702 karma · joined May 29, 2010
2) I highly doubt Sparrow will work with upcoming iOS versions, which means the people that bought it recently have been ripped off.
However, also from the outside, it seems like YC is creating entrepreneurs that experience their first business startup in a dreamworld that doesn't exist anywhere else; a bubble if you will, but not the kind of bubble that pops and brings down an industry...more like the bubble that private school kids experience during high school that sends them into a tizzy when they breathe the free air of college.
What happens to these founders when their first startup fails and they try again in the real world without the thick black book of strategic contacts in PG's back pocket and the guaranteed $150k from Yuri and Co? Starting companies out here in the "ghetto" (where money is earned, not given) is hard.
There is a story that's sitting near the top of HN right now that says YC is like a bootcamp for founders. That's a joke, right? I'm pretty sure it's more like summer camp for founders...or maybe a gentleman's club for founders where the sexiest startups dance on stage and investors try to stick money in the g-strings of the founders.
So, getting more to the point, I'm less concerned about what Y Combinator will look like in 3 years and more concerned for the founders that fail on round one and don't have the cushion of YC's couch to sleep on while they dream up their next big idea. But YC will most likely be exactly what PG wants it to be in 3 years, just like it always has been.
We're about to release another paid app in March on both platforms that will be give us more data about the performance of apps in each marketplace. Maybe I should write a blog post about it...
Your product is promising, but isn't easily differentiated from Feedburner and thus it's difficult to charge anything for it. I'm surprised you have any paying customers actually.
However, if the guts of the application are as solid as they seem, then you have a gem on your hands that just needs the right business touch to position the product for the right market.
I'm starting a new software business, but I'm not a developer. I come from a product manager background, therefore most of the capital (my personal savings from a couple successful startups in the past) I'm using to start the business is going to the developers who are actually doing the work and the rest is being saved for marketing later. The devs are a couple of amazing guys who are building an amazing product.
What I'll do if you grant me a ticket to BoS 2010:
There is a local nonprofit here in Jacksonville that tutors adults, helping them learn to read, write, and do basic math with the aim of helping them find jobs to support their families. They need a website to help raise funding, but they don't have the funds to do it properly (catch22). If you give me a ticket to BoS 2010, I'll build them the best damn website ever.
scottmagdalein@gmail.com :)
(Honestly, I'm going to build the website for them whether you give me the ticket or not, but this is supposed to look like a "pay-it-forward" scenario.)
P.S. Due to a mishap by United Airlines, I have a free ticket anywhere in the US that I would use for this trip. Also, I have a friend in Boston who is willing to let me sleep on his couch. So, the only expense left to cover is the ticket to BoS 2010.
P.P.S I want to attend BoS 2010 because our product will be launching around that time and I want to make sure I'm positioning it properly for the most potential.
Thanks for your consideration!
This product will be offered as a SaaS product and be priced between $50-$500 per month. Most of the competition is enterprise level software that's sold directly to their customers, although there is big money being spent on search advertising (between $15-$20 per click) in this market as well. Because it's direct sales and custom software packages, it's difficult to gauge pricing across multiple competitors. Also, since many of our competitors offer applicant tracking as one piece of larger HR software suites, it's difficult to gauge user experience and user satisfaction with these tools.
Does that information help at all? I'm still very interested in more feedback. I know the HN community has a ton of super-smart folks that have either been in my shoes or are just smart enough to figure it out.
I'm clear on my audience (HR leads at medium- to large-sized businesses looking to reduce costs and increase efficiency for this part of their job responsibilities.
I'm already casually doing what you suggest with Adwords research using the adwords targeting explorer. The other advice about forming partnerships or a CPA program (what is that, btw?) is intriguing. Thanks!
iOS Engineer: http://www.lifechurch.tv/jobs/37
Blackberry: http://www.lifechurch.tv/jobs/39
Symbian: http://www.lifechurch.tv/jobs/41
Web UX Designer & Developer: http://www.lifechurch.tv/jobs/42
Partnership Development (PR/Marketing): http://www.lifechurch.tv/jobs/36
When I gave it to my wife, it took her 5 minutes to say that she'd never use it. And she gave one reason. You can't chat on Facebook AND do something else on Facebook. For example, you can chat and browse your friends at the same time. She handed it back to me and grabbed her 13" MBP and never thought about the iPad again.
It's a shame really. A device pitched as the greatest wife-computer of all time, and my wife hated it within 5 minutes.