HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

scarcely

30 karma · joined September 11, 2018

submissionscomments
scarcely··on British Telecom bars Huawei's 5G kit from core of network
They always make sure to put a TON of "citations” in their comments too lmao.
scarcely··on The “bicameral mind” 30 years on: A reappraisal of Jaynes’ hypothesis (2007)
Agreed. It's not for nothing we talk about "thinking out loud". That suggests that there is some kind of vague awareness that thinking and speaking are not fundamentally different activities (compare: "feeling aroused/jealous out loud" which doesn't even make sense)

Sometimes I wonder if human acquired the ability to "silently" think thoughts only recently. That the ability to silently think evolved much like how the ability to silently read evolved (even today I sometimes run into country folks who have little ability to read without audibly reading, or cannot transfer their password from phone to computer without broadcasting it to everyone around)

Presumably audible thinking and audible reading were the original forms. Then silent thinking and silent reading evolved because of their obvious utility (it's fitness enhancing to be able to hide your thoughts from your enemy blah blah)

scarcely··on Ask HN: What heuristic made a big difference to your life?
Unhappiness with my own life causes increased interest in politics and decreased interest in technology, math, philosophy, literature ...

I use it as a warning signal.

scarcely··on Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real
Though worth pointing out "political" is ambiguous and that this a case of politics in the "office politics" sense not in the "use science to justify policy" sense
scarcely··on I’m Chinese, Google’s DragonFly Must Go On
Chinese people criticize the government/party all the time when talking to each other. What even was your perception of the situation that would lead you to talk about "outing" lmao
scarcely··on Samsung's folding screen tech has been stolen and sold to China
You are what
scarcely··on I’m Chinese, Google’s DragonFly Must Go On
If you see no difference between the Chinese government and the Nazi government, you should perhaps consider advocating for war (unless you are a non-interventionist)
scarcely··on Show HN: The Reader View of Wikipedia
Why are people so aggressive towards each other on this website lmao
scarcely··on Twitter’s Kafka adoption story
Results about Apache Kafka are of interest only to a subgroup of software engineers. Results about Franz Kafka are of interest to a much larger group of people (Frankly, there is simply no comparison). It's the considerate thing to do.

And it's not simply a matter of the ordinary person having to type an extra word. There exist tons of valuable web resources (literary analysis, criticism, journal articles) out there about the novelist that does not contain "Franz" anywhere.

Finally, it's not like there's an absolute need for any piece of software to be given any particular name.

scarcely··on Tracking China's Muslim Gulag
Because if someone tells me not to do X, yet he himself would do X in the same circumstances, that's reason to think his behavior does not stem from a sincere moral conviction but is a cynical attempt to manipulate me?
scarcely··on Tracking China's Muslim Gulag
It didn't help that "China is locking up Uighurs" is the news title used everywhere.
scarcely··on Tracking China's Muslim Gulag
Given that "China is locking up Uyghurs" is the title used pretty much everywhere, I think you may be onto something. :)
scarcely··on Tracking China's Muslim Gulag
Would you say the same thing about those from Muslim countries who have engaged in terrorist activities against the US? Many of them travelled half of the globe over to carry out the attack and many were willing to sacrifice their own lives.
scarcely··on Tracking China's Muslim Gulag
The factor lying at the root of everything is that China's government is fundamentally illegitimate from the West's point of view. Because of this perceived illegitimacy, when a violent bombing/stabbing incident happens, the default assumption (so the West insists) to make is that it's an case of oppressed subjects fighting for freedom; the burden of proof is on the Chinese government to show that it's a genuine act of terrorism. Likewise when activity purporting to be terrorism prevention measures take place, the default assumption to make is that it's an attempt at ethnic cleansing ala Nazi Germany, the burden of proof is on the China government to show otherwise. At bottom it's a disagreement over where the burden of proof is located. Because both sides are operating with different standards of evidence it's a dispute that's basically impossible to resolve.
scarcely··on Twitter’s Kafka adoption story
Slightly off topic, but I feel that when naming one's technical creation it's best to avoid using the last names of famous people especially when that person has become so famous it's become standard to refer to him/her simply by last name. Just google "Kafka" and check out the first page of search results and you'll see what I mean. (No, googling "Franz Kafka" isn't the same)
scarcely··on China Expands Research Funding, Luring U.S. Scientists and Students
When I was little a game I would often play with myself is to switch on the Pinyin IME, keep pressing random keys for a minute or two, and then try to make sense of the ridiculous stuff I typed out. It was a lot of fun because you can always make some kind of sense of it.
scarcely··on China Expands Research Funding, Luring U.S. Scientists and Students
I'm sure he's not a monster. Thing is, Americans find it very hard to see us as anything other than monsters. It's exhausting to try and have a conversation when the interlocutor is ready to terminate it at any point because s/he decides that you are either evil or brainwashed. (To me, that's where the real prejudice lies - the inability to imagine other people as moral, not just intellectual, equals)

I should also say that the distinction between "criticizing government" and "criticizing people" is routinely not observed, even by Democrats. When Obama was making a case for the TPP, one of the main argument he gave was "The TPP would let America, not China, lead the way on global trade". Zero-sum language like this sends a signal to Americans that if doing something X is bad for this other group of humans, then that's an argument in favor of doing X, not (crazy thought!) an argument against doing it. That's how you get to where we are now where prominent Democrats like Chuck Schumer can say "we must be united in our fight against the Chinese" and not a single American, liberal or conservative, even took issue with that kind of language.

scarcely··on China Expands Research Funding, Luring U.S. Scientists and Students
As a Chinese person the thing I find most dispiriting is that, if this comment had been made in a slightly more subtle and polished way (without a Hitler comparison right at the start, for one thing) it would have received a lot more upvotes and given a lot more credence
scarcely··on We are Google employees – Google must drop Dragonfly
As a Chinese living abroad, I censor my internet voluntarily via custom ublock cosmetic filters that kick in automatically upon match of certain regex patterns. I call it my "outer great firewall". Very effective protection against hate speech
scarcely··on We are Google employees – Google must drop Dragonfly
Well, presumably the ideas we are talking about are political/social/moral views. To base your acceptance/rejection of them, even in part, on your knowledge of their genesis is already quite intellectually lazy. ("John made such and such claim about topic X. When I consider the claim's intrinsic merits I'm not complete sure what I should think, but given these biographical knowledge I have of John I accept/reject the claim" is only acceptable reasoning when X is an empirical topic (say about genetics) but not when it's a moral/political one)
scarcely··on We are Google employees – Google must drop Dragonfly
Ah! My bad for not realizing that. I would only add that those who give so much weight to tone/delivery heuristics are also to blame. But I see your point, I feel similarly frustrated sometimes and I can definitely imagine myself acting the same way you did.
scarcely··on We are Google employees – Google must drop Dragonfly
You can literally make this argument anywhere.

Any good China does for its people or for other nations? That will just serve to legitimize their totalitarian government and encourage imitations abroad. Ergo it's bad.

In general it's better to state your fundamental premises at the beginning of the argument rather than reveal them midway through

scarcely··on We are Google employees – Google must drop Dragonfly
they hold different views? (they were born in China? they are brainwashed : no they can't possibly hold different views)

It's futile to explain yourself to someone if the person will just declare you "brainwashed" if you don't agree with them

scarcely··on We are Google employees – Google must drop Dragonfly
I'm not a programmer, I'm an academic. Topics in my academic specialty routinely get posted on HN. When they do, I browse the comments section, look for users who exhibit many signs of lacking rigor and/or intellectual honesty, and add to my filter accordingly, on the grounds that their opinions on programming topics are probably not worth reading either.

I'm also a Chinese person. China matters is like an extra AOS for me and so I apply cosmetic filters for the same reasons

scarcely··on We are Google employees – Google must drop Dragonfly
I don't think the user you are responding intends his comment to be putting forward some watertight argument. It sounds light-hearted to me. It's puzzling to me that you'd pick on this one particular comment to produce a detailed, five-point rebuttal in a thread like this one where there are so many other more important targets to go after.
scarcely··on We are Google employees – Google must drop Dragonfly
Censorship has its uses. I often open these China threads on HN just to add users to my cosmetic filter.
scarcely··on We are Google employees – Google must drop Dragonfly
> and believe me, the later is much worse for a westerner.

"Believe me" signals to me that I'm about to hear something shocking, yet it's followed by the anticlimactic "for a Westerner".

scarcely··on I still miss my headphone jack, and I want it back
Maybe your baby ate the dongle?
scarcely··on The Burning of Library.nu (2014)
I agree that our intuitive reaction is to think that in one case there is clearly a victim whereas in the other case this is much less clear. However as I said when I brought up the omnivore vs dog/cat-eater example, our intuitive moral reactions are often unreliable and we need to always subject them to critical examination.

When I ask myself, why does it seem to me, intuitively, that there is clearly a victim in the case of espionage but not in the case of piracy, I find that I cannot point to anything other than the sheer "graphical" character of espionage. When I think of espionage what comes to mind is careful, deliberate, calculated planning and execution (the evil villain in cartoons and all that), whereas when I think of piracy I think of a harmless dude at home sitting in front of his computer wrapped in bathrobes.

The question though is whether this sort of difference has moral relevance. And I'm strongly inclined to think not. First notice that neither the spy nor the harmless dude physically harmed anyone. The damage is entirely monetary. (I will spare your American sensibilities and not bring up the violent character of those thefts I brought up in my OP).

Now you may say, the harmless dude at best cost a few dollars damage but the spy cost billions. But on reflection this doesn't hold water, because (i) there are millions of these harmless dudes, so the damages add up and (ii) the damage caused by the spy is not on any single individual but is also similarly distributed, so at the individual level it could may well be very tiny.

I could go on, but I hope you'll agree that the challenge I've poses for Americans (how to reconcile their different attitudes towards piracy and industrial espionage) is far from a trivial one and it's intellectually dishonest to pretend otherwise.

I should also add the following point. Suppose in the future 3D duplication became a reality, so that those who want more KFC can just buy one and perform 3D "copy-paste" (sitting at home wrapped in bathrobes) - no need to steal the secret recipe. Likewise to get one more advanced CPU there is no need to spy and steal the secret blueprint and all that, just 3D "copy paste".

Would you say that, in this future scenario, where making copies of fried chicken/CPU chips are no different from making copies of ebook and mp3s ─── would you say that these acts of "IP theft" also suddenly become virtually "victimless"?

(Typing in a hurry so some editing may need to be done later on)

Addendum: a variant of my parting example above. Programs written in some languages (e.g. Javascript) are much easier to reverse engineer than others (e.g. C). To get the source code of a closed source C program you pretty much have to conduct espionage (hack the developer's computer), whereas to get the source code of a closed source JavaScript program, it may take little more than hitting a few buttons.

Would you argue that if someone's closed source C app source code is stolen via espionage/hacking, the developer has been victimized, but if someone's closed source JavaScript app source code is stolen via "hitting a few buttons", there is now suddenly no victim? It seems to me that holding such a view would have some absurd consequences. Suppose I can write an app in either C or JavaScript, I may then reason: "I should write it in JavaScript, that way I won't ever be victimized." - which I hope you'll agree, is clearly nonsensical.

scarcely··on The Burning of Library.nu (2014)
(i) Imagine a billionaire who acquired his fortune from pyramid schemes. One day he fell victim to someone else's scam and is left penniless. He goes to confront the scammer to demand his money back. The scammer admits to carrying out the scam, but points out to the former billionaire that the money stolen from him was stolen in the first place. "That's just whataboutism," the former billionaire protests indignantly, "just because I did something bad in the past doesn't give you the right to do bad things to me".

Do you see the problem with the former billionaire's response?

(ii) To describe trade secrets as "science" sounds incorrect (I would reserve the term for the kind of stuff published in science journals, that genuinely tries to push the boundaries of human knowledge).

(iii) The kind of trade secret you are referring to are much more like source codes for proprietary software. You are sold some device that does a certain job. However, how exactly it does this job, is kept from your knowledge, because if you know it you would be able to make copies of it yourself, which would hurt the bottom line of the party selling the device. A more homespun example is KFC's recipe for their fried chicken. If the secret recipe is known, people would be able to make their KFC-flavor fried chicken at home. They wouldn't need to visit KFC to get it.

(iv) once we see that the "trade secrets" alluded to are things like closed source software's source code, and KFC's secret recipe, one thing that should immediately come to mind is the entire free software movement, the most prominent spokesman of which has repeatedly argued that proprietary software is "evil". Is it really okay to sell things that is promised to do a certain job but how it does that job is not being revealed? Would we ever allow drug manufacturers to sell drugs that promise to cure some condition via undisclosed mechanism? How do we know the closed source software isn't spying on us? Etc.

(v) Moreover, it becomes obvious at this point, that the only difference between the libgen type of cases and the "trade secret" cases is the difference in how easy it is to make copies. If you have a physical book or an ebook or an mp3, it's trivially easy to make an identical copy. But if you have a piece of KFC fried chicken in front of you, that in itself is of no help if you want a second helping. You can't just xerox the fried chicken, you need the recipe. And if the recipe is being locked away in some secret cabinet and you absolutely need it, then you need to steal it. But then this seems to suggest that those who pirate books have little basis on which to claim moral superiority to those who steal recipes/source codes. At the end of the day, they are both making unauthorized copies. The only difference is that the pirares are much more fortunate in that they have a much easier time making copies than the thieves stealing trade secrets. But is that a morally significant difference? How can it be that crime A is morally less bad than crime B simply because A is easier to commit?

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →