HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

scrupulusalbion

63 karma · joined July 7, 2015

submissionscomments
scrupulusalbion··on In Arbitration, a ‘Privatization of the Justice System’
In the present discussion, the increase in usage of arbitration is not necessarily motivated by libertarian philosophy. It would seem simpler to assume that the companies that include binding arbitration in their contracts are simply making what they believe to be a good move. Further, unless the corporate executives or lawyers come out as libertarians, then I think it is putting thoughts into their heads to treat this issue as anything other than an apolitical, pragmatic move.
scrupulusalbion··on Shielding your files with Reed-Solomon codes (2008)
How easy are those to setup and how reliable are they?
scrupulusalbion··on Brazilian Judge Shuts Down WhatsApp for 48 Hours
Perhaps I am overstepping my bounds, but to me it seems that using coercion to get information from a witness (Whatsapp appears to be in the position of a witness) is a recipe for getting unreliable information when the witness.

Whatsapp seems to be in a position that it could retaliate against this Brazilian judge by giving false testimony. Afterall, Whatsapp and the parties to the messages are probably the only people who know what was said in those messages; Whatsapp could modify the messages such that they exonerate the accused. If the judge has played his only trump card by blocking usage of Whatsapp in Brazil, then Whatsapp knows the absolute worst that can happen by lying about what was said in the messages. Worse, the Judge may not even be able to prove what the messages actually contained.

scrupulusalbion··on Atlassian's success reminds what a crappy place Australia is for tech business
>When you're a programmer, what is the difference to your work between 10 and 100mbps, really?

While you asked about programming, I think it is the non-work stuff that matters, namely entertainment. If you play video games and/or watch Netflix, then a greater than 10mbps might make those things easier and thus more enjoyable, afaik.

I presently have a 1Mbps connection, which is consumed mostly by YouTube videos. All my other internet usage could be satiated with 1/3 of my present bandwidth.

If I cared to watch Netflix or played video games, then I would be unhappy unless I had a substantially better connection, perhaps >10mbps.

scrupulusalbion··on The assault on neurosurgeons’ privileges by software and bureaucrats
Assuming at least some users are going to write down their passwords, I wonder if it would be appropriate to show them more secure ways to do that. Unfortunately, my "better" way is to stuff the sticky note in my wallet.

If I could find a device (w/ touch or keyboard for input) that fit into my pocket and has no wireless capabilities, then I would probably use that as a password manager.

scrupulusalbion··on How Jane Vonnegut Made Kurt Vonnegut a Writer
> He could write in his free time. “I get sick with fear that I’m a bluff, that I’m actually no damned good,” he confessed.

Vonnegut clearly suffered from Impostor Syndrome.

scrupulusalbion··on Paredit.js – structured navigation and editing of s-expressions
Works fine for me (Chrome, Windows 7).
scrupulusalbion··on Why do trolls go after feminists?
>Ban and move on.

This might have mixed results. Some trolls see getting banned as proof of successful trolling, whereupon trolling via another account might still be an option.

I think the users are the key to making trolls go away, because it is a social issue and not a mechanical issue. Put another way: you can't program away trolling, despite how fun XKCD's idea [0] might be to implement.

[0] https://xkcd.com/810/

scrupulusalbion··on Why do trolls go after feminists?
FWIW, trolls don't uniquely focus on feminists. Their emotional buttons are just so easy to find and push; when your advocacy === your emotional button, then you are broadcasting how to make you upset. If you are easily made upset, then you are self-primed for being trolled. So, if you don't like being trolled, then either hide your emotional buttons or change what happens when someone pushes those buttons.

The fact that feminists appear to be uniquely targeted by trolls is indeed the result of a societal structure, but it is not unique to feminists. Instead, feminists are just another set of humans who are louder when they get upset. People used to complain about so-called Soccer Moms being too easy to upset.

If you don't like the trolls, then don't feed them. I had thought that people had learned from the vi-vs-emacs flame wars how to avoid unproductive drama. Feminists spin their wheels by getting upset at trolls, just as vi users wasted their time getting mad when emacs users were not using vi.

scrupulusalbion··on Questions About Shaken Baby Syndrome
> I would be in favour of less incarceration and more rehabilitation and reinsertion into society as happy/useful participants

While I agree that mere incarceration is often fruitless in terms of helping the person being incarcerated, one must be careful to not replace prison with brainwashing, to put it bluntly. That is, rehabilitation might work with narcotic addictions, but social issues (I am categorizing violence as a social issue, because it necessarily involves interaction between two or more persons) revolve around opinions, beliefs, conscious and unconscious assumptions about others, etc.

I recall movies and TV show episodes revolving around the totalitarian nature of some criminal justice system that seeks to fix inmates's behavior through overt (torture) or covert (therapy, interviewing, social engineering, etc.) means.

> I believe that most people would not commit the crimes they commit if they had access to better welfare/education/neighbourhoods/etc.

This is essentially the idea that poverty causes crime, which is a controversial position. This might be why you have gotten downvoted.

scrupulusalbion··on Windows 10 Review
It would be sensible for hypervisors to require IOMMU for all PCI passthrough, but it looks like Xen allows it without IOMMU for paravirtualised guests:

"VT-d Pass-Through is a technique to give a domU exclusive access to a PCI function using the IOMMU provided by VT-d. It is primarily targeted at HVM (fully virtualised) guests because PV (paravirtualized) pass-through does not require VT-d (altough it may be utilized too)."[1]

[1] = http://wiki.xenproject.org/wiki/VTd_HowTo

scrupulusalbion··on Ronald Reagan’s shameful legacy: Violence, the homeless, mental illness
It depends in what aspects. Certainly technological progress has not been declining since the '80s. American GDP has more or less been steadily increasing since the '60s. While I too have the feeling that America is on the decline, I have not found any solid evidence to show in what ways America might be declining.
scrupulusalbion··on Windows 10 Review
Not all new hardware provides IOMMU. For instance, the i7-4770K does not have the VT-d extension, which is Intel's version of IOMMU. [1]

[1] = http://ark.intel.com/products/75123/Intel-Core-i7-4770K-Proc...

scrupulusalbion··on Windows 10 Review
You are correct that it is dependent upon whether your motherboard has IOMMU [1]. Nevertheless, given the following paragraph, then it seems to be the reverse: it is generally unwise to willy-nilly give out PCI pass-through, unless you have confirmed that your hardware has IOMMU.

Xen documentation explicitly states how to determine whether you have IOMMU on your hardware.[2] The hardware listed here [3], while out of date, conspicuously notes, for example, that "Core i7...most "K" versions don't support VT-d", which, according to Intel [4], means that the i7-4770K, for example, does not support IOMMU (VT-d). This tells me that if you are concerned about this issue, then you must check your hardware, even if it is new hardware.

[1] = https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IOMMU

[2] = http://wiki.xenproject.org/wiki/Xen_PCI_Passthrough#How_can_...

[3] = http://wiki.xenproject.org/wiki/VTdHowTo

[4] the i7-4770K probably lacks IOMMU because it would negatively affect performance on a CPU that is sold as a near top-of-the-line CPU for gaming, which generally excludes most virtualization use cases.

edit: formatting

scrupulusalbion··on Windows 10 Review
Be careful with GPU passthrough in general; you are giving Windows in that VM direct memory access. [1] In the last year or so, a group was able to overwrite Xen (in order to get additional privileges outside the VM) by merely being given GPU passthrough. [2] Even if you aren't using Xen, PCI passthrough necessarily entails the in-VM OS getting direct memory access which more or less spoils any security separation between the in-VM OS and the host OS.

To be clear, I don't think very many people are likely to have to deal with this as a security problem. I just think its appropriate to be aware of the power/danger inherent in the seemingly benign nature of GPU/PCI passthrough.

[1] = "you can use PCI passthrough to assign a PCI device (NIC, disk controller, HBA, USB controller, firewire controller, soundcard, etc) to a virtual machine guest, giving it full and direct access to the PCI device" (http://wiki.xenproject.org/wiki/XenPCIpassthrough) [2] Sorry, I can't find a link.

scrupulusalbion··on Loglan – The Language of Logic
It would seem that an additional source of information (e.g. a nearby seismograph bolted to bedrock) would be the solution to this problem. This is analogous to a blind person trying to identify whether a sound is a recording or the Real McCoy. The solution is to either somehow make him able to see or to allow him to use some other sense (e.g. touch) by which to measure the origin of the sound. If he hears a dog barking, then if he sees/feels a dog, he is almost completely assured [0] that it is a real dog that was barking and not a recording playing from a machine.

Thus, adding another sense (a seismograph and sightedness/touch, respectively) would seem to eliminate the problem. If this is correct, then such problems are more ones of a lack of relevant, heterogeneous information and less of a lack of logical expressiveness of probabilities.

[0] = I say "almost", because knowledge is a fundamental philosophical problem. The usual means to "almost" assurance is, as I am arguing, to employ more heterogeneous sources of information until the only logical alternatives to what you believe are absurdities (e.g. impossible).

scrupulusalbion··on Tails 1.5 is out
> Install a 32-bit GRUB EFI boot loader. Tails should now start on some tablets with Intel Bay Trail processors among others.

If any of the devs are reading this, you have no idea how excited I am at seeing this. I have a 32-bit EFI Intel tablet that I got for $70 a few months ago; it has sat around collecting dust simply because I could not find a actively maintained distro to run on it. I will have to test it to see if it works properly.

scrupulusalbion··on Unix System V Release 1 Programming Guide (1983) [pdf]
I had never heard of bitsavers [0] until just now. They've got two sections: documents and software.

I have so far found blueprints associated with the PDP-1 [1] in the documents portion, but mostly image files in the software section.

[0] = http://bitsavers.trailing-edge.com/ [1] = http://bitsavers.trailing-edge.com/pdf/dec/pdp1/blueprints/

scrupulusalbion··on The pressure to achieve academically is a crime against learning
Homeschooling in the simplest form requires a stay-at-home parent (traditionally the mother) to dedicate his/her time to teaching the kids. So, if you already have to send your kids to daycare, then you probably will find homeschooling difficult to accomplish.

For what its worth, Sudbury Schools [0] provide an interesting alternative to homeschooling. (TIL there is a Sudbury school in my area! [1])

Your comment points to the fact that, for at least some parents, schools amount to daycare with education tacked on.

[0] = https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sudbury_school [1] = https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Sudbury_schools#United...

scrupulusalbion··on Pliny the Elder on Dolphins (77 CE)
I wonder if people would pay for a magazine that contains ancient writings, but altered in style to appear like they were written today; the original Greek/Latin texts could be referenced if necessary to maintain the original meaning of the text.

With a catchy appearance and some artistic license, this might be an avenue to get people to read ancient texts. Now, there need be no lying, the magazine could plainly state that what is presented was written thousands of years ago.

I personally would like to get a magazine in the mail that contains excerpts of Plato, Socrates, and Marcus Aurelius, etc. For good measure, throw in some modern commentary as the op ed section.

scrupulusalbion··on Analyzing the 2013 Bitcoin fork: centralized decision-making saved the day
A fork on the blockchain will only ever occur if one or more nodes are operating on different rules; the danger of a fork is proportional to the number of nodes that differ on those rules, because it would waste miner resources.

Suppose Node A thinks that a block should be no larger than 1MB, but Node B thinks that a block can be as large as 2MB. When a client presents a 1.5MB block to both nodes, Node A rejects it for being too big but Node B accepts it for being small enough. Since clients and miners ask for new blocks from nodes, anyone that asks for blocks from Node A would not get the 1.5MB block, but would get it if they had asked Node B. If 10% of node agree with Node A, then the 1.5MB block could be gotten by a lot of clients and miners, but not all. If 50% agree with Node A, then you have a serious problem in which a lot of people are not going to get the 1.5MB block and a lot of miners will spend their time on it for probably no ultimate benefit.

Thus, the problem does not really begin until any miners start accepting blocks from the chain of blocks that will eventually be rejected by the network generally. Unfortunately, there is no way to tell ahead of time which is the right side of the fork, but this could last for hours. So, fork detection is critical to avoidance of wasting precious mining resources.

scrupulusalbion··on A Response to Your Petition on Edward Snowden
> Right now, he's running away from the consequences of his actions.

So this is what passes for responsibility according to the President's advisors? It might be appropriate to bring this up the next time Obama undermines some reportedly-bad Republican-made policy and the Repbulicans turn around and demand that Obama step down as president. According to Lisa Monaco, it would be irresponsible for Obama to run away from the consequences of his actions by not stepping down in that situation.

scrupulusalbion··on Java 9 Early Access: A Hands-On Session with JShell – The Java REPL
This may certainly be an instance of non-Lisp languages gaining features from Lisp until everything is rated according to its Lispiness: "Not only does this new ISA have native s-expressions, but it also has a REPL! Its accessible via JTAG."

I can dream, can't I?!

← PreviousPage 3 of 3