HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

russellallen

1,228 karma · joined July 4, 2009

Sydney based IP, IT, film & entertainment lawyer. Open source developer.

http://selflanguage.org

http://russell-allen.com

http://russellallen.com.au

submissionscomments
russellallen··on Silk: why we use Haskell
The most important sentence for me was "Two of us (me and Sebas) are enrolled in the Software Technology master program at Utrecht University, where we often use the programming language Haskell."

What you're familiar and comfortable with is one of the most important considerations in language/platform choice.

russellallen··on Amazon’s $23,698,655.93 book about flies
Sanity checks, people. Sanity checks.
russellallen··on Evolution of a Prototypal Language User
7. Learn Self :)
russellallen··on A death sentence for a young Chinese businesswoman chills entrepreneurs
If China had a justice system where trials were carried out in the open rather than in secret behind closed doors and a press blackout, then it would be easier for us to determine the truth...
russellallen··on Advanced programming languages
I was giving my four suggestions to show how the author could have chosen more variety; eg functional, oo, concatenative and distributed/actor. Mercury/Oz mentioned by Mahmud below is another great idea, they don't get nearly enough love.
russellallen··on Advanced programming languages
If he thinks that Smalltalk is a "alternate yet fully capable universe that branched off from mainstream computing long ago" then I'm not sure I want to know what he thinks about selflanguage.org ...

But seriously, his four 'advanced programming languages' seem to be all in the functional space. That's great, but I'd recommend looking outside that as well. Maybe Haskell, Pharo, Factor and Erlang?

russellallen··on Web Censorship by Country (map)
Australia is marked as 'under surveillance' (together with Russia and Turkey if I'm reading the map right). I don't know what this is meant to be.

Currently Australia does not have a mandatory filter (and given the political climate is unlikely to get one). Locally hosted sites which host material with high levels of sexual and violent content (which would be illegal under normal publication laws) can be given a takedown notice, but this is a paper tiger as the material can be moved to an overseas host. Australia has the normal range of laws against possession or distribution of material such as child pornography (and normal IP laws).

I don't know of anything currently in law which would materially distinguish Australia from Europe or the US; and in comparison to Europe we have fewer restrictions on, for example, Nazi material.

russellallen··on No evidence of time before Big Bang
I'm always suspicious of phrases such as "ripped his arguments to shreds" especially in such a young and contested field as AI and doubly when dealing with the difficult issues of sentience and Strong AI...

I'm not accusing you of anything, but as a general comment, without necessarily supporting them, the response to his arguments on this issue often seem to involve overly emotive language.

russellallen··on Prototype based vs. class based inheritance
This may be true but if it is I think it must be specific to JavaScript. It's the opposite to my experience with Self, which is that prototypes help my code be clearer and simpler.
russellallen··on Prototype based vs. class based inheritance
Some thoughts:

Given a sufficiently flexible and late-bound class system (like Smalltalk's), the differences between prototypes and classes can blur.

But in general I would say that it is easier to build classes on top of prototype systems than vice versa, which is one argument for prototypes.

All prototype implementations aren't the same, though, any more than Smalltalk and C++ both have the same class systems! Javascript and Self are quite different in some ways, especially when it comes to delegation (ie inheritance) and iolanguage and research such as Kevo are different again.

Despite the first answer to the linked question, I don't think that either class based or prototype based languages are easier to write a VM for.

What attracts me most is that prototype systems are conceptually simpler in an Occam's Razor sort of way. Instead of needing two concepts: classes and instances, we only need one: objects.

russellallen··on Redline: Smalltalk in “small talks”
For people who like smalltalk, Redline has a lot of promise and James Ladd is definitely one of the good guys.

Worth watching.

russellallen··on The computer programming language known as "open source code"
I love it when outsiders to a community (like journalists) get things like this wrong, because it makes me rethink my mental categories.

We have absorbed a culturally agreed set of differences between a computer language, a platform, a framework, a library, an OS... and we're comfortable with licencing being coextensive with these units without getting confused, for example.

russellallen··on Anonymous stops dropping DDoS bombs, starts dropping science
"In the concept of Anonymous there are no genders, faces or names, all are equal."

Sounds ghastly.

Edit:

Lol, so I'm at 0.

No, seriously, as an aspirational statement it sounds horrible. The elimination of difference instead of its celebration! The difference is life, and faces and names are individuality!

And the privileging of certain characteristics inherent in such sameness would itself be tyranny if carried beyond a game. Everyone is deemed a Gentleman and questioning that homogenisation is considered worthy of downmodding?

