HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sahil50

218 karma · joined February 18, 2019

submissionscomments
sahil50··on Astronomers discover a strange galaxy without dark matter
"armchair" and "no real credentials"

fine if you want to call me an "amateur cosmologist with a few credentials"

sahil50··on Astronomers discover a strange galaxy without dark matter
The tweets above are good questions! This is how to do science!

Meanwhile it's good to restate the obvious.

Modified gravity (MOND), where acceleration at galactic scales isn't just GM/R^2 but modeled as sqrt(GM/R^2 * cH/(2pi)), works for 100s of galaxies, and is more precise than cold dark matter (CDM).

Modified gravity only has one free parameter. cH/(2pi) = c^2 / 87 bly.

sahil50··on Astronomers discover a strange galaxy without dark matter
http://astroweb.case.edu/ssm/mond/fit_compare.html

cold dark matter (CDM) is a superimposed amorphous blob of invisible non-interacting matter, hence its inability to model the kinks in the real rotation curve

modified gravity (MOND) models the kinks in the rotation curve

sahil50··on Astronomers discover a strange galaxy without dark matter
Related to your idea,

- modified gravity (MOND), which accurately models the centripetal acceleration of stars in hundreds of galaxies, models acceleration as sqrt(GM/R^2 * cH/(2pi))

- cH/(2pi) = c^2 / (2pi * 13.8 bly), which looks like some super extreme v^2/r centripetal acceleration

- like something moving at c, from a point 2pi * 13.8 bly away = 87 bly away

- maybe if ones goes straight for 87 bly, one ends up at the "same point" in abstract space

- maybe the universe has the shape of a hypersphere. maybe the radius of the hypersphere is 13.8 bly.

sahil50··on Astronomers discover a strange galaxy without dark matter
Appreciate the feedback. These statements are a synthesis of ideas from people who've already synthesized all the complexity of the CDM vs MOND debate, but now I'm talking at the level of HackerNews so people do something!
sahil50··on Astronomers discover a strange galaxy without dark matter
I look back to where this started, and this started with Fritz Zwicky noticing that galaxies and galaxy clusters are moving faster than expected. This is the root observation.

From there, a good question is "How do we model it?". And sqrt(GM/R^2 * cH/(2pi)) works really well.

By the way, cH/(2pi) = c^2 / (2pi * 13.8 bly), which looks like centripetal acceleration.

sahil50··on Astronomers discover a strange galaxy without dark matter
I have a degree in Computer Science from Yale. I built https://zedtime.live and I'm building https://spase.io, and I've been in direct communication with cold dark matter (CDM) and modified gravity (MOND) cosmologists for the last 20 weeks. I basically ask the questions that I'm gonna guess everyone has on their mind, and I'm just moving the conversation along faster.
sahil50··on Astronomers discover a strange galaxy without dark matter
Yep 5th figure at that link. Also McGaugh's words here, https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/dark-matter-may-b....
sahil50··on Astronomers discover a strange galaxy without dark matter
Hey, glad to meet you. Maybe we can have a discussion. Glad we agree on modified gravity (MOND) being able to accurately account for galaxy rotation.

- galaxy clusters

- lensing

- Bullet Cluster, El Gordo

all have answers in the work of modified gravity (MOND) cosmologists. Stacy McGaugh does a really good job going through each one.

The essential thing, and I mean really essential, is that modified gravity (MOND) uses fewer free parameters than cold dark matter (CDM), by a long shot.

sahil50··on Astronomers discover a strange galaxy without dark matter
Answer on the 5th figure on this page.

https://tritonstation.com/2022/01/10/the-curious-case-of-agc...

sahil50··on Astronomers discover a strange galaxy without dark matter
http://astroweb.case.edu/ssm/mond/fit_compare.html
sahil50··on Astronomers discover a strange galaxy without dark matter
fyi, "dark matter" is not a real thing. Modified gravity (MOND) accurately models galactic rotation for hundreds of galaxies with sqrt(GM/R^2 * c*H / 2pi), without the stupid and ludicrous idea of invisible, noninteracting blobs of dark matter around every galaxy.

The reason "dark matter" has persisted in the public consciousness is that TV cosmologists keep pumping it, and academics currently in charge built their careers on it and don't want to lose their funding.

sahil50··on 20 reasons Satoshi Nakamoto is Elon Musk
Yep see the examples of source code for Zip2 and X.com and commentary from other engineers
sahil50··on 20 reasons Satoshi Nakamoto is Elon Musk
Perfect clip, thx
sahil50··on 20 reasons Satoshi Nakamoto is Elon Musk
I don't think Fridman asked the question in response to or while aware of this information above. And neither Elon.
sahil50··on 20 reasons Satoshi Nakamoto is Elon Musk
Recapping the top 5 reasons

- capability

- will

- linguistic similarity

- call with chief of staff

- Los Angeles IP address

sahil50··on The $11B Webb telescope aims to probe the early universe
I expect we'll see more mature galaxies in the distant universe.

This is a glaring problem for the standard model (big bang LCDM) right now.

XMM-2599, SPT0418-47, MRG-M2129, all mature galaxies, far away

sahil50··on Show HN: I was playing with fundamental constants and 13.8 b years popped out
Heads up: click "Use Planck's constant", otherwise Wolfram Alpha assumes h is hours.
sahil50··on Show HN: I was playing with fundamental constants and 13.8 b years popped out
Can we consider a few other possibilities?

As in, taking the point of view of cosmology about 100 years ago, before the redshift was attributed to the Doppler effect. And before the notion of a big bang was the default basis of reasoning.

- What if H is just a measure of redshift? Literally just redshift. Not expansion. Not an age. Just photons losing energy. At a rate of H.

- What if H actually is constant? Like G and like h and like k (Coulomb's constant).

- What if the universe doesn't have an age?

^ not rhetorical questions. Actually asking.

sahil50··on Show HN: I was playing with fundamental constants and 13.8 b years popped out
Sure there many coincidences that are meaningless.

I think this one stands out because it has to do with charge & gravity, and protons, electrons, & photons. Which are the stable & abundant "things" in the universe.

sahil50··on New Evidence Against the Standard Model of Cosmology
Cut the sarcasm because it's going to backfire.

That there are galaxies that appear more frequently at 500 million light-years from each other, is the raw fact. I've read the papers that say that raw fact is proof of big bang LCDM, but that's not actually true. It's not "if and only if" proof, because those papers presuppose the big bang is true and squish the "500 million light-years" observation into their model. They don't consider the possibility of an eternal, eternally evolving universe where 500 million light-years might be an interesting peak of a distribution coming from some interaction of charge and gravity at large scales. Something like chemistry, but at galactic scales.

The cosmic background radiation is likewise not "if and only if" proof of the big bang model. In fact, non-expansionary, non-big-bang models predicted a cosmic temperature around 3K 50 years before Penzias and Wilson. For some reason, this history gets little coverage. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cosmic_microwave_background#Ti.... There's also a curious coincidence that 2.7K is related to 1/3 electron energy density when in equilibrium with its surroundings. https://twitter.com/sahil5d/status/1413375131078914055 ^ not a fact, just speculation.

k is Coulomb's constant. F=kqq/r^2.

The plot of all known redshift data fits photon hubbling (continuous photon decay) (tired light) more accurately than galactic recession. https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1HI61-pDIzzSItw48K0ga...

I could spend lots of time whacking moles, but instead I'm fixing the problem at the root, and that problem is interpreting the cosmological redshift as galactic recession. The reason the academic establishment 100 years ago claimed the redshift was the Doppler effect of galaxies receding, was that it was the only "generally accepted mechanism" at the time. That bug in the code has been covered up with patches and patches of convoluted logic for 100 years. Like "space expanded faster than the speed of light". How people swallowed that one, I'll never know.

Gotta fix the bug at the root. Then talk about the rest like dark matter, dark energy, baryon acoustic oscillations.

sahil50··on New Evidence Against the Standard Model of Cosmology
You misread.

The cosmological redshift is not attributable to galaxies receding.

The cosmological redshift is photons losing energy as they forge a path through the gravitationally connected universe. It's the cost of traveling.

Total redshift = Cosmological redshift (photon forging a path through spacetime) + Doppler redshift (for example, Andromeda drifting toward us) + Gravitational redshift (like how Sun-to-Earth photons are redshifted because the Sun is more massive)

sahil50··on New Evidence Against the Standard Model of Cosmology
How do you know?
sahil50··on New Evidence Against the Standard Model of Cosmology
Maybe. But my reasoning is to assume as little as possible and start reasoning up from the point in history where the need for an explanation arose.

And the need for an explanation arose when Hubble saw the redshift. He and Zwicky preferred tired light over galactic recession, but the halfwit academic establishment went with galactic recession.

sahil50··on New Evidence Against the Standard Model of Cosmology
How so?

Considering all the data on redshift we have, tired light fits. Not galactic recession.

Rough calculations https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1HI61-pDIzzSItw48K0ga...

Data from https://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/Library/Distances/

sahil50··on New Evidence Against the Standard Model of Cosmology
The standard argument is a straw man argument. Tired light is not photons getting scattered, and is not photons bumping into stray electrons.

Tired light is because there is a cost to traveling through spacetime. The photon is warping the shape of all the universe mass around it. The photon is doing work.

sahil50··on New Evidence Against the Standard Model of Cosmology
Hubble's constant is related to all the other fundamental constants. And is not a measure of "expansion", which is one of the core ideas of the Standard Model.

Relation to the cosmological principle: self-similarity not just in terms of density and homogeneity, but also macro and micro scales. H, a measure of cosmic stuff, is literally derivable from atomic stuff.

sahil50··on New Evidence Against the Standard Model of Cosmology
What Hubble objectively measured wasn't galaxies receding. He measured redshift. Or photon energy loss.

And there's another way to explain this, that is simpler, self-consistent, and doesn't require the concept of "inflation" where apparently space expanded faster than the speed of light.

The explanation: photon hubbling, tired light. That galaxies are frankly right where they are. They're not receding. The photon loses energy. It costs energy to forge a path through spacetime.

sahil50··on New Evidence Against the Standard Model of Cosmology
Photon hubbling, tired light. The photon is doing work as it moves through spacetime. Modeled as E_t / E_0 = e^(-Ht), where H is Hubble's constant, and t is time of travel.
sahil50··on New Evidence Against the Standard Model of Cosmology
(1/H * c) = (1/α * ke^2 / (electron mass * c^2)) * (h / (proton mass * c * pi/2)) / (2G * proton mass / c^2)
← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →