HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

seekely

803 karma · joined August 6, 2007

submissionscomments
seekely··on Is The Game Industry A Happy Place?
This observation is just not true, or maybe it varies depending on your position. As a developer in the industry, you will rarely be without a job or in a position where you can not jump to another studio. Once you are in the industry, you will end up with friends at studios all over the place. The turnover and 'grass is greener' syndrome in the industry is just too high for networking not to naturally happen. You do not even have to try.

As for the friendless of the people, while I like working in games for the games, the culture that develops around the people working on games is the bigger draw.

seekely··on My [husband] works for Electronic Arts, I'm ... a disgruntled spouse. (2004)
And I don't think the apologizing to families and stupid hours will ever completely go away because working in games for many is a big part of their life/identify/pride for better or worse. Given 1 year or infinite years, some people will choose to make their current project their life. Just as many choose to make their startup/band/sport/passion their life.

The only problem comes when the studios, like EA Spouse, get abusive and ridiculous due to incompetent management. However, over the last 5 years of being tangentially and directly involved in games, I see this happening less and less.

seekely··on My [husband] works for Electronic Arts, I'm ... a disgruntled spouse. (2004)
Keep in mind your friend is at one studio of many under the EA umbrella. Just like the entire game industry, some studios are a mess. Unfortunately (and probably unfairly) EA takes the brunt of the bad PR.

However, EA and most other studios industry wide have taken great strides to improve the treatment of employees since the EA Spouse ordeal. There will probably forever remain bad/overworked studios, but I see plenty of those outside of the game industry as well in environments even less enjoyable/creative/fun.

seekely··on EA Sports Locks Out Multiplayer Modes On Used Sales
Ha, we're on the same page. I meant the line in a 'if EA wishes to stay in business, they will have to recoup their costs from their customers' way.
seekely··on EA Sports Locks Out Multiplayer Modes On Used Sales
This is not the same mentality as the pirate discussion. A pirate gets a $60 game for $0. That's a huge price discrepancy.

At used game stores like Gamespot, the difference between new and used is often $5 or less. It also doesn't matter what the retail price point is set at. The used game price point will always be lower. Since new games are currently identical to used game, why not pick up the game for $5 less? This helps Gamespot and hurts EA.

Now, more a burden will placed onto Gamestop. They will have to lower prices on used games to compensate for the new 'taxes'. If anything, this is a win for used game buyers at the expense of Gamestop (an undesirable company from the perspective of EA).

seekely··on EA Sports Locks Out Multiplayer Modes On Used Sales
The used game market is money left on the table from the perspective of EA. A company should not leave money on the table if it makes fiscal sense to grab it.

EA was probably 'comfortable' with the used game market as long as they were rolling in cash because new game sales were profitable enough to compensate for the used game market and piracy.

However, as budgets increase and margins tighten, EA can no longer just look the other way. EA is hurting and many times X works out to be less than Y.

You suggest they change their business model. That's exactly what they have done. Reward gamers for purchasing the game new while not increasing the price of the game at retail while punishing the used game market which does not fiscally support EA.

seekely··on EA Sports Locks Out Multiplayer Modes On Used Sales
I don't think it's theft at all. It's perfectly rational for a gamer to buy and sell used games. But it's also perfectly rational for EA to try to make as much money as possible from the used game market which completely undermines its business.

I suspect the used car market is also a thorn in the side of auto manufactures. They probably carry higher prices at retail to compensate for the used market as much as possible (assumption). That works for them.

EA could do the same thing and raise the prices of its games to $80-$100. However, they have options. EA would rather shift the cost from 'good' gamers buying new games and go after 'bad' gamers buying from the used market who are only indirectly customers.

Why is this wrong? In the end, somebody has to pay for what EA produces.

seekely··on EA Sports Locks Out Multiplayer Modes On Used Sales
The hostility against these decisions always frustrates me. The market will sort this out, and I'm pretty sure despite all the moaning, it will fall in EA's favor. You can't expect EA or any game publisher to just give their product away.

EA is a business and needs to make money in order to sustain making AAA titles. Nowadays, there are hundreds of people working their hearts out to deliver each title. These people would like to get paid. Gamestop does not pay their salaries. EA does. Every time somebody gives $55 to Gamestop instead of $60 to EA, an hour or two of somebody's work is potentially taken at a loss to EA.

Budgets of games are not going to go down. Gamers wouldn't go for the drop in quality. The used market is not going to go away. It's perfectly rational for gamers to try and make a buck. But this puts EA in quite the quandary.

Rewarding gamers for purchasing the game new is rational and fair. Not evil. EA will make money and the gamer will continue to get well made games. Just because a feature or part of the game was once 'free' doesn't justify it always being 'free'. The market is allowed to correct itself.

seekely··on Atlanta HackerNews Meetup #2: Thursday Mar 11th 7pm at Rira Pub
A facebook group was created http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=354809954022
seekely··on Atlanta HackerNews Meetup #2: Thursday Mar 11th 7pm at Rira Pub
A facebook group was created http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=354809954022
seekely··on Ask HN: Showing off customer feedback useful to you? (new from YC 07)
We search both blog content and blog comments, so if a TechCrunch article or TechCrunch comment mentions you, there is a good chance it will show up in the dashboard. Given the volume of tweets versus blog comments versus blog content, the blog content is usually more buried and has to be filtered out with the radio buttons provided when browsing a Stream.

Admittedly, we are not running our own crawlers right now, so it's hard for us to direct searching at older content or specific sites/blogs. We currently use Backtype (http://www.backtype.com) and ContextVoice (http://www.contextvoice.com) for finding blog comments and blog content respectively.

Our end goal is to find and rank social media content in real time. If somebody as prominent as TechCrunch mentions you, we would like you to know immediately and have that piece of content displayed, noticeable and ready for your approval in our dashboard within minutes.

We are not there yet and it sucks when we completely miss important mentions, but I promise we are working our damnedest to get better.

seekely··on Ask HN: Showing off customer feedback useful to you? (new from YC 07)
Thanks for the feedback. For many searches, there is a lot of noise and very little signal. This is a big usability problem. As we progress the product, we want to get really good at identifying the signal and filter out the thousands of duplicate and irrelevant comments (as you unfortunately stumbled upon).

The best searches for smaller companies right now will be those with unique names or those using a direct Amazon/YouTube/Rss URL, which is obviously not helpful for everybody.

Thanks for pointing me in the direction of Google Checkout Reviews. I'll see if I can get that added by early next week and let you know.

seekely··on Ask HN: Showing off customer feedback useful to you? (new from YC 07)
To somebody just using Tweets (keep in mind that we currently also pull from Amazon, YouTube, Blogs, Blog comments and any RSS/Atom feed), we provide an extra safety net with our moderation. If you just incorporate the Twitter api directly on your site, you have to accept whatever users say showing up. With our moderation in between, you run no risk of the random or ugly comments showing up on your site.

Also, if you do to use more than just Tweets, our API returns normalized data so you have a consistent and reliable set of fields no matter the source.

You can see an example of results from our API here: http://www.habitstream.com/api/service/http?key=973dce2bcf7d...

If you look closely at any of the Tweets in the set, all the data you can get from the Twitter api is still there.

seekely··on [dead]
Is something like this even possible? Can Windows physically tell a battery 'don't hold charge anymore'? Isn't it more likely laptop batteries are always going bad (and boy are they), but now it happens to be at around the same time as a Windows upgrade cycle? And how the hell is this [Confirmed]?
seekely··on 7 Major Sites that Send Passwords Unprotected, & China's Deep Packet Inspection
You can prevent this circumvention by only allowing the client side generated hash to be good for one login attempt. This is done by giving the client a unique challenge string for each login request and hashing the password with the challenge string.

For example, the user browses to http://www.example.org/login. The generated login form on the page contains a hidden field called "challenge" with a randomly generated hash from the server. When the user submits the login form, have the client do a hash(challenge + password) and send this to the server. Upon receiving the hash and checking credentials, the server invalidates the challenge string regardless if the login attempt was successful.

This obviously does not work if the user does not have Javascript enabled and is not preferable to SSL.

seekely··on Fuzzwich (YC 07) featured on the Rachael Ray show (of all places)
Our little segment starts at 2:00 in the posted video.

The best part...

We have been working very hard on a new product to be released in the next month. My head has been buried in work and I, the guy in charge of all the servers and infrastructure, somehow missed the memo we were to be featured on Rachael Ray, a show which receives an average of 2.6 million viewers. Our poor servers are in a long transition to a new setup and weren't prepared for the load. Fun morning.

seekely··on Don't complicate your billing
Meant to hit the up arrow. Hit the down arrow by accident. My apologies.

I agree completely. There are now so many subscription billing providers, writing your own, for such a small service none the less, is a big waste of time.

seekely··on There's No Rulebook for Sex Verification
The amount of work, dedication, persistence, and pain Phelps has endured to achieve the results he has is no less than the work, dedication, persistence and pain an engineer on the first Apollo mission endured. Phelps and the engineer just happen to be good in different domains. They are both amazing people with amazing accomplishments. The world takes all kinds.
seekely··on There's No Rulebook for Sex Verification
The media ruins everything through overexposure and pathetic coverage, from politics to celebrities to crime. I think it is a bit unfair to take it out on sports and competition. What people like Michael Phelps do is nothing short of amazing, and we shouldn't penalize his accomplishments, the entertainment he provides, or competition in general because the media is sick.
seekely··on There's No Rulebook for Sex Verification
Competition sports are historically good for entertaining (actively and passively) billions of people. Do you have an alternative activity which is as engaging to as many people? Why not be entertained by watching fellow human beings push their bodies to the absolute microsecond limit? Why not reward those which are the most entertaining? Most of what we do in the end is completely pointless anyways if you get philosophical enough about it.

If we were all robots capable of performing brain intense activity all the time with no need for leisure activity, you may have a point about sports being pointless. However, we obviously are not. Sports are easy to relate to, easy to participate in, easy to admire and easy to watch. And since sports have remained popular for so long and now have such specialization, the differences amongst the most elite athletes are now only microseconds or centimeters. There is nothing wrong with measuring or finding entertainment from such small differences. I argue it makes it even more exciting.

seekely··on Watch This Video. Do The Complete Opposite of Whatever It Says.
Read the Terms and Conditions (http://www.ijango.biz/Portals/1/IJANGOTermsConditions072809....) to find out what $149 + $19.99 monthly fee can buy you!

I feel angered for all the people that will inevitably be burned by iJango. What are the options to getting something like this shutdown or at least investigated? What is the likelihood this will succeed?

seekely··on Will universal health care motivate the 'job-locked' to start businesses?
Sincerely out of ignorance, are there (or have there ever been) any free market health care systems which have been considered widely successful (by the public, not the providing companies)?
seekely··on Major League Baseball's outdated, misleading offset camera angle
Being anywhere but right behind or right above the plate is going to make it difficult to tell if the pitch was a ball or a strike. Regardless of a dead center or offset camera angle, they are both from the outfield, which makes visually inferring when the ball crosses the plate a hard problem for our eyes to handle. Since pitches, even fastballs, have incredible amounts of movement, watching from a television means guess work at best. Thankfully, all baseball broadcasters have all kinds of camera angles and pitch tracking to show exactly where the ball crossed, and those features are used frequently so the viewer is rarely left in the dark on questionable calls.

Neither is optimal and I personally thought the offset camera did a far better job indicating the pitch was outside for the fastball pitch the article focused on (though the slider movement was indeed exaggerated). Then again, I have watched baseball from the offset angle all my life and it's probably just a arbitrary preference at this point.

seekely··on [dead]
Because a large number of investors and potential clients read Techcrunch, so having your startup mentioned on the site does a lot for your notoriety amongst the business crowd. While Hacker News, Engadget and Gizmodo might be more interesting to us hackers, their audiences expose your company to fewer business prospects.
seekely··on [dead]
To me, this site is about consistently seeing well thought out and educated comments, not a place to let everybody express their viewpoint or opinion just because they have one. I never hesitate to upvote comments which are not in line with my thinking if they are insightful or well constructed or come from an authority on the subject matter or most importantly clearly have more than 2 minutes educated thought behind them. I will always downvote comments which are shallow, reactional, blatantly wrong, or of the 'my opinion matters' type. Most people know very little about everything, and I like how this site and the voting tends to value those who can bring something of value to the table over those who feel like they should be heard but only have shallow (if any) knowledge. Because of this, I will continue to downvote comments which I believe do not belong here, even if the comment presents an alternative view.
seekely··on Google Calculating Which Employees Are About to Quit
When looking for a job, the work from multiple companies can all seem just as enticing. If I'm going to be happy working at any one of the companies, good perks can put one ahead of the other.

And besides, if the perks are outstanding enough, what is wrong with taking a job where the work isn't the most important factor in your choice to be there? For many, jobs are just a means to provide for their needs and wants in life. Not a place to spend their creative energy or brain power. They save those for the rest of their more enjoyable life activities.

Note: I personally have to work at a place where the work is interesting or I'll go nuts. Work is important to me and is a form of expression. But it's not like that for everyone.

seekely··on XP Mode in Windows 7 is a scam
I will never ever understand all the hate for Vista. Excusing the annoyance of UAC, it is their best effort yet. Not without problems. Not without missing features when compared to your favorite OS. Not an incarnation of a perfect OS by an ideal company. But certainly a very functional and reliable product. Maybe my dataset is just too small.

Though, Microsoft just can't do anything right by techies anymore. A comparison to ME? Really? Such fanatical hate.

seekely··on Why baseball benched Microsoft Silverlight
Maybe. But as a paying MLB.tv customer, the Silverlight implementation was TERRIBLE. Despite having all year to make improvements, the thing never worked even remotely correctly. I scolded myself as I signed up this year, but there really aren't any other options. To my surprise, I started up the first game today (go Tribe), and couldn't believe how much the player improved. Judging by how many more (functioning) features and polish are in the Flash player than were in the Silverlight player, I suspect it wasn't just market penetration.
seekely··on Popcuts (YC S08): Buying Music Has Never Been So Profitable
Reading over Popcuts' site, they don't proclaim anything about your ability to make a profit or start a new living by buying music off their site. In their about section, they specifically angle it as getting something back for having 'good' taste in music. And they seem to be delivering on their pitch, as the top earner you cited is getting a 41% discount on the music they purchased. Their music prices are also aligned with both iTunes and Amazon, so I would hope nobody feels ripped off or deceived for purchasing market rate music with the chance of getting something in return.
seekely··on [dead]
I don't think the reason this is not in is because of the number lines of code. You are correct, it would probably be trivial. But, the ability to reverse a vote, unless restricted to a very short period, would encourage group think and certainly wouldn't reduce the signal to noise ratio as you originally claim.

The number of mistaken up votes is probably a very tiny percentage of total votes, and accidental votes from multiple users on the same comment or post are most certainly even more rare. So the odds any given 'noise' comment or post is accidentally upvoted up to a meaningful level are extermely low.

And group think is already a problem on any voting news site. Allowing people to change their vote after they can see how everybody else is voting would certainly not alleviate that problem.

So while allowing a change of vote would help out an individual on their rare case of accidental upvote or downvote, I think the overall community effect would be detrimental.

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →