HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

scroogl3d

-8 karma · joined September 21, 2017

submissionscomments
scroogl3d··on Waymo wants Uber to pay $2.6B in damages, just for starters
"svn checkout" of something you were a core developer of and could fetch 14k files.

Not negating your point but putting it in perspective. Downloading and archiving your own work email inbox is also far from uncommon I'm sure. Doesn't imply you definitely have a specific use for it.

scroogl3d··on Waymo wants Uber to pay $2.6B in damages, just for starters
> If what I create with my mind isn't my property, then what you create with your hand isn't yours either.

That implication is not a logical necessity. There is a big distinction: if I take away the thing you made with your hands from you, you have one fewer thing, and I have one more thing.

If I learn or copy what you have in your mind, both of us have something. I cannot take it away from you.

Also, the whole phrase "Intellectual Property" is a misleading thing that should not be used in any reasonable discussion, because it derails the arguments by unifying a bunch of pretty different things[1].

We should be calling copyright, patents, and trademarks what they are: they are not properties, they are monopolies authorized by the government (trade secrets may be a bit distinct here). Perhaps authorized monopoly is a more accurate term than "intellectual property". cf. [2]

[1] https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/not-ipr.en.html

[2] http://www.locusmag.com/Perspectives/2016/11/cory-doctorow-s...

scroogl3d··on Waymo wants Uber to pay $2.6B in damages, just for starters
IP... Imaginary Property.

"Theft" is not a technical jargon. It's an emotionally charged phrase to trigger public opinion in favor of patent monopolists.

Also, didn't the judge throw out the patent case and the dispute is merely trade secrets now?

scroogl3d··on Waymo wants Uber to pay $2.6B in damages, just for starters
Is it just me or does this sound like the typical big company coming out of the woodwork to sue to sabotage someone else's IPO. Isn't it just jump the shark moment for Google?

I find HN sentiment too favorable to Google these days, compared to Yahoo's lawsuit against FB at their IPO time. I think this theory should at least be considered.