HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

saulrh

6,105 karma · joined March 13, 2011

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/saulrh; my proof: https://keybase.io/saulrh/sigs/mU5eGace0cFoKIiAp-sVGuZ6iwF9V_AhysRP_3SEG-E ]

I have yet to find a way to retract a misclick on the "flag" button, much to my annoyance.

submissionscomments
saulrh··on A Bendy RISC-V Processor
> 1) How would wiring to you processor work?

My (relatively limited) experience is that this is what really makes wearable projects obnoxious.

Even if you have a chip with a tiny footprint, you either put it on a breakout board that isn't tiny or you spend twenty hours soldering nearly microscopic bits of magnet wire to it. It's the same for the piles of passive components and peripherals that every project requires, the voltage regulators and smoothing capacitors and power transistors and stuff: You either attach everything to a big PCB or you're faced with a spaghetti nightmare of point-to-point wiring that makes "normal" dead-bug circuitry, the kind you might find embedded in a block of resin for aesthetic points, look like a walk in the park.

Flexible processors don't necessarily solve that problem, but they definitely demonstrate that flexible circuits in general are advancing in useful ways, better signal quality and longer runs and better process yield. The bigger these things get the better they are for replacing that mess of integration spaghetti that I always see DIY wearable projects suffering from.

(I think that industrial wearables typically solve this by concentrating everything complicated down to a rigid brain-box, c.f. smart-watches or those heated jackets that have a socket for a power tool battery in the pocket.)

saulrh··on U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issues broad injunction
Even when you're in a major international market like the United States it's frequently the case that books are nearly unobtainable, especially if they're older or limited printings of specialist material. Sometimes I'll get recommended an old SF book or a particular reference manual and it turns out that it had one run in 1985 and there are four copies available on the used market at prices between three hundred and three thousand dollars. Tons of works are one minor complication, like living in the southern hemisphere or not being rich, away from being effectively non-existent.
saulrh··on U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issues broad injunction
Unconditional basic income. Grants for the arts. Stipends. Unconditional basic income. Sponsorships. Unconditional basic income. Donations. Maybe even unconditional basic income.

Look, no artistic endeavor needs to make a billion dollars. Even when something does take a billion dollars in revenue, none of it goes to the artists anyway! Music labels and movie studios and book publishers are infamous for creative accounting and bogus contracts and outright lies to fuck over almost every person that actually contributed to the art. They're worse than politicians. It's all there to funnel even more money to people who are already rich. If you put artists on basic income you're not paying them any less, you're not losing anything, 99.9% of them come out ahead of where they would've been if they'd sold their work for money. Maybe add a couple more nines to that list. For every multimillionaire movie star or generation-defining author there are literally hundreds of thousands of artists just barely scraping by. Capitalist art only benefits the leeches.

saulrh··on Ask HN: Sci-fi recommendations by non-western authors?
So, I intentionally refrained from recommending any specific works for "novel perspective", and I'll hold to that: There are just too many different angles for me to cover, my recommendations would be relatively low-quality in many places because I'm not an expert in all domains, and there's no real way for me to provide anything like a "primer" because the entire point is to get hyper-specific rather than easing people into things or starting with general coverage. If you're looking for novel perspectives, just keep digging. The key is that you probably won't find much that's particularly unusual in the top-rated lists because the top-rated lists filter for mass appeal in the same way that mass market paperback publishing does. As a specific example, Royal Road's community is infamous for leaving bigoted one-star reviews on anything with queer characters. Instead, you'll want to move sideways through things like AO3's tagging system and the shout-outs that RR authors put in their after-chapter notes.

For general introductions to amateur fiction and fanfiction, though, though, I'm happy to share my starter recommendations. These are just plain good fiction. You can find a lot of other good works starting from these.

* Xenoethnography (https://archiveofourown.org/series/913458): Optimus Prime, realizing that there are people whose job is facilitating cultural understanding, hires an ethnographer to live among the refugee Transformers and document their culture. Familiarity with Transformers not required. This one probably is a pretty good work for the refugee/immigrant perspective.

* Katalepsis (https://katalepsis.net/): A serial web novel about cosmic horror and human fragility, urban fantasy and lesbian romance.

* Super Supportive (https://www.royalroad.com/fiction/63759/super-supportive): Hopeful, sometimes cozy sometimes harrowing commentary on trauma, colonialism, sacrifice, and self-actualization. It takes its time about it, but IMO it's worth it.

* To The Stars (https://archiveofourown.org/works/777002/chapters/1461984): Old Man's War, guest starring Iain Banks and Greg Egan... as a Puella Magi Madoka Magica fanfic. It's shockingly deep and twisty. You do ~need to watch PMMM first, but that's absolutely stellar too, and I have no reservations recommending both.

* Divided Loyalties (https://forums.sufficientvelocity.com/threads/warhammer-fant...): Swords-and-sorcery diplomatic intrigue with a heavy helping of worldbuilding. Familiarity with WHF not required.

* Bioshifter (https://www.royalroad.com/fiction/59450/bioshifter/chapter/1...): A story about love, self-acceptance, neurodivergency, and a whole lot of trauma. Seriously, it's extremely good, but also super rough to read.

* Lieutenant Fusilier in the Farthest Reaches (https://forums.sufficientvelocity.com/threads/lieutenant-fus...): Lesbian war robot questions her purpose while coping with the fact that the humans keep themselves busy in the post-scarcity space-future by cosplaying as victorian english nobles.

* The Commonweal, starting with The March North, by Graydon Saunders (https://dubiousprospects.blogspot.com/2018/09/where-to-get-m...): How to build a good place to live when physics hates you and every other polity is an expansionist totalitarian sorcerer-kingdom, featuring radical egalitarianism, military ethics, and eldritch spider granny weatherwax. The least amateur thing here, but I'm pretty sure still traditionally unpublishable - the text is aggressively dense and elliptical.

saulrh··on Ask HN: Sci-fi recommendations by non-western authors?
Other people are covering the big names, so I'll throw in a suggestion in completely the opposite direction: Large portions of the fanfiction and online amateur fiction community, even in English, are international. Even the Western authors frequently bring minority perspectives. Amateur fiction and especially fanfiction doesn't have to be accepted by a publisher or get through editing, so they're free to explore topics and reinterpretations that would be anathema to marketing and PR and the need to make a profit.
saulrh··on Big Pharma claims lower prices means giving up miracle medications. Ignore them
If funding pharmaceutical research is a common public interest, then it should be funded the way all common public interests should be: taxes. Taxes pay for the weather predictions that make modern agriculture possible. Taxes pay for the basic physics research that keeps Moore's Law on track. Taxes pay for the transportation and logistics infrastructure that make the modern economy possible. Taxes pay for the fire engines that might keep your house from burning down some day. Taxes can and should pay for the pharmaceutical research that makes modern medicine effective. This kind of generalized "everybody needs it but no single person can pay for it and trying to do it through capitalism distorts everything" benefit is precisely what taxes are designed for.
saulrh··on Ask HN: 19yr old child suffering from internet gaming disorder? Any suggestions?
If you're calling a B average at a nationally-ranked EE/CS program, plus an internship, "insufficient", then, bluntly, their behavior is probably an attempt to escape from the pressure that your expectations put them under. Roblox is not that engaging, as games go; the only way someone can be attached to it for 12 hours a day is if everything else in their life is worse.

So one thing to do is to ask yourself: Why would they dislike their internship and so much? Did they want that internship with that company? Are they doing a degree that matches their interests, or are they doing it because it's "good for their future"? I'd ask if they have any hobbies, but clearly they don't have any that you recognize as such, so instead I'll ask if you've ever prevented them from pursuing a hobby because it was a "distraction" or "expensive" or it "wouldn't get them a job". I'm not saying that you're necessarily wrong about, say, teaching history not being stable employment, but I am saying that maybe they'd be throwing themselves into a performing arts or english degree in a way that they aren't engaged with an engineering degree. And why are they living in your house while doing a degree and internship, anyway? Have you "known" where they were going to go to school long enough to have moved there years ago, or did you move to follow them when they selected a school? Would they be hanging out with their friends in the evening if they lived in the dorms?

Whatever comes out of that, be very careful how you talk to them about it. It'd be all too easy for them to repeat back what you've been pushing at them their entire life, reinforcing the stresses that they're seeking to escape. Get them a counselor or therapist and then guarantee them the privacy they need to discuss their problems honestly and openly with that counselor or therapist, without you hovering over them. Like. Leave and go grocery shopping during their appointment. And whatever you do, don't cut off the video games; if they weren't gaming right now, they'd probably be doing drugs or joining a gang or the like.

Source: I internalized expectations from my parents and mentors that were not realistic or healthy and have struggled with them my entire adult life. I find myself using video games to escape from stress and burnout.

saulrh··on DARPA wants to bypass the thermal middleman in nuclear power systems
I meant precisely what I said. Tracking NiCads to the standards of the NPT would presumably be impossible. If your standard is "keep it out of the food supply", though, I guarantee that there's a little bit of NiCad in that hot dog in your fridge, and there'd be much less NiCad in your hot dog if they tripped a radiation detector before they hit the incinerator or the landfill.
saulrh··on DARPA wants to bypass the thermal middleman in nuclear power systems

    Not dangerous unless broken up and
    ingested, but need to be kept out
    of the food chain.
No worse than a NiCad in that respect. Probably better, if anything, since it's so much easier to detect and track.
saulrh··on Researchers discover a new form of scientific fraud: 'sneaked references'
Extracting the key definition:

  These additional references were only in the
  metadata, distorting citation counts and
  giving certain authors an unfair advantage.
Papers with metadata that doesn't match the contents of the paper. The article notes that Google Scholar is unaffected, as it extracts citations from the paper itself by parsing the text of the printed bibliography.
saulrh··on Dear Roku, you ruined my TV
You can put any android TV into dumb mode ("Basic TV") during setup, which disables many-most of the smart features without affecting core display functionality: https://support.google.com/googletv/answer/10408998?hl=en.
saulrh··on Silicon Valley's best kept secret: Founder liquidity
The founders I've known were already wealthy when they decided to do a startup. They aren't at risk because even if the startup falls through without making a cent they have enough money in their bank account to withdraw $200k/year for thirty years. There's no risk there.
saulrh··on Ask HN: Machine learning engineers, what do you do at work?
There were a couple "not prod" environments, but they were either replicated directly from prod or so poorly maintained that they were unusable (empty tables, wrong schemas, off by multiple DB major versions, etc), no middle ground. So institutional culture was to just run everything against prod (for bare selects that could be copied and pasted into the textbox in the prod-access web tool) or a prod replica (for anything that needed a db connection). The training docs actually did specify Real Production, and first-week tasks included gaining Real Production access. If I walked in and was handed that training documentation today I'd raise hell and/or quit on the spot, but that was my first job out of college - it was basically everyone's first job out of college, they strongly preferred hiring new graduates - and I'd just had to give up on my PhD so I didn't have the confidence, energy, or pull to do anything about it, even bail out.

That was also the company where prod pushes happened once a month, over the weekend, and were all hands on deck in case of hiccups. It was an extraordinarily strong lesson in how not to organize software development.

(edit: if what you're really asking is "did every engineer have write access to production", the answer was, I believe, that only managers did, and they were at least not totally careless with it. not, like, actually responsible, no "formal post-mortem for why we had to use break-glass access", but it generally only got brought out to unbreak prod pushes. Still miserable.)

saulrh··on Ask HN: Machine learning engineers, what do you do at work?
> HIPAA my left foot.

That was my experience as well - training documentation for fresh college grads (i.e. me) directed new engineers to just... send SQL queries to production to learn. There was a process for gaining permissions, there were audit logs, but the only sign-off you needed was your manager, permission lasted 12 months, and the managers just rubber-stamped everyone.

That was ten years ago. Every time I think about it I find myself hoping that things have gotten better and knowing they haven't.

saulrh··on How do our brains adapt to control an extra body part?
https://www.noisebridge.net/images/9/91/Jne5_4_r02.pdf and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_Bach-y-Rita are probably what you're looking for.
saulrh··on How do our brains adapt to control an extra body part?
Yeah. If you ever thought it was annoying to have to spend two hours on the phone to get Comcast to cancel your internet, imagine how much it would suck to try to do that with a sign language interpreter sitting next to you, or with text-to-speech and speech-to-text systems in the loop.
saulrh··on Signal: Will leave the EU market rather than undermine our privacy guarantees
> there is no way to verify that it works in the way that it does

Since we're specifically talking about Signal, I think that it's worth mentioning that Signal is uniquely predictable here. They published their entire cryptosystem, it's been extensively inspected by the cryptography community, there are multiple open-source implementations that agree with the published mathematics, and I strongly suspect that more than a few people have sat down to verify that the bytes coming out of the app are actually produced by the published protocols. Claiming that that's not "working the way it does" is reaching out into territory along the lines of Trusting Trust, the unproven existence of trapdoor functions, and the Problem of Induction.

saulrh··on How do our brains adapt to control an extra body part?
This is absolutely the case - in software, accessibility features are in many cases identical to power user and engineering quality features. Color-theme support is necessary functionality for color vision deficiency modes, labels and tags on UI elements enable screen-readers just as much as they enable automated testing suites, configurable keybindings make it easier to get your app working with assistive input devices. It's such a strong relationship that even bigcorps know it's a thing; I got talks about it during Google employee trainings.
saulrh··on Ticketmaster confirms data breach with a SEC filing
Does anyone know what "fraud details" are? Is this just ("just", I say) the answers to security questions, or is this, like, your mother's maiden name and every address you've ever lived at and all the other stuff that would let anyone on earth open a bank account in your name?
saulrh··on Ask HN: Why do games companies not release source code for old games?
> In a lot of cases it would involve tossing an incomplete bunch of code over > the wall with few instructions about actually using it. Which is > probably not what the recipients had in mind.

Minecraft modders deobfuscate and decompile the game every time Mojang publishes a new release so that mods have the symbols to link against. There are way more people out there who want to play old games and have the skills necessary to modernize a game's codebase than there are making those engines, and they have more time and better-aligned incentives. Essentially every game I know of that's been open-sourced has had someone put in the time to get it building again, even things that barely anyone played. Heck, popular frequently have full-blown from-scratch remakes, c.f. the Spring Engine, OpenTTD, OpenRCT2, StepMania.

saulrh··on Cognitive reflection, intelligence, and cognitive abilities: A meta-analysis
You're exercising your cognition. It's no surprise that the acute effects include exhaustion. The long term effects are you have stronger cognition.
saulrh··on Computer scientists invent an efficient new way to count
Huh, that's a clever twist on reservoir sampling. Neat.
saulrh··on Romance author gets locked out of Google Docs for "inappropriate" content
Having built tools to organize and drive human curation, human review only means that you get different errors and different people get fired as scapegoats. When you're doing content moderation, rather than simple data curation, you don't even get "far" better results - you frequently get worse results! - and you start traumatizing your moderators enough to destroy them. On top of that, who the fuck would ever use a product if their private notepad was going to be read by a human moderator? There is no easy answer here.
saulrh··on FDA: Do Not Use Cue Health's Covid-19 Tests Due to Risk of False Results
COVID is still an order of magnitude more immediately deadly than the usual influenza strain. Furthermore, influenza basically either kills you or it doesn't; COVID continues to have a horrible habit of leaving young and perfectly healthy people permanently disabled.
saulrh··on 2.4M person study: Internet use boosts, not hurts, well being
Which is why you need high-quality and large-scale data on the relationship between income and internet usage and the relationship between income and happiness so you can chain those together and subtract the whole thing out. Yes, error bars stack up rapidly. That's why you need 2 million data points to get a reasonable conclusion, when you only need ~1000 to get high-quality information on things like consumer preferences or political affiliations. Good thing that we have plenty of people that are very interested in things like "how much happier does money make you" and full-scale datasets like that are produced on a regular basis!

Really, the math isn't any harder than what's necessary to land a rocket screaming along at mach 8 or reverse a couple terabytes of voltage readings into a nice clean volumetric medical image.

saulrh··on Show HN: A web debugger an ex-Cloudflare team has been working on for 4 years
The benefits of SSO kick in way faster than you'd think, in some cases before you even have a company, much less revenue. I could easily see a Hackerspace wanting SSO, for example, and adding an SSO tax of fifty dollars a month would double membership costs. Then there's stuff like https://twitter.com/NireBryce/status/1564100084652036096.
saulrh··on Ask HN: Seeking ideas for preschool/school projects
Minecraft has a mod called ComputerCraft, which adds lua-powered computers to the game. They can read various state from the world, like redstone levels and chest contents, and move things between chests and set redstone outputs and play sound and etc. You can also upgrade them into turtles, which can move around and mine blocks and stuff. It's a nice environment for basic robotics programming with immediate feedback.

(IIRC there's theoretically an "educational edition" of this, but I don't know if I'd put much stock in that; you're close enough and personalizing the learning enough that you're probably better off just using the normal mod.)

saulrh··on Shell sold carbon credits for carbon that was never captured
The EPA. OSHA and per-state equivalents. The part of the FDA that inspects production lines. The FSIS. The NTSB. The USCSB. Essentially every individual city, municipal area, and state has its own health inspection service that shuts down unclean restaurants to keep them from killing people. Seriously, I listed Upton Sinclair's The Jungle for a reason, this is not a theoretical concern, this actually happens to this day and we know what it looks like when we don't have people dealing with it. This is not just something we can do, it's something we actually do, continuously and successfully, at every scale of government. This problem has known solutions that are reliable enough that every single city in the country has successfully implemented them.
saulrh··on Shell sold carbon credits for carbon that was never captured
You absolutely can measure that, in the same way that you measure that manufacturers are producing cars that don't emit nitrogen oxides above regulated limits or that manufacturers aren't dumping cadmium into nearby rivers or that worksites aren't making employees work on telephone poles without safety gear: You have an organization that reads all the relevant research, develops tests, runs those tests, and is empowered to Apply Consequences To violators. You don't trust some anonymous "bureaucrats", you trust a dedicated organization of subject matter experts and specialist inspectors that know how things are supposed to work and understand all the dodgy tricks that people are going to pull. This is how we went from The Jungle and Silent Spring and the hole in the ozone layer to where we are today. This approach works.
saulrh··on As private equity dominates wheelchair market, users wait months for repairs
Yeah. Don't complain about regulation existing. Complain about regulations being controlled by private equity. Complain about private equity existing. Complain about capitalism. Not about the existence of government.
← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →