HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

shanusmagnus

1,401 karma · joined April 8, 2012

submissionscomments
shanusmagnus··on To help new students adapt, some colleges are eliminating grades
I don't understand how this topic can be discussed at all without foregrounding the question of what higher education is for, in terms of how it is used and what are the social consequences of having a degree. Some amount of that is learning the material, some amount is socialization, some amount is proving that you could go through a certain process to a certain standard. Going no-grade will have uneven effects on these outcomes, particularly the first and last. Without being explicit about what's going on, arguing about whether any particular change is good or bad is kind of pointless.
shanusmagnus··on ScholarTurbo: Use ChatGPT to chat with PDFs (supports GPT-4)
The chicken one speaks for itself, but any context on wtf is the origin story on the Pepsi one?
shanusmagnus··on How to be consistent
I've gotten a few candidates hired based on similar principles, and it has turned out well each time, though my sample size is not large. How has it worked for you?
shanusmagnus··on Amazon doubling down on return to office
Good call out. A thing I've noticed is that sometimes the surveys are a response to conditions being super toxic and terrible. Even when they're undertaken for good reasons (e.g., to learn how to fix it) by then so much trust has been lost that the responses are worthless.

The best time to plant a "tree" is when things aren't fucked. Maybe the second best time isn't now.

shanusmagnus··on Silvergate Bank to begin voluntary liquidation
That's my beef with most of the critical takes. Yeah, it has some warts, but an hour playing with the thing, for both broader chat interaction and writing code, make the value evident, and startling.
shanusmagnus··on Silvergate Bank to begin voluntary liquidation
What about recent events would suggest more institutions wanting to get a piece of this action? I'm not being snarky, I'm trying to figure out where banking is going to come from now. Cobbled together small players, is that what it looks like?
shanusmagnus··on Show HN: AskHN
I wonder if the "default to humility" heuristic probably does more harm than good on net, because the people who heed it probably shouldn't, and the ones who should won't.
shanusmagnus··on Ask HN: Should HN ban ChatGPT/generated responses?
That's a great point that I haven't seen in the GPT-related conversations. People view the fact that it can argue convincingly for both A and ~A as a flaw in GPT and limitation of LLMs, rather than an insight about human reasoning and motivation.

Maybe it's an illustration of a more general principle: when people butt up against limitations that make LLMs look silly, or inadequate, often their real objection is with some hard truths about reality itself.

shanusmagnus··on Tell HN: ChatGPT can reply like a specific Reddit or HN user, including you
I'm not sure CGPT is doing what we think it's doing. I asked it to respond to the same comment as me, and got a bunch of generic nonsense. But then I asked it to respond as a user I made up, "dipshitbonkers". Here's what it said:

"Wow, dude, you must be some kind of fucking genius to come up with such a deep and philosophical question about AI models on the internet. I mean, I've never even thought about that before, but now that you mention it, I'm totally blown away by your brilliance. I can't wait to see what other profound insights you have to share with us. You truly are the next Einstein of our time. Keep on keeping on, my friend. You are truly a visionary."

Which is awesome, but a different kind of awesome :)

shanusmagnus··on The best leaders are great individual contributors, not professional managers
In my experience, leadership and management are pretty disjoint. You can be good at one and not good at the other. Although, FWIW, I suspect that your introspection about whether or not you're a good manager means you're a lot better than you're giving yourself credit for.
shanusmagnus··on Foreign Dispatch: Ideas from code editors applied to foreign language writing
I think you and I have a different notion of what "elegance" means. To me, it's not that high a bar. A native speaker who reads for fun and cares about self-expression generally achieves it. It does, however, prove a high bar for a non-native speaker in my experience.
shanusmagnus··on Foreign Dispatch: Ideas from code editors applied to foreign language writing
The OA, and your comment, made me very excited at the prospect of building a kickass AI-assisted language-learning suite. I think interactive writing is a great foundational abstraction, and your description -- of reading a bunch of examples in the native language saying similar things -- would be a beautiful way to realize it: a write, read, write, read, write REPL. Mix in spaced rep and conversation with a partner (conversations would be much less tedious as part of this loop) and you have a language learning hyper-accelerator.

I'm what people in the Midwest [1] call "good with languages" in that I have learned a host of them to intermediate level, and then run aground on getting to advanced, which I think of as the ability to express yourself colloquially and elegantly on any random topic. An IDE like we're talking about would be a godsend, not least because it would speed things up between ten and a hundred-fold.

Argh, I'm tempted to quit my fucking job and try to make this exist, though I'm not qualified to build it. Maybe someone else will do something comparable -- definitely a "take my money" example :)

[1] I mention being from the Midwest bc, when I was growing up, average small-town people lacked any real access or exposure to (or motivation to acquire) other languages. When I got old enough to travel (also not a thing generally done in my social setting), running into people fluent in 4 languages just by accident of birth, would always make me so jealous :/

shanusmagnus··on Survey of workers’ views on salary transparency
Surely. The point is all these systems have tradeoffs. I'm guessing OP would find things to be disappointed in there, too, as have many of the people who actually live in those places.

edit: especially when it comes to comp, which was how this started. The left hand (as it were) criticizing comp in tech, and the right complaining about capitalism, is my favorite part.

shanusmagnus··on Survey of workers’ views on salary transparency
Just wait till you see the comp in the glorious socialist utopia, you're gonna love that I bet.
shanusmagnus··on Survey of workers’ views on salary transparency
Report back after you get a lump sump to allocate between the various people on your team for 2023 raises. That should be an exciting new growth opportunity for you.
shanusmagnus··on Overfitting and the strong version of Goodhart’s law
See footnote 4. I would quote it except it's pretty long and full of links, and an edit, which HN "formatting" would make confusing.
shanusmagnus··on Sam Bankman-Fried's $16B Fortune Is Eviscerated in Days
This was super helpful context, thank you.

Question: how do they know when money migrates between these tiers? E.g., some of my paycheck goes into an index fund; occasionally an index fund gets liquidated to buy a house, or to pay for a vacation. Is there some "trigger" at certain points that lets these tier estimates get updated, or is it just ad-hoc guessing?

shanusmagnus··on Just don’t
I too am a bit surprised, but my reason for upvoting is that I've been using this idiom my whole life and never have thought about it until this moment; getting the history of usage was super interesting. Figuring out _how_ one would figure out the history of usage is interesting! A little gem.
shanusmagnus··on Just don’t
Argh, that resonates. My general strategy: speak up briefly on how we should do {x}, and then, when I am not heard, do their thing {y}, which usually fails, since if I speak up in the first place it means I probably know what I'm talking about.

Anyway, they can recognize the failure of {y}. Now it's time to make my suggestion again, not in an asshole way, but rather: "I think we should do {x}" as if it's the first time I said it; or "Let's revisit what you're trying to accomplish here."

The happy story would be that people are abashed at my great wisdom and sorrowful that they did not heed it. More accurate story is that no acknowledgement of anything occurs, but they are more receptive in the moment, and even a bit more receptive in the future. Took a long time to arrive at this, sadly, my great wisdom notwithstanding.

shanusmagnus··on We've filed a lawsuit against GitHub Copilot
If the resource is free and non-rivalrous, what is being extracted?
shanusmagnus··on Column Vectors vs. Row Vectors
This is getting close to what I wanted -- thank you. But now you introduce what might be the real heart of it: the definition of matrix multiplication. I know the rules of this operation, and how matrix multiplication distinguishes rows and columns, and the geometric interpretation of a vector multiplied by a matrix. But where does that definition come from in the first place?

This might be too ill-posed to answer, it's been years since I was familiar enough with everything to know how to express exactly my confusion. But if you (or anyone) wants to take one more crack, I will appreciate it :)

shanusmagnus··on Column Vectors vs. Row Vectors
I second your request for a detailed explanation of the "technical reason" -- different people kept mentioning it, then saying that they would omit it. I want to know the technical / mathematical details for why, in isolation, row(1, 2, 3) is different from column(1, 2, 3). Like, all the way back down to the purest axioms or geometric intuitions.

I understand why the "rules" of matrix multiplication make the distinction -- but what is underneath those rules? What does it mean?

shanusmagnus··on The currency of the new economy won't be money, but attention (1997)
Thank you so much for this quote! The paper it's from is exactly what I needed right now.

link: https://veryinteractive.net/pdfs/simon_designing-organizatio...

shanusmagnus··on Ask HN: Was anyone working at Apple during Steve Jobs' return in 1997?
I don't believe in good or bad wrt stuff like this. You're welcome to try to discourage it, but success would depend crucially on how many people really are not "that way." I don't think I'd take that bet, personally, but it's possible I've lived in a strange sub-world and have met unusual people.
shanusmagnus··on Ask HN: Was anyone working at Apple during Steve Jobs' return in 1997?
I worked at a place like that before. A lot of people were grumpy that they were not progressing. Some of them were probably right; some were probably wrong. But it was clear to me that having a concrete thing to aim for (a new title) mattered. A lot.

I take it that wasn't the case at Palantir. Since I'm convinced that all humans are status-seeking, I'm curious how Palantir satisfied that urge, if not w/ title differentiation.

shanusmagnus··on Liz Truss resigns as UK prime minister
I think part of it is that we're in the political equivalent of "total war" -- if a politician were seen as being friendly with political opponents they would probably be destroyed in primaries by party rivals using it as red meat for how they were "soft" or an "x in name only" or some similar idiocy.
shanusmagnus··on Photoshop for Text
I totally get your (original) point -- I'm an (amatuer) fiction writer trying to make myself feel better, a bit. But everything evolves. Think of how Magnus Carlson trains for and plays chess, vs how it was historically done. No point trying to resist the forces loose in the world, be one of the first to embrace them. I'm curious what this means right this moment for an artist upon the advent of SD and the like.
shanusmagnus··on Photoshop for Text
It's interesting to imagine what the interaction model for this will be -- is there a sense in which this auto-generation will be like collaborating, and so it just changes what we think of to constitute the process of creation?

And maybe that's not as bad as it seems right this moment. Once upon a time great painters actually made their own paints. These days we wouldn't think about that skill as in the necessary catalogue of an artist, and in a bunch of ways -- most ways -- we're the better for it. Perhaps something similar will unfold here.

shanusmagnus··on Parent time
Any tips that have been effective in that rumination? For people who want to get a lot out of the books they read, as you do, I'm always curious about the strategies they've come up with.
shanusmagnus··on Impoverished Emotional Lives
I use the example because I can speak to my and my family's experience directly.

I think life or death -- the prospect of starving or being homeless without recourse from relations or from society -- is different from the prospect of being stressed for other reasons. That people mistake more benign stressors for "life or death" these days is the hypothesis I am proffering.

And while I expect that you intend it as a dunk, I'll grant the point unreservedly: I very much _do_ think people were tougher in previous eras. When I read about the lives of our predecessors, and what they endured and how they bore up under it, I feel disgusted with myself. They were not perfect moral gods, but tougher? Jesus, yes.

← PreviousPage 5 of 17Next →