HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

s_m_t

824 karma · joined September 20, 2015

submissionscomments
s_m_t··on Another Roman dodecahedron has been unearthed in England
Why would Zeus care? The greek afterlife is a sort of pointless outcome to Pascal's wager so it isn't even worth factoring in.
s_m_t··on Bay Area couple shocked by $200K hospital bill for rabies shots
Sure the plumber is free to only offer outrageous rates but I'm not sure they would be able to markup a roll of teflon tape they used in the repairs as 50k and say that is covered by "plus unexpected expenses up to 50k".

To me it just seems like fraud. Forget about patient choice because in this situation the patients conceivably could have shopped around for rabies shots, AFAIK you aren't going to die because you got your rabies shot a few hours later the you needed to. The problem seems to be that even if they were able to shop around and find the lowest price apparently the hospital can just charge whatever they want regardless of the expected or quoted cost.

Going back to the example of the plumber; Imagine if my house is flooding and I get into contact with two plumbers, one tries to price gouge me and quotes me $5k/hr and one is seemingly honest and quotes me $80/hr. I go with the plumber that quotes me less but then he ends up charging me $50k for the teflon tape he used anyways. We can see this isn't a breakdown in being able to shop the market and the normal competitive dynamics that arise from that, the breakdown occurs because of the fraud.

s_m_t··on Bay Area couple shocked by $200K hospital bill for rabies shots
How is that legal? What is stopping the hospital from charging 200 million dollars for the rabies shots?

If I hired someone to fix my plumbing and they wouldn't give me an estimate and then decided to charge me $20k/hr I don't think a court would honor that contract.

s_m_t··on NIST AI Risk Management Framework
Why would ChatGPT provide me with dangerous code if I prompt it benignly? I just the other day used ChatGPT to create a webscraper for a friends project and it provided me with an only slightly wrong implementation to scrape data from a specific website. 15 minutes of reviewing the code and editing literally three lines and I was done. Unless it was trained on a bunch of webscraping code that also contained malicious code I just don't see how it could happen.

If anything they could enable an option to have ChatGPT review the code for you and let you know that it hasn't accidentally thrown in some fishy code.

s_m_t··on NIST AI Risk Management Framework
Not the poster you asked the question to but:

I think we are going to be building and using 'sub-AGI' models for a very long time, probably well after we (probably achieve) full AGI. I think these 'sub-AGI' models are going to radically change the way we think about intelligence in the sense that we are going to be better able to nail down what we find special about human intelligence while at the same time discovering that it is a narrow and somewhat arbitrary subset of what we consider advanced intelligence.

ChatGPT seems to me like a very advanced Markov chain, which isn't to denigrate it, the surprising part is how useful and effective it is which to me shows we have been thinking about intelligence the wrong way. IMO an important portion of our brain probably works in a very analogous way but you could build as advanced a version of ChatGPT as you like and it wouldn't become 'sentient' or go HAL9000 on us.

There is definitely a danger of someone taking ChatGPT9 and telling it to create you computer viruses to take down digital infrastructure or telling it to trade in a way to crash the stock market but that's going to happen when all the zero-day exploits are detonated in the lead up to WW3 anyways and all things considered that has a higher chance of happening sooner than ChatGPT9 or the equivalent is used to do it. Instead of getting worried over rogue AI we should probably just harden our infrastructure.

s_m_t··on Creator of Catan, Klaus Teuber, has died
Catan's trading is a mistake in game design for sure
s_m_t··on Why and how I use Org Mode for my writing and more
You could always try and fix it so the table logic is aware of the latex snippet renderings.

I recently messed around with org-drill, found it wasn't really behaving like I wanted it to, decided to change it myself, and then was pleasantly surprised to find that changing its basic functionality was way easier than I expected (and I've barely started learning lisp/elisp.

s_m_t··on Critique of the mind/body problem
I missed that, just shoot me I won't notice as the author says lol
s_m_t··on Critique of the mind/body problem
Seemed to left have out the simplest explanation. Consciousness doesn't exist. Unrelated but it is a bit strange to me that a lot of (most? nearly all?) atheists believe in consciousness.
s_m_t··on Anki SRS Algorithm : Spaced repetition explained with code
Doesn't just putting the cards in order of concepts essentially accomplish this? When I was doing Anki I adjusted my new card rate so my retention rate stayed above 90%. If you do it this way then your chances of getting stuck in a certain areas of the dependency graph (if you were to model it) is pretty low. If it does end up happening then do some extra study on those concepts outside of SRS. This way you don't have to model the actual dependency graph.

You really shouldn't be doing all your study in SRS anyways because so called "flashcard blindness" (i.e. only being able to recall the concepts in the context of your SRS program) is a real thing.

Furthermore, in my experience, what really made Anki effective for me was to write my new cards just in time. Meaning no pre-made decks except for something like the primitives of what you are studying (i.e. symbol names, alphabets, extreme base level concepts, etc). When you write your cards just in time you can really connect the context of what you are learning to the concept. From this perspective it really seems strange to build an entire ontology based on dependency graphs of a concept you haven't even learned yet!

s_m_t··on Milk and dairy products: good or bad for human health? (2016)
The studies aren't doing the same thing. Yours looks at only the effects on obesity, cardiovascular, and metabolic disease. The OP's study purports to look at all health effects.
s_m_t··on Milk and dairy products: good or bad for human health? (2016)
Study says it assesses the "totality of scientific evidence" but conveniently ignores all of the scientific evidence for the negative side effects of dairy. It is a very stupid study.
s_m_t··on We've known how to prevent a school shooting for more than 20 years
No, they typically aren't really bullied.
s_m_t··on California sues Tesla over ‘racial segregation’ claims at factory
Left and right are relative, obviously. If we go according to the original definition of being opposed to the ancient regime in France then that would make essentially the entire United States decidedly left-wing. That isn't very useful.
s_m_t··on Is America exceptionally good or exceptionally bad?
This is by design. The game theoretic winning strategy is to highly target 50% of the voting population (adjusted for electoral representation) and by doing that you are guaranteed to piss off or confuse a lot of the remainder. Imagine you craft a set of policies that appeals to 70% of the voting population. I then craft a set of policies that appeals to 65% but because it is smaller it is also more highly targeted so it steals voters from you. You then craft a set of policies that appeals to 60% but because it is smaller it is more highly targeted and you steal voters for me. Continue until we both have policies that appeal to 50%. The rest is pretty much up to chance and incumbent effects.

Because we have somewhat arbitrarily divided a highly multi dimensional space representing voter preference in two it isn't really a straight cut so there are a lot of idealogical inconsistencies and contradictions and whatnot and since there are a lot of angles at which you can cut something into equal parts the angle of the cut can rotate quite freely in this space so the two sides rotate around in this highly multi dimensional space confusing us poor 3d creatures.

At least, that is why I think Tucker Carlson was mad about M&M's being made less sexy than they once were.

s_m_t··on Reports: “Graceful exit” for Kotick helped convince CEO to sell Activision
I mean, the stock price did go up ~100x with him as CEO
s_m_t··on “Autism is a spectrum” doesn’t mean what you think (2019)
Unless a kitchen is specifically set up for preparing food completely gluten free without cross contamination then there is going to be cross contamination. Most kitchens simply aren't big enough. It isn't a matter of taking it seriously and any kitchen that knows what they are doing will let you know they can't make a gluten-free guarantee.
s_m_t··on Project-Nested: An NES Emulator Running on the SNES
Yes, but you need very good latency to the other player for it to work well. The typical setup is to use something like parsec where one person hosts the emulator and streams audio/video and the other person sends keyboard commands.

