HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

shawnee_

2,443 karma · joined December 20, 2010

github @indie
submissionscomments
shawnee_··on Net neutrality is in jeopardy again
I have yet to see any proof of this whole 'sell your internet history' complaint

What the bill stripping Broadband Privacy rules does is make it nearly impossible for the law to set a precedent for what should be considered illegal to sell when it comes to users' data. What may have happened if broadband privacy rules were enacted as intended here[https://www.nytimes.com/2016/10/28/technology/fcc-tightens-p...]

... someday somebody who didn't "opt out" would have discovered their [medical, financial, insert whatever] data had been sold to their detriment. Lawsuit. Legal scrutiny. Precedent == Baseline for what is acceptable and what is not for people who don't opt out.

Now, with no consumer privacy rights by default on broadband, and no neutral delivery system (net neutrality), and with provisions the GOP inserted into the Broadband Privacy rollback explicitly to make it harder to sue entities who sell your data, the default situation is already stacked badly against the average person.

shawnee_··on Net neutrality is in jeopardy again
Net neutrality is fundamental to free speech. Without net neutrality, big companies could censor your voice and make it harder to speak up online. Net neutrality has been called the “First Amendment of the Internet.”

Not just harder. Infinitely more dangerous. Probably the scariest implications for NN being gutted are those around loss of anonymity through the Internet. ISPs who are allowed to sell users' browsing history, data packets, personal info with zero legal implications --> that anonymity suddenly comes with a price. And anything that comes with a price can be sold.

A reporter's sources must be able to be anonymous in many instances where release of information about corruption creates political instability, endangers the reporter, endangