HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sacrosancty

786 karma · joined January 24, 2022

submissionscomments
sacrosancty··on Caring for the only known full kākāpō feather cloak in the world
As with the German umlaut and the Chinese pinyin tone marks, it's also easiest to ignore ;) New Zealand has a few generations of people who pronounce Maori words by ignoring the macrons and with more English-like vowel sounds. It's as if the language has changed but there are perfectionists trying to spread popularity of the official pronunciation too.
sacrosancty··on Mouse embryo with brain and beating heart created from stem cells
If you declare just about everything to be a disaster then, yea, I agree the future will probably be full of disasters. But Blade Runner iirc is about people who seem normal but have some "bad" origin which makes them eligible for abusive treatment. We wouldn't do that today any worse than we already do, of course with foreigners/etc. but I'm assuming the doomsayers are worried about something worse than what we already widely do and accept.

> (As an aside: that's already abuse, so you apparently defending it, even if that wasn't your intent, should demonstrate why we may end up being awful to such life).

I gave the example of an artist who works for personal satisfaction. You call that abuse to have allowed that person to be born? I don't. If someone is intrinsically motivated to be a slave, then being a slave may not only be the best possible life them but could even be better than the life of a normal free person. If it's actually abusive like using human slaves, then people will see than just as we can see that today.

sacrosancty··on U.S. appeals court rejects big tech’s right to regulate online speech
I'd better not get too involved in this because it's ugly politics nonsense, but it's easy enough to find criticisms of California for its power grid, leftism, pro-abortion-rights (which is obviously seen as a bad thing by many people), and political use of immigrants.
sacrosancty··on Mouse embryo with brain and beating heart created from stem cells
Nonsense. Farm animals are unnaturally bred and essentially slaves. We somehow have them. Are you opposed to their existence too?

Yes, people have disagreed about slavery and farm/working animals and all those grey areas of animal and human rights. But it's arrogant of you to take your personal opinion and try to impose it on an entirely different society with creatures that you know nothing about "just in case" the members of that society happen to be morally wrong by your standard. Let them make up their own mind just as we make up our own minds today. They'll be in a much better position to do so.

sacrosancty··on Mouse embryo with brain and beating heart created from stem cells
Who says they'll be property and not have the same rights as normal people? Slavery was banned. If this becomes so objectionable, it'll be banned too. Why are all you people assuming laws and civilization will stop existing in the future? Are you afraid that future people might not share your current political views? Get over yourself and let them have their own sovereignty and vote for what they want.
sacrosancty··on Mouse embryo with brain and beating heart created from stem cells
None of that sounds like a disaster. What's wrong with a defacto slave enjoying their life doing what makes them most satisfied? Doesn't seem all that different from a normal human who works for pleasure, or even an artist who may work without pay but only for personal satisfaction.

You seem to be forgetting that people will get things banned if they're obviously bad. If simulating another person becomes a problem, we'll just write a law for that, same as we already do for fraud. You can sign somebody else's name on a document, you know! s How do banks survive the onslaught of fraud! /s

sacrosancty··on U.S. appeals court rejects big tech’s right to regulate online speech
You're probably living in a filter bubble. You'd be hearing only the same kind of things about California if you were in a different bubble.
sacrosancty··on U.S. appeals court rejects big tech’s right to regulate online speech
Didn't happen with EU's internet laws. Instead, we get cookie banners all over the world. I don't think exiting a market full of money because of ideology is good business.
sacrosancty··on Mouse embryo with brain and beating heart created from stem cells
Why would we abuse them? We treat disabled people OK, don't we? What exactly is your fear? Some kind of prejudice against people who were born through different procedures? We already have test tube babies walking among us and nobody mistreats them.
sacrosancty··on GPU mining no longer profitable after Ethereum merge
If you say something's bad, you imply something else is good. So can you identify some contrasting technologies which didn't start out as a "garbage fire of greenhouse gasses and e-waste" or the appropriate equivalent? Are you wanting a world contains only those born perfect technologies?
sacrosancty··on Stripe has decided to nuke my entire business
I've had my Paypal account frozen because I was cheating by living in a different country, not just on holiday. I managed to recover it by giving them the documents they wanted to "prove" that I lived in the country my account was in. I think this included getting my bank to send statements to a family member's address and have them email me a copy. I know some people really do get locked out for good but that wasn't my experience.

Trying to get money from a real bank account (Lloyds in England) after moving out of the country was much harder though. It involved writing several letters and getting a policeman to stamp something, as well as multiple phone calls, including to several staff who gave me wrong advice. But still, they returned my money eventually.

sacrosancty··on Team led by Japanese researchers reveals best way to put crying baby to sleep
human physical contact ftw. All these devices are just a substitute for a mother.
sacrosancty··on Death by hockey sticks
Hockey sticks usually end up being S-shaped curves. The author is just doom-screaming because we're currently in the rapid change phases of lots of them but hasn't shown on any of the graphs the point where disaster will occur. What's the critical rate of extinctions that would end global economic growth before most of the world has western quality of life? He has no clue! So his worries are just emotional and based on misleading graphs.

One of the graphs (forest cover) is extrapolated into the future and shown to be zero. He could instead have shown in plateauing if he wanted to tell a different story.

sacrosancty··on Climate change: Six tipping points ‘likely’ to be crossed
Pakistan in its current state could be what civilizational collapse in the west would look like. You can't fall off the floor.
sacrosancty··on Climate change: Six tipping points ‘likely’ to be crossed
Any science behind your implied claim that port cities will stop operating because of sea level rise, rather than adapting or migrating?

It's incredible how widespread misinformation about climate change is. All these replies from people who support the OP's claim but have no idea why and are just taking random stabs at imagined reasons.

sacrosancty··on Climate change: Six tipping points ‘likely’ to be crossed
So it's made up extremism?
sacrosancty··on Climate change: Six tipping points ‘likely’ to be crossed
> very likely collapse of civilisation

Have you got a reference for that claim? I hear it a lot and assume it's just made-up extremism, isn't it?

sacrosancty··on Killing invasive species is now a competitive sport
That's just arrogance though - "Even if you disagree with me for any reason, including reasons I never thought of, but excluding the one possible reason I did think of, I'm still right so disregard your silly opinion and do it my way.".
sacrosancty··on Queen Elizabeth II has died
Well yes, but that's not what your parent comment said. Normal people watch the news and see all the prime ministers.
sacrosancty··on We Are Not Adults Just Because We Say So
Marriage in some countries comes with a bunch of legal rights and obligations, so you do need the government to agree if you also want it to enforce those things.

In New Zealand, marriage has no legal value as far as I know. All the law that I know of, such as for property rights, immigration, and social welfare that would usually be about marriage is instead about being in a "relationship of the nature of marriage". That's kind of scary because you can sleepwalk into becoming effectively married and then suddenly you lose some of your property rights.

sacrosancty··on We Are Not Adults Just Because We Say So
> Governments did not invent this; therefore, they do not need to be consulted when two people enter into an agreement.

This is what I call argument soup. Stuff that sounds like logic but is nonsense intended to fool people who like the feeling of logic without actually applying it.

sacrosancty··on Queen Elizabeth II has died
Just like every other 96 year old though, right?
sacrosancty··on Queen Elizabeth II has died
None of those things you mentioned are real or big problems visible at an individual level any more than the problems of previous decades. If nobody told you they'd happened, you'd be enjoying the same stability and comfort as before. Perhaps the problem is how the media presents events, not the events themselves.

Without an objective way to measure "badness", all you're doing it reflecting what the TV told you to feel.

sacrosancty··on Breaking the silence around academic bullying
No doubt. Or not even have such minor contributors as authors in the first place. Perhaps you should have to have actually written part of the paper, like an actual author, or at least done some novel research of your own. Technicians and others who assisted with it, even did all of the grunt work could just be acknowledged if they want some fame. But I guess that authorship is a kind of payment-by-exposure instead of actual money and enough people are desperate enough to take it.
sacrosancty··on Why companies are interested in Myers-Briggs types
What always seemed an obvious problem with Myers-Briggs is that there's no way to be "normal". Somebody who's at the mean of all 4 axes is going to get a random score and look just the same as someone who's extreme in some way. Surely many or even most people are going to be close enough to the mean on some axes that error in the test can't place them on the correct side.
sacrosancty··on Killing invasive species is now a competitive sport
You should kill pigs regardless of your stance on killing pigs?
sacrosancty··on I patched my Slack client to keep “oops” messages others delete
You're not countering the parent's point. Of course you can agree to allow it if you choose.
sacrosancty··on I ran the worlds largest DDoS-for-Hire empire and Cloudflare helped
If it's not illegal then it probably isn't causing any serious harm, so Cloudflare doesn't need to block it. If it is, say a direct death threat or telling others to harm someone, then it's already illegal and your explanation isn't needed.
sacrosancty··on Breaking the silence around academic bullying
I'm 2nd author on a 2-author paper where my only contribution was answering a couple of questions on how to use some software, and then proofreading the couple of paragraphs that mentioned it. I didn't even read most of the paper, let alone know what it was really about. Surely there's a need to communicate the fact that my contribution is less than that of the real author?
sacrosancty··on A hormone may boost cognition in Down syndrome
Worth noting that some mothers perfer not to test for it because there's an implication they'll decide to kill their baby if it's "defective" which they find horrible and unloving. Eugenics, basically.
← PreviousPage 4 of 14Next →