The only sane response is to continue as close to normal as possible while protecting the vulnerable and reducing risk via masks and distancing.
Somehow _this_ is the controversial opinion.
562 karma · joined January 18, 2016
The only sane response is to continue as close to normal as possible while protecting the vulnerable and reducing risk via masks and distancing.
Somehow _this_ is the controversial opinion.
Also, in the case of Vietnam, only 14% of their population is over 55 years old, whereas 29% of the USA is over 55 (and 31% of Belgium, another hard hit country). Seeing as this disease hits people over 55 the hardest (and is barely noticed in those under 30), it is no wonder Vietnam is seeing less of an issue here.
It seems age demographics _could_ have more correlation with outcomes than any government intervention. That of course doesn't explain Vietnam entirely. Also keep in mind, Vietnam has only administered 12,000 test per 1 million people, whereas the USA has administered 492,000 per 1 million.
Yes, COVID has killed a _lot_ of people, but so has the response to COVID. We focused all resources on one enemy while other allies of Death stalked in the back door.
20% of NYC can have the virus and the general level for herd immunity can still be what is postulated. NYC is incredibly dense compared to the rest of the USA and as such will naturally have more mixing and a higher threshold than say Topeka, Kansas
I am sorry to hear of this and I hope your wife (and you!) find answers and see improvement.
I want to be very clear that I am not dismissing long COVID. In fact, I am hoping that via a more accurate diagnostic environment (which it seems like you went through) we can better identify true long Covid vs. anxiety/depression.
The better we can (and forgive my terrible analogy) separate the wheat from the chaff and identify true long Covid patients the better we can help true sufferers
Or keep on beating the same old drum while the rest of the world has moved on.
For we are doing great, but we are not the worst either. That is basically the story of the USA in general I think
The greatest lie we were told back in March was that lockdowns were temporary to beat COVID. There is no beating COVID, we are not gods. The disease will continue until it doesn't.
I watched the show "Afflicted" on Netflix, and it made me sad more than anything. (In my opinion) a majority of the afflicted were clearly suffering from psychological problems, but they were kept on very expensive drugs and the doctors were just throwing darts at a wall.
I hope that mental health becomes less taboo, and more research into why mental health is declining is funded.
Stay healthy and glad you are doing well.
Imagine getting tested for COVID, you've had it hammered in to your mind that this is a terrible disease that you are lucky to survive. You watched in Italy as the bodies piled up. You saw NYC and refrigerated trucks.
But what you are feeling doesn't align with what you were told. You don't feel _that_ bad. It feels like a bad cold. You are still scared shitless. How does the brain adapt to this? Is it possible that there is an element of guilt (All these people died, but I am OK) or fear (I am still waiting for the other shoe to drop and to end up on a vent). Could the mental stress of this cause fatigue?
I am sincerely asking someone who knows more about this than me to explain the chances that this is a phenomenon that exists and whether it can account for any of the long-hauler symptoms.
People are overinvested in the opinions they held in March, and will find evidence to support what they believed then.
On one side, we have the cohort of people who see this as literally the worst thing ever and we will all die. And you hate children and humanity if you want to eat at a restaurant.
On the other side, you have the crowd who sees this as a moderate case of the sniffles and society is overreacting due to the fact that the news media hyped this so aggressively
There is a very, very small minority of people who see it as squarely in the middle, a scary disease that we should protect people from, but with a more nuanced approach than lockdowns.
The important questions are as follows:
1. What is the _severity_ of reinfection?
2. What is the average immune response of re-infections?
3. If the infection is less severe, what is the shedding rate? How infectious are the re-infected?
4. Does re-infection occur in those who receive mRNA vaccinations (this is not really testable yet)
The pearl clutching with everything COVID related is quite concerning, moreso than the disease itself. The science is interesting, but the medias obsession with exaggerating and fear-mongering this disease is incredible. With that said, I appreciate that the link is to the paper, and not a media report on the paper. However I do await the stories that this proves we are all doomed :(
Stay safe, Portland is a good town at times, just it's 2020 you know?
I called 911 to report an assault in progress. I was on hold for four minutes, and the police took over an hour to arrive.
The problem is pearl clutching. When every. single. thing. Trump. does. is an "ohh the humanity!" panic moment, the actually terrible stuff he has done is drowned out by all the not-that-terrible-but-still-bad stuff.
This happened in 2016. The Trump campaign ran on 1 message. Clinton is corrupt. Emails? Corruption. Ties to Obama? Corruption. Clinton Foundation? Corruption. Every single attack line focused on that one point. Whereas Trump was a joke, then a sexual abuser, then a Russian asset, then unfit mentally, then this then that. And while all of those may have been, to some extent, true. The noise overran the signal and no clear attack ever formed. So it was "Clinton is corrupt" vs "Trump is so many things but it changes every day". All these virus hit pieces, and the military support hit pieces, and so on and so on are all _true_, but it is all noise. Whereas Trump is saying that Biden represents the fringe left, and that he will bring protests and unrest to the suburbs. Or he will take away 2nd amendment etc. All focused on him being a radical leftist. Of course he isn't a radical leftist, but it is one label and Trump is going to hammer it to victory.
See you in 2024
At no point in my mind, or I hope anyone else's mind, did "beat" mean zero infections, or zero deaths, or even zero outbreaks. It meant that we have the resources to manage infections as they occur. This means within hospitals as well as in the world at large. It means we have PPE etc and surge capacity. And it means that we reduce the infection rate enough to not overwhelm the resources.
Every thing we do slightly chips away at that infection rate. Masks do a bit, distancing does a bit, isolating when sick does a lot etc. Add even a minority of the population being vaccinated, and you _do_ have enough control over things to largely go back to "normal".
But, if the goalposts have moved so far that even 1 infection or 1 death is too many, then we are pretty well fucked. This is a coronavirus, it will be with us forever.
Please also remember, when speaking of the United States, around 15% of the population has already been infected by SARS-COV-2[1], and even the most pessimistic of epidemiologists say that herd immunity is around 60%. So we need "infect" 45% more of the population to give COVID-19 a knockout blow. even 50% efficacy (which I believe is the standard lower bound for an approved vaccine), 300 million doses should do quite nicely (600 if you count boosters, which I should have).
Those are all worst case scenarios. Most likely, the efficacy will be higher than 50% (maybe not 90%, but I think 75% is safe) and most likely herd immunity is below 60% (due to heterogeneity in mixing and t-cell "immunity").
Things are looking up!
Here are the concerns that I do not see addressed with this:
1. Will the City of Portland make the required infrastructure improvements to support more density? For example, will the storm sewers, which currently overflow poo into the river, support all the extra.. poo.
1a. Will the city invest in roads and public transit? Walking and biking are both great, but Portland is cold, dark and wet for 7 months a year. No matter how easy and safe you make it, people won't want to ride in those conditions.
1b. Portland 911 systems are currently stressed beyond reason. I waited on hold for 4 minutes on 911 (not non-emergency) a few weeks ago. This isn't a rare occurrence.
1c. Will Portland address the tent in the room? Homelessness is endemic in the city, and it isn't _only_ due to lack of housing. The city has very few options for mental health and drug treatment. Will the city invest in that? If not, livability will be negatively impacted by this.
1d. Assuming COVID ever ends, will Portland be business friendly enough to attract employers to employ the expected glut of people? Right now, large business are leaving Portland (Google has halted its expansion plans for example).
1e. Will Oregon fund schools in a way that can account for the new residents? Schools are already over-crowded and Oregon has one of the worst graduation rates in the country. Will the city/state commit to building schools to support new students? If so, where? They are in-filling in neighborhoods with few plots available
2. This will disadvantage low-income workers who won't be able to afford the new houses. Though more density does lower prices, it normally lowers prices in the less desirable neighborhoods. People of means buy the new condos/townhomes that are built, leaving the poor to take the less nice houses or continue to live further out.
2a. The Utopian dream of a urban playground where everyone is walking and birds are chirping and there is Trek in every garage doesn't play for a majority of people. People rarely live where they work. This is not normally a personal choice. Other factors play into it. Being around their family, kids' friends, better schools, new job on the other side of town etc. I understand the myopia of the crowd on this site is to picture everyone has a well-connected and well-heeled tech worker, but reality is far different.
3. Tongue in cheek-isg: this is all celebrated within the same week as another story claiming people are abandoned the density of SFO, NYC, SEA to work remotely in towns like BOI, AUS, Bend etc. There is obviously a _desire_ to have land and space and privacy. If we go to a remote-first work world, why do we think that anyone would want to live in this density?
Sometimes logical fallacies get a point across in a way that is the most succinct.
But there is a real difference between using deplatforming as a means of defunding hate groups and what happened with Reddit. Reddit itself has no means of monetization. While you could certainly argue that Reddit leads to platforms that do monetize, that is a slippery slope.