HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sebastialonso

342 karma · joined April 30, 2013

submissionscomments
sebastialonso··on How to Criticize Computer Scientists (2001)
What a lame comment. I could have written one better If I had the time!
sebastialonso··on Facebook is autogenerating pages for white supremacists
Move fast and break things is a terrible slogan. See Google for example.
sebastialonso··on Cargo Cult Science (1974)
Any scientific theory has two well defined goals: to tie multiple part of the known together, and also tie those parts to some part of the unknown.

Prediction is an important point, but it's just as important as meaningfully stitching together what's already known to produce new knowledge.

I'm academically ignorant about economics, I'm honestly asking is there really a body of knowledge about economics, like different theories conversing between each other? Are theories built on top of each other?

sebastialonso··on My survey article on P vs. NP (2017)
I think Aaronson himself addressed most of this criticism in the survey. Look under "The Kitchen-Sink Objection" and "The Mathematical Snobbery Objection".
sebastialonso··on Avoid Contentious Terms
What I think grandparent comment should think is: is it more important to convey my idea or to show that I'm part of a group?

Both do well for different contexts. Probably choosing one for every context is a terrible idea.

As that saying goes: "if wearing a tie or not is more important than to pitch your idea, then your idea wasn't that important to begin with"

edit: parent -> grandparent

sebastialonso··on Avoid Contentious Terms
I think that's one of the main points of the article. And arguably, a point that perhaps every reader should take with them after reading it.

Not that "using some words give the listener implicit information about you", but that if some words activate some bias in the listener, than perhaps is better to avoid them, only for a while. Maybe wait until a common set of understanding has taken root before taking out the lingo.

This is only relevant if your intent is to actually reach across the aisle and understand where the ignorance/hate/whatever comes from; in essence to engage meaningfully for both parties, not necessarily convince.

If that's not your intention, then probably you'll feel offended at the discouragement of using some words. I'd say bias is the ultimate enemy here, and unfortunately, it's very hard to defeat bias head on, it's easier to lay a trap for it and slowly chip it away. I wouldn't say "patience" is a quality of any kind of discourse nowadays, from any "side".

sebastialonso··on We haven’t seen a quarter of known bee species since the 1990s
I cannot make sense of your second paragraph. It's either badly written, badly argumented or both.

I'll try again. If the metaphor you're choosing is a company losing their clients, then your argument is wrong, because what happens is that the competitor(s) fills the void and the system balances itself.

Why would that not happen in the scenario parent comment proposed? What rule prohibits it?

sebastialonso··on Perseverance rover’s descent and touchdown on Mars [video]
So what about the previous rovers? What were they using?
sebastialonso··on Superintelligence
But points against what? The very idea that a hyperintelligent being is _possible_ very much lingers in the land of science fiction. Yes, even today.

Anyone with a little education in artificial intelligence knows that it's either impossible or somewhat possible but not likely. We truly are no closer to artificial consciousness that we were 500 years ago, it's all still smoke and mirrors.

The thing that's actually a dangerous scenario is the dumb artificial intelligence we can build to start misbehaving, due to human programming errors or statistical bias: self-driving cars running over people; military systems confusing friends from foe; this stupid predictor keyboard not predicting correctly what I'm trying to type. This is the stuff of real, possible and demonstrable fears. Anything grandeur has no basis in reality.

I haven't read Bostrom's book yet, but from what I've read from others about the book, it's all about this nonsense that we can create a new kind of intelligence who will instantly destroys us. This is cool for people ignorant of the basic tenets of what A.I. is (so far) but for people who actually know or understand the current state, they should know better.

Worrying about an hyperintelligent A.I is like worrying about ghosts while living in a neighborhood filled with serial killers.

edit: grammar.

sebastialonso··on Poor evidence that Q-tips are harmful
IMO this is infantilizing is completely justified in many fields, but not all.

Ignorant people are like children, infantiles. And we are ignorant in different things, by in many things. There's a reason you infantilise infantiles, do you not?

sebastialonso··on 'Havana syndrome' likely caused by directed microwaves – US report
It seems you have discovered the egg and the chicken problem.

What is a "well-credentialed" Investigator if it's not measured by peer review? It seems to me like an argument from authority, which is ten thousand times worse than "problematic peer review" you claim. Define well-credentialed without peer review without a cycle please.

What is "backing of a large-scale professional firm or institution"? They already exist, they are called journals, which perform, surprise, peer reviews. Other alternatives you mention are probably private organizations, you seriously believe it's less problematic than already less problematic journals? Much naivety in this argument.

Peer review has its problems, but as you've been told before, it's the best we have come up with. Your proposals are much worse than what we have.

sebastialonso··on 'This is not science fiction,' say scientists pushing for 'neuro-rights'
Chile la already discussig this scenario for their new Constitution. One of the first in the world even.
sebastialonso··on Pigs are as smart as dogs. Why do we eat one and love the other?
Uuuh...dogs can't eat any type of food. Everyday things like garlic, onions, avocado and chocolate, in no big a serving, can kill them in a relatively short time.

Please be aware of our little friends can and should eat.

sebastialonso··on Mars Problems vs. Venus Problems
That's certainly part of the solution, but not the whole picture. Even if you stopped pumping CO2 today, 1) global weather processes have already started,. 2) the rest of the already pumped CO2 is not going to magically dissapear. It will take time, time we don't have.

The only actual solution is to engineer many solutions, supported by reducing the pumping CO2 at a minimum, hopefully zero.

sebastialonso··on Mars Problems vs. Venus Problems
I don't understand, maybe I'm misinterpreting your position.

Based solely on the scale of the problems yourself presented, you must surely agree that (mega)engineering is the most factible solution in terms of time. Greening the desert might be the best idea but the scale certainly sounds right.

sebastialonso··on Dream Vendor "Canna_Bars" Sentenced to Prison
Which is hilarious if you're monetising their videos.
sebastialonso··on GoDaddy and Felons.io – The life of an unregistered domain
That's fair. If we use the high standards you mention, then neither story presented credible evidence (or any evidence whatsoever). This was a massive waste of time!
sebastialonso··on How real are real numbers? (2004)
I don't understand. You didn't say anything remotely political
sebastialonso··on The Zen of Erlang (2016)
your first statement is correct. if you can leverage none of the language's strength, why do X thing in it? what can be gained?

IMO that's what makes languages "great": domain specificity.

General purpose languages beg the scenario of a person who only knows 1 language and tries to do everything in that language instead of learning a more appropriate one.

sebastialonso··on Ancient human ancestors carved handaxe from a hippo femur 1.4M years ago: study
I'm trying to come up with alternative ways to convey meaning as precise and detailed as to carve handaxes from bone without using spoken language, primitive or not.

Maybe some mix of sign language, sound and pantomime?

sebastialonso··on How to track and display profile views on GitHub
why the need to make everything "social"? I doubt most of the population has levels of insecurity enough to be continually thinking where to implement such things.
sebastialonso··on Göbekli Tepe
I'm intriged.

> the current state of knowledge is

Do you mean specifically to this site or to the profession in general?

sebastialonso··on Göbekli Tepe
To me, the alarms sound way before that. You can change the tune of your idea if you need to persuade people, while at the same time being honest about it.

What I don't like about Hancock is that he uses Gobekli Tepe as a prop: we don't know the whole story/history about it, but he will gladfully use it to support his claims, without actually producing evidence that furthers our knowledge on what Gobekli was!

I can surely entertain the idea of lost civilizations, but that doesn't imply I validate the dishonest handling of unknowns as "evidence".

This is what pseudoscience and con men do to appear respectable.

sebastialonso··on Sensors detect rise in nuclear particles on Baltic Sea
What the hell? Thanks for this, haven't seen anything about this anywhere.
sebastialonso··on Show HN: Segfault, a podcast mapping the field of computer science
Are you avaliable on Spotify? I found a Segfault podcast there, but it's completely on a non-common language.
sebastialonso··on 'Into The Wild' bus removed from Alaska wilderness
I'd argue that any "lofty ideal and romantic notion" is by definition wrong, because it assumes a simplicity about the world that empirically, demonstrable does not exist.
sebastialonso··on Facebook fires employee for publicly scolding a colleague
> Intentionally not making a statement is already political. Consider that next time you think of Recoil.

This part right here, pal. Asking is proposing something, and politely accepting whatever answer is given back.

What he said was closer to coercing and appealing to community shaming, which is evidently not professional.

sebastialonso··on Officer of China’s People’s Liberation Army Arrested at LAX
I don't follow. The charge doesn't seem to be for the visa charge, it's evidently because of the state-sponsored theft of IP.

I too would argue for longer, harsher sentences for foreign spies. Force rival nations to stop or to get better at it.

sebastialonso··on I’m a Developer. I Won’t Teach My Kids to Code, and Neither Should You (2018)
Seriously.

> Sure, make it available for those who are interested, but let’s be honest—most kids will have little interest in coding, and forcing them to learn it anyways will not provide any lasting benefit.

This could apply to mathematically skills also. Personally, I would never raise any kids under this ideology. It seems to foster ignorance and conformism.

sebastialonso··on I’m a Developer. I Won’t Teach My Kids to Code, and Neither Should You (2018)
I think I might be losing something, but why would you put your kids into art school if you want to develop games?

Even thinking about the aspirational reason, game artists don't make the money you might be thinking. That's engineering and engineering only.

It's like a tower of mistakes.

← PreviousPage 5 of 7Next →