HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

shaki-dora

1,513 karma · joined November 26, 2016

submissionscomments
shaki-dora··on Climate protesters storm Garzweiler coal mine in Germany
Slavery was legal, interning Japanese-Americans during WW2 was legal, Apartheid was legal etc. Legality often lags morality.

The Civil Rights Movement also stepped on a few lawns it wasn't supposed to.

shaki-dora··on 8chan served with search warrant [pdf]
"It" did actually happen, shortly after the post, and was therefore both imminent and likely.

This was also the second such incident within just a few weeks. Knowledge about Christchurch should maybe have informed these "shitposters'". Can't really claim it's all just a joke after people have died.

shaki-dora··on 8chan served with search warrant [pdf]
The "oh it was ironic" defense sounds especially weak when OP subsequently shoots up a synagogue. Guess he didn't get the irony? And neither did the Christchurch incel a few weeks earlier? That incident should have maybe informed the community's opinion on the future viability of that particular excuse.

It's also telling that both un-ironic murder sprees resulted in general approval, and no visible signs of regret on these boards. Or, you know, shutting them down.

shaki-dora··on The Coming Ice Age (1958)
Because "The Solar System travels through the Galaxy, creating cycles" is meaningless drivel.
shaki-dora··on Magnesium and major depression (2011)
Needs a [2011] and some scepticism: Many people have tried Magnesium because it is cheap and available without prescription. If it were as effective as "success in 220 out of 250 cases" claims, that would show up.

The 220 of 250 claim also doesn't fit with "as effective as the tricyclic antidepressant imipramine". No antidepressant is 90% effective.

shaki-dora··on NOAA upgrades the U.S. global weather forecast model
Forecasts have improved dramatically. A 7-day forecast is now somewhat useful when deciding to have your party indoors or outdoors, whereas in the 90s next-day forecasts could hardly compete with the naive assumption of "the weather will stay as it is".

But by mentioning machine learning, I'm guessing you are looking at a different timescale, i. e. "within the last two years". And any progress in the short term will be slow compared to what we have seen in other domains such as image recognition etc.

I'm no expert on weather forecasting, but I believe the explanation may be that forecasts have long been (among the) best financed "big data" problems out there. That means they incorporate lots and lots of domain-specific work. As a result, naive machine learning models currently still lag all the specialised work, which in turn isn't structured in a way to easily take advantage of progress in, say, GPUs.

shaki-dora··on When murderers were hanged quickly (2014)
Crime, especially violent crime, is lower today in all those "soft" western countries than ever before, so we can't be doing everything wrong. Among them, the murder rate is about five times as much in the only country still using the death penalty (the US) than, for example, western Europe (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_intention...)

> I'd want to watch, too.

So I really don't understand why you seem to be indulging in such fascist revenge fantasies? It's not healthy.

I also don't get why such people are always obsessed with rape and paedophilia? The latter isn't even crime, btw.

> Aggravated armed robbery (which is terrorism)

Now you're just redefining things. Terror has a definition: to cause terror (fear). Robbery has a different intention (getting something valuable).

> ID theft all warrant something like this in my mind.

Sure. Also breaking the speed limit and taking the express checkout lane with more than 10 items.

shaki-dora··on Seattle has stopped charging people for personal drug possession
It's a bit cynical to call homelessness "risk free" in any sense of the term.

You seem to be arguing for criminalising poverty. That's going to work just as well as criminalising stupidity, short-sightedness, death, or losing your car keys.

shaki-dora··on Seattle has stopped charging people for personal drug possession
The US has 500,000 homeless people. Let's say it would cost about $1,500 per month to provide them with basic lodging and basic needs. That's $9 billion per year, or about $30 per citizen.

As a comparison: The F-35 fighter program is expected to cost $1.5 trillion over 55 years. That's $27 billion per year, or about three times as much as it would cost to fix homelessness.

Let's compare with what you're advocating, which appears to be the status quo. The existence of homeless people (not all of whom are drug addicts, by the way) shows that drug criminalisation doesn't work.

Homeless people don't need more suffering to finally get their act together. Life on the streets is plenty uncomfortable and dangerous, and nobody operating according to your simplistic model of sticks & carrots would chose it.

