HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

saltminer

934 karma · joined April 8, 2019

She/her/hers
submissionscomments
saltminer··on Court docs reveal Epic CEO's anger at Steam's 30% fees
People talk about the cut as if it's a tax that, if lowered, would benefit consumers because prices for games would fall, but this is just not true.

Steam does not require pricing parity between marketplaces as long as you are not distributing Steam keys through them. I.e. if you sell Steam keys on Humble Bundle, you have to have price parity with Steam and match sales within 30 days before/after the Humble sale. But if you also sell on GOG, which does not provide Steam keys, the GOG price can be whatever you want. (So if you sell on these 3 platforms, if the normal Steam price is $30, then the normal Humble price also has to be $30, but you can price it on GOG at $5 all the time.)

To further illustrate my point, let's take some real-world examples. Ubisoft owns the Ubisoft Store and presumably takes a 0% cut for their own titles. The Ubisoft Store does not sell Steam keys, so it is not required to have pricing parity with Steam. One would therefore expect Ubisoft would attempt to court players into its own store with lower prices so they could get a higher percentage of each sale.

But if we look at Assassin's Creed Valhalla, the regular price is the same on both storefronts. Even more interesting is when we look at historical price data [0], which shows it actually goes on sale on Steam more often than it does on the Ubisoft Store.

Likewise, EA has F1 2024 available for pre-order at $69.99 on both Steam and the EA Store [1]. EA Sports FC 2024 also has the same normal price of $69.99 on both Steam and the EA Store, and it seems to go on sale on both platforms at about the same rate [2].

Cyberpunk 2077, developed by CDPR, owners of GOG, is also priced the same across all storefronts and goes on sale at about the same frequency on each [3].

For lack of a better term, the cut is a cost of doing business - it's a hidden tax that doesn't affect the end price consumers pay, even absent the typical pricing parity agreements that many D2C companies have entered into to get their product on traditional retailers' shelves.

Even in cases where there are no legal obligations to price match, the companies still do it, and when you think about it, the reason is obvious: the only people who benefit from a cut being lowered are executives who see bigger bonuses and shareholders who see larger dividends and increased stock prices. It doesn't actually affect the consumer, nor does it result in better pay for the individual developers.

If the cut were reduced (and back when games were mostly distributed by retailers, the cut was typically 60%+, so we have historical precedent for the effects of it being reduced), very few companies would drop prices - most would be content to enjoy the extra revenue because games are not a standardized commodity thanks to IP laws. (Think about it: Forza and Dirt don't really compete in the same market, despite both being racing sims, so one dropping the price won't be winning many customers from the other.)

I'm sure some small indie devs could meaningfully benefit from a smaller cut by the storefront, but indie devs typically price their games lower, so the ultimate monetary gain is much smaller for them than it is for Ubisoft, EA, etc. and if a decreased cut is what saves them from bankruptcy, they weren't in a very sustainable position to begin with.

I'm not trying to say a 30% cut is right, just that people talk about it as if lowering it would be a win for the consumer and for individual developers (and that Valve is holding the industry back as a result), when historically, the only ones who have really benefited are the AAAs' C-levels and shareholders.

[0]: https://isthereanydeal.com/game/assassins-creed-valhalla/his...

[1]: https://isthereanydeal.com/game/f1-24/info/

[2]: https://isthereanydeal.com/game/ea-sports-fc-24/history/

[3]: https://isthereanydeal.com/game/cyberpunk-2077/history/

saltminer··on Court docs reveal Epic CEO's anger at Steam's 30% fees
If you sell a lot, Valve will reduce their cut on Steam to 15% IIRC. And Steam keys are free to developers - that is, you can generate Steam keys on your website and sell them and Valve gets nothing in return, and there's no volume requirement like there is for reducing Valve's cut on the Steam store.

Steam also doesn't do exclusives (beyond Valve's own titles), nor do they pay any OEMs to pre-install Steam - with the exception of the Steam Deck, all Steam installs come from people who actively seek them out. It's not like Apple where (until recently) you had to go through them to get your app on iOS and pay them every step of the way for the privilege.

saltminer··on Nikon to acquire RED
I loved that movie! It truly is gorgeous, right up there with Blade Runner IMO. I just wish they'd release it in 4k, I'd re-buy it in a heartbeat.
saltminer··on Leaving LinkedIn
Oracle certainly has. Several GBUs realized they were working towards the same goal of a microservices base layer for future service hosting (for handling auth, logging, databases, etc.) and combined their efforts, and I happened to work on one of the resulting teams.

I'm not sure how public they've been about all this, but you certainly can teach an old dog new tricks, provided there is management buy-in (which we certainly had - at one point, our teams were moved between GBUs to save us from budget cuts).

saltminer··on The Empty Adderall Factory
You can keep operations going while still investigating the company. Imagine if Marathon Oil was discovered to be smuggling crude oil from Russia into their refineries and splitting the difference with Putin so Russia could bypass international sanctions, and an agency completely shut down Galveston Bay and Garyville (the two largest oil refineries in the US) in response - as soon as the news hit, prices for gasoline, propane, LNG, new plastics, etc. would go through the roof and runs on gas stations would begin. The public outrage would be swift and Congress would force whoever shut them down to let them resume operations while the case was underway.

There's no such sympathy for people unable to function without their meds, sadly.

saltminer··on Hindenburg research alleges sketchy accounting and product issues at Temenos
Every time I read one of their reports, I'm continually amazed at the depths some companies sink to juice their stock price and the flagrancy of the ponzi schemes they uncover. I should really be desensitized to it at this point, having read many of their articles since the DraftKings expose, but still.
saltminer··on The majority of traffic from X may have been fake during the Super Bowl
At this point, there's only a few people I care about left on the platform. And now that I think about who I used to follow...this certainly tracks.
saltminer··on Tips for Remote Workers
Working link: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07WRWFK33
saltminer··on Tips for Remote Workers
Don't forget the small things. Obviously, ergonomics and having a separate work space are important, but what frequently gets overlooked is having an area that you actually want to work in.

- Get some plants, photos, or other decorations that add some life and personality.

- Dislike having cold hands? Get a heated desk mat (I started out with a heated mouse but upgraded since I hated only having a warm mouse).

- If you don't like seeing a mess of cords, get monitor arms and cable trays.

- Figure out what size cup/water bottle you prefer. If you like to get up and stretch a fair amount, a smaller cup can provide more excuses to do just that. If you're like me and drink less from smaller cups since you don't want to risk running out when you're in the zone, get a larger one.

saltminer··on Microsoft Teams outage causes connection issues, message delays
The place I work at now uses Teams, and I legitimately didn't notice anything amiss.

- Channels randomly taking several minutes to load or outright refusing to load? Normal

- Calls dropping on a fast, stable ethernet connection? Normal

- Messages not sending, or appearing to send but silently never arriving/being dropped upon arrival? Normal

- Messages double- and triple-sending? Normal

- Messages being sent out-of-order? Normal

- Messages sending extremely slowly? Normal

- Attachments not loading? Normal

- Teams deciding logging in is just too difficult and I have to restart it at least once? Normal

I remember when I got an email today about an apparently outage describing all of the above (minus the call instability), I was like "wait, it's not supposed to be like this?"

And now that I type this out, especially having used Slack in the past, I realize what an indictment of Teams that is. (But I've also worked at a place that used Lync/Skype for Business/whatever they're calling it now, and it still manages to be pleasant compared to that mess. Though I won't give MS any credit there; the bar was on the floor, and they managed to avoid tripping over it.)

saltminer··on GCP Incident Affecting Operations, Cloud Logging, Google Cloud Dataflow
Link to the specific incident: https://status.cloud.google.com/incidents/bMAYzVmupVWVNUjPhc...
saltminer··on YouTube Cuts 100 Employees as Tech Layoffs Continue
If people stop watching a channel, even if they're subscribed, unless they have all notifications enabled for the channel, YouTube will just stop recommending it to them and notifying them about new uploads. This isn't a conspiracy; it makes a lot of sense for a recommendations engine, and it more accurately models a pattern that repeats itself time and time again: person gets big off of something popular, that something falls off a cliff, and unless they pivot and their audience pivots with them, they also fall off a cliff as their audience gets bored and stops coming back. Why should YouTube keep prioritizing and recommending videos to the people that no longer watch them?

IMO, YouTube has done a much better job recommending content from small channels the past couple years, and has introduced me to some great creators I would otherwise never have known about. Perhaps part of the recommendations have come at the expense of "channels you used to watch and maybe still would if they actually put out something fresh for a change," and there certainly is a conversation to be had there about the lack of transparency from YouTube whenever they change the algorithm, but as to which is better (subscriptions vs. small channels tangentially related to your viewing habits) is a matter of personal preference.

saltminer··on YouTube Cuts 100 Employees as Tech Layoffs Continue
I believe it only does sponsors by default, and some categories (like filler) are not shown at all by default. If you never went into the settings, you'd never know.
saltminer··on A site that tracks the price of a Big Mac in every US McDonald's
Yeah, unless you're willing to try the emergency turnaround spots (if there's a cop speed-trapping, you'll get a hefty ticket, and by the time you've slowed down enough to use the turnaround, it's probably too late), you'll probably end up more than paying the difference in tolls.

If you already passed through the Lee Toll Gantry by MM 10, you'll have to drive all the way to exit 3 to turn around, go to the cheaper McD's, then pass through the toll readers around MM 10 to turn back around at exit 10, then incur another toll after getting back on the highway.

You're better off exiting the highway to eat at the McD's off exit 10, which is still $0.40 more expensive than the eastbound service plaza location, but still $1.00 cheaper than the westbound service plaza location.

Edit: Turns out I was wrong. I calculated the difference, and paying the toll thrice would cost $0.75-$1.80 (vs. paying $0.25-$0.60 once), depending on if you have E-Z Pass MA, E-Z Pass (other states), or pay by mail.

Depending on how you pay the toll, you'll save $0.20-$0.70 paying thrice to visit the eastbound McD's vs. paying once to visit westbound McD's, but the cost of gas might make it a wash. If you're paying by mail, the best choice is exiting the highway, paying $7.09, then re-entering. (That said, if you're going eastbound, stopping at the service plaza wins every time.)

saltminer··on A site that tracks the price of a Big Mac in every US McDonald's
This assumes that Five Guys is in direct competition with those other chains and that people are directly comparing prices when choosing where to eat. People are not the perfect rational actors economists like to pretend they are, and they tend to make assumptions about prices and have personal preferences (e.g. the last time I went to BK it was so bad you would have to pay me to go back).
saltminer··on Copilot key will eventually be required in new PC keyboards
Not defending MS, but keyboards already have controllers and have since at least the original PC (probably much earlier than that but I'm not very familiar with old mainframe terminals). Considering how many SKUs already exist for different layouts and the like, this isn't that big of a burden - at most, this requires updated firmware and pad printing layouts, and firmware already changes a decent amount as controllers and membrane layouts are modified for new SKUs and cost-reduction. And it's not like they have to update their existing stock or retool their lines right now, the phase-in will likely take some time.

Also, unless I missed something, I don't think the article says one way or another how this will be implemented. It could be a new scancode or emulate a key combo.

saltminer··on First new U.S. nuclear reactor since 2016 is now in operation
Electricity demand isn't that simple, it's not like Sheetz dropping the price of gas to $1.776/gallon on the 4th of July and having to bag the pumps within the hour [0].

Electricity is quite interesting as a market because it's truly the logical endpoint of just-in-time manufacturing: the time between generation and consumption is measured not on the order of months, weeks, days, or even hours, but in milliseconds. It travels at 300,000 km per second/186,000 miles per second [1], which is incomprehensibly fast (it's fast enough to cross the widest span of the continental US, 4,799 km/2,892 miles, over 60 times in a single second).

As such, in order to maintain 50/60 Hz at nominal voltages and amperages (and that frequency is very important - in a 60 Hz system, 59.4 Hz is "we have 5 minutes before the entire grid blows up and plunges us into a 3+ month blackout" level bad [2]), utility companies aren't in the power generation business so much as they are in the predictions business. They have to take everything into account, from the weather to consumer purchasing habits, to determine exactly how much power needs to be generated at any given moment or the whole grid will collapse. That wide area synchronous grids like the UCTE (continental Europe) and Eastern Interconnection (eastern US) are able to operate is a testament to human ingenuity, as these really are quite fragile machines.

All this to say that you can't just "make power free when there's excess and people will magically use it up". Even if we can reliably predict excesses, people won't really be able to take advantage of it unless their schedule lends itself to it (e.g. being able to plug their car into a charger at work that only turns on when there's an excess), but even then, when done on a large scale, this only makes the predictions even harder for utility companies to plan around (think: thundering herd problem but on a national scale). At a macro level, it just doesn't work.

[0]: https://www.cnn.com/2023/07/04/business/sheetz-july-fourth-g...

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Speed_of_electricity?useskin=v...

[2]: https://www.houstonpublicmedia.org/articles/news/energy-envi...

saltminer··on First new U.S. nuclear reactor since 2016 is now in operation
The A-35 (a highway in Quebec) has been under construction since 1966. When finished, it will be 34 miles/55 km long.

Two decades isn't very long for an infrastructure project, which is unfortunate since long-term planning benefits greatly from political stability, and many areas are seeing large shifts for the worse in that regard.

saltminer··on At Least 15% of Reddit Content Is Corporate Trolls Manipulating Public Opinion
@dang the author has created yet another account
saltminer··on At Least 15% of Reddit Content Is Corporate Trolls Manipulating Public Opinion
None of the citations match the claims, either. The author appears to have made up one of its most important citations while misrepresenting the other [0], which is par for the course for this author [1][2][3][4].

[0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38700636

[1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38627266

[2]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38523309

[3]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38371060

[4]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38199597

saltminer··on At Least 15% of Reddit Content Is Corporate Trolls Manipulating Public Opinion
Wonderful.

I did some searching at my university's library to get a broader journal selection and cannot find anything related specifically to reddit disinfo campaigns beyond US elections, but even then, nothing to suggest a specific % of reddit posts are fake. Judging by the author's other works, they seem to be on par with Real Raw News for bullshit artistry.

