You don't need to win. You just need to tip the scales a little bit. Even two stage request response of PoW would dissuade some scraping.
> if you want to require an attacker to burn one second of computation time, some cheap smartphone user will now be stuck for five minutes.
I don't want attacker to spend 1 second per request. I want them spend 10 ms per each of their millions of requests. You don't hit them by being request hard. You hit them by making them pay even if just a little bit for each inefficient action they take.
> Most web proof-of-work stuff has worked because it breaks the normal flow and the typical scraper is supremely dumb, not because of the proof of work, which has largely been a total red herring.
It's not really important how you win. It's important to have a control over your hosting costs in this brave new world.