HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

scottyah

1,290 karma · joined February 13, 2013

learning & venting
submissionscomments
scottyah··on Rust Style Guide
Is this a reply to my comment? The first sentence appears to be putting a lot of words into my mouth that were never spoken, and the second is completely tangential.

You tried to assert that nobody writing meaningful software has ever thought something like "hey, y'know what, that's actually kinda cool! I'm going to change my mind about LLMs being useless", which is easily false. They don't need to declare they're generals to agentic armies, they just need an open mind.

Which it seems all writers of great software do. And you don't...

scottyah··on Google's Rust Style Guide
Either you can put it in a linter and automate/force it, or people/agents will take liberties. I feel like there's usually exceptions where a well-meaning guideline doesn't properly fit a specific scenario.
scottyah··on Rust Style Guide
Unlike Linus, Jeff Dean, DHH, John Carmack, Guido van Rossum? I really want to know who you think writes "100% of the software that people actually use and actually keeps the real world running"
scottyah··on Rust Style Guide
I doubt it, Rust developers compete only with crossfit and vegans in the race to be noticed.
scottyah··on Claude Duet
You 'member Kubernetes and Microservices hype cycle?
scottyah··on Things to know when you get cancer
Low effort posts just telling people to pay money for advice is bad advice for sure, really it's almost worthless. I don't think anyone asking basic legal or medical advice is unaware of Doctors or Lawyers, they're just looking for either best-effort or things that shouldn't require looking for and paying for professional services. There are enough bad lawyers and doctors that lead people astray too, which also takes away from how useful the "advice" is- perhaps a recommendation for a certain lawyer, or some relevant literature.

I'd never just tell someone to go "ask a software engineer" if they had questions on database configurations or any other specific problem.

scottyah··on Things to know when you get cancer
They trained on reddit too hard. Everything is "Talk to a therapist, lawyer up, consult with your medical doctor". It's just used for deflection after someone gives (usually bad) advice.
scottyah··on Things to know when you get cancer
What do you think AGI means? ANI would arguably be better here.
scottyah··on How Amazon pushes up prices all across the Internet
Are you a Prime member?
scottyah··on Fire at Starlink site in Bulgaria after suspected sabotage in Poland
Wow that's a wild world view to have. Not sure how it holds up to reality when all the engineers are completely free to do whatever they want, but his companies are massively more successful than any others. Even with the previous World's Richest Man Bezos trying to poach everyone he has and copying/funding pretty much all the same ideas. Dare I ask which multi-trillion dollar companies you've been able to steal?
scottyah··on Fire at Starlink site in Bulgaria after suspected sabotage in Poland
I appreciate the response, but quotes of people spreading known misinformation is not addressing the main concern. These are still just opinions.
scottyah··on Fire at Starlink site in Bulgaria after suspected sabotage in Poland
Yes- if they were using it for drone attacks and the service stopped/slowed, that was not Starlink, because it never would have happened in the first place.
scottyah··on Fire at Starlink site in Bulgaria after suspected sabotage in Poland
Can we narrow down asking for a link to be some sort of legitimate news? These are links to forum posts linking to bluesky posts of "political commentators" that are factually incorrect.

Starlink != Starshield. Musk does not own Starshield. SpaceX does not own it. It's like blaming a flight route cancellation on Boeing.

scottyah··on Fire at Starlink site in Bulgaria after suspected sabotage in Poland
Haha you really just can't win as a builder. Half the people despise him for doing anything for money, and the other half hate him because he cares for politics over money.
scottyah··on Fire at Starlink site in Bulgaria after suspected sabotage in Poland
Lots of quotes from Ukrainians about what they are accusing SpaceX of, and even misleading titles "NO WARNING BEFORE STARLINK CUTS", but the actual meat of it is pretty hidden.

Starlink never allowed use for offensive drone attacks, Starshield is what they were using, and it is a product fully controlled by the USG.

scottyah··on ICE Planning $100M 'Nightmare' Domestic Spy Program
Sheesh, you claim to know so much about me (so incorrectly) that I doubt the veracity of any of your claims. Why do you want so bad for me to be racist and sexist? Do I have to be in order to fit your world view?
scottyah··on ICE Planning $100M 'Nightmare' Domestic Spy Program
Yes, it's widely reported from both sides. Even people like Andrew on Channel5 covered people coming over in droves. I really don't know of anyone refuting it, just whether or not it's good or bad.
scottyah··on Amazon pushes up prices across the Internet
Yeah I've never seen this despite buying from amazon multiple times a month if not week. I assume they're living somewhere with weird regulations or something.
scottyah··on Submarine cable resilience
I think people conflate decentralization with redundancy or resilience. IMO it just means you have multiple points of failure instead of one.
scottyah··on Show HN: How random are you?
Maybe they are not training to make a TTS, but training on accents to make STT.
scottyah··on Redesigning source control at Anthropic
I think offline work is increasingly impossible these days, or at least so hindered that there's no reason to optimize for it (especially with how reliable internet access is). Imagine working at Anthropic and not having access to Claude. Google has been online-only for a long time now.
scottyah··on Mass Driver: Solar system routing mini-game
Thank you! It was off by a decimal point, and a couple other moons too.
scottyah··on Mass Driver: Solar system routing mini-game
I've been thinking about mass driver scheduling/routing lately and thought it'd be fun to have claude make a little game out of it after seeing the lens interactive diagram.
scottyah··on Typesafe AI raises $870M at $7.5B
> OpenAI's own Decisions API [1] beats it

Have you heard that from a different source than OpenAI? From what I'd heard other models haven't gotten close, and the open source ones are like running gemma4 E2B against Opus 5.5- sure, the API calls go in and are returned the same but the quality isn't close.

scottyah··on Cloudflare acquires Deno
Do you really think someone off the street, armed with Opus 5.5 could recreate Deno? Or would you pull Cloudflare people off what they were doing (meaning it's a very inefficient company) to work on this?

At the end of the day, great engineers armed with great tools are going to outperform anyone who just has the great tools.

scottyah··on Cloudflare acquires Deno
Do you think Deno was real competition for Cloudflare, and now that they've merged we don't have alternative options for goods/services that are mostly essential?

I think if Cloudflare and Google merged, it still wouldn't be a monopoly because of AWS (and many others).

scottyah··on Red Hat being phased out of existence?
Things like Cloudflare Workers, boxd.sh, fly.io's sprites, etc. Just different takes on how much needs to be packaged into a container with a pipeline and how deploys work. I think that especially with AI, we're going to see a lot quicker method of code -> prod. Right now there's a lot of overhead with kubernetes that most customers I know don't really benefit from.
scottyah··on Claude Says
Google's web search AI is pretty great at it!
scottyah··on FTC is investigating OpenAI, Anthropic and other AI companies over product risks
https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/two-defendants-employed-la-ar...

https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2026-09-16/la-homel...

https://calmatters.org/housing/homelessness/2026/09/la-homel...

It's so crazy how politicized fraud has gotten. Diehard Dems offhandedly dismiss Nick Shirley and DOGE even though all they look for is proof of fraud. If someone is doing that for free, why on earth would you want to stop or dismiss it before any evidence or reporting has been delivered? There's no shortage of it from either side, why defend the scummy parts of your party vs trying to root it out?

scottyah··on FTC is investigating OpenAI, Anthropic and other AI companies over product risks
At the state/city level, California and Los Angeles have much more blatant corruption. From the High Speed Rail to LA's billions of homeless money (now some invoices showing house purchases, ubers to and payments at strip clubs). I think more politicians are just shameless about it lately. Karen Bass was reelected anyway, and Gavin is gaining support in a run for presidency even. Buying votes has never been easier.
← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →