HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

scotty79

15,713 karma · joined July 7, 2009

submissionscomments
scotty79··on Breaking the open web won't stop the bad bots
You can pick a good hash. But even at million times efficiency it's still ok because with scrapers they can generate million time more traffic than casual users.

You don't need to win. You just need to tip the scales a little bit. Even two stage request response of PoW would dissuade some scraping.

> if you want to require an attacker to burn one second of computation time, some cheap smartphone user will now be stuck for five minutes.

I don't want attacker to spend 1 second per request. I want them spend 10 ms per each of their millions of requests. You don't hit them by being request hard. You hit them by making them pay even if just a little bit for each inefficient action they take.

> Most web proof-of-work stuff has worked because it breaks the normal flow and the typical scraper is supremely dumb, not because of the proof of work, which has largely been a total red herring.

It's not really important how you win. It's important to have a control over your hosting costs in this brave new world.

scotty79··on French digital tax may kill VideoLan non-profit
> internet is largely ad-sponsored

They should tax ads then. Since that's the source of money that fuels everything they should tax at the source.

Make the companies report how many ads they run, how much they get paid on that and tax that.

You won't catch them all initially but you'll catch some and then you can gradually tighten the system.

And this will go far enough from the consumer that he might actually not notice. Ad budgets of companies are very flexible and if you hit all of them, they'll all just reduce their ad spending at no harm to anyone.

scotty79··on Breaking the open web won't stop the bad bots
If you have an endpoint with interesting information and you don't want it spammed with requests, require a proof of work from the client, scale up the hardness of it as the load goes up so it never exceeds what's comfortable for you. Even a hard proof of work won't slow down somebody that makes one request per second because they are reading the site but will sighificantly interfere with crawlers that hit you 10000 a second currently at very little cost to them.

The module doing proof of work might be a part of your frontend that is static and on CDN.

If you want agents still have access to your data, just not through scraping, provide alternative format for them. Like periodic sqlite dump.

I made a prototype of such PoW two years ago. A challenge is a random number. Checking the client's solution is calculating one hash of the challenge glued to client's solution and checking if the resulting hash is less than a specific value. The lower the value, the harder the task for the client to do. Client needs to calculate this hash multiple times to find a response that will result (when glued with challenge) with low enough hash.

The server needs to keep short lived cache with challenges so the client can't just make up one or reuse another solution and provide two responses for every challenge, first, very small and fast with a challenge, and the second one with actual content (if response was correct). Nothing much worse than CORS preflight.

scotty79··on US Reps Lead Democratic Resolution Opposing A.I. Bubble Bailout for Big Tech
Yeah, probably it wouldn't be as bad as they made it seem to be, but still, there was a reasoning behind the bailout. I see not reasoning for AI bailout.
scotty79··on US Reps Lead Democratic Resolution Opposing A.I. Bubble Bailout for Big Tech
I have no idea who would they even bailout. Investors? Why? What for? What would that change?

Bailing out banks made some sense so that they couldn't operate. Without the bailout there would be no more banks and a hundred million of people left on the ice.

If you want to keep AI operating you can just (temporarily?) ban investors from tearing down the AI companies they invested in for parts. You could say they are important for national security or something. I'm sure they are already earning enough to keep the lights on. Just not enout to give investors payback for insate capital expediture to set up.

Such ban wolud the governement zero, especially if you write the law well enough, so that it can't be succesfully challenged in court.

scotty79··on We won't "just hang out"
Hanging out, sure. With people? Ew.
scotty79··on Zombie stats: Where the numbers AI quotes come from
An apple a day keeps the doctor away and Santa wears red.
scotty79··on I Used AI to Fake a Scientific Paper. Here's What Happened
In other news people prompted a model to pick a problem to solve, solve it and write a paper about it. And it did and the paper contains novel contributions.

https://www.reddit.com/r/OpenAI/comments/1xgqv27/two_physici...

scotty79··on Qwenputer: A functioning, deterministic RISC-V CPU inside Qwen3.5
The most interesting part of this is normal LLM interacting with directly attached deterministic computation unit.

It's like successfully wiring your brain to a calculator.

I think it would cheaply provide LLMs a lot of benefit if we embedded in them directly a computer and a memory so they can internally process things predictably.

And some benefit is indeed shown even in this cursed experiment.

scotty79··on Survival LLM: AI assistant and emergency library that runs on your own computer
If you have AI model there it can make any search engine for you as per your needs.
scotty79··on Survival LLM: AI assistant and emergency library that runs on your own computer
Qwen 3.8 27B runs well on my laptop. And I can fit terabytes of human knowledge on it.
scotty79··on Survival LLM: AI assistant and emergency library that runs on your own computer
Just few days ago I thought digital preppers are soon gonna make something like that. It's a generally good idea.

I'd put in this also a ton of software documentation, minimally for Rust.

And a bunch of scientific literature.

scotty79··on AI use leads UC Berkeley math professor to see 'no point' in grading homework
> probably hasn’t graded a homework set in a while

Honestly he should just tell student to grade their homework with chatGPT themselves.

scotty79··on New iPad mini
Phones today have plenty of power to generate 120 screens per seconds. Capping them with a screen is a terrible idea. Smooth form a decade ago isn't the same as smooth of today.

20 years ago I was gaming at 30fps and called it smooth. Now 120Hz feels like bare minimum.

scotty79··on New iPad mini
I'd love to have eInk at 90-120Hz. But I agree that 60Hz or 5Hz is pretty much similar expeirience when it comes to scrolling.
scotty79··on New iPad mini
You don't have to know what Hz is to see that scrolling on some devices is smooth and on other (coug..Apple) devices is choppy. 60Hz feels like a decade old phone.
scotty79··on IBM CEO says open weight models are now good and cheap on-prem
Is to deprive yourself of the slightest chance of winning?
scotty79··on A 10-year-old CNN outperforms frontier LLMs for skin cancer diagnosis
I think Jev tapped into a real desire of many people. A dream of (a kind of) Oracle. Where you ask the question as messily as you like, but you get as an output a decision that a plank of wood (or a piece of code) could follow literally.

Doesn't matter it's wrong significant fraction of the time and you have no clue what went wrong because the output is yes/no.

Classifier models actually make it think about how the input should be formatted and pre-processed and that kinda breaks the dream.

scotty79··on Amazon’s “digital pacifier” for toddlers
Not really. More like, suck it up. Things might be harmful and beneficial at the same time. Worse is better. Technology shapes humanity. It's the humanity's role to adapt to the bad and benefit from the good.
scotty79··on IBM CEO says open weight models are now good and cheap on-prem
After years of trump any intelligence is a democrat.
scotty79··on Amazon’s “digital pacifier” for toddlers
> Whereas we already know this technology is harmful.

Technology is harmful, starting from fire and farming. So what?

scotty79··on Amazon's "digital pacifier" for toddlers
Put AI on it an you have the future of upbringing.
scotty79··on OBS Studio 33
I'm not strongly opposed to your point of view.

How about Truth Social?

scotty79··on OBS Studio 33
I'm not that deep in the culture wars. I just know pronouns is not all that the so called right was whining about.
scotty79··on No signs of AI payoff outside the tech sector
> Every computer and cellphone in the office is an "AI powered appliance". Every application can be an AI powered one.

True, but funnily enough those are not workhorses of most businesses outside of AI. Jevons paradox was about that. Introduction of computers into most businesses didn't traslate to immediate performance gains so it's hard to imagine that automating computers will have strong immediate effect.

I think the most powerful way that software is going to benefit businesses outside of IT is creation and maintenance of custom software for every business that's going to be better fit, faster and cheaper than anything IT industry can deliver. Though even those gains are still going to be modest to moderate.

At some point real AI powered appliances might show up, like robots or full stack AI management.

scotty79··on America has lost 200k of jobs in media, film and the arts. How much is AI?
25% increase in half a century? We ahd like 3 technological revolutions since then and economy grew massively.

Compare that to how much wealth appreciated, like a price of gold or real estate.

Median real wages increased by the narrowest possible meaning of this word.

Trickle down economy is literally a trickle.

scotty79··on No signs of AI payoff outside the tech sector
> new light fixtures and appliances had to be purchased and installed

Exactly.

> There's nothing holding back anybody.

The same thing is holding back AI. Most businesses don't have AI powered appliances. Yet.

The industries that used appliances that can be AI powered, the AI took over in months.

scotty79··on OBS Studio 33
> Since when is anyone freely entitled to my time and attention?

Funnily enough the same people say the same when it comes to pronouns and such. The right (if we can call them that) immediately copied, perfected and weaponized all the attention seeking and whining they've seen and complained about.

scotty79··on Sam Altman: 'I No Longer Think We're Gonna Be Able to Just Patch All the Bugs'
We spent decades creating those bugs. Give it few years at least to find them and patch them.
scotty79··on OBS Studio 33
I hate that this whole cluster of beliefs exists, but software on my own computer enforcing what I can and can't do for ideological reason is a bit much.

Unless they just didn't implemented it for whatever reason, but someone else can implement this as an extensions or something. Your software obviously doesn't need to support everything.

← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →