HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sepositus

527 karma · joined February 4, 2025

Often present the minority view on HN (and pay the karma price).
submissionscomments
sepositus··on Visual Reasoning Is Coming Soon
My (much) older kid still does ridiculous things that defy reason (and usually end up with something broken). I don't think it's fair to say that every action they take has some deeper meaning behind it.

"Why were you throwing the baseball at the running fan?" "I don't know...I was bored."

sepositus··on Agenda Behind the Facial Recognition Tech Used by ICE and the FBI Revealed
> “Power creep” doesn’t necessitate or justify the behavior of this administration.

Well, neither one of those words showed up in my comment. I said that, based on the growth of this technology, power abuse was inevitable. Not justified, not necessary, simply the natural outcome of such things as history has shown us time and again.

sepositus··on Agenda Behind the Facial Recognition Tech Used by ICE and the FBI Revealed
> Both sides are not the same here. Name me a democrat president who has done equal or worse what the trump admin has done.

I think you might have missed the point. The way I read the comment, and perhaps I'm wrong, is that this sort of power creep was inevitable. Which administration it happened under is likely an influencing factor, but to think it was never going to happen seems a bit far-fetched at this point.

sepositus··on We're back: How tuberculosis is set to surge globally once again
Sounds interesting, I'll add it to my list. Appreciate the response.
sepositus··on 'Minecraft Movie' Leaks Online: Full Unfinished Version Shared
> This shows that the limits of the first amendment are speech when its convenient. Links, webpages, and more are speech, but also completely censored in the US media.

I'm a bit confused by this. Are you saying that publishing the text (speech) of a copyrighted book, and then having the link to that text de-indexed, is the equivalent of violating the First Amendment? I assume Google and Bing just treated this as any other copyright violation.

sepositus··on We're back: How tuberculosis is set to surge globally once again
> they vastly underperform us govt agencies

Interesting. I'll have to dig into the data more, then. I wouldn't be surprised if they beat out NGO's dollar-for-dollar (it's expected for the government to have far more funding via taxes), but I'm more curious about the average efficacy of those dollars.

sepositus··on We're back: How tuberculosis is set to surge globally once again
The premise sounds interesting, but it seems a bit reductionist if it boils down to that, no? Is the book looking at it through the lens of government actions or private charities? I'm not aware of any evidence that suggests charities simply stopped operating because of capitalism.
sepositus··on We're back: How tuberculosis is set to surge globally once again
> it is true leadership and collaboration

This is a great outlook, but I think it's slightly short-sighted if you don't consider that there are several ways to achieve the same outcome outside of USAID. I think the US can lead the world through public example rather than trying to set that same example through the government.

For example, I treat my charitable donations with the same seriousness that I apply towards my 401k. I am researching organizations, determining their overall efficacy, and splitting my funds to where I think they would be the most beneficial, given the current global climate.

I would love to see this principle applied more broadly to the public. There might be services out there that already provide such "charity portfolios," but I'll admit that I'm pretty content doing it myself, so I haven't looked much. But, given our government's history of mismanagement, I think this sort of approach would have far more impact than funneling everything through a large organization like USAID.

sepositus··on We're back: How tuberculosis is set to surge globally once again
This was an enlightening article (as I wasn't too familiar with the history of TB), but I'm struggling to grasp the overall point. If USAID is all that's standing between us and TB taking over the world, that's a _seriously_ lousy place to be in. Why are we not spending time talking about resolving that issue instead? You could argue that restoring USAID gives us more time to resolve the issue, but then I would ask what has been happening during the time the funding was active?

Maybe I misunderstood the author's assertion.

sepositus··on Show HN: I made a platform to load and performance test API's
Looks neat, but I hate the "limited free" thing. What's the actual price? If I make this product a part of my team's workflow, what's the future sticker shock?
sepositus··on A number of electric vehicle, battery factories are being canceled
Sure, but I'm not pointing out the longevity of the batteries, but rather the maintenance cost if/when they fault. I understand it will get better over time as technology improves, but it's been a large impediment to me (and probably others) from investing in them.

Here's a recent synopsis that suggests 50% of the car value on average back in 2020 [1].

[1]: https://www.recurrentauto.com/research/costs-ev-battery-repl...

sepositus··on A number of electric vehicle, battery factories are being canceled
Does the total cost of ownership include battery maintenance? My Toyota 4Runner has 180k miles, still runs great, and is worth several thousands of dollars in Bluebook value. My biggest fear with EVs is that I've never heard a single positive story about what happens when the batteries fault.
sepositus··on The slow collapse of critical thinking in OSINT due to AI
> The idea that everyone is either full lazy or not lazy is a bit reductionist.

Fair point. My intention isn't to be absolute, though. Even in a relative sense, I can't imagine a scenario where some level of laziness didn't contribute to the problem, even in the presence of external factors.

It seems like the author was eliminating laziness with their statement and instead putting the primary force on the LLM being "confident." This is what I'm pushing back against.

sepositus··on The Slow Collapse of Critical Thinking in OSINT Due to AI
Yeah, which I consider a form of intellectual laziness. Another reason to doubt that these professionals "were not being lazy."
sepositus··on The slow collapse of critical thinking in OSINT due to AI
> Participants weren’t lazy. They were experienced professionals. But when the tool responded quickly, confidently, and clearly they stopped doing the hard part.

This seems contradictory to me. I suspect most experienced professionals start with the premise that the LLM is untrustworthy due to its nature. If they didn't research the tool and its limitations, that's lazy. At some point, they stopped believing in this limitation and offloaded more of their thinking to it. Why did they stop? I can't think of a single reason other than being lazy. I don't accept the premise that it's because the tool responded quickly, confidently, and clearly. It did that the first 100 times they used it when they were probably still skeptical.

Am I missing something?

sepositus··on TV Garden
My children were interested in playing with it, but this was my fear. Is there actually pornography streaming on it?
sepositus··on Netflix’s Media Production Suite
I barely even remember the last one that I watched let alone enjoyed. I guess it was Arcane which is a total fluke.
sepositus··on How each pillar of the First Amendment is under attack
> I think much of what you say comes from the right-wing disinformation machine

Here we are again. It seems to be the default mode for anything that doesn't match the mainstream narrative. Perhaps you've never heard of it because you haven't been misidentified with the right before? As a centrist, it happens a lot, and there have been plenty of instances where I was called a Nazi.

Of course it's impossible for either one of us to prove how regularly this happens. However, it seems silly to be surprised that someone on the left is unaware of it. Of course, they are. It's completely logical, just like someone on the right being completely unaware of how the right often treats left-wing individuals.

sepositus··on Talkin’ about a Revolution
> Everything that exists deserves to perish.

Well, we can start with this problematic statement. Taken to its literal conclusion, it's not surprising to think it could end up with mass graves. Granted, it originated from Mephistopheles, but Marx wasn't being poetic in his recitations.

sepositus··on How each pillar of the First Amendment is under attack
I mean, this is exactly the kind of thinking that got us here. We just attribute everything to disinformation and throw our hands up as if none of this was avoidable. I'm convinced that people on the right were called Nazi's long enough that some people literally think _every_ one of them is a literal, actual Nazi. To the point where they think there's no hope in ever reaching them.

I saw this coming years ago. The rhetoric on both sides was never going to end up in anything remotely resembling healthy. Both sides are too busy pointing fingers now to really want to do anything about it.

sepositus··on How each pillar of the First Amendment is under attack
A lot of people don't like being told to what say/think/do. It turns out if you bully those people enough they elect a dictator. It wasn't and still isn't a surprise to me.
sepositus··on How each pillar of the First Amendment is under attack
I'm still scratching my head at how some people are surprised by this overreaction. It seems a lot of people think the current fawning over authoritarianism came out of a vacuum. All of the sudden a majority of America came out of stasis and flocked to the polls to elect a dictator.
sepositus··on Luigi Mangione-inspired ballot initiative targets health insurance denials
There seems to be an increasingly large subgroup of people who would never have the nerve to commit murder but are participating in the radicalization of people that _are_ capable of doing such things. They are mostly OK with it now because it's benefitting them. The problem will arise when things inevitably get out of control.
sepositus··on Around the World, Many People Are Leaving Their Childhood Religions
I came to this realization long before I embraced religion. It seems pretty fundamental to the way we do science.
sepositus··on Around the World, Many People Are Leaving Their Childhood Religions
> Why not make them right from the beginning?

I don't intend to come off as obtuse here, but this was my original point. Our current understanding suggests this is a design flaw and is "wrong." However, there are plenty of cases where new discoveries have changed our understanding of a system.

So, I'm simply putting forward the question: At what point can we confidently say something is poorly designed? I'm not disagreeing that, based on our current understanding, some systems in the human body seem suboptimal.

sepositus··on Around the World, Many People Are Leaving Their Childhood Religions
This seems to propose that IT systems deal with the sheer amount of variability a living organism has to contend with on a daily basis. I don't think it's a fair comparison.

At Google (as an SRE), a large portion of my work was trying to understand problems that people have never even comprehended due to the sheer scale we operated at. Reading through code, I would often scratch my head at some decisions, only to later find out it had a really good reason often associated with some high-level incident. I feel the same can be said for biology. Just because it doesn't immediately fit into our theoretical understanding doesn't mean it was designed poorly.

sepositus··on Around the World, Many People Are Leaving Their Childhood Religions
For context, I've been a leader in various (American) Evangelical churches over the last decade.

The fundamental thing that I think many people need to understand is that many of these "changes" are merely an outward reflection of an inward problem. Meaning a large majority of these individuals were often pursuing Christianity due to some external factor. Take, for example, cultural Christianity. I've sat in rooms with people who have literally been in crisis because they don't understand why people don't stay for the potlucks anymore. The entire foundation of their faith was on the culture surrounding Christianity in America. With that now (as the article points out) fading quite rapidly, they are joining their peers in leaving (or, worse in my opinion, becoming Christian Nationalists).

Many of us have seen this coming for a long time. Heck, if you go back and read Francis Schaeffer's writings, especially his later ones, it's almost uncomfortable how accurate his predictions were.

sepositus··on Around the World, Many People Are Leaving Their Childhood Religions
I'm sure being mercilessly mocked is a contributing factor to these statistics.
sepositus··on Around the World, Many People Are Leaving Their Childhood Religions
To play devil's advocate, are we at a state where you can confidently say the design is sloppy? I feel it's akin to looking at an incomplete puzzle and judging it prematurely.
sepositus··on How to write blog posts that developers read
> It reached the front page of Hacker News, even though readers there are generally hostile to cryptocurrency-focused stories.

The real litmus test :)

← PreviousPage 4 of 9Next →