HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

russelldjimmy

490 karma · joined November 7, 2020

submissionscomments
russelldjimmy··on How Dowries Are Fuelling a Femicide Epidemic
This is still common in Indian society. Even in cities, among well educated circles.
russelldjimmy··on Ask HN: What challenges are you facing offshoring development to India?
Indian product designer here. I’ve worked closely with engineers and product managers, and recently was at a job that required me to collaborate with US teams almost every day. Ask me anything.
russelldjimmy··on Google DeepMind CEO says some form of AGI possible in a few years
Off topic - a pet peeve of mine is seeing humans termed as “irrational”. Please forgive my rant, as it is not personally targeted at you.

We only seem “irrational” when we are talking about a narrow view of “rationality”, i.e., as defined by the cold hard logic of machines. We do not question why we have this definition of rationality. Our “irrationality” simply seems so because we have not bothered to understand the larger complexity of our evolutionary programming. It’s the same as not bothering to understand how a car works, and then claiming that the car works on magic. If one understands how it works, then it is no longer magic. In the case of humans, we may never fully understand how we work, but we can work towards a compassionate understanding of the same.

/rant

russelldjimmy··on Apple Music Classical
I would love that as well!
russelldjimmy··on Apple Music Classical
From a different thread on HN about the same topic, some commenters mentioned that the information architecture and navigation required for classical music is different enough from other music to warrant its own app. I would be surprised if Apple made a decision to cut corners on work and ship a product faster (because from their other products, they seem to be a company that believes in taking their time and delaying releases till they are done to a level that they deem satisfactory)
russelldjimmy··on The FTC wants to ban tough-to-cancel subscriptions
My bad. I meant what you wrote.
russelldjimmy··on The FTC wants to ban tough-to-cancel subscriptions
> The issue with their charging ports being changed frequently

iPhones have consistently had lightning since 2005

MacBooks have had USBC (compatible with all USBC plugs) since 2016

iPads Pro have had USBC (compatible with all USBC plugs) since 2018

iPhones are rumoured to join the USBC club What am I missing?

> They even tried to abuse the USBC standard

When did this happen?

russelldjimmy··on How India’s caste system manifests in Seattle-area workplaces and beyond
We will not move past the “caste system” (or any other system or “-ism”) till we face our fear of being expelled for non-conformity. This is the root of it every -ism, I believe.

This is difficult and will not happen in one or two generations. This cannot be regulated or incentivised into happening.

It will take much more introspection from each and every one of us. It requires each of us to awaken to the suffering we bring unto ourselves and unto those around us. Till that day comes, each system and -ism will continue to thrive.

I shared a personal experience on another HN thread of the same type. It might give some insight into this problem: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34876455

Hating on a system of hate will not solve the issue. Becoming aware of the potential hate within each of us, accepting that the hate is a coping mechanism for fear, and then discarding it is the only way forward. It starts by looking within each of us, and then changing our own lives, and hoping that this sets an example for those around us, who can choose to follow and change, or may also choose to continue in their set ways.

russelldjimmy··on Seattle could become the first city to ban caste discrimination
I’m not sure why you are getting downvoted for expressing the issue in clear terms. This is a real issue in India.
russelldjimmy··on Seattle could become the first city to ban caste discrimination
I want to share a personal anecdote here. It may be tangential, but I think it’s worth sharing anyway.

I live in a cosmopolitan city in India. I am an “upper caste” Hindu. I have been brought up in a relatively liberal environment and have not experienced much first hand caste-based discrimination (because of my sheltered upbringing no doubt). I have always thought of my family as liberal.

A few years ago, I wanted to marry a girl who was out of my caste. My family did not accept her immediately. They never uttered the word “caste”, but made snide remarks about “her community”, and about how “our community” is full of “ambitious intellectuals” and hers is not (implying moral superiority to ambition and intellect). They had not even met her. They just knew her surname and had seen pictures. Made me wonder where all of these assumptions came from.

She was not privy to these conversations but she realised that something was not right, and asked me if caste was being an issue.

And that’s when it struck me that maybe it was caste that was being the issue. My mind swirled with nasty thoughts for a few weeks. “Should I marry this girl who is outside of my caste?”, “What if no one accepts me? I’ll be alone”, etc. For someone who is fairly liberal, well educated, and well travelled, I was shocked at the kind of thoughts appearing in my mind. They were more powerful than I ever thought they could be.

Thankfully, due to my meditation practices, I had developed the ability to “witness” my thoughts without simply giving in to them. That way, I could let my thoughts flow, and wait for my fear to pass. After the fear had passed, my mind would settle down and I’d think rationally again.

What’s the point of this anecdote? I had an important realisation. It is quite possible that the things we call “casteism” is nothing but a flavour of the fear of abandonment, or the fear of being expelled from society by not conforming to societal standards. I realised that the standards can be absolutely absurd, but it is the mere fear of being abandoned by society that can make a human being conform and commit the most ridiculous actions. All out of fear.

Take whatever conclusion you may from this. It is an insight into the mind of someone who never thought would discriminate on the basis of caste, and yet my mind veered into that abyss, if only for a short duration. I escaped and lived to tell the tale. Thanks for reading.

russelldjimmy··on Ask HN: What is the best advice you got on any aspect of life?
What is the way to genuinely communicate “I will think about it” then?
russelldjimmy··on I want to lose every debate
It seems to me that the author spoke about one particular Hindu they met who was not upset by their state of poverty. It’s not clear to me that they claimed that your community is not upset by it, and is not doing anything to fix it. Help me with clarity.
russelldjimmy··on Could you be a web designer?
Heh. You're right, I did. Yet, I did not have fun. YMMV.
russelldjimmy··on Could you be a web designer?
I’m a product designer and I totally bombed this. Never in my career have I been required to know exact hex codes (especially of pure blue - which I have never used thankfully), or exact border radii.

This quiz misses the idea that humans perceive the same values differently in different contexts. A button with 5px border radius might not feel “round” enough in a UI where everything else is very “round”. Or if you have two colours of the same hex value, except that one is surrounded by white pixels, and the other is surrounded by black ones, then it is unlikely that the colour will be perceived the same way in both cases (see the Checkerboard illusion). Identifying fonts immediately by just looking at them (which I can do well) has been a neat party trick, but has never found utility in my work.

A designer’s strength is not knowing these values by rote, but having the sensitivity to understand the tools at our disposal (including knowing how human perception works) and using them to create something functional and beautiful.

This “test” does not evaluate any of that.

russelldjimmy··on Academic addiction goes unnoticed (2018)
I could relate to this article and I’m glad it was written. HN has a strange obsession with demanding “citations” when someone is writing an anecdotal experience. It’s as though anecdotes are immediately dismissed as “false” till they’re backed with “citations” which are “true”. It’s bizarre.
russelldjimmy··on Why Is Tipping Everywhere You Checkout?
This happens in India. It’s called a service charge and is usually ~10% of the bill.

* Upper-mid to more expensive restaurants usually keep a service charge.

* Customers have the right to ask it to be removed.

* When there’s no included service charge, some restaurants’ waiters point this out, possibly expecting a tip.

* When there’s no included service charge, and the waiter doesn’t point this out, some customers feel free to leave a tip in cash.

* Some restaurants include a service charge and outright reject tips (politely) - this is rare but it has happened with me. Even when I tried to tip them after hosting a large party.

russelldjimmy··on Why Is Europe More Equal Than the United States?
> Outcome should still be proportional to effort and skill however.

It seems to me that this is an unsolvable or at least a very hard problem. Ask 10 people about what they think the correct and fair compensation is and you’ll get 10 opinions. It is difficult to quantify effort and skill. If a very talented person produces better results - with less effort - than someone less talented but very hard working, who gets compensated more? These are tough questions to answer.

> Yes, the winner played better, but not to the extent of warranting double the earnings.

I am curious about these sporting events. Please help me understand them better.

russelldjimmy··on The Art of Deliberate Imperfection (2017)
That’s a great perspective I didn’t think of earlier.

It seems to me that humans are attracted to a sort of “conceptual perfection”, E.G. the kind of perfection that the equation of a circle describes. It’s fine to use this as a guideline to achieve ever more accuracy but no such perfect circle exists in the real world. So, in my opinion, practices such as those mentioned in the article help ground us to realise that this form of conceptual perfection is meant to be a North Star to help our efforts to better humanity, but we must never literally try to achieve it. The overarching goal must always be to help humanity and not achieve perfection for the sake of perfection.

On a tangent - if one ever finds oneself chasing literal conceptual perfection — as I have found myself doing in the past - it might behove one to take a step back and introspect if this is merely a distraction from some deeper issue within ourselves. It certainly was for me.

russelldjimmy··on Meet HN: HN Bangalore Meetup
I grew up in Bombay, whose name was changed to Mumbai some time in my childhood. My friends and I still call it Bombay. We use “Mumbai” in more formal contexts, or with people who grew up in a different city.

Similarly, I know of people who say “Calcutta”, “Bangalore”, “Gurgaon”, etc.

The thought of colonialism does not occupy mindshare. It is just the name we grew up using and find it comfortable to continue using it.

russelldjimmy··on What alcohol does to your body, brain and health [video]
You should join the Inebriati! https://youtu.be/-Zj50DmBFp0
russelldjimmy··on Nobody optimizes happiness
It seems to me that the truth is somewhere in the middle. There are those who are stuck in in unfortunate financial circumstances and are not able to think of happiness and fulfilment as an immediate goal. But then there are those who actively choose not to optimise for their happiness despite being financially secure, or maybe even those who (subconsciously) are too attached to non-optimising-for-happiness goals.
russelldjimmy··on What I Miss About Working at Stripe
Haha wow! Nice to meet you.
russelldjimmy··on Ask HN: How to get developers and UI designers to work well together
Product designer here. Yes, I agree with you. I would also encourage a longer-term view.

Having cycled through different design tools, it is my experience that Figma is the best (or least bad, depending on how you see it) tool out there. They have been slowly, but steadily, adding features that have a legitimate value add for designers and engineers both. I read this as a signal that they understand the pains of both parties and they are cooking up features that will eventually solve these pains.

No one else is doing this. Sketch has been a total disappointment in this regard. I was a Sketch user for years until I switched to Figma. Sketch is an example in contrast - they release features that are either late to the party, or don’t have significant value add.

tl;dr I believe patience will pay off. I think design tools are on the right trajectory.

russelldjimmy··on What I Miss About Working at Stripe
I’m reminded of this article when I see a comment like this

https://www.riknieu.com/the-gods-on-hackernews/

russelldjimmy··on Taking things less personally
As a non-white person living outside of the US, I am curious about your experience. Would you care to elaborate?
russelldjimmy··on Talking about layoffs
Thanks for sharing your experience with such honesty. I don’t think you’re an idiot for how you handled the situation. You just didn’t know better and that’s simply unfortunate. It’s amazing that you pulled yourself out of that rut.

I’ve not been laid off as part of a mass layoff, but I have been put on an impossible PiP because my new manager was not able to manipulate me despite his best efforts. At the time, I had no clue why I was put on PiP despite solid performance for the 7 months I was in the company (it was a startup and I didn’t have a direct manager for that time). I was in shock for 3 days but I pulled myself together and investigated the matter by speaking diplomatically with my manager. When I realised he could not answer any questions that would make the PiP “less impossible”, I realised that he just wanted me gone. I resigned the next day.

I look back at that layoff with gratitude:

1. I quit a toxic culture that was bringing out the worst in me

2. I re-calibrated my relationship with work. I no longer push myself all the time (at the time, that’s the only way I would relate to work - by going the extra mile every time)

3. I started a meditation practice that I still practice. It changed my entire outlook on work and life. My relationships are better and life is much much less stressful.

russelldjimmy··on Pepsi: Breathtaking Design Strategy (2008) [pdf]
Yes, we are in agreement.
russelldjimmy··on Pepsi: Breathtaking Design Strategy (2008) [pdf]
Here’s how I believe it works:

1. A link is posted to HN whose content can easily be made fun of, because it appears bizarre without context.

2. People on HN jump at the opportunity to make fun of said link so they have something to take a dump on. It’s a wonderful ego-trip. They cannot get enough of it. Most of those who do not need the ego-trip to feel better about themselves usually move along without comment.

3. Comments like yours which are trying to be curious instead of mocking are “raining on their party”, i.e., ruining their ego-trip.

4. Instead of engaging with you on a level of thoughtful discussion, i.e., “let’s explore why such a bizarre document exists instead of just mocking it because there is nothing to be gained by doing that”, such commenters are more than happy to take a dump on your comment too.

Instead of engaging with your comment in its entirety, they will nit pick on the fact that your comment features the word “sophisticated” and base their entire response on that. Anything to keep the ego-trip and judgement going.

russelldjimmy··on Alain de Botton on existential maturity and what emotional intelligence means
I hope you some day will be free of needing to win arguments with strangers on the internet. Peace.
russelldjimmy··on Alain de Botton on existential maturity and what emotional intelligence means
If you read OP’s post carefully, you might notice that they are not being dismissive of working for money, but it seems to me your response to the post treats it as though it is (a strawman).

To me, the OP’s post is an inquiry into “why” we do what we do. It is a useful inquiry that may be followed up with personal introspection, which might lead to a better understanding of ourselves if done with integrity.

For example - we work to earn money. Why do we earn money? So we can live comfortably (your answer might vary). Why do we want to live comfortably? And so on…

The line of reasoning you seem to have chosen ends at “to earn money” and then pivots to philosophers being affluent while seemingly (to me) proceeding to dismiss all the learnings procured by affluent people as though that makes them inherently different to the learnings procured by others (a conclusion that seems to have no solid basis).

← PreviousPage 3 of 6Next →