Celebrate individuality and difference, don't deny it. Fight sexism by celebrating each individual and not by pretending that gender doesn't exist and then calling everyone Gentlemen.

russellallen··on Things to hate about OOP
Btw, for context, here is his publications list: http://scg.unibe.ch/staff/oscar/onpubs

He's not an anti-OOP guy, he's a pro-OOP guy who's giving a roast as the banquet speech at ECOOP.

russellallen··on Things to hate about OOP
This is a roast, so picking it apart is to spoil the fun a bit :)

But: "If we go back to the origins of Smalltalk, we encounter the mantra, “Everything is an object”. Except variables. And packages. And primitives. And numbers and classes are also not really objects, and so on. Clearly “Everything is an object” cannot be the essence of the paradigm."

Even in Smalltalk, packages, numbers and classes are all objects. Primitives are methods, which are objects.

In Self, variables (in Selfspeak 'slots') are also objects.

russellallen··on More than you ever wanted to know about Marijuana strains
For what it is worth, I have been told by the head of a paediatric mental health unit at a major hospital that there was increasing evidence in the literature of a link of some kind between marijuana use and the onset of episodes of schizophrenia, although the mechanism wasn't agreed upon. She said newer research was increasing the confidence in the link rather than decreasing it.
russellallen··on If you could only learn three programming languages, which would you choose?
Woosh? :)

Btw, how do I see the current tally?

russellallen··on If you could only learn three programming languages, which would you choose?
Well at least you know pg's voted.
russellallen··on If you could only learn three programming languages, which would you choose?
My other would be Self :)
russellallen··on [dead]
We should also be careful when discussing the case not to fall into the trap of demonising the women involved, based on little or no available evidence, just because we like Assange and approve of what Wikileaks is doing.

Reasonable doubt is rational. But I'm seeing a lot of misogynistic attacks elsewhere on the Interwebs, and they're irrational and counterproductive, as well as being icky.

This article is good: http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/2010/dec/07/rape-claims-juli...

russellallen··on Visa.com Now Also Down Under DDoS
Without commenting on the morality of LOIC, what makes its current use illegal are laws, passed by legislatures.

Pick a jurisdiction and you'll find some law forbidding DDOS attacks. Here for example:

http://www.austlii.edu.au/au/legis/nsw/consol_act/ca190082/s...

That section would cover anyone from NSW participating in this botnet and could be used to prosecute this guy if they find him:

http://www.smh.com.au/technology/security/the-aussie-who-bli...

russellallen··on Anonymous Ousted from Twitter and Facebook
They have hit the front page of nearly every major news source with a story that cements the connection between Wikileaks and anti-social vandalism and hacking in the minds of the public.

Well done, Anon.

All they have done is make it harder to get accross the point that Wikileaks is a legitimate news organisation (like The Guardian and the NYTimes who are also publishing the cables) and as such should be protected as exemplars of a free press.

Their actions are harmful, narcisistic and juvenile.

russellallen··on Visa.com Now Also Down Under DDoS
Fair enough. It was a bit snarky. I withdraw it.
russellallen··on Visa.com Now Also Down Under DDoS
Oh I knew everyone would say "But it was a graphic novel". Bar humbug. Anonymous all wear plastic masks from the movie at protests for a start.
russellallen··on Visa.com Now Also Down Under DDoS
V for Vendetta starred Natalie Portman, Hugo Weaving, and Steven Fry. It was a mainstream Hollywood movie which took over $132 million at the box office. It was a Warner Bros film, a subsidiary of Times Warner which is "the world's second largest entertainment conglomerate in terms of revenue (behind Disney and ahead of News Corporation and Viacom), as well as the world's largest media conglomerate".

Your dreams of anarchism were manufactured in a bottle and sold to you on a silver screen.

Grow up.

(Edit: as acknowledged below, the final 'grow up' is a bit snarky. Sorry, that's withdrawn)

russellallen··on Weebly featured in Chrome Web Store
"Google is really pushing people building on web technologies to create their websites more like traditional apps."

Alas poor hypertext, we hardly knew you.

russellallen··on If you could give a book to your younger self, what would it be?
The hungry, hungry caterpillar. Best book ever!
russellallen··on Speed-Freak Football
As an Aussie brought up on Rugby, this is the thing which most gets in the way of me enjoying US football - its so stop/go! They seem to only play for about half a second, then they stop - there doesn't seem to be any flow. I keep on wanting to yell 'Get on with it!'
russellallen··on Shut up and do the impossible
Your first sentence is sort of what I mean.

The medium and the message are not unrelated; the first isn't just one of many possible carriers for the second. This isn't 1910 any more, and any reinvigorated modernism must coherently respond to post-modernism.

russellallen··on Shut up and do the impossible
I can't quite put my finger on it, but something about the stuff that comes from lesswrong.com feels, well, wrong.

Maybe its an air of being too certain about things - a lack of doubt?

← PreviousPage 4 of 6Next →