HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

rumpelstiltskin

768 karma · joined April 30, 2009

submissionscomments
rumpelstiltskin··on Stop Being a Wimp
by being incented to take bigger risks than they need to, or to over-commit to things

But that would increase their own value as well. YC and WePay are in this together, there's never really a situation where something is good/bad for one and not for the other.

rumpelstiltskin··on How to save money running a startup
I agree. What tips would suggest instead?
rumpelstiltskin··on 8 in 10 Americans Say Economy Is Bad
What else would you expect when 4 out of 5 media outlets say the economy is bad?
rumpelstiltskin··on How Authors Really Make Money: The Rebirth of Seth Godin
You're making an awful lot of assumptions but since this is HN and not a gay webmaster forum, I'll bite.

you can get .05 a click, but it won't matter if that particular keyword converts at 1:200.

Just because it converts at 1:200 for you doesn't mean that that's the rate for someone else. 90% of marketers can't make dating work on facebook, but the rest of the 10% make a killing. If you take their average CR, it'll be something atrocious (not as bad as 1:200, but bad nonetheless), but it makes no difference for those 10% of marketers. My point is that industry averages don't mean anything. It comes down to how good a marketer you are.

I know the mechanics of the industry...nothing can actually convert at 1:10.

Then we are in different industries.

ESPECIALLY if you do ppv and media buys like you say.

80% of my traffic generation is via media buys, 18%-19% via ppc and 1%-2% via ppv.

Hell...most products don't have 1:10 conversions for the actual order form.

Again, this comes down to the marketer. If that's all you can pull in with your landing page and copy, then that's all you can pull.

So you are going to tell me your colleagues are converting at 1:5 for an ebook product? How about 1:1?

1:1? No. 1:5? Yes. But they care more about the CPC and EPC than the CR.

the only way you can actually get 1:10 conversion rates...is if you do VERY targeted CPC...which usually means you are getting low volume(which explains the 40 cents CPC).

Of course I laser target my CPC, only a newb marketer wouldn't. But while low volume = low CPC, the inverse isn't necessarily true. It comes down to the marketer - a newb will pay $5 CPCs but an experienced one can get high volume traffic at a 10th of that price.

How many actual sales do you have every month at that 1:10 conversion rate?

Here are my numbers for July (rounded from memory) -

  price of ebook - $8
  visitors - 71,000
  CPC - $0.40
  expense - $28,400
  CR - 10.9%
  buyers - 7700
  revenue - $62,000
  EPC - $0.87
My advice is still the same - try not blanket everyone in a niche with your experiences or the avg #s for that niche. There's a reason why 90% of marketers barely make any profit and see dismal CRs and EPCs. It's because the rest of the 10% take everything (ever hear of 'Truth About Six Pack Abs'? that ebook's author used to net over $500,000 a day while the majority of the marketers in the health/exercise niche were barely breaking even.)
rumpelstiltskin··on How Authors Really Make Money: The Rebirth of Seth Godin
conversion rates depend on your traffic. You can get 1:50 or you can get 1:200...or you can buy some paid traffic and get 0:25,000

This doesn't even make any sense as an argument, it's like saying water is wet and air is dry. And 'buy some paid traffic'? Virtually all marketing traffic is paid traffic, that's what marketers do, they buy traffic.

I'd like to see the product that you are getting 1:10 conversion rates on. Frankly that sounds like bullshit. And if you are really getting those numbers...then you wouldn't be saying you are "just an above average marketer".

So my fault is being modest? Fine, I'm a kickass marketer. Either way, my product is an ebook for which I buy traffic via ppc, ppv and media buys and avg a CPC of $0.40, an EPC of $0.90 and a CR of 10%.

The only way to get numbers like that is by pitching a product that has 0 competition(something like water bottle art making)....which usually means there is almost 0 traffic there.

You have no clue what you're talking about. My numbers are peanuts compared to those of my colleagues (and no, they don't make them by pushing scammy rebills). Take some time to actually study the mechanics of the industry and you'll see what's possible and what's not. Maybe work with an experienced marketer or 2.

rumpelstiltskin··on How Authors Really Make Money: The Rebirth of Seth Godin
Your numbers are way off. Take the conversion rate for example - 1 in 200 is absolutely ludicrous and if that's what a marketer is averaging, then he should quit. I sling ebooks aplenty and I average around 10% CR, and I'm just an above average marketer.

Same goes for the affiliate commission. No seasoned marketer would give away 75% (unless there's a backend upsell). It's more like 25%-50%.

I think I know what ebook Tim is referring to here and if it's the same one, then the author is selling 100,000-200,000 units at $100 a pop with the affiliates making 40%-50% in commissions.

P.S. It's interesting that your comment got so many upvotes. I have a feeling a lot of ppl are voting based on their gut reaction of '$10,000,000 a month? No way. That's bullshit!' rather than actually thinking the numbers through.

rumpelstiltskin··on [dead]
Marry a millionaire, avoid a prenup, then divorce them.

P.S. Replace 'easiest' with 'most efficient' and then you'll have a nice discussion.

rumpelstiltskin··on This is the best "we're hiring" image ever drawn
Sorry, I meant price.
rumpelstiltskin··on This is the best "we're hiring" image ever drawn
Build/buy your dream computer.

What's the limit tho?

rumpelstiltskin··on Ask HN: All startup websites look the same
That is a really good looking site. Any reason why the layout isn't centered?
rumpelstiltskin··on “Ugly” Sites that Make Millions (and What We Can Learn from Them)
Anyone consider the idea that they might be successful despite their 'ugly' design?
rumpelstiltskin··on Ask HN: Tracking unique visitors on a page by page basis
I could be wrong but I don't think unique pageview = unique visitor.

If our site gets 10,000 uniques today, we'd like to see a breakdown of the pages that brought in these 10,000 uniques, not their uniqe pageviews.

rumpelstiltskin··on Ask HN: Payments/Subscriptions Based Startups and Niches
37Signals
rumpelstiltskin··on Ask HN: LLC vs C-Corp? What about the State?
So can we set up as an S-Corp in Delaware for the time being, and change to a C-Corp in Delaware when we're ready for VC funding?
rumpelstiltskin··on Ask HN: LLC vs C-Corp? What about the State?
Is that it?
rumpelstiltskin··on Ask HN: LLC vs C-Corp? What about the State?
Actually, no, there is no restriction that's keeping us from an S-Corp. What advantages would an S-Corp give us over an LLC?
rumpelstiltskin··on Ask HN: Tips and Tricks to Save Money While Running a Startup
Yep, thats us as well. We currently pay for software thats in the ~$100 range, but hope to pay for $1000 software in the future.
rumpelstiltskin··on Ask HN: Tips and Tricks to Save Money While Running a Startup
We're doing (or not doing) all of the above, except for the office. We tried the working from home thing, but the productivity drastically suffered. We realized it's better to spend a couple grand a month and have a place where everyone shows up everyday to work and our productivity shot through the roof.

This was, of course, for our team. YMMV.

rumpelstiltskin··on Ask HN: Tips and Tricks to Save Money While Running a Startup
We do use TPB. What do you use it for?

Edit: Don't know why people are downvoting, but to clarify: I wasn't sure if jeb was using TPB for the same purpose as we are or if he was suggesting TPB as a way to take a break (movies, music, games etc)

rumpelstiltskin··on Full Trailer For Facebook Movie ‘The Social Network’ Hits The Web
From wikipedia - David Fincher was brought into the project very late in its development, after a proposed version written by Vincent Ward (What Dreams May Come) at the helm fell through. Fincher had little time to prepare, and the experience making the film proved agonizing for him, as he had to endure incessant creative interference from the studio. The film was Fincher's debut in big budget film making, and at the relatively young age of 27 he had to shoot the film without having a definite script. The added weight was also to create a film worthy of the work of the two revered directors that had gone before him, James Cameron and Ridley Scott.
rumpelstiltskin··on Rate my startup - 123LinkIt.com
Make sure to take HN's feedback in context. The average HN'er is NOT your target customer. So take their criticism of your site looking/reading too spammy with a giant grain of salt. In fact, I'm surprised you'd even ask them to rate your startup.

A better place to ask for feedback would be a forum for bloggers (your target demo) who would be interested in exploring other avenues for monetizing their blog/site besides adcents. I, for one, think that your design and copy are fine. Just split-test regularly and keep track of your conversions (which is what any self-respecting aff marketer should do anyway)

Do change your domain name though. It's pretty bad. There's plenty of good ones left, just be creative and use domai.nr to check their availability.

Also, check out your competitors - skimlinks, amazon affiliates etc - to get an idea of their design, strategy etc.

rumpelstiltskin··on Elon Musk: Correcting the Record About My Divorce
the wife only gets half after ten years or something

You mean 'spouse' right?

Edit: Granted, there may not be very many instances (or any for that matter) where the man is going after the woman's wealth, but the point is that the provision applies to both parties.

rumpelstiltskin··on The Way I Work: Justin Kan of Justin.tv
Do you guys do new york as well?
rumpelstiltskin··on Track conversions across multiple domains (using third party cookies)
Ahh I see. Cool.
rumpelstiltskin··on Track conversions across multiple domains (using third party cookies)
So no more iframing etc?

Genetify is open source - http://wiki.github.com/gregdingle/genetify/ - you can have your programmer go through it for the algorithm. That'd be a good starting point.

Statistically valid optimization would be a HUGE plus. Enough for me to pay for VWO instead of using genetify.

rumpelstiltskin··on Track conversions across multiple domains (using third party cookies)
Are you saying this was how things were done before? Or this is how things are done now?

P.S. Also, does your software's MVT optimize itself like genetify - http://www.shoemoney.com/2010/03/03/split-testing-with-a-gen...

rumpelstiltskin··on TELL HN: Many sites at Bluehost got hacked today (including their CEO's blog)
I can understand your bitterness, one of my earliest wordpress sites got hacked. I just feel that the benefits of wordpress (ease, flexibility, SEO etc) far outweigh the risk of getting hacked.
rumpelstiltskin··on TELL HN: Many sites at Bluehost got hacked today (including their CEO's blog)
Maybe you should tell them to secure their wordpress install instead:

1. Put an IP lock on the login page via .htaccess so that it can't be accessed from anywhere else but your IP - this one change alone can stop a significant percentage of intruders.

2. Add this line to the .htaccess file at the top level of your WordPress install - <FilesMatch ^wp-config.php$>deny from all</FilesMatch> - it'll make it harder for your database username and password to fall into the wrong hands in the event of a server problem

3. Create an empty wp-content/plugins/index.html file. Otherwise, you leak information on the plugins you're running. One of the easiest ways to break into a wordpress site is to hack through outdated/unsecure plugins. So don't let anyone see what plugins you're running to begin with.

4. In the header.php file for your theme, look for - <meta name=”generator” content=”WordPress <?php bloginfo(’version’); ?>” /> - this line reveals the version of your install. Again, hackers look for wordpress sites that haven't updated to the latest version, so delete this line and don't reveal your site's version.

5. Remove 'Really Simple Discovery' and 'Windows Live Writer' - http://falcon1986.wordpress.com/2009/07/15/remove-unwanted-w...

6. Block injection of malicious code with these 2 steps - http://wpcult.com/wordpress-security-hacks/

7. Whenever wordPress patches a security hole or releases a new version, apply it/upgrade to it immediately

The above steps should stop everyone but the most dedicated intruder. This is a lot more efficient than boycotting wordpress altogether.

rumpelstiltskin··on [dead]
But do you end up with just 13% of that half mill tho? I doubt it.
rumpelstiltskin··on You Know Where Else It’s Hard To Delete Your Account? Mahalo
Predicting a Jason nation rant on this hitting inboxes in 3, 2, 1...
← PreviousPage 4 of 5Next →