HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

saulpw

3,890 karma · joined August 6, 2021

You can email me at hackernews@saul.pw.
submissionscomments
saulpw··on It's still ok to enjoy programming
We were lucky for decades to get paid to do what we enjoy. Virtually no other field gets this. Maybe artists but note that very few artists make even a living from their work. So yes it sucks but as they say, "don't cry because it's over, smile because it happened".
saulpw··on It's still ok to enjoy programming
"Gathering mental capacity to simply know what next I need to do" is not a waste. That is work. In fact it is the most important work with LLMs. If you spend all day in a hammock dreaming up what next needs to be done (and it's the right stuff), and then type a few sentences into the LLM to generate it overnight, that is better time spent working than spending all day cranking out 20 PRs that are of mid-low value.
saulpw··on How employment is changing at Anthropic
> AI can make it very easy to do more and more busywork that doesn't move the needle.

I'm struck by the fact that the origin of the word "business" is "busy-ness".

saulpw··on Documents: Police officer gave her Flock login to her ICE agent husband
Also Cory does not have Qualified Immunity, and if Cory is caught doing this, Cory can be punished.
saulpw··on Personal software factories are a waste of time
Typescript was Microsoft and Swift was Apple, so those follow the same pattern of Go and Rust.

10 years is enough time. The industry was absolutely using Perl (1987) in 1997 and I was using Python (1991) professionally by 2003.

I mentioned Zig already; Julia also feels like it fizzled in a similar way, by getting attention without commensurate adoption.

But I will concede that you're right about Lean. It feels important that it's solving tomorrow's problem (i.e. today's) rather than yesterday's problem.

saulpw··on Personal software factories are a waste of time
AFAICT there have only been two programming languages that people rely on today that were created after the year 2000: Go and Rust. Both were sponsored by large organizations which had clear goals that drove the design and development. All other modern languages are not going anywhere. The days of Python and Ruby and Perl and PHP being personal projects that people created, that grew into widespread languages that other people use seriously, are over. (Zig feels like it's a potential counterexample, but it's already been 10 years; for every other language mentioned above, after 10 years they were clearly well along their adoption curve.)
saulpw··on Personal software factories are a waste of time
Depends. I say, let your needs drive your personal infrastructure. For example, I wanted to run Claude Code in YOLO mode 6 months ago, but I have lots of projects that I wanted to keep separate from one another (or at least be intentional about how they interact), and especially I wanted give some a set of permissions that they needed, but not this other set, and vice versa, and I could see them doing "grep -r" and "find $HOME" to just search over everything (with constant "I'm sorry, I exfiltrated these API tokens, so you need to rotate them"), so I built a little container setup to isolate them, and it's been working decently well for me and given me peace of mind when I let a project cook for a few hours.

Now I find that sometimes I do have tasks that I just want completed, and they're small or obvious or scoped enough that I know my role would be basically opening up a session and telling it to implement it and then asking another LLM for review and then fix the problems it found and then rubberstamp it--this is all for my personal setup so "QA" just involves me trying out the feature in my normal workflow anyway. So now I have a little miniature "software factory" that does the above, but without me needing to be in the loop. I press Alt+N and type e.g. "make TTS streaming" and continue about my other business, and in 5 minutes my text-to-speech setup has gone from nothing showing up until I toggle my push-to-talk switch, to words showing up at every pause.

I know it's not a bigco "software factory" but it serves my needs. And isn't that what this new era is about? We have a magic genie that grants wishes as long as they're well-enough defined and it's connected to the right other pieces to make it happen. So create an internal process that allows that genie to grant your wishes reliably and in bulk. What else is a "software factory" anyway?

saulpw··on My old job feels distant now
Keep your identity small[0].

[0] https://www.paulgraham.com/identity.html

saulpw··on My old job feels distant now
> What is needed is a human at the beginning, to decide what needs to be done - and a human at the end, to decide whether it’s finished.

I've been thinking the same, this is very well put.

saulpw··on 90% of US working hours are spent on tasks not covered well by AI benchmarks
diskprices.com, I was going to say $500 but looked it up before posting.
saulpw··on 90% of US working hours are spent on tasks not covered well by AI benchmarks
I'm pretty cynical about the outcomes of capitalism in general. But I can buy a new 10TB HD for $300. Or a gigabit internet connection for $100/mo. Think back 10 or 20 years. How is this not a radical price-per-bit decrease for consumers?
saulpw··on I sold all my SP500 yesterday morning
Yup, I learned all too late in life that it's not really about buying and selling, but about allocation. Sounds like they dramatically increased their allocation of (US) cash? I don't think that sounds like a better place to park your money right now..
saulpw··on I let an AI run my startup for a week
Children prefer to have a stable home, food on the table, and a camper van to travel in with their family. They just don't know it until those things aren't available.

Not saying their Dad was right, often client work feels more urgent than it is. But Dad probably internalized "need to make sure business is taken care of so I can support my family" and that is what it looked like.

saulpw··on Where is all the new, good software?
Same here. I'm making more software than ever, for myself, and I'm finding it incredibly useful. But even though I've been a proud open-source software developer, I'm not releasing this new code because I don't see the value in it: I won't get the credit (because I "only" designed it, and didn't write the code), nor will anyone else use it, and if they did use it, I wouldn't want another maintenance burden for myself. So it stays private.
saulpw··on The gap in shared understanding of LLM capability is widening
I'm also amazed at the abilities of AI when I can verify them. But, how do you know that Claude is right about your dishwasher? I mean you're not that much worse off if it's wrong (compared with a similar medical query), but isn't this a case of trusting the AI without verification, just because it looks correct and was stated confidently?
saulpw··on Grieving the loss of details
You're crazy, I'm...not even arguing. You'll see that even in the course of this one thread that I've been quite ambivalent. And I've already talked with Claude about it plenty, and few ideas that feel workable in our present climate. I don't feel like I'm "ignorant" but then we never do, right? Would love some pointers to ideas. What you got? Communism? Georgism? UBI?
saulpw··on Grieving the loss of details
Throwing shoes into the mechanism doesn't seem to have done anything but coin a new word. But I'm all ears! What other options do you see that could work at a larger-than-village scale?
saulpw··on Grieving the loss of details
The only people who even somewhat successfully resisted industrialization are the Amish. Is that what we should be doing, forming religious communities that are increasingly isolated from the rest of humanity? Unable to contribute meaningfully to the discourse, but still subject to the externalities of the dominant paradigm?
saulpw··on Grieving the loss of details
You mean like all the benefits of industrialization? The real externalized human/environmental costs of our fast/cheap fashion, of our iPhones, of cars, of electricity, of agriculture?

I saw a video today, talking about how this is really the end goal of what we've been working towards for 200 years. Automation and scale and convenience uber alles. As structured it's not a good idea and it seems that Dr. Kaczynski wasn't wrong in diagnosis, only in the treatment. But here we are and we're pretty pot-committed, so I guess we have to see for ourselves what's on the other side.

saulpw··on Sorry, I'm in a meeting
It's like the old 'Boss' screen in 80s videogames. It's a thin veneer so that anything just cruising to see if you're available will be deterred.
saulpw··on Margaret Hamilton has died
This feels like a black bar event. RIP Margaret Hamilton.
saulpw··on JetBrains reports revenue growth, net financial loss for 2025
But you learned English (or some other human language) before either of those..
saulpw··on Anthropic reported diary entry to police, woman faces felony charge
I think you should be allowed to write that exact line in your journal. If you rob the bank that can be used as evidence against you, but in no way is it acceptable for private reflections alone to be used to arrest you. Or else every author who's written a novel with 'bad' characters would be arrestable.
saulpw··on LeCun has "zero concerns" about AI wiping out humanity, recent "rogue" incidents
The AI cannot smell a rose, nor mourn the loss of a parent, nor envision a more just world. These aren't fringe abilities of the human brain/mind either, they've been pretty definitional.
saulpw··on Show HN: Timeline of the Far Future
we aren't even a type 1 civilization yet, and type 2 is 10 orders of magnitude greater in terms of power usage.
saulpw··on Our AI Midwife
I mean if "AI medicine via chatbot" gets better results than the human medical system, I'd say that vindicates it..
saulpw··on Celebrating the 100th birthday of the kidney donated to him as a teenager
Could you have gotten it back after he passed away? Or was the kidney forwarded on to someone else?
saulpw··on To grieve, or not to grieve?
Isn't it remarkable that this works? I wouldn't have thought so either, and yet here we are.
saulpw··on Show HN: Timeline of the Far Future
I found the first part engaging, but some of the animations were on a timer instead of the scroller and went too fast, I couldn't read them.
saulpw··on Is Claude Conscious?
And let's grant consciousness to elephants and pigs and orcas before we grant it to silicon.
← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →