342 karma · joined April 30, 2013
Does it qualify as an actual prediction? Broken clocks are correct twice a day but...
Money or any monetary transactions plays two roles in these kind of business. The unrecognized one is that it plays the role of guarantee (ideally, but in reality is something like 'more or less'). What guarantee do I have as a driver or as a client if I use an ad-supported billing system, which we all know is next to crap? This is a really poorly-thought idea. Uber's strength is in the elegance of its business model.
If you're going to propose a crazy but interesting possibility, you cannot pull the 'can't speculate, they're to superior' card. You already speculate by sharing the idea!
As such, should we nurture, protect, and by all means spread the intelligence sickness? I'd think yes.
Exhaustion doesn't qualify as a real argument, in my opinion.
They didn't have a good ride that time, and it's a fact that they won't have a good ride now.
Why is this a bad thing? You decided to download and to play the game. You put yourself under the "game" rules. You are an adult, not a child.
>Even worse is when they later convince themselves that the money was well spent (say, for an extra life in Candy Crush).
This is a highly subjective claim to make it pass as an argument. I may personally agree that every money spent on games is money not well spent but that is just my opinion.
Users are not babies. As long as no gun is pointing at them (i.e. the game gives you any content for free but also offers you more if you pay ), every purchase they do is legitimate.
Maybe I'm losing the point of this whole debate, I don't understand what you think users need protection against.
I tried 'how many seeds an avocado has?, 'How many hairs an average human has?' and finally 'how tall is Brad Pitt?'.
Only the third one got a straight answer, the rest started talking about avocados in general and types of cells in the human body. Needs more work, but I like the idea of a simpler Wolfram Alpha.
And in which context are you using the "evil" word?
>And there are plenty of reasons to think that what goes on inside the brain cannot be mimicked by a computer or algorithms as we currently know them. We don't even know what consciousness is! We should at least admit as much...
I agree, it's a huge jump! And that's precisely my point. The brain as a computer paradigm has nothing to do with the idea that an i5 core can't recognize cats, is the theoretical aspect of a computing machine that is used when trying to argue in favour of the BaaC paradigm.
Conciousness is precisely what doesn't fit in the BaaC paradigm. So the research should start from there. I'm curious if the definition conciousness will have to be changed in the near future. Exciting times!
Brain as a computer, in my opinion should be the default state for this discussions. Why? Consider the old and tired brain-made-of-matter argument. There's no reason to think there's something magical or supernatural inside the brain, so treat it as an organized collection of atoms doing cool stuff. The default state cannot be magic, it has to be something that can be disproved or ruled out.
Some parts of it seem to work, as fas as we know, in a (suspiciously) algorithmic way, or in other words, a highly abstract step-by-step chain of actions can be identify for a given part of the brain.
Why not start with the crazy assumption that the whole brain acts as a computer (the theoretical concept), and then identify which parts of it fail the analogy? The key part here is the word 'fail': it should not mean 'too complex for any computer we have built' nor 'we don't know any algorithm that does that', it should mean that there are parts that inherently cannot be modelled, under any circumstances, like the definition of algorithm. If some part is discovered not to hold the analogy, you should just then question if the analogy is question is apt or not.
As I can see now here in HN, a lot of people idealize the idea of Open Source to mean the stereotype of the current zeitgeist good side, when it does not.
>No. This is not an issue of partisanship.
Okay, let's read on then...
3 of the 4 reasons OP explained are directly linked with her being a part of the Bush Administration.
I do believe having Ms. Rice on board is a bad idea. But please don't say one say one thing ("it's not because she was a part of the Bush administration") and then do other ("IT IS because she was a part of the Bush administration").
Bad way to get people behind you, and makes you look painfully unserious.
And what do I gain from it?
If? Neat.
In most of Latin America, English lessons are not something important for most people, because the actual chance to go abroad for work and actually speak the language is non existent. And that has to do with the nature of the jobs here. Having said that, I've notice that at least in Chile, and particularly in the startup/software development sector, this is changing at very quick steps, I'd presume it's the same in the rest of Latin America.
So, it's only natural that we have one language for programming, and don't think is a bad thing, quite the opposite. As a social measure, SO is hitting the jackpot, giving spaces for those who didn't have any.
I, personally, would focus more in teaching real life English, i.e. speaking the damn thing in the first place, focus on real life situations, and what not. SO should think this measure is only a patch, in some form. Is not, and it shouldn't be think of as a solution.
Then it becomes impossible to move further, without changing the social schema. Possibly into a hive form, where everything is easier to manage.
From an engineering point of view, it's the perfect choice: easy to manage, easy to enhance, divide labour and what not. From a social point of view, yikes.
Is there a branch of sociology or something that study the effects of different social schemas?
I'm all for innovation,and finding ways to make things, environments and habits, better, more efficient, safer and more intelligent. This, however, raises an interesting moral dilemma. In these ecosystems, prior to the disruptor, agents live and thrive. After the disruptor, these agents must adapt or otherwise, be gone.
When you think these agents are actually human beings, with issues, dreams and families, a new variable is added to the discussion. Is it OK to disrupt an ecosystem if you find a way to make everything better? Is it moral? You found a better way, so surely it must be implemented, and there are few arguments against that. The agents in the ecosystem had almost all what was needed to find the new way, to enhance their ecosystem: time, experience, imagination. And for one motive or another, they failed to do it. What is their argument when someone else comes along and provides a better solution?
I'm not trying to sound Randian or anything, but I truly believe that 'we have families to feed' or 'will lose job' is not a very good argument. Is the ecosystem supposed to be kept in the previous state just for the agenda of a subset of the agents? Under that argument, we shouldn't have cars in the first place. Nor bronze age (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-EGAtLGDU7M)
Is this a testament of the inherent cruelty (cruelty in a poetic way, just as natural selection can be thought of cruel) of the free market, or just a testament of the importance of innovation as a way of survival? Maybe both? I can't help but notice heavy analogies with Natural Selection.