HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

shandor

693 karma · joined June 3, 2016

submissionscomments
shandor··on US solar plant costs fall another 30 per cent in one year
Thanks! That is quite surprising, and very encouraging.

It seems that solar is a very good overall fit for even most of the world, and once the tech is good enough to be used in huge numbers the differences can probably be compensated with other, local power sources (like hydro in Scandinavia, which is huge there).

shandor··on US solar plant costs fall another 30 per cent in one year
This is fascinating if true. Do you gave any sources, I'd be really interested in reading more on the matter.
shandor··on Apple Scales Back Its Ambitions for a Self-Driving Car
So what do avionics companies use? C, C++, Ada? Anything else?
shandor··on Why We Terminated Daily Stormer
Sure you can, no one even implied otherwise.

The only thing I said was that the term you are talking about most probably does not inspire the loathing it should (and once did) after all the crying-the-wolf. And considering that, I tried to hint that maybe in the future it might be sensible to take this effect into account before going down the same rabbit hole again.

shandor··on Why We Terminated Daily Stormer
I am not doing any of that. I'm just pointing out that this is a very real case of "crying the wolf" effect working it's voodoo, and that maybe, in the future, something could be learned from all this.

Personally, I'm not even from the US, and find many of the policies of the Republicans almost absurd. Where I'm from, your run-of-the-mill republican would be considered so deep into the right wing as to be completely niche. Almost alt-right, if you wish.

Look, I see where you're coming from. But is it so hard to see that waving the nazi stamp around willy-nilly really will dilute the meaning and connotations of the term, no matter how much you think it was justified. Nazi's are probably the Satan of modern times, literally the thing people use to mean "the worst there can ever be". However Republican policies seem baffling to me, I see no reasonable way to stamp them with that kind of stamp. They're 50% responsible for running your country, for God's sake :)

shandor··on Why We Terminated Daily Stormer
One would think that, for the people calling Republicans "nazis" in the 2000's, the absence of swastikas and Nazi Hails should have cleared things up. But they did it anyway.

People are not simple creatures, and things like crying the wolf actually do confuse us pretty easily.

shandor··on Why We Terminated Daily Stormer
That's not the problem. The problem is that for many, the years and years of calling your run-of-the-mill Republicans and whatnot "nazis" has diluted the term, just like GP mentioned.

So, now, when people try to get others to understand that the Nazis we now have are almost exactly the same we had in Germany way back then, people don't really make that connection (even if they say they do) on emotional level. Instead, they associate the self-professed Neo-Nazis with the "nazi Republicans" and the not-really-a-nazi-alt-righters that have been cried at in the 2000's.

Source: many acquaintances who are clearly very, very confused on the matter.

shandor··on Stop tech-driven problem-solving
I think you're still missing the point. I understood that the author was criticizing the mindset of the companies which "want to use blockchain". In those cases, "moving the goal posts" is actually the sensible thing to do, when said companies are looking into the blockchain without understanding if they are actually going to benefit from the core blockchain benefit of decentralization.

There should be nothing wrong in moving the goal posts, when the original goal seems to be the wrong one.

shandor··on The Blockchain Problem Space – When to Use Blockchain?
That's...surprisingly simple. As it happens I was just today lamenting to a colleague that for all the blockchain hype, I have yet to hear about any other relevant use case than those which have an ideological agenda to require decentralization at their very core.

Reading this it seems like the author comes pretty much to the same conclusion.

Is it really that simple? I feel like I must be missing something, because the hype is so real.

shandor··on Why some of the best developers keep quitting
> Almost nobody wants to work on the exact same thing for more than a few years unless it's genuinely super interesting

That's a really, really tough problem actually. Businesses naturally want people to work on things that they are already very good at, to keep productivity high.

This is especially important in software consulting houses that churn out apps and whatnot without their own products, because their whole business scales only by the factor between the hourly price customers will pay for their work and the salary the developers are getting for that said work.

Which is not to say that I wouldn't agree with your point. It's just that I can also see how painfully expensive not going that route could (i.e. shoehorning) become for such a company, so I'm kind of sympathetic to their apparent reasoning behind it.

shandor··on Flash Is Dead: What Technologies Might Be Next?
Thanks, that was really interesting. Guess I'll have to go and read on mruby now!
shandor··on Flash Is Dead: What Technologies Might Be Next?
Embedded stuff in Ruby?

Now that's a story I want to hear. Any pointers?

shandor··on Passwords Evolved: Authentication Guidance for the Modern Era
The real problem relating to "profit" in these cases is that companies are not penalized at all for leaking their users' secrets, not the fact that security has "tradeoffs".

Software industry is in the same boat regarding this as car manufacturers were decades ago, i.e. it was "more profitable" to make cars that killed their passengers in every other car crash, since people were just making the very rational choice of buying the cheaper rather than safer car.

shandor··on Is 2017 the beginning of the end for the app economy?
This is so stupid. I mean, I don't need the apps, so any kind of coercion is pretty much doomed to fail. I don't usually need LinkedIn, and I definitely don't "need" Pinterest, ever.

Making their websites suck more to encourage me to install some never-used app just means I use their whole product less, making it almost impossible that I'd ever get invested enough in it to install an app for it. Conversely, if their websites were awesome, it might make me use them more, which would only increase the likelihood of me wanting to go the extra mile to even install an app.

shandor··on Blockchains are the new Linux, not the new Internet
> the DAO fork was a result of centralized control due to social factors. As with bitcoin, a >50% consensus is necessary to fork a blockchain

I'm not very well-versed in computational power requirements on this scale, but it doesn't sound at all infeasible that a nation state (or a couple in unison) could setup a "51% attack", thus reducing the social form of control back to only the computational one. And if anything, that threat is only going to become worse with ever-increasing computational capability, advent of quantum computers at some point, etc. Nations (and other huge players) have the resources to tap into all that new power, while the individuals ideally making up the bulk of a blockchain's computing power would most probably not, at least not in big enough scale.

I don't see how that could be prevented, and that leaves me somewhat confused on why the blockchain is advertised as "immutable" as it is.

shandor··on Blockchains are the new Linux, not the new Internet
I keep hearing about an inherent problem in this capability to "resist contentious changes". In dark corners it keeps whispered that if any one entity gets control over 50% of the mining capacity, they can essentially decide the "immutable truth" in the blockchain. Is there any merit to that scenario, or is it complete bogus? And if it's true, how come it's not more openly discussed?

I guess what I'm asking is if things like the hard fork of The DAO Ethereum blockchain are actually a fundamentally solved problem. Stuff like that happening when our banking infrastructure has moved to a blockchain sounds like a disaster.

shandor··on Little Things I Like to Do with Git
Seriously, the more complex your use case is, the better the command line gets.

Personally, I use mostly command line git and on occasion a little bit of gitk if I get lost between all the branches. I die a little (read: a lot) inside when I have to help my team members with git and they adamantly stick to TortoiseGit. It's a prime example of the UI improving discoverability at the expense of performance (and even then the individual actions tend to get lost between all the numerous possible actions).

shandor··on A crashed advertisement reveals logs of a facial recognition system
Thank you, this was the first comment actually telling more on the matter after all the "it said I'm X years old!" comments :)

I guess using such a system just to analyze people in real-time might already violate some surveillance laws like you said (in my country all such cameras must be warned about, even traffic cameras). But do you have any idea if those things also record data on customers? I could see how keeping such a database on customers might be dancing on the fine line of creating a "registry", which is pretty heavily regulated by laws at least here. Even more so if there is a possibility to identify real persons from that data.

shandor··on Ode to the use-after-free: one vulnerable function, a thousand possibilities
I was just going to post a comment asking why your proposed way is not the standard way. Surely free is (usually) not called that often that the overhead would be anything close to unbearable? This seems like a so simple method of handling most of the cases, as you point out, that I feel I'm missing some obvious downside.
shandor··on Better Git configuration
Me too, though I have them setup on shell rather than .gitconfig. Saves that one space after 'g' :)

The ones I find myself using most are 'gru' for git remote update, and 'gka' for "gitk --all -500 &". (The -500 is there to prevent my laptop dying when I run gitk with --all on the Linux kernel repo without second thought...)

shandor··on Firefox 57 as the first release where only WebExtensions will be supported
Definitely. This is exactly the reason I switched from Chrome ro Firefox. I mean, when I'm on mobile it's even more important than on desktop that I have my adblocker in place, as both bandwidth and screen estate are more limited.
shandor··on Announcing GVFS: Git Virtual File System
Could you elaborate a little what has changed there? My understanding is that submodules are still considered a mess, but would be really nice if some actual improvements have happened.
shandor··on Ask HN: Switching from developer to project manager. What to keep in mind?
This probably depends on your exact role, but usually there's enough technical role left for devs-come-PMs that keeping your technical skills top-notch is really important. In the end, you are the one to make a lot of decisions that have impact in the future, so better make those decisions as informed as you can. It's easy to get lost in all the new things with new role, so keeping up technology-wise will need work.
shandor··on Chrome browser for businesses
Sorry but why is that a bad thing?

I can understand that it's "bad" that their story was lacking at release, but isn't it awesome that they'd go to such lengths to serve fans and buyers and have a good product in the end, if not in the beginning?

shandor··on New NIST password guidelines: don't require character types or rotation
The same got my attention too. A really great idea, though I'm not aware of it being used currently at all. It might be, but I've never come across/heard anyone mentioning it. Hopefully this takes root!

Actually, couldn't privacy-caring service providers also check current passwords against newly-leaked lists in case something pretty big gets disclosed and warn their affected users? Would probably take some time for services with big amount of users, but that would be some awesome help to users who use same passwords in most places.

shandor··on What Makes a Senior Software Developer?
That's actually fascinating. Is the formula for the mentioned "developer impact" a hush-hush trade secret, or can you go into more detail on how you calculate it? Would be really interested in hearing more!
shandor··on Stealing sensitive information by using pixels of ad banners
Yeah, but actually the easier the exploit the more concerning this kind of stuff is. I mean if we can't even trump the easy stuff, how about the more sophisticated attacks?
shandor··on How to translate a large C project to Rust
Sorry, but I really have to say that I think adding a waypoint through yet another language can't be a good thing. You're probably much better served by using the time saved from the second rewrite on the actual rewrite (C to Rust) you want to do, giving yourself more time to make it right.
shandor··on Developers’ side projects
I have nothing against Joel. But to be fair, as people in finance use to say, "history is not indicative of the future".
shandor··on We don't need a Tech Lead
While this sounds good in theory (and I've been in teams that were very self-organizing and operated well without a formal tech lead), I feel that it omits some key aspects of real life. Let's look at the list towards the end, for example:

- When there are newcomers, we need a strong coach.

- When there are architectural challenges, we need an experienced architect.

- When there are internal conflicts, we need a mediator.

- When there are external blockers or lack of resources, we need a concierge.

- When we need to negotiate and integrate with other teams, we need a ambassador.

Ok, so the author marked those under "leadership". My experience with other developers is that there is a surprisingly large dev population who would absolutely abhorred if they had to touch any of those things (maybe apart from the architecture part). And in my experience, the effect doesn't grow smaller, and might even become more profound, with prolific devs who have tens of years of experience; they want to code because coding is what they love (this of course applies to more junior devs too).

So the point is not to elevate one individual to some golden standard know-and-do-it-all aka Tech Lead. The whole point, which the article actually does touch, is to have different roles between team members, so that ideally everyone can focus on the things they are passionate about. If more than one people feel that they want to take responsibility with the things mentioned in the above list, fine, the team can have many "tech leads".

Just make sure that if you omit the whole role that people are not burdened with responsibilities they are going to hate. Because that is something that can destroy even a good team pretty well.

← PreviousPage 6 of 7Next →