HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

scottLobster

5,318 karma · joined April 26, 2015

submissionscomments
scottLobster··on The Therac-25 Incident (2021)
Whoops, wrong thread :P
scottLobster··on The Therac-25 Incident (2021)
<deleted - wrong thread>
scottLobster··on The Therac-25 Incident (2021)
I was a Computer Engineer, so not quite the same, but we got taught about Therac-25 in our Engineering Ethics class when I took it over a decade ago.

Unfortunately Computer Science is still in its too-cool-for-school phase, see OpenAI being sued over recently encouraging a suicidal teenager to kill themself. You'd think it would be common sense for that to be a hard stop outside of the LLM processing the moment a conversation turns to subjects like that, but nope.

scottLobster··on F-35 pilot held 50-minute airborne conference call with engineers before crash
You sure about that? You should look at the F-35's performance in Israeli hands in their recent strikes on Iran.
scottLobster··on GPT-5
Please describe these "great lengths". They allowing customer audits now?

The first law of Silicon Valley is "Fake it till you make it", with the vast majority never making it past the "Fake it" stage. Whatever the truth may be, it's a safe bet that what they've said verbally is a lie that will likely have little consequence even if exposed.

scottLobster··on GPT-5
How certain are you that those challenges are "genuinely novel" and simply not accounted for in the training data?

I'm hardly an expert, but it seems intuitive to me that even if a problem isn't explicitly accounted for in publicly available training data, many underlying partial solutions to similar problems may be, and an LLM amalgamating that data could very well produce something that appears to be "synthesizing a new thought".

Essentially instead of regurgitating an existing solution, it regurgitates everything around said solution with a thin conceptual lattice holding it together.

scottLobster··on White House prepares order targeting banks for "unbanking" for political reasons
Honestly, the root of most of our current problems can be traced to Congress not being able to effectively pass legislation and ceding ever more power to the Executive and Judiciary as workarounds.
scottLobster··on Leonardo Chiariglione – Co-founder of MPEG
Different posters, Taek made the post you're referring to, I'm responding to voakbasda.

Regardless, why are you white-knighting for him? He made a moral argument about career choice, and I responded to said argument as someone who took the other side. This is a discussion board, we discuss things.

scottLobster··on SUSE Donates USD 11,500 to the Perl and Raku Foundation
If there's a couple of hard lessons I had to learn as an adult, it's that justice and morality are something you quite literally have to pay a premium for, and public opinion doesn't matter nearly as much as most of us were raised to think.

Amoral optimization for money is the only way past upper middle class outside of sheer luck.

scottLobster··on Leonardo Chiariglione – Co-founder of MPEG
That's all great and noble, but at the end of the day it's about who has the resources. If you can get the necessary resources yourself and have complete control over their allocation, congratulations you won the jackpot of life. Plenty of people, some of whom are smarter and better than you, tried to do the same and failed due to reasons beyond their control. Try to remain a good person and not waste the opportunity if you ever get to that stage.

For the remaining 99.99% of us, we have to negotiate for resources as best we can. That typically means maximizing shareholder value in exchange for a cut of the profits. Not all your labor needs to be vacuumed up, I make enough to support my family, live a relatively safe and comfortable life with some minor luxuries and likely a secure retirement. Better deal than most people get today.

scottLobster··on Tesla withheld data, lied, misdirected police to avoid blame in Autopilot crash
No need for anything so drastic, just make the fines a sufficiently large percentage of corporate free cash flow.

Make negligence unprofitable and the profit-optimizers will take care of the rest. Then 80 years later when people get too used to "trustworthy" corporationns we can deregulate everything and repeat the cycle

scottLobster··on So you're a manager now
As an IC, one reason I left my old (hated) job was precisely that. The product was barely-functional shit. We once spent 8 months implementing a "feature" that had senior engineers walking off the program in protest, only for them to be validated when said feature caused us to miss our contractual requirements just like said senior engineers said it would, and we spent another 8 months ripping it out.

Naturally I went looking for answers, started asking polite questions of my boss at 1-on-1s, started attending program-level meetings that engineers didn't typically show up to but were large/open enough I could blend into the background, and discovered that the root of the problem was roughly 3 levels into management and they weren't going to give a shit about what some engineers thought they should prioritize, even if we could tie it to financials/hours worked/cost savings (we tried and were politely ignored).

Left for a smaller program at a different company, and it's night and day. I remember suggesting that it would be nice if we could have an additional server for a system we were building and got told "yeah good idea, go ask <PM> if it's in the budget". It was, and we got it. I was in heaven.

scottLobster··on Killing the Mauna Loa observatory over irrefutable evidence of increasing CO2
We already have insane and growing wealth inequality and stagnant wage growth. The one thing that somewhat compensated for it is cheap goods, taking that away is not a winning argument in this environment. It's also a hard sell when Jeff Bezos has a wedding in Italy where dozens of private jets flew in and collectively emitted more carbon for that one wedding than all the gasoline vehicles multiple generations of my family have driven in their lifetimes.

And yet I, with my already depressed wages and kids to feed, should sacrifice steak and coach airline tickets?

I'm all for climate action, but it has to be policy level. If it's a choice between a warming world where we're solvent with some middle class prosperity, and a warming world where my wife, kids and I are broke because we went into six figures of debt replacing our ICE cars with EVs and retrofitting my house to passivhaus stanadards, I'm taking the former.

scottLobster··on [dead]
Like all tools it depends on how you use it and your prior knowledge.

I've found AI to be extremely useful for providing example code customized to my situation when using new libraries.

But for debugging, as appears to be the case in this study, I don't see how an LLM is much more helpful than static analysis. It can't build, run or test the code, it can't experiment, it can't construct a meaningful simulation of the running code to do any of the above. Might be good for a first pass, but otherwise you're back to basics.

scottLobster··on Linda Yaccarino is leaving X
I'll do it for $5.5M/year

Seriously, Elon should put the position up for auction and see how low he can drive the price. Would be hilarious PR

scottLobster··on Blind to Disruption – The CEOs Who Missed the Future
So would a universal cancer vaccine, but no one is acting like it's just around the corner.

I'm old enough to remember when "big data" and later "deep data" was going to enable us to find insane multi-variable correlations in data and unlock entire new levels of knowledge and efficiency.

AI as currently marketed is just that with an LLM chatbot.

scottLobster··on LLMs should not replace therapists
Seriously, if for no other reason than you can ask the LLM to clarify its initial response.

I had difficulty with math as a kid and well into college (ironic given my profession), and one of the big issues was the examples always skip some steps, often multiple steps. I lost countless hours staring blankly at examples, referencing lecture notes that weren't relevant, googling for help that at best partially answered my specific question, sometimes never getting the answer in time and just accepting that I'd get that one wrong on the homework.

An LLM, if it provides accurate responses (big "IF"), would have saved me tons of time. Similarly today, for generic coding questions I can have it generate examples specific to my problem, instead of having to piece solutions together from generic documentation.

scottLobster··on LLMs should not replace therapists
Depends on how large your insurance network is and how well served your region is. I've never had to wait longer than a month to see a specialist aside from non-critical checkups/exams. Granted I pay extra for the "broad network" option at my employer, I'm in a decently well-populated area in suburban Maryland so there's plenty of providers, and I did have to call around to multiple providers to find openings sometimes when I was a new patient.

Everything else wrong with US healthcare aside, I'm pretty sure we have better wait times on average.

scottLobster··on The $25k car is going extinct?
Nah, it's price.

Issue was every manufacturer slashed production during the pandemic either intentionally or due to parts shortages, so cars built during the pandemic years are abnormally scarce.

Add in that used car loans always have higher interest rates than new car loans, if you're buying with anything other than cash there still isn't that much of a discount on gently used/certified vs new.

You have to really go back a few years or get a relatively high mileage before you start finding cheap options again.

scottLobster··on The United States has lower life expectancy than most similarly wealthy nations
The "Regional Differences" section is behind a paywall, but for an overview, here's a map of all-cause mortality in the US by county:

https://hdpulse.nimhd.nih.gov/data-portal/mortality/map?cod=...

scottLobster··on Trump's NASA cuts would destroy decades of science and wipe out its future
The fact that you think scientific research, and NASA specifically, are driving our budgetary shortfalls shows your own bias.

You don't cut government budgets because it's intrinsically righteous, you do it to save money that you can then spend on other things. You could cut the NASA budget to zero and it wouldn't get us out of our current fiscal hole.

And it is incontrovertible from any reading of the history that government support is the reason we have modern air travel, the internet, and GPS, among many other facets of modern life. There is no compelling argument I've heard that the private sector can or would develop such things on their own, unless you're arguing that we should be completely reliant on the occasional eccentric billionaire having an interest in something scientific and setting up a foundation.

scottLobster··on Monks Behaving Badly: Explaining Buddhist Violence in Asia
And now we're in a Buddhist version of Ghandi's comment that "Your Christians are so unlike your Christ"

If we say "we expect followers of X religion to be nonviolent because their holy texts explicitly say so" then I guess there aren't many religious people in the world. I see no reason to expect a self-identifying Buddhist to be less violent than a Christian or Muslim beyond pop culture stereotypes.

scottLobster··on Foreign visits into the U.S. fell off a cliff in March
"Most" in this case means 49.81% of the vote, with 48.34% voting against. And that's with people largely expecting Trump to behave the same way as last time and a historically unpopular Democratic candidate. Whatever right wing cope you may have read, if the election were held today he'd probably lose.

Granted I don't blame foreigners for not risking ICE abuse. And Hockey fans can just be dumb sometimes. A lot of Americans have severe recency bias, the right is saying "the same people telling you this will be catastrophic were the same ones who locked down schools over a cold and told you inflation would be transitory". These people are going to have to touch the stove to learn it's hot, and then they'll admit that it's hot but deny that it's burning them, and then enough at the margins will start to defect such that they start losing elections, leaving a hard-core to endlessly complain about how if they'd only held on until 3rd degree burns the stove would have turned itself off.

scottLobster··on US Administration announces 34% tariffs on China, 20% on EU
The older I get the more I appreciate that those proverbs aren't just rhetorical.

I always assumed people would learn from history, because everyone knows that proverb. And yet now as I'm pushing 40 it seems more a warning, people will refuse to learn from history, and they will repeat it. So be as prepared as you can.

scottLobster··on Stockpile 72 hours of supplies in case of disaster or attack, EU tells citizens
I'd ask who isn't already doing this, but the pandemic taught me that most people don't have enough toilet paper on hand to last the week.
scottLobster··on The Internet Slum: is abandoning the Internet the next big thing? (2004)
My dad used to be a Professor at a major State university, and he talked about how one of his older colleagues, who was a professor of Electrical Engineering, had his secretary (yes, he had a secretary) print out his emails for him every morning and put them in his physical inbox. He'd read them, type up his responses, print them out, and have her transcribe and send the responses later in the day.

Just sad really.

scottLobster··on Ask HN: Where Do Seasoned Devs Look for Short-Term Work?
Only when you're trying to sell bullshit. If I can actually solve someone's problem, and they don't mind my price, then we're helping solve each other's problems and everyone benefits!

Where things get sleezy is when you're competing with applicants that will bullshit, so you have to bullshit as well just to keep up, or when customers have unrealistic expectations and waste your time.

scottLobster··on Study finds bullies have more children than non-bullies
Counterpoint: I was bullied, have two kids and want more.

I was fed a diet of "just ignore them and they'll go away" (ha), the school promising to do something about it but never more than a slap on the wrist for the bullies, "violence never solves anything", I learned to stay within view of the teachers at recess.

As I got older, I realized the issue was the authority figures in my life never allowed or taught me how to fight, physically or otherwise. The practical solutions to the problem made them so uncomfortable that they avoided even discussing them. So they just let me suffer for years knowing that eventually I'd graduate and the problem would "go away".

Let's just say that my kids won't have that same upbringing, and any bully who tries what I experienced will be in for a shock.

scottLobster··on We are the builders
You mean like this freedom of speech? https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2025/02/elon-musk-to-fix...

You and others on the right, as a group in 2025, only argue for freedom of speech when it suits you. Yes, the left does this too, and it's just as despicable.

scottLobster··on NASA's James Webb Space Telescope faces potential 20% budget cut
Is he? Obsessed people are generally hyper-focused on their obsession by definition, Musk has pivoted to electric cars, "free speech" and now re-shaping government since announcing his Mars ambitions.

He's definitely obsessed with being seen by others as the guy who's going to be the first to Mars, but I'd put it in the same camp as his obsession with being seen as an elite Path of Exile 2 player.

← PreviousPage 7 of 34Next →