Further criminalising behaviour you don't like such as being badly dressed or prone to shouting random, schizophrenia-induced nonsense seems not just heartless, but rather close to dividing society into your kind and "subhumans" to be exterminated. Because if you don't think they deserve food or shelter, and you want to drive them out of cities (and, presumably, towns) where are they supposed to go? I want to be as charitable as possible here, but "push[ing] people out of the public sphere" seems to be a euphemism to bus them into the desert and not watch them die.

Being slightly annoyed by homeless people is also the least you can do if you actually believe in the "public sphere" as a community of citizens, and not just the place to get cheap takeout. If others' suffering cuts into your bliss, either through its annoying smells and sounds or because there are remnants of empathy in play, that should be motivation to solve the problem. There are many countries poorer than the US that have far smaller homeless populations, so it is entirely possible.

shaki-dora··on You probably don’t need ReCAPTCHA
"all their data" is a bit much, isn't it? ReCAPTCHA gives Google exactly one datum, namely the user's visit to the one page it is on.

And I would even hazard a guess that the TOS specify that Google will not retain/link that information, considering that's how Analytics is run.

shaki-dora··on Mary Meeker’s 2019 internet trends report [pdf]
That's a pretty amazing slide even with that error(? see below). 15 of the top 25 tech companies had 1st or 2nd gen immigrant (co-)founders.

As to booking.com: from reading the Wikipedia entry I gather the original dutch-founded booking.com was at some point acquired by Priceline Group (which had an American founder), which later changed its name back to booking.com. It seems the slide is (technically) correct, and any attempt to capture such cases in a workable definition would be complicated.

shaki-dora··on Pylon – Declarative layout primitives for CSS and HTML
One man's pedantry is another blind man's attention to detail. Or ability to participate in society.
shaki-dora··on Pylon – Declarative layout primitives for CSS and HTML
One answer reveals itself by just switching two lines around:

> Why were tables declared evil? > Granted, we develop for a fixed screen width.

Personally, I was always more disturbed by the anti-semanticism of the layout use of tables. But I guess at some point the web developer community just really stopped caring about such issues. Or at least that's my takeaway of the common atrocity of style attributes on individual elements that css-in-js approaches frequently produce.

shaki-dora··on G20 agrees to push ahead with digital tax
The issue isn’t so much any anti-competitive misbehavior. Even though there are some specific practices that have landed FAANG in hot waters, those aren’t really different from any other companies’ of similar size.

Monopolization just happens to be the natural state of any system that has network effects and where all costs are front-loaded (I. e. write the code once, scale to billions of users at, if you squint, zero marginal costs).

But neither of these issues are the motivation for calls for a “digital tax”. Nor is economic nationalism. There have always been industries that were dominated by one or just a few countries: the US has media/entertainment, consumer goods manufacturing has almost entirely moved to Asia, etc.

What’s different about “digital” is that requires essentially zero presence or taxable activity at the consumers’ location. Nobody felt the need to tax Hollywood’s movies because a ticket to ‘Titanic’ in Austria may have meant 2€ leaving the country, but the bulk of it actually stayed in the local economy, as (taxed) revenue of the theatre, local distributors, corn growers, and breweries.

For physical products, this is even more obvious. French champagne served in a Billings, Montana restaurant is about 50% margin for the venue, 30% for the US-based distribution chain, and only 20% goes to funny mustaches people in striped shirts.

shaki-dora··on G20 agrees to push ahead with digital tax
Even the EU does not have the power to tax. It’s practically impossible that a rather informal forum like the G20 would be granted such authority.
shaki-dora··on Search the Full Text of Nonprofit Tax Records for Free
I also looked there first and was surprised that they apparently do not publish their financial reports themselves.

It's not a major issue, since the data is disclosed on the government side, but it's just bad service and leaves an impression of in-transparency.

shaki-dora··on Magic mushrooms, illegal in most places, may have therapeutic uses
It's just a state of extreme bliss, plus (and distinct) an appreciation for all sorts of suddenly very beautiful things: music, landscapes, people, etc. Sound especially feels incredibly precise and 3-dimensional.

Long term, the effect is rather small. I didn't have any negative hangover as some people apparently do, but rather a sort of low-intensity glow that slowly diminishes. In terms of treating depression, I don't think it made much difference either way. But since I have been suffering for as long as I remember, it was actually the first experience of such strong feelings I now at least know what improvement would feel like.

shaki-dora··on Search the Full Text of Nonprofit Tax Records for Free
$37 million for salaries, $32 million "other expenses", and $12 million that weren't spent.

see https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/460...

(I planned to make a smart-ass comment about this story literally being about an interface to answer such questions. But "other expenses" is just slightly to meaningless to declare victory here)

shaki-dora··on Magic mushrooms, illegal in most places, may have therapeutic uses
I suffer from severe depression. The surprise with LSD was actually that it made me happy. I had expected (and got) weird colors etc, but I thought its emotional impact was somewhere from neutral to negative.

In about 8 trips over as many years, I haven't had a bad experience, except one that just went on too long and became exhausting.

Yet I have had friends that are far more psychologically stable react negatively to it.

I've never seen anyone react badly to MDMA, and I think it may actually be more useful for emotional work. LSD makes me generically happy, but I'm more likely to develop a fascination with areal mapping than gaining any introspective.

Marijuana is pure hell. Sleepless nights of mild nausea, intense headaches, and terror nightmares. And mixing it with alcohol drops my blood pressure to syncope/sweating/panic levels.

shaki-dora··on Magic mushrooms, illegal in most places, may have therapeutic uses
The recent interest in Ketamine/MDMA/psychedelics is long overdue. But I can't help feeling the optimism is somewhat too high?

I would encourage everyone to try LSD at some point in their lives. There are just vast parts of culture and humanity that you will suddenly understand. Most striking for me was seeing everyday scenes on the streets–people in cafés, parks, etc.–exactly as they are depicted in impressionist paintings. Or, of course, The Dark Side of the Moon.

But I'm sceptical regarding therapeutic use. Somewhere between 2% and 5% of people have recreationally tried most any given category of drugs. It was explored rather thoroughly in the therapist community in the 60s and 70s. If, indeed, they had the potential to essentially cure any of the diseases we have so far failed abysmally (depression, schizophrenia), no moralising majority would have had the power to suppress them.

What's promising are some less-frequent diseases such as PTSD. PTSD is somewhat unique because it involves memory, a system which we seem to have a much better chance at influencing compared to the evolutionary ancient limbic system of emotions.

Another fun aspect is the use of MDMA in talk therapy. For psychiatrist, it's an absolutely mind-blowing experience. They have often devoted their life to learning to get people to open up to them. And here you give them a pill and the effect is, reliably, like that scene of Robin Williams hitting Matt Damon in Good Will Hunting.

shaki-dora··on USA lags behind EU, Brazil and China in banning harmful pesticides
"One study found that not using pesticides reduced crop yields by about 10%"[0]

That's not terribly bad. There are also communities of organic farmers working on methods to improve yields without pesticides. There is a lot still to be learned (and re-learned) about crop cycling, for example. Other ideas are mixed fields with different crops, new tilling protocols etc.

Some pesticides are also legal under different certification schemes. Sulfur, for example, is the most used pesticide in the EU. Pyrethroid is allowed under some schemes, and it's actually a drug approved for human use (lice), and therefore (and because it's rather old) thought to be safe at the far lower doses one is exposed to via the food chain.

The chart https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pflanzenschutzmittel#/media/Da... is also rather interesting, in that it shows highly diverging use of pesticides and fertilizers across EU countries. There is no definitive pattern here, with Sweden and the Netherlands as the extremes on opposite sides, two countries that are rather similar both in economics as well as climate. Spain/Italy/Portugal might be high because they have much larger shares of multi-year crops such as wine and olive trees, while yearly crops such as corn and wheat are less susceptible because the diseases die with the plants every year. OTOH, at least olives aren't fertilized I believe.

What's also interesting is the positive correlation between pesticide use and fertilizer use. I expected the opposite, i. e. farmers compensating for expected losses to disease with increased fertilizer and vice versa. This not happening may point at a cultural issue at play here, with some farmers choosing these tools excessively, or maybe a lack of knowledge of alternatives.

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pesticide#Benefits

shaki-dora··on Advertising may make people miserable, but it still has its uses
> The overwhelming majority of modern ads serve a singular purpose: to drive sales.

You don't say!

> absolutely nothing to improve the quality of purchasing decisions.

They do communicate the existence of competing products, and are basically the only way to compete with an entrenched market leader. In this sense, advertising is rather important to keep markets fluid and allow better products to flourish.

> rationally consider the direct marketing points you convey

For someone considering themselves hyper-rational, you comment shows a surprising amount of negative emotions.

It's also rather irrationally to believe one of the largest industries is consistently wrong by not following your preferred format of notarised feature comparison spreadsheets.

Because marketing is really full of spreadsheets: those showing that people do sometimes have emotions, and that appealing to them is good business and, frankly, not quite the end of the world.

shaki-dora··on The decline of the family has unleashed an epidemic of loneliness
> Not to excuse the behavior of your drivers, but...
shaki-dora··on The decline of the family has unleashed an epidemic of loneliness
It reads like kitchen psychology. "Wants to leave a pretty corpse" also seems like the worst possible motive, among many. Access to firearms would be a far easier explanation. Just with in the "pretty corpse" theme, I would consider "does not want those finding her to be shocked for life" to be far more important than vanity.
shaki-dora··on Judge Alsup Slams Patent Troll
Imagine a vim v. emacs trial. Do you think a jury pool recruited from the tech community would be able to set aside any pre-existing opinions on the topic, and use just their general knowledge to fairly adjudicate the case that is actually presented in court?

Yes, that requires a lot of "teaching" of the non-expert jury during the trial. But that's perfectly fine, because the purpose of a jury trial is not so much getting a verdict that is "better" in some objective sense than whatever an expert panel would come up with, but to create a process where the public at large feels represented and is able to follow the proceedings and trust the results.

shaki-dora··on Coverage of a Disinformation Operation Against 2019 EU Parliamentary Elections
If, as you suggest, opinions expressed online don't have the power to change anyone's mind, what does it matter when their free expression is curbed by new laws?
shaki-dora··on Coverage of a Disinformation Operation Against 2019 EU Parliamentary Elections
WTF is a "UN banker". Stop mixing up your stereotypes!
shaki-dora··on Logical fallacies in software engineering
The concept of "fallacies" is somewhat overdone, to the point where I'm tempted to coin the "fallacy fallacy".

They are used far too often to shut down some debate: Oh, you want to do this yourself? Not-Invented-Here-Syndrom! Oh, you want to buy from a reputable vendor? Appealing to authority!

I believe the "appeal to authority" fallacy is especially misguided: it's impossible to verify every statement we rely on from first principle. At some point, when the New York Times has an article highlighting the benefits of vaccinations, while @TheyAreTryingToKillYou241234 on twitter says the MMR vaccine will cause your kids to grow a second head, it is perfectly fine, or even necessary, to consider the source of some information as evidence in evaluating it.

This mechanism, of evaluating sources of time and establishing trust, is so pervasive we tend not to even notice it. You are far more likely to hand your car keys to your spouse when asked than to a random stranger.

shaki-dora··on Huawei’s Yearslong Rise Is Littered with Accusations of Theft and Dubious Ethics
This stereotyping is as old as industrialisation. "Made in Germany" was originally a label forced upon the country by the UK, who wanted customers to chose their superior products over the newcomer's low-quality knockoffs. We all know how that turned out.

It was then repeated with Japan, South Korea, and now China.

shaki-dora··on Nudging out support for a carbon tax
I wish I had your optimism. I'm almost certain that even a revenue-neutral bill would be presented as a tax increase in the right-wing media.

And, of course, even something that is revenue-neutral overall will have some winners and losers: SUV owners will pay more than those commuting with public transport. Poorly isolated single-family homes in the south relying on air conditioning through the summer will be more expensive compared to flats in northern brick houses, etc.

← PreviousPage 3 of 18Next →