HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

russnewcomer

1,034 karma · joined January 26, 2011

"Full Stack Developer", also was once a Mobile App Developer, IT Generalist. Midwest USA now, other time in non-American counties. Software for agriculture, manufacturing, worked in education for a while.

username same at the google mail service

submissionscomments
russnewcomer··on The Reluctant Prophet of Effective Altruism
This article seems to carp at the downsides of institutionalizing any movement (which are legion) without touching the other (to me obvious, and clearly deteriorating) downside features of the EA community, to someone solely an outside observer to that community (but not to development or charity work):

It doesn't care about individuals, does not seem to think about culture, and seems to have an unexamined savior complex and egotism that leads it down bad rabbit holes.

EA people have their hearts in good places. But when you start to look at 'maximum impact' and at the metrics used to define it, EA only focuses on statistically testable social group problems, and not on individual issues. So the way that EA philosophy seems to me to regularly be expressed is that an EA proponent would say something like, "unquestionably, we should give $50k to fund mosquito nets to raise the quality of life for 5k people" and not even consider something like "we should give 50k to train local trauma counselors to help 500 people be more mentally stable and whole" and the vibe that I have sometimes gotten from reading blogs EA advocates that individuals are not worth helping because that's not impactful or impactful enough. We see the understandable precursor of this in the article, where Matt Wage talks about the idea of it being more impactful to cure 200-4000 people from glaucoma. It gets a pass because it is framed around minor improvement to QOL in the West versus significant improvement in QOL in a developing country, but also, look at the quote just proceeding that, around saving people from a burning building.

See, the work that EA advocates do is important. But when we only try to fix societal problems from the top down by addressing them at a society level, we often ignore or damage the individuals that we are nominally helping. I'm not saying that mosquito nets, for example, are bad and shouldn't be given to. I am saying there is also a down and dirty component of individual attention and flourishing that has to be looked for and addressed. I'm not saying that EA as a movement or as a set of goals is fundamentally wrong, just that it needs to have some temper with personal and individual care. I see EA advocates looking down on people that "do things that don't scale" in YC parlance, in areas of the world where there are plenty of people doing things that don't scale because doing things that do scale is almost impossible to do well. EA also seems, again from the outside perspective, to really focus on things that play well to Western mindsets, and doesn't really consider community-versus-individualism or guilt/innocence-versus-honor/shame cultural paradigms. It seems obvious to me that in 100 years, that the hands-off, Western-directed action promoted by EA will be seen as colonialism 5.0. There are also really not a lot of prominent non-Western voices in the EA sphere, nobody that seems to have been raised to leadership levels, and that also is concerning for the long-term health of the institution.

In the quest to make the most impact, the savior complex and all the corrosives that come from it can easily permeate the movement (and indeed seem to be starting from the article), justifying institutions, power, prestige, and rank. It's easy to see MacAskill falling into that (see the braces/teeth gap aside), and when I often read EA advocates, I note that many of them do not seem to spend any time doing thankless, individual work (like as a trivial example volunteering at a homeless shelter, let alone be in a developing country or war zone) and the ones that have seem to quickly burn out and decide that it is more proper/moral for them to 'earn-to-give' and donate more. It is entirely possible that, not being in the EA community, I don't know the people that do this well since they are not blogging/community building.

All this may be a pot-calling-the-kettle-black since I too struggle with working with humans instead of developing systems, and in some ways I have chosen to earn to give instead of earning less money while doing more direct individual work. But I think that this actually helps me lend some criticism that can be seen as "I have thought about what you do, and see some weaknesses" if any EA advocates read and consider this post.

The other struggle I have with EA is that there is a recycling of stoicism with early 20th Century progressivism there, tinged with monasticism and moral superiority. I have worked with and have good friends who were in war zones or developing countries for years, and spent some time in one myself. The personality types who seem to gravitate toward EA often seemed, when overseas or in impoverished communities, to burn out or be ineffective in building personal relationships or unable to have fun in the work. EA needs to, in my personal estimation, figure out how to address some of these weaknesses if it is going to be able to be effective by outside measures.

(NB, I interact with development work mostly in Protestant Evangelical religious spaces, which has its own set of difficulties and pathologies that I am not entirely unaware of, but that also can provide some color to my critique)

russnewcomer··on Asus put out like 40 models of a laptop called the “Eee PC” (2021)
In 2008 or 9, I had about 20 Eee 701s shipped to the international school I was the IT Director at in Central Asia to make a mobile computer lab, outfitted some Gorilla cases with power and foam, and had a pretty decent cheap expansion lab. The downside was that our internet was a 10:1 oversub’d satellite with a max 1mb (and that was upgraded from the 5:1 256k that we had been on) and the teachers wanted the lab to do internet-based projects, and between that and the 3 DDWRT’d Linksys routers that I had scrounged from the bazaar since I had no room out of my 10k tech budget for the year that had to cover _everything_ tech for the 400 student K12 school, it wasn’t a great solution for the actual problem, but those little machines were awesome at the time.

I know for most people, phones or tablets fit that gap, but I think I would prefer an Eee over my Surface Go for casual use, if just for the typing form factor.

russnewcomer··on I analyzed hospital price lists so you didn't have to
Conceptually, yes, it solves a small corner of them.

I'm going to ballpark migrating from Epic to OpenEHR without losing data would probably cost you something around $500/patient. So consider a medium-sized hospital that has 250k patient records. $12.5m project. That takes 2 years. (I'm considering all the places that Epic has custom integrations with other systems, with your insurer, etc, in that $500/patient, which is probably low, but gotta start somewhere). Add in the cost of re-training staff to use the new EMR, finding out after implementation the 'shadow IT' systems like someone exporting data to an excel spreadsheet and then doing a huge workflow on that that no one outside the department really knows about but is absolutely vital to the pharmacy's ability to operate...

OpenEHR can help address some things for one part of the system. But that is like saying fixing OpenSSL bugs will make all the internet secure.

russnewcomer··on I analyzed hospital price lists so you didn't have to
FWIW, pretty sure duffpkg was involved in the creation of OpenEHR, and therefore probably has heard of it.
russnewcomer··on Ceiling Air Purifier
I wonder if there is going to be an issue with the structural integrity of the filters, since they are designed to rest on an object rather than hang? Wouldn't think it would be a big issue, but possibly? If you were wanting to do this long term, feels like a series of light wood frames to support would not be too expensive/difficult to construct or possibly 3d print, and have advantage of reduced adhesive smell.
russnewcomer··on Software engineering ethics by Uncle Bob
I don’t feel like much of this post actually talked about ethics. It talked about quality, competence, flexibility, and reliability, and assumes that ethical software would have all these things.

That’s not really _ethics_ as I understand the term. Software ethics would do more to plumb the question of, is it ethical for the WebKit team to ship a feature that will make one of Apple’s business goals more viable at the cost of increasing daily energy consumption of the iPhone by 3%? That is actual ethics, not ‘did I make this system easy to extend?’

russnewcomer··on Ask HN: Resources for “Learning” Manufacturing?
Depending on what you are making, a local manufacturing job shop or small scale contract manufacturer may be the way to go. 15 years ago during/right out of college, I worked as the software dev/IT department for a company in Central Kansas (http://www.grainbeltsupply.com/) that would be an ideal partner for you on something like this. I don't know where you are, if they still would be (live in different state, haven't talked to anyone there in about a decade), etc, but everything you are describing sounds like the kind of thing a job shop like GBS would be helpful for manufacturing the kinds of small scale production you seem to be talking about. Searching for "fabrication job shop" with your city/region should get you a number of google hits for places that would be helpful.

Speaking solely from what I have observed being on the IT side of two manufacturing companies, your budget for machinery investment is probably an order of magnitude low. Probably want a partner to start.

russnewcomer··on A Fire Upon the Deep by Vernor Vinge (1992)
If you are interested in listening to an hour long podcast discussion of the novel, I was recently on the fun HugosThere podcast discussing this, one of my favorite novels.

https://hugospodcast.com/podcast/hugos-there-podcast-57-a-fi...

As someone who read the book when I was younger and the internet was younger, I’ve always wished for the ‘Net to have translation pathway headers.

russnewcomer··on Show HN: Pageturner – a community for building a reading habit
I am getting the same thing when connected via corporate VPN that blocks certain kinds of sites/adtrackers/etc. I don't get it when not connected via VPN - if I had to guess, I'd guess that you are not handling some error related to that as gracefully as possible.

edit:Whoops, meant to reply to bcye's sibling comment. Apologies.

russnewcomer··on Moral Competence
I have been thinking about this basic idea a bit, trying to reason how to design durable institutions that can help function as crisis mitigation organizations while also working on problems in a community, or put in terms of the article, how to structure an institution that is morally competent.

One problem to this is that many institution that have a morally competent start soon struggle with many of the problems that plague institutions, things like nepotism, political players attempting to coopt the organization for their own good, institutional survival over problem solving, and the like. While these problems can be mitigated by strong boards of directions who adhere to a larger mission, I think the better idea is to have many small organizations that promote problem solving while being part of a larger network that has the goal of solving the problem, and hope that the morally competent people can be spread about the network enough to encourage the solving of the problem, instead of the working on the problem.

russnewcomer··on Whitewood Under Siege: The front lines of the pallet wars (2013)
One of the most interesting things about stories of this vintage re-appearing is that you can feel like you are research the future! I know I read this story around the time that it was published, and so it was fairly familiar to me. But that gives us the chance to see what has happened.

For example, in the article, it mentions Bob Moore, and his idea for resin coated pallets and PalletWorks. Does not appear to have worked (sorry, couldn't resist) and instead, Moore has a new company called GoTo Pallets (https://gotopallets.com/corporate-leadership/) that seems to be planning on/is actually (hard to tell) building another version of the CHEP/9Bloc Pallets and leasing them out. Ricky Mock and his Mock Pallet company seems to still be operating.

russnewcomer··on Open EMR
Thanks for that perspective. Helps me understand why their use case ( my friend talked about multiple nurses needing to have about 20in of records organized in binders and then coordinate between the nurses in case Nurse A saw someone in Place 1 but then Nurse B saw them in Place 2 a month later...) is helped by the computerization (along with the record keeping they needed to provide for grants/funding), but people working clinical settings that I've talked to are not really interested...
russnewcomer··on Open EMR
That's clearly true from talking to several foreigners I know who do medical work in developing countries.

Yet it also seems like there is a lane for a simple piece of software to do basic record keeping. For example, I wrote the app (https://github.com/russnewcomer/SeventyTwo) for my friend to solve the problem (somewhat specific to the culture they work in) where they don't have a clinic site or really the ability to make appointments but instead travel to homes or communities to do their work, and they have to cart around all their binders full of records. My simple app works for their use case, but this also feels like a spot where there are more opportunities to help.

Anyway, I definitely support open source EMR efforts, wherever they may lead, and I thank and applaud you for your service!

russnewcomer··on Open EMR
I recently worked on a very small, very custom open source 'EMR' system for a friend involved in prenatal care in a developing country, and so what I wonder is are there attempts to get OpenEMR/Clear Health etc into countries and settings where there is not the same huge regulatory barriers? To me it seems like the U.S. is largely lost for a generation for open source/patient-centric EMR, but maybe there is hope for other countries?
russnewcomer··on The Hypertext annotated version of “A Fire Upon the Deep” (1993)
Whine here - this version used to be available on Kindle - I know, because I purchased it. However, it is no longer available and my copy got ‘updated’ to just the regular text, sometime between my original purchase in 08 and ~2015.

I now no longer solely purchase Kindle versions of books that have some characteristic I value, and I think Vinge would solidly approve of that stance. Not sure about the reaction of the Blight, though.

russnewcomer··on Early Work
Scene is another big thing, and in the article, Graham draws on SV as a scene, too. That community can be really sustaining, even when you move past the organizing reason. I have not modded Total Annihilation in nearly 20 years, but I still post on the community forum at times because of the people still there.
russnewcomer··on Early Work
I had one thought forming while reading this piece, then read to Carmack's quote in the footnote which encapsulated it. I learned how to program modding games as a teenager, and as an adult now looking back on it, I realize how rough and ready the game engines were in 1996-1998, and how that rough and ready state, combined with my teenager's imbalance between time and money, led to a bunch of what Graham is calling early work where my bad 3d modeling skills, terrible art sense, and ability to sling values around in text files and use tools that other community members made, allowed me to make an entire faction for Total Annihilation that was clearly lower quality than the originals, but really not that much worse. Contrast that to about 2017 when I looked into what it would take to make a very small mod for XCOM, and boy oh boy, so much more work. What advantages I gained from being in that place at that time...
russnewcomer··on No-till no-herbicide farming system in trial since 1981
As an American software engineer who used to work at a small ag software company but left after it got acquired in part because of business model of the new company, I just want to say that what I've seen of Apollo is extremely promising in understanding how to improve the lives of smaller-scale farms, which I believe is key to the future of agriculture as a leveling power across the world. Thanks for working at, and please keep at helping small ag!
russnewcomer··on Json-Base – Database built as JSON files
Short version - I worked in that country for a few years and still care deeply about it.

If you want the long version, or you are interested in ways you could also be involved in that kind of project (or know C# and WinForms and want to help??? :) ) my email is my hn username at gmail.

russnewcomer··on Json-Base – Database built as JSON files
That is a little more complex than, "Here's a .exe, it will save files into your My Documents. Click Export to make a zip, import to read someone else's zip." Plus generating instructions on how to do that would have been tough, and this way should be much easier to spread the app around.

Basically, you don't have a bad idea, and if I were a couch expert or were not on the other side of the world, I might have chosen that. But since I know C#/WinForms well enough, and if we went with the browser I would have to support mobile phones and I don't want to support mobile phones for this use case for a lot of other reasons.

russnewcomer··on Json-Base – Database built as JSON files
Nope, that's too much complexity.

Because then someone has to run and manage a webserver, and there is no guarantee that ServiceWorkers will work like they do in 5 years or on an ancient Windows7 laptop running IE7.

I want this to be able to run for years without my intervention. :)

russnewcomer··on Json-Base – Database built as JSON files
In this case, this NGO is not going to get acquihired. It's more likely that I'll get an email in 5 years from someone who I don't recognize asking me if I know anything about this program because my email has been attached to this thing they got gifted from a dead project, and have been using after all of the original people have moved on. :)
russnewcomer··on Json-Base – Database built as JSON files
I did something vaguely similar to this recently, and I still maintain it was a good choice.

I volunteered to write a medical visit recording app for an NGO in a developing country (a friend works with the NGO and asked me if I would help), and they have almost no budget, no guarantees of internet connectivity when their folks are in the field, and the likelihood that they may be using this software for years.

So I wrote a C# app that uses Winforms, and stores all data as JSON files, the 'table' structure is basically directories in the file system.

It lets them share visit file by import/exporting a zip file of the JSON via sneakernet USB drives [super naive last record written wins], does not rely on an internet connection anywhere at all ever, and all files are stored in plain JSON so that they can conceivably in the future do some data analysis on it. Their alternate plan was to continue using paper, or some terrible regular reconciliation of excel spreadsheets.

Having said all that and defending my decision on this single use-basically-I-wanted-to-have-independent-JSON-instead-of-SQLite-so-in-the-future-maybe-have-a-web-function-to-sync solution,

This feels like a different use case.

russnewcomer··on America’s ‘Fried Chicken War’
Salina native here who never thought I'd see Brookville Hotel on HN.

Brookville Hotel chicken really is great, a lot of food, but great. If anyone reading this is ever driving down I70, you won't go wrong stopping there, right off the interstate in Abilene. Hey, make a whole trip of it and visit the Eisenhower Museum, too, they have done a lot of remodeling and it is a fascinating slice of WWII and Eisenhower's presidency.

russnewcomer··on Book Review: Hoover
I have not read the reviewed book, so I can't say for sure, however, it would be hard for almost any book to be more informationally dense than The Power Broker.
russnewcomer··on Book Review: Hoover
I've recently been reading The Power Broker by Robert Caro, about Robert Moses, the Parks Commisioner who drove most of the building of the parks and roadway infrastructure of New York in the 20s-60s. It's a huge book, with a lot of asides into Alfred Smith, Tammany Hall, FDR, etc. (I'm only about halfway in, before Moses runs for Governor).

I can't help but notice parallels with Moses and Hoover, with the 'politicians' they decry, the ones they seem to celebrate, their sympathy for the masses crossed with personal antipathy toward individuals. I can't help but consider lessons this has for our current crisis, I can't help but think about how Truman relatively successfully navigated the assumption of the presidency from Roosevelt after being frozen out and manages to not totally bungle the end of WWII. I can't help but note how some people are who are completely effective in one time requiring action end up totally screwing up in others.

All that to say, I think we can learn lessons from Hoover, from the past, and apply them to our current situation and the future.

1) Sometimes, the egomaniacl jerk gets great things done. Later, they can use the power to screw up massively. 2) History lets us review responses to crisises and point out how they could have been done better, but we probably won't apply any of those lesssons to our own crisis. 3) Demonstrably compentent people can have demonstrably incompetent responses to crisises - demonstrably incompetent people rarely have compentent ones.

russnewcomer··on Miscarriage can lead to 'long-term post-traumatic stress'
Responded. Sorry for delay.
russnewcomer··on Miscarriage can lead to 'long-term post-traumatic stress'
The causal link between PCOS and obesity is more thought to go the way that PCOS (and endometriosis) can cause obesity, not the other way around.
russnewcomer··on Miscarriage can lead to 'long-term post-traumatic stress'
I hope you and your partner have found help and support for recovery.
russnewcomer··on Miscarriage can lead to 'long-term post-traumatic stress'
Sure. Email me (address in profile, or hn username at gmail)
← PreviousPage 2 of 8Next →