You can add a small delay to the host to even things out but to properly account for latency is a major reverse engineering project which afaik off the top of my head has only been done for super smash bros melee

s_m_t··on Is Philosophy an Art?
Agreed, 'art' as something distinct from any other creative activity is a fairly recent western invention. If you take art at face value from it's basic definition it just means something like 'technique' and that meaning is good enough to make sense of it all imho.
s_m_t··on Anime is booming, so why are animators living in poverty?
You shouldn't think of the anime in isolation. They are multimedia franchises. The anime is there to sell the manga, the figures, the light novel, etc.
s_m_t··on Doom Eternal can hit 1k FPS courtesy of the id Tech 7 engine
One fun example from dark souls 2 on pc: If your FPS was set to 60 (from the consoles ~30fps) your weapons would degrade twice as fast apparently due to weapon durability loss being counted per frame that your weapon was in contact with a wall, floor, corpse, etc.
s_m_t··on Show HN: MDAnki – convert Markdown to Anki cards
Ah yeah, I'd typically create cards "just in time", so to speak, because I found that my retention would drop significantly without the context of what I was learning fresh in my mind.
s_m_t··on Show HN: MDAnki – convert Markdown to Anki cards
Why were you adding 20 new cards a day? IMO its better to adjust your new card rate based on your retention rate. Your ideal retention rate probably depends on how you react to the "stress" of missing cards. Personally it would majorly stress me out if my retention rate was below 80%, I ideally liked to keep it around 90-95% because for me this was where it went from feeling like work to actually being fun and exciting.

I might go for a couple of days without adding anything, do a couple days adding 5, add 10, 15, 20, or even 30 depending on the circumstances.

s_m_t··on Challenging the myth of individual programmer productivity
shell script to do the same thing?
s_m_t··on The light is off. War is over
It took longer for twitter to (fail to) load than it took for me to read the tldr
s_m_t··on Tearing apart printf() (2018)
>1. printf may malloc so don't use it in an out of memory situation. Though I think this problem is vanishingly unlikely these days.

I feel like you've just saved my future self from a terrible bug in the future. Thanks

s_m_t··on Unofficial Windows XP SP4
maybe it was defragging?
s_m_t··on Getting started with Docker and Kubernetes
In my experience it usually is some sort of stupid config error from which I glean no deeper understanding. I'd much rather rely on magic than go around chasing bugs that I might not ever be able to convince the owner of a repository to fix, assuming the thing is even open source to begin with.
s_m_t··on Using Web Bluetooth to Communicate with Bluetooth Devices
This is huge imo. It is exactly a web interface that can use bluetooth. One of the major problems with the BLE protocol is that there is really no standard client for a user to interact with devices. To access on the computer you'd need to download a program, on mobile you would need an app... just to have a meaningful user interface to a BLE device.

Its like if you needed to download a new web browser for every website you visit, absolutely ridiculous.

s_m_t··on You may never see Studio Ghibli’s movies on streaming services
>I don't understand much Japanese personally. But it seems like Japanese voice-actors over-rely upon "vocal tics", like a character drawing out a particular sound or having a catch-phrase. >Ex: "Dattebayo" from Naruto, "Arimasu" from Shana, "Nyan" from many, many cat characters (Hellsing Ultimate, Stein's; Gate, Log Horizon), "Desu", etc. etc.

Arimasu and Desu aren't vocal-tics... It's just differing levels of politeness or formality. A character always using them can signify a lot of things like haughtiness, noblesse oblige (misplaced or not), deference, a failure to integrate with/judge the nature of their relationship with one's peers. It really depends on the situation.

stuff like "dattebayo" and "nyan" is sort of a humorous spin on the whole concept of explicitly encoding these things into grammar. They don't generally add these into the dubs because it wouldn't make any sense as English doesn't really have this sort of thing to the extent Japanese does. Honestly I have no idea how you would translate "dattebayo" because it is a corruption of Japanese to begin with to show Naruto as having trouble fitting in, being mischievous, childlike, while also having a level of ambition wildly out of place with his position of practically village leper.

← PreviousPage 2 of 9Next →