HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

s_m_t

824 karma · joined September 20, 2015

submissionscomments
s_m_t··on Suicide instructions spliced into kids’ cartoons on YouTube and YouTube Kids
Anti-vaxxers and flat earthers are perfect fulfillments of American values. Watch just about any Hollywood movie or popular YA novel, isn't it always about a bunch of losers discovering a conspiracy, being ignored or hindered by all the supposed experts and authorities, and joining forces with other miscontents to stop it?

Your Russia comment may have just been a throwaway idea, but it is also a good example of one of these stories. The literal losers of an election invent a conspiracy to rally themselves around because it is really hard to accept that they lost.

s_m_t··on Facebook Decided Which Users Are Interested in Nazis – and Let Ads Target Them
Shit, I guess I'm a Nazi because I like history.

Edit: Just checked my bookshelf and I might also be a genghis khan sympathizer.

s_m_t··on The Death of a Dreamer
Cool, thanks for the consideration
s_m_t··on The Miracle of Applied Mathematics (2001) [pdf]
You've missed a step here. No one thought to do math until people started to seriously worry about proportions, distance, quantity, time, etc of the natural world. Once you've set up those rules (and necessarily rigged them in favor of explaining the natural world) you can stay in the platonic realm, change the rules so they apparently stop reflecting reality, and rely on your sense of aesthetic, but then I think the onus is back on you to explain where this sense comes from.
s_m_t··on An ex-YouTube whistleblower on their recommendation engine
The danger is when the state or a political party or some other organizarion with the states levers of power controls the algorithm. It won't be flat earth videos that get deranked it will be anything that contradicts selling us trash and invading other countries.

That warship wasn't actually bombed by the enemy, they probably didn't use those chemical weapons, why is our state department funding the same terrorists we were just fighting yesterday, actually those moderate rebels aren't so moderate will become the new flat earth.

s_m_t··on The Death of a Dreamer
Have you considered that what this essentially leads to is the only acceptable emotional response being either classic nerd commiseration or over-intellectualizing yourself out of any position that risks any sort of conflict. Essentially, a website of mostly socially stunted nerds with a set of rules to reinforce their unfit social behavior.
s_m_t··on Humanity Has Hope: Pro-Gamers Win 1 of 11 StarCraft Matches Against DeepMind AI
I thought the camera limited match was the only one it lost?

Once alphastar was faced with a scenario that couldn't be brute forced with perfect micro it pretty much stopped working.

s_m_t··on Humanity Has Hope: Pro-Gamers Win 1 of 11 StarCraft Matches Against DeepMind AI
Not having to move the camera around is massive. High level starcraft has been likened to something like poker by many pros. Except, instead of getting a steady trickle of information in terms of the cards being put down you have control over what information you gather. But the information is spread out across space and time and the viewport only gives you a small slice. And the human eye only lets you look at a small portion of the screen as well. If you check your minerals, gas, and supply, you cannot be checking your minimap at the same time. Alpha starcraft can look at the minimap constantly while knowing the position and health of every single unit not in the fog of war.

For human players maintaining this map awareness is definitely the hardest part of starcraft. The micro isn't really that hard, you can train on special custom maps and get most of the tricks down pretty quickly. The build orders and meta level strategies aren't very hard to wrap your head around either, the possibility space is actually pretty small here.

What is hard is constantly task switching, not hyper focusing on a couple of units, knowing what you should be focusing on at any given point in time... Well, those are all pretty much the same, it is, "how should I spend my very limited attention".

If your opponent has infinite attention resources some strategies that work against humans dont really make sense. Drops for instance are balanced around the idea that if the opponent recognizes that they are being dropped they will be able to pretty easily defend against it. Against a computer that will instantly see the drop the millisecond it comes out of the fog of war... Well, you just gave away the hard part for free. A human player would either have to a) get lucky and happen to glance at the minimap in the small window to counter the drop. or b) anticipate the drop and make the conscious choice to spend precious attention rescources to catch it.

s_m_t··on DeepMind – StarCraft II Demonstration
Well, ignoring spam clicks, APM is a measure of the number of decisions that a player makes throughout the course of the game. You'd expect a player making more decisions to come out ahead in a game as fast paced and action oriented as Starcraft.
s_m_t··on It took seven miles to pull over a Tesla with a seemingly asleep driver
Isn't the autopilot in a tesla pretty similar to what is called autopilot in an airplane?
s_m_t··on How to Make a Roguelike
>Maybe your LoS algorithm sucks with 1x1 columns and windows, so decide your game doesn't need them and you move on.

I really like this viewpoint. The awesome thing about a game (and a roguelike in particular)is that YOU generate all the data your algorithms operate on. I'd take your solution a step further. If LoS is the thing holding you back... don't put ANY walls or LoS blocking terrain in your game. What would a roguelike look like without walls? Would it be any fun to play? Maybe you'd have to make it set on the high seas or in space to justify not having walls or LoS blockers.

Typically walls are used in a game to limit the players movement, limit information, and provide meaningful choices in terms of where to go next. Keeping in line with the LoS theme, you need some sort of gameplay mechanic to fulfill those criteria without forcing you to code a sophisticated LoS algorithm. Wind, current, and fog could fulfill those criteria without having to code any LoS beyond fog of war.

s_m_t··on When Trump Phones Friends, the Chinese and the Russians Listen and Learn
The president is the commander in chief of the armed forces so pretty much anything the military does is under the presidents authority or by authority delegated down the chain of command from him/her. The president could personally lead troops into battle if he wanted to. I think the only president to have served as an actual general during their time as president was George Washington during the whiskey rebellion.
s_m_t··on Algebra and the Lambda Calculus (1993)
I guess the tape is just a linked list of bits? What confuses me about lambda calculus, and a lot of math in general, I guess, as opposed to something like the turing machine, is that, how do I put this...

To actually implement Lisp or lambda calculus in real life you need "cons", right(?), and some way to increment your equivalent to an "instruction pointer". Or else you don't have any memory or information to operate on and you don't have any way to move on to the next step. If you are doing it on paper I guess the act of moving your pen to an empty space is your cons and moving your eyes across the page is like incrementing your instruction pointer... In the idea of the turing machine this is all explicitly explained but every time I try and read about lambda calculus it seems like they just expect you to know it right away. This might seem really trivial to other people but its how I tend to think.

s_m_t··on Show HN: Lipreading with Deep Learning
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laser_microphone
s_m_t··on Was Tony the Tiger Driven Off Twitter by Unbelievably Horny Furries?
Its obviously a 'self aware' chan joke. There is a pretty big chan culture and furry culture overlap because of the many conflicts between the userbases. Eventually the furries won and now inhabit quarantine boards on 4chan.

The whole "brony" thing, for instance, was started on 4chan and started a practical civil war that ended with the dedicated quarantine board /mlp/. Furry and mlp porn was so frequently used to nuke threads on various boards that another quarantine board, /trash/, was created to hold everything that no one else wanted to look at. The idea was that the spammers would be happier hanging out, umm, discussing their artwork of choice, and forget to mess with everyone else. It seems to have worked actually.

As for over the top, well, we are talking about people who spend thousands of dollars on animal costumes

s_m_t··on Mathematics as thought
Have you considered that this perspective is also an almost perfect ego preserving technique?

It's not my fault I'm bad at math, its just that those other guys have memorized the language. I just think different so of course I wouldn't be suited to the normal way of doing things. If only someone had nurtured my special way of thinking and treated me as the individual that I am I'd surely pass by those who so readily conformed to the standard without really understanding. We should teach math with a child like curiosity, because children have infinite potential (and so do I).

I also suck at math. I have had these thoughts. I don't think they are healthy or constructive, they probably come from a place of pride and ressentiment. I'm not saying you have these thoughts or there is a direct connection between what you wrote and what I did but it certainly reminded me of that thought pattern.

s_m_t··on What are some things that only someone who has been programming 20 years knows?
In information theory you can't come up with an encoding that will give you more than a bit of information per bit of source on average. Of course, the information we usually care about is usually highly structured, so we use encodings that compress the highly structured parts we care about and dont care if in that same encoding it would take many bits more to encode some other part. Ever used some sort of library or framework where in the beginning you get a ton of progress made in a small amount of time but when it comes to getting it to do exactly what you want you find your code balooning around the corner cases? Same idea in my opinion.
s_m_t··on What are some things that only someone who has been programming 20 years knows?
Its just compression and information theory.
s_m_t··on Serious design flaw in ESS ExpressVote touchscreen: “permission to cheat”
What problem are electronic voting machines supposed to solve?
s_m_t··on “Prestudy”: Learning Chinese Through Reading
After using what was essentially this technique to learn to read Japanese I'm not entirely convinced it is actually all that useful compared to just reading. I found myself spending so much time in anki that sometimes I wouldn't do real reading at all... And for what? So I would have a chance at being sort of familiar with a character when I came across it? So called "flashcard blindness" is also a real thing. Context is so important when learning, sometimes it was like I had to learn two words, the word I 'learned' in anki and the word in the wild. Even though they were obstinsably the same word somehow they couldn't connect.

If this technique did help at all I think the effect was mainly psychological. Looking at a page with a bunch of words you don't know is stressful and demoralizing. Even being able to think that you have seen a character somewhere without knowing what it means can be comforting. It sounds silly but any amount of stress can severely inhibit language acquisition. You might be better off meditating for 15 minutes... Or taking drugs

The only thing that seemed to be 100% effective was readimg content that I was completely engaged in. It didn't matter if said content was close to my skill level or way beyond my skill level. As long as I am sufficiently engaged it doesn't matter how many times I have to reference the dictionary or comb google for grammar explanations.

s_m_t··on Ask HN: What's the most difficult part of learning to program?
Programming itself I think is fairly easy if you have the mindset for it. What isnt easy is making your program work with existing technology and programs.

Same goes for writing vs reading code. Maybe we teach and learn programming all wrong. For instance, when learning a natural language you dont read a manual on the grammar and then go off and try to write a novel looking up vocabulary along the way... There is absolutely no way you would be succesful with that approach, you would invent your own messed up version of the language that seems absolutely strange to everyone else. But that is sort of what we expect people to do when they learn to program.

It might be better to spend a year reading and dissecting good code of varying complexity in a debugger before you ever even write a line of code.

s_m_t··on My life with 12 programmers, 2 rooms and one 21st-century dream (2016)
Hmm, strange way to live...
s_m_t··on Why Do Keynote Speakers Keep Suggesting That Improving Security Is Possible?
I think you are missing a crucial point. I as a consumer really do not care in the least if someone hacks my device. Worst comes to worst I either do some sort of factory reset or just throw it out, I was probably looking to buy the shinier version anyways. Who cares?

I really dont care if my tea kettle is part of some botnet. I cant even imagine a reason why I should care. I guess it sorta sucks for the people getting ddosed :/

For instance, my router cost me $20. It is probably full of security holes. I dont care. To buy a router that was secure I would have to pay more than $20. I would not feel any benefit for spending that extra money. So I don't do it.

On the other hand, as a developer I'm always thinking about security because it is fun and I feel a sense of responsibility for the things I make.

s_m_t··on The Age of Cretinism
Yeah, Hitler was no trojan horse. He pretty much laid out his plans in a book... Which he wrote in prison after a failed coup.
s_m_t··on War Without End
Everyone seems to also forget the then recent success of the Korean war. At risk of confusing what was known then and what is known now, well, look at NK vs SK today. Vietnam under socialist control turned out to be not anywhere as extreme but it would have been hard to guess that right during China's "great leap forward". Of course, things didn't turn out as well for neighboring Cambodia.
s_m_t··on Apple is removing Alex Jones and InfoWars’ podcasts from iTunes
So why now. Sandy Hook was five years ago.
s_m_t··on The Blockchain Bubble Will Pop, What Next?
Can't you do the same thing with a simple chain of hashs a la version control?? Why would you need distributed consensus on a patient's health record. My understanding is that Blockchains only make sense in a low trust distributed environment... If you have that low of trust in your doctor it doesn't even make sense to show up.
s_m_t··on Riot Games Approach to Anti-Cheat
Sorry, in "if cheaters are allowed to completely run rampant this isn't the case." I meant "the case" as something like "the perception of cheating is more damaging than the actual cheating". Poorly written on my part.
s_m_t··on Riot Games Approach to Anti-Cheat
I don't think it is really the cheaters that degrade the experience, it is the knowledge (right or wrong) that cheaters exist that reduces trust that makes for not fun experiences.

I've played online games for many thousands of hours over the past two decades and I can count the number of times I encountered a blatant cheater on my hands. Every time it actually happened people had a good laugh about it and either hopped servers or banned the person cheating. Sure I have probably unknowingly encountered a bunch of map and wall hackers but I didn't know so it didn't degrade my experience. For all I knew those players were just better than me, plenty of those around. Having played with some extremely high level players in various games, it actually feels like the good players are using map/wallhacks more than the actual hackers because they have such good gamesense.

On the other hand, I have been accused of cheating more times than I have actually for sure encountered real cheaters. It isn't fun when a server turns sour because everyone is accusing each other of cheating and getting salty over nothing.

Of course, if cheaters are allowed to completely run rampant this isn't the case. But any game with a modicum of community power to enforce rules won't have that problem. The major places you reliably encounter cheaters are non-private servers and matchmaking services that have essentially been abandoned by the developers.

s_m_t··on Death: From Dungeon Crawl to Meat Boy
I imagine it is just easier to balance that way. "Death" in these games really just means teleporting you to a predetermined position and restarting the encounter (in the souls games also adding a chance to permanently lose some of your gathered resources, which based on the non-linear stat leveling don't actually matter all that much). I would also add that in the souls games the dodging is very lenient, if you spend the first couple of minutes of a boss fight simply not getting hit you can usually see most of the bosses attack animations and beat it on the first try if you don't mess up.

Based on the alternatives that actually exist the cure may be worse than the disease. In many modern AAA games you never really have to learn anything, the game just lets you progress regardless. Unless you play on the extremely hard difficulty modes that just completely break the balance of the game (the hardest difficulty mode on the Uncharted remastered is a good example of this).

← PreviousPage 4 of 9Next →