HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sarupbanskota

145 karma · joined December 22, 2013

ceo @ codecrafters.io (build your own bittorrent etc)
submissionscomments
sarupbanskota··on Launch HN: CodeCrafters (YC S22) – Practice writing complex software
Thank you! Our language support mechanism is OSS, and we welcome community contributions. It's designed in such a way that you don't strictly need to have knowledge of the course material to be able to add support for a language.

https://github.com/codecrafters-io/languages/blob/master/doc...

sarupbanskota··on Launch HN: CodeCrafters (YC S22) – Practice writing complex software
Thanks for your question. If I understand right, you mean for example projects that involve a frontend web component?

That's on the cards (e.g we have Build your own React on the pipeline). There are unique challenges to making that experience predictable, so we're focusing on the "console-based" projects for now. There's also often a "subjective" nature when reviewing/testing UI so we need to think through the ideal feedback workflow for courses with frontend components.

That said, I do wanna highlight that these courses do cover a lot of ground. I look forward to your feedback once you manage to get your hands on it!

sarupbanskota··on Launch HN: CodeCrafters (YC S22) – Practice writing complex software
Gotcha, I got this. I'm happy to spend some time on Figma hand-crafting a super slick certificate for you. Just reach out and ask!
sarupbanskota··on Launch HN: CodeCrafters (YC S22) – Practice writing complex software
Agreed!

One of the things we also hear frequently is: "I don't know what to build"

sarupbanskota··on Launch HN: CodeCrafters (YC S22) – Practice writing complex software
Thanks for your feedback here! While we don't offer lifetime plans currently, our quarterly and annual plans are one-time.
sarupbanskota··on Launch HN: CodeCrafters (YC S22) – Practice writing complex software
True. From our research and speaking with customers, many tech companies have learning / professional development budgets in the range of $500-$5000. Often they're trust-based, and self-directed, so engineers are free to spend them on whatever they feel helps them most with their growth.
sarupbanskota··on Launch HN: CodeCrafters (YC S22) – Practice writing complex software
Thanks for signing up, excited to see what you build! Our quarterly and annual plans are both one-time, so you should be good! I also verified your details on Stripe and can confirm this.
sarupbanskota··on Launch HN: CodeCrafters (YC S22) – Practice writing complex software
We do have user pages.

Here's an example of a real user's page, who's in-progress: https://codecrafters.io/users/jaredpalmer

And some examples of "completed" users: https://codecrafters.io/users/eyalfoni https://codecrafters.io/users/byarr

Do these help? Please feel free to drop me a brief note (sarup@codecrafters.io) and I'll be happy to help you write a compelling case for PD and also explore certificates.

sarupbanskota··on Launch HN: CodeCrafters (YC S22) – Practice writing complex software
Thanks for the ideas — you're right that automating the UI-oriented testing is more difficult. We're already piloting some ideas in this area (e.g Build your own React) — but the current focus is on perfecting what we have.

Our testers are all OSS. Here's our git tester for example — https://github.com/codecrafters-io/git-tester.

Others can be found on our GitHub org. https://github.com/codecrafters-io

We need to do a better job of exposing links to testers in our in-app UI — good feedback!

sarupbanskota··on Launch HN: CodeCrafters (YC S22) – Practice writing complex software
Yep! We support 14 languages, C# included.

https://app.codecrafters.io/tracks — full list here!

sarupbanskota··on Launch HN: CodeCrafters (YC S22) – Practice writing complex software
That gives me an idea for a tagline! "We explain the magic"
sarupbanskota··on Launch HN: CodeCrafters (YC S22) – Practice writing complex software
Thanks for your appreciation! I've touched on the pricing topic a bit here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32345899
sarupbanskota··on Launch HN: CodeCrafters (YC S22) – Practice writing complex software
Indeed, you're spot on!

Our current target is professional developers and teams with learning budgets.

Here are some reasons why experienced engineers have found value (the first expensed it, the second didn't):

1. One customer manages the Redis team at an infra company, and they used CodeCrafters as a starting point to get up-to-speed on Redis internals — to be able to do their job better. We ended up getting feedback from them on areas we could dive deeper on, to be useful to platform engineers in general.

2. A Distinguished Engineer at a Fortune 500 had built a database product before, and wanted to pick up a new language (Java, if I remember right). So they did our course because they preferred the "learning by doing" approach, and existing resources felt a bit too "hello world / todo-app"-ish.

sarupbanskota··on Launch HN: CodeCrafters (YC S22) – Practice writing complex software
I think we know what happened there (our message for the "close" button on the trial modal was confusing), and we've fixed it.

Please give it a try once more?

sarupbanskota··on Launch HN: CodeCrafters (YC S22) – Practice writing complex software
Thanks for your suggestion!

I've touched on the topic a little more here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32345899

sarupbanskota··on Launch HN: CodeCrafters (YC S22) – Practice writing complex software
Thanks for the kind words, and I appreciate your interest!

Our long-term intention is indeed to be able to help anyone who's interested to learn and grow regardless of their financial situation.

We also realise that not everyone has access to a learning budget. As an early-stage company, our pricing reflects what our current target audience is comfortable paying, and is also a test for long-term sustainability. Over time, we hope to be able to overcome pricing-related hurdles and enable broader access.

sarupbanskota··on Launch HN: CodeCrafters (YC S22) – Practice writing complex software
Thanks for the great question. We support ~14 languages at the moment and are working on adding more. You can visit our tracks page (https://app.codecrafters.io/tracks) to see the courses available against each language.

As a 2-person team, we're prioritising making a complete experience for Go, Python & JS for starters (our most popular languages).

So far, our tests are language agnostic. Our testers are written in Go (they’re open source, example: https://github.com/codecrafters-io/redis-tester). The testers interact with user code by testing for observable behaviour - exit codes, stdout/stderr, files written etc.

Although the testers are language-agnostic, a lot of the educational “content” is language-specific. We emit language-specific hints in stages where appropriate, and have expert solutions that are language-specific. A lot of this is new, so we might not have coverage across all challenges - this will improve over time.

Does that help explain our setup a little better?

sarupbanskota··on Launch HN: CodeCrafters (YC S22) – Practice writing complex software
Thank you for flagging, looks like you hit an edge case. We've pushed a fix, please try again?
sarupbanskota··on Launch HN: CodeCrafters (YC S22) – Practice writing complex software
Argh, I'm so sorry, our pricing page should have been clearer (fixed now).

The trial is available on all plans, so no need to ask the wife!

sarupbanskota··on Launch HN: CodeCrafters (YC S22) – Practice writing complex software
Of course! Please feel free to drop me an email, I love working with engineers to get their companies team accounts. It's even more fun with colleagues :)
sarupbanskota··on Launch HN: CodeCrafters (YC S22) – Practice writing complex software
Thanks for the kind words! We kind of stumbled into the language learning insight.

In the early days, we'd find folks sign up to do CodeCrafters because they had a "niche" job that involved knowing Redis or Docker internals (typically platform engineers at infra companies).

However, we saw that there were a set of engineers that would do all of our courses, then do redo some of them in different languages. We initially thought that to be strange (why re-learn the internals once you've already done it) — and they clarified they were in fact looking to pick up a new language.

Possibly my favorite customer call till date is a final year college student who didn't know what Redis was, had experience with C but none in Java — and within a few weeks times, he had learnt about what Redis was (and a bunch of backend concepts while he was at it), then it's internals, while learning Java at the same time

sarupbanskota··on Launch HN: CodeCrafters (YC S22) – Practice writing complex software
My Indian Mom thinks the pricing is outrageous
sarupbanskota··on Launch HN: CodeCrafters (YC S22) – Practice writing complex software
Indeed, you're right — it's companies where our engineer customers work. It's been a while since we looked at that list tho, so it probably could use a refresh!

For some companies on that list, we do have more than one engineer subscribing, and for in many cases we've spoken to them to learn about their motivations and feedback. We also have a Private Leaderboards feature for teams.

In the past few months, a nice small win for Paul and I is what we like to call the "Slack Share Effect".

It's when one of our users shares CodeCrafters within their company Slack, and then we notice multiple new users that work at the same company. When we get in touch with them, I always enjoy asking "how did the OP describe CodeCrafters on Slack?" and 100% of the time, I discover that customers do a better job describing CodeCrafters than we ourselves could. It's also how we uncover use-cases :)

sarupbanskota··on Launch HN: CodeCrafters (YC S22) – Practice writing complex software
Agreed. Who likes "talk to sales" :)

We have a pricing page — https://codecrafters.io/pricing, and do have it linked on our menu and footer. Would that help?

sarupbanskota··on Launch HN: CodeCrafters (YC S22) – Practice writing complex software
Thanks for the kind words!

The logos highlight companies where our customers (the engineers) work. Since we're early stage, so far it's more common for engineers to discover CodeCrafters, sign up by themselves, and expense it to their company. That might explain why you can't find information about subscription on the intranet.

We also do have cases where we work with companies to land team subscriptions, so if you'd be interested for us to engage with your company, feel free to drop me a note — sarup@codecrafters.io, and I'd love to help. It might be that the person you couldn't locate has moved on from the company, but I don't have a good explanation for why you couldn't find them on LinkedIn :-D If you emailed me, I could ask them and find out for you (for references, etc) — for most listed on the website, I've been in contact with them :)

sarupbanskota··on Launch HN: CodeCrafters (YC S22) – Practice writing complex software
Thank you for your kind words!

Until a few months back, we were focused solely on the "challenge" aspect of the product. Based on customer feedback, we've been making new features available that offer more guidance when you're stuck — a 2min preview is available on this demo video — https://codecrafters.io/videos/demo.

1. We show you expert-vetted code approaches for different languages in each stage, and also explain the interesting / difficult parts in the approach.

2. For further inspiration & knowledge, we now also include source walkthroughs for many of the stages, which link to how the official implementation does it. Here's one for Redis, which explains how the PING command is implemented (stage 2 of Redis). https://app.codecrafters.io/walkthroughs/redis-ping-command

sarupbanskota··on Launch HN: CodeCrafters (YC S22) – Practice writing complex software
I think doing the first 2-3 stages of any course is usually a good enough to understand the core for the learning experience. The later stages tend to get more involved (e.g the last stage of Git & SQLite are rather tricky for most).

Good suggestion regarding having trial projects for every language, we'll consider that.

sarupbanskota··on Launch HN: CodeCrafters (YC S22) – Practice writing complex software
Def enough time to complete a project with 1h/day, and you can also do it in "super deep dive mode" to take full advantage of the experience. We've definitely seen engineers do that.

For example, we're now starting to introduce source code walkthroughs. Here's one going over how the Redis event loop is implemented — https://app.codecrafters.io/walkthroughs/redis-event-loop.

So as you build out your Redis project, you can study in parallel how the official source does it, learn some cool facts, and overall spend more time developing fluency with the Redis docs.

One of the ways you could contribute is adding language support. If one of our courses doesn't support one of the languages you work with, you can add support for it here — https://github.com/codecrafters-io/languages.

sarupbanskota··on Launch HN: CodeCrafters (YC S22) – Practice writing complex software
Good assessment, lines up quite accurately with what we're seeing. In our post, when we said "experienced engineers", we meant more "folks with programming experience" and less "pro" users :) We've updated the post.

When we first started out, we didn't pay any attention to guidance at all, and instead focused entirely on the "challenge" aspect. At that time, it was less common for early career engineers to try out the product.

We've evolved a bit since, and now it's common for us to also see early career professionals, support engineers at devtool companies, bootcamp grads, etc. From time to time, we come across Engineering Managers who'll do our modules as a way to "stay in touch" with programming (and picking up a new language they'd been itching to learn — e.g Rust).

We're probably not suitable for someone new to programming, but otherwise all other levels are welcome and find value.

sarupbanskota··on Launch HN: CodeCrafters (YC S22) – Practice writing complex software
You're read correctly about the challenges available. A new one ships next week!

Today it takes us ~2 weeks to build the "core" parts of a challenge (planning, stage instructions, tester etc). From then on, the changes are incremental (adding support for more languages, better hints/instructions, getting experts to provide feedback on solutions etc).

Hard to say how much time the incremental changes take because they’re done over a span of months, but it’s definitely work. At times our community pitches in to add language support: https://github.com/codecrafters-io/languages

Paul also did a series of tweets when we were building the SQLite challenge if you’d like to see what the challenge-building process is like: https://twitter.com/RohitPaulK/status/1421517393780740100

← PreviousPage 4 of 5Next →