement took over Russia and China.

Maybe the violence can't be taken out off the fascist movement, as much as freedom can't be taken out off truely democratic societies.

But what happens if a new kind of fascist finds its way into the western societies again?

Would they have learned the leasons from the past or they would just want to retake control from current ruling elites? Just to take Europe or maybe other countries back to the 30's? Then who knows where they would lead the human history.

Freedom can only persist if we - who like it - watch over those who do not really like you to have options and the freedom to choose from them.

rtwrtwer54··on Where We'll End Up Living as the Planet Burns
so much drama about this stuff, the real issue is for the elites which have their investments geographically attached (real state, industrial centers, etc.), but the common citizen will be pursuing northern and southern locations to live in at sustainable temperatures. Also much of the northern hemisphere will became fields of everything you can seed now much closer to the Ecuator. Again, that severily defies the stablishment investments.

Most of the losers of the XXII century have their countries way too much close to the Ecuator to be reasonable livable, that's the big deal with "climate change", the end is near for several world elites, as new elites surface in other - already fully controlled - parts of the planet.