Sadly, this fake news is spreading like wildfire: https://www.reddit.com/submit?url=https%3A%2F%2Fmedium.com%2...

saltminer··on At Least 15% of Reddit Content Is Corporate Trolls Manipulating Public Opinion
I can't even find the paper. The full article can be found at [0] and there is no citation for the study, just this:

> Two significant studies, the Pew Research Center study conducted in 2018 and the Computers in Human Behavior study published in 2020, have shed light on the prevalence and impact of corporate trolls on Reddit.

So I went looking for 2020 publications in the journal, and found 8 articles containing the word "reddit" [1], none of which were about corporate astroturfing.

[0]: https://archive.is/D60ep

[1]: https://www.sciencedirect.com/search?qs=reddit&pub=Computers...

Edit: When I include 2021, I get more articles from 2020, but still nothing related to corporate trolling on reddit or even just astroturfing on reddit in general.

Edit 2: The Pew study, on the other hand, is linked [3], but it's from 2017 and (from what I've skimmed) it doesn't talk about corporate trolling/disinfo other than to say that it happens and linking to news articles which are merely reporting on fake news and thus do not substantiate any percentage claims.

[3]: https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/2017/03/29/the-future-o...

Edit 3: I checked the reddit links cited as sources and none of them seem to support any percentage claims, either, just that disinformation campaigns exist and that trolling exists.

I have to wonder if the author is making stuff up as part of some broader agenda or is just trolling, because if this is just a troll, well played.

saltminer··on MusicXML
That sounds like a nightmare to deal with, I'm surprise you don't mention this in the comparison example for multiple voices.

Another suggestion: you highlight the MusicXML elements being discussed in blue, but not the MNX elements. Especially on the longer examples, highlighting the relevant MNX elements would be nice.

saltminer··on MusicXML
> MusicXML provides multiple ways of encoding the same musical concept, and some applications don't take the effort to check for all possible scenarios.

This sounded interesting, so I went to the webpage, and found this point specifically called out:

> It prioritizes interchange, meaning: it can be generated unambiguously, it can be parsed unambiguously, it favors one-and-only-one way to express concepts, and multiple programs reading the same MNX file will interpret it the same way.

But I'm curious to see some examples of this. https://w3c.github.io/mnx/docs/comparisons/musicxml/ provides an interesting comparison (and calls out how the same MusicXML can be interpreted in different ways for things like octave shifts), but it would be nice if the page also included alternate ways that MusicXML can represent the same composition and talk about how certain programs end up misinterpreting/misrepresenting them. The Parts comparison, for instance, mentions how you can represent the same thing in two different ways in MusicXML (score-timewise and score-partwise), but only provides an example for one (score-partwise), and doesn't go into much more detail about if this leads to ambiguity in interpretation or if it's just making things needlessly complex.

saltminer··on Half-Life: 25th Anniversary Documentary [video]
Is this available on Steam? I can't seem to find it on there. Or is this just the message you get when adding videos to your account on Steam?
saltminer··on Show HN: Trains.fyi – a live map of passenger trains in the US and Canada
If the NYC subway gets added, don't forget PATH trains!
saltminer··on VMware is now part of Broadcom
We are already seeing the squeeze from this. We have recently been informed they are dropping their academic list pricing entirely, which will cause many institutions to pay double or even triple what they do now. As a result, several major universities (specifically the Big Ten but I'm sure many others are as well) are looking into alternatives to reduce license costs ahead of next year's contract negotiations.

Source: Someone higher up in my department.

saltminer··on Broadcom and VMware Intend to Close Transaction on November 22, 2023
We have been informed they are dropping their academic list pricing entirely, which will cause many institutions to pay double or even triple what they do now. As a result, several major universities (specifically the Big Ten but I'm sure many others are as well) are looking into alternatives to reduce license costs ahead of next year's contract negotiations.

Source: Someone higher up in my department.

saltminer··on From email to phone number, a new OSINT approach (2019)
A bit late but I had completely forgotten about KDE Connect. Back when I last tried it, it did not filter out spam messages (though maybe Google Messages' spam filtering operates on its own layer and thus spam classifications are not reflected back in the OS SMS store, making it impossible for KDE Connect to know about them). Regardless, I get much less SMS spam these days, so maybe that'll be a viable option once more.
saltminer··on Half-Life 25th Anniversary Update
The Steam version is basically dead; WON is what most runners play. (Though it would be interesting if this revitalized the Steam categories.)

For those curious, you can download WON from https://www.speedrun.com/hl1/resources ("GoldSrc Package" and "Half-Life 2005 Package" are the builds allowed in the WON categories). You will need Half-Life on Steam to run them (which is currently free until Nov 20 - get it while you can).

← PreviousPage 2 of 12Next →