HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

shaki-dora

1,513 karma · joined November 26, 2016

submissionscomments
shaki-dora··on An Invisible City Beneath Paris
The New Yorker is the one US magazine I subscribe to. It's only about 1 Euro per week even outside the US, so I don't feel bad about not reading it. I'm also planning to use the collected covers to paper a kitchen wall soon, which will solidify my reputation of an insufferable hipster but also look kinda neat.
shaki-dora··on What Can Prewar Germany Teach Us About Social-Media Regulation?
It's obviously statistical malpractice to draw conclusions from one or two datapoints.

But anyway: the UK and France have arguably more restrictive free speech laws than Germany, yet they have far longer democratic histories than the US.

It's also somewhat misleading to present the US as some sort of haven of free speech. Just look at the widespread "de-platforming" of anyone even remotely left-wing during the "red scare"/McCarty era. Or the FBI and other agencies' efforts to undermine both the Civil Rights movement as well as anti-war effort in the 1970s.

shaki-dora··on America’s Oldest Gun Maker Went Bankrupt: A Financial Engineering Mystery
Oh c’mon... This is just empty, nihilistic cynicism. It actually contributes to the problem, because people just stop trying when, completely independent of their actions, they are continually derided as stupid/corrupt/egotistic/lying/etc.
shaki-dora··on Huge study finds drugs stop HIV transmission
I was hinting at the answer: it’s not a known concept, so your (potential) partners will tend not to trust it. Plus I would prefer both to be on it.
shaki-dora··on Guardian records first operating profit since 1998
The fact that you have to link to an archive copy, because even the loony bin that is “counterpunch” has chosen to disassociate with the raving anti-Semite author, speaks volumes.
shaki-dora··on Guardian records first operating profit since 1998
When discussing the media, it’s singularly important to speak of “citizen”, not “consumers”. The importance of media is far larger than entertainment. You could never read a single newspaper or magazine, neither in print nor online, nor watch TV or listen to podcasts, and still you would profit immensely just from others having access to quality news.
shaki-dora··on Guardian records first operating profit since 1998
To be fair, it’s also below the article, and neither a pop up nor interstitial. At that place in the page, it’s rather unimportant how big it is.

It is far less annoying than, say, Wikipedia or even NPR. Everyone should be happy about these results, as it is vastly superior to both paywalls and the ad-infestation other free sites have seen.

(I would also guess it’s rare for the box to actually take up more vertical space than the article. Maybe in breaking-news scenarios, where they start with a single-sentence item, then update it)

shaki-dora··on Huge study finds drugs stop HIV transmission
In a Bayesian framework, a person telling you they are HIV+ would seem to serve to establish some trust. Why admit to to that, but then lie about viral load?

On a more practical level, I would probably go on PreP if I regularly had hookups with men. I’m actually somewhat envious of the gay scene in that regard. The option just doesn’t meaningfully exist at the mostly-hetero sex parties I’ve been at.

shaki-dora··on Huge study finds drugs stop HIV transmission
Your number is definitely wrong, even by your own calculation. Why don’t you update your posts above, which just peddle some ridiculous stereotype of Africa?

Your reasoning also leaves out that a lot of health care never goes through government coffers, both in African nations but also, for example, in the US.

shaki-dora··on Facebook Bans Louis Farrakhan, Milo Yiannopoulos, InfoWars and Others
So someone asks for a nexus between Milo and white supremacists, and someone linking a source with a video of him serenading neo-nazis with their arms stretched out gets voted down?

The it’s-about-free-speech-not-alt-right-sympathy shtick really needs some update...

shaki-dora··on Memory Makers Plan to Cut NAND Flash Production
But they won’t be leaving the market, right? Therefore, they expect to make some profit at the expected higher price, and would stand to gain the most if all others cut production, except for them.

This is a classic prisoners’ dilemma, where everyone should defect. If they don’t, it must be due to coordination, either ex- or implicitly. And because anti-trust is civil law, it criminal, the standard of poof is “preponderance of evidence”, i. e. >50%.

shaki-dora··on The Treaty That Forced the Cherokee People from Their Homelands Goes on View
That depends on the meaning of “these treaties”. The texts have probably been in the PD forever, assuming they were drafted by government lawyers (somewhat likely judging by the content), because everything created by the federal government is. Barring that, copyright would have long expired. So go ahead, I really want to see an adaptation of Indian law to VC term sheets.

The physical documents are not PD, because the concept has no meaning in the physical realm.

Photographs are works separate from the objects they show, but the same limitation as to government works as above applies.

shaki-dora··on Whale with harness could be Russian weapon, say Norwegian experts
This is the sort of totally obvious prisoner’s dilemma that just a tiny bit of international cooperation could easily avoid, if only Russia (and now the US) had not gone down the road of pseudo-macho brutalism in politics.

With the beluga cat now out of the bag, any maritime conflict will be liable to justify the wholesale slaughter of large marine mammals, just as 60 years of preservation efforts have been showing some good results, and incidentally proving that international cooperation actually can work.

On the plus side, nothing was gained. Whales as a weapons, or reconnaissance, platform may have worked as a tactical surprise. But it is useless once it’s known. Killing all the whales in the Atlantic is a day’s worth of fun for bored sailors.

Instead, everyone could have just played солитер all day in the safe knowledge that they are doing the best work of their life.

shaki-dora··on I Can’t Answer Standardized Test Questions About My Own Poems (2017)
That’s sort of like a parody I would write to prove my point.

You’re clearly emotional about the topic, to a degree that cannot be explained purely by doing a few interpretations in school. I don’t see, for example, this sort of venom directed at sports, even though I have heard more anecdotes about the dread of PE classes.

I could also make the same sort of claim about science and math: namely that school did little to inspire any sense of wonder and appreciation for the subject; that it tended to dwell on the rote application of some learnt rules to slightly varying problems without capturing the essence of the subject.

I have an inkling that people here might agree that some amount of rote learning was necessary for sciences to later be able to appreciate them, and that some of us may not have been ready to appreciate those subjects fully as early teens anyway. To not extend this sort of benefit of the doubt to the humanities them seems baffling. It may be explained people never going further in those fields and therefore not evolving the understanding that lets them reinterpret their early experiences. Or it’s an almost active socialization, a choice to fully identify with one group of academia and to deny the other’s validity in an in-group/out-group dynamic.

It’s also somewhat indefensible to claim “pure bullshit”—one just needs a single counterexample to show this, and others in this thread have brought up law as a rather impressive example of the power of interpretation. Personally, I’d point to Hannah Arendt, but I’m sure there are other philosophers for everyone. Heck, even Ayn Rand is squarely in the humanities. Or Carl Schmid if you like Trump, or Hobbes if you hate everyone.

Oh, and I just noticed this, Frankfurt’s On Bullshit is itself very much in the humanities’ wheelhouse.

Were the interpretations you were taught mere bullshit? I bet if you were to go back in time, or pick up a textbook, you’d find that no, they tended to be, if anything, a bit too much on-the-nose. Of course it’s not just about a white whale, but about something in the human experience that we can see far more often than any hunt for large marine mammals. But as teenagers, that sort of introspection was liable to instill a certain amount of existential dread, and quite possible ruin the easy enjoyment of what is otherwise an engaging but rather superficial adventure story on the high sees.

shaki-dora··on I Can’t Answer Standardized Test Questions About My Own Poems (2017)
It’s possible to leave traces of whatever inner conflict tortures you in your writing without even knowing.

For example, the disdain of the humanities in this thread (and generally on HN and the tech community) is just begging for an explanation, because the stated reasons (entirely useless, plain wrong) are neither true, nor would they seem sufficient to warrant the level of emotion.

So there’s something else in the subtext, such as status anxiety, even though the authors would vehemently deny it.

shaki-dora··on Burger King is rolling out meatless Impossible Whoppers nationwide
The uncarnine valley.
shaki-dora··on The Lo-Fi Voices That Speak for America
Quote: „...as better-sounding FM signals become cheaper to broadcast and would-be listeners turn to the internet for entertainment.“

So the premise of the article, in my understanding, is „let’s ignore the bigger media and look at his somewhat anachronistic, yet surprisingly lively niche“.

shaki-dora··on Google Staffers Share Stories of ‘Systemic’ Retaliation
Yes, I think that would be fine. But maybe you just don’t need to talk about people with some term encompassing a multitude of different issues.

It’s long been said that the left/right dichotomy isn’t entirely meaningful, leading to an expansion into a 2D economic/social space. Still, left/right or progressive/conservative, or SJW/fascist tend to lead to just stereotypes that everyone projects their opinion on.

shaki-dora··on Anti-vaxxer leaflet found inserted in book sold by Amazon
Funny how everyone is in this threat is objecting to „this useless crap on the frontpage“, on an article describing parents upset about useless crap coming with their book.
shaki-dora··on Anti-vaxxer leaflet found inserted in book sold by Amazon
By that logic, no propaganda could ever have any negative impact. We should therefore put fliers with all sorts of maybe just random text, or even a sampling of the most vile hate speech we can find into every book sold. Then, we sit back and watch the world improve. Because a thousand monkeys with typewriters may not be Shakespeare, but they are a learning opportunity.
shaki-dora··on Google Staffers Share Stories of ‘Systemic’ Retaliation
So please tie this back to the case on hand. Because I see little nexus between employees advocating against AI arms sales to some „individual“ or „collective“ right, unless it’s the individual war lord‘s right to aerially decimate the collective.

Alternatively, maybe „SJW“ is just a pleasantly blank canvas, pliant to change meaning to whatever is currently needed when one is unwilling to argue the actual case? With the added benefit of inverting the usual moral framework, because arguing for what’s considered „good“ now becomes the meat of the charge against the speaker.

shaki-dora··on Google Staffers Share Stories of ‘Systemic’ Retaliation
Could we do without the derogatory „SJW“ insult? It’s blatantly obvious that it never leads to any discussions of value.

And as far as insults go, it’s an incredibly lazy one. Because there is absolutely no defense against it: the mere advocacy of, for example, anti-discrimination or against AI arms trade will expose you to being called an „SJW“. It’s an insult of last resort, because actually engaging for discrimination or selling drones to child soldiers in Western Africa or whatever would make you look like a deranged crank. Therefore, you use precisely the fact that something is generally recognized as good as an argument against the speaker.

Theoretically, I guess there’s a „no-risk“ accusation included as well (see also: virtue signalling). But apparently, organizing a walk-out and risking your career (see: this article) doesn’t actually qualify as „risk“.

shaki-dora··on Katie Bouman, the computer scientist behind the first black hole image
That... seems like an extremely malevolent take on this?

She has a doctorate from MIT and isn't being glorified for turning on a computer, but for her algorithmic work squeezing information out of the gravitationally mangled paths of spurious photons reaching us after 80 million years.

That "learn to code" meme has also become a favorite of the alt-right to go after anyone they don't like.

shaki-dora··on Katie Bouman, the computer scientist behind the first black hole image
Craig Venter
shaki-dora··on Marissa Mayer on career growth and how a revenue guarantee almost killed Google
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19620176
shaki-dora··on Marissa Mayer on career growth and how a revenue guarantee almost killed Google
Nobody has ever accused Musk of outsourcing his dry cleaning when discussion his workload.
shaki-dora··on Marissa Mayer on career growth and how a revenue guarantee almost killed Google
Funny how you meantime exactly two CXOs. And that those „useless“ two happen to be women, while something like less than 20% of tech leadership is.
shaki-dora··on Marissa Mayer on career growth and how a revenue guarantee almost killed Google
I would be far more willing to believe this if it happened in a discussion of Elon Musk or Jack Dorsey.

But I do not remember this point ever being made in discussions of those workaholics. Until a woman came along.

Also: the same user calls Mayer (and Holmes) „attention whores“ downthread. I rest my case.

shaki-dora··on Public Sans – A strong, neutral typeface for text or display
Indeed! If people just assume you’re corrupt, incompetent, lazy, etc: why even try?
shaki-dora··on Battery Power's Latest Plunge in Costs Threatens Coal, Gas
I may be wrong in the interpretation, but LCOE would seem to apply only to the actual capacity, and not the grid‘s entire throughput.

Yet batteries would only be needed for a fraction of the installed power, to adjust for fluctuations in supply and demand. Most power would never see the battery in such a grid.

And, of course, batteries are only one of multiple strategies to get supply and demand to equalize. Smart consumers is probably the most underdeveloped now, from cars that would charging (and possibly even discharge into the grid if your schedule allows), washing machines picking the best times when possible, or cooling and heating working with their respective reservoirs.

← PreviousPage 4 of 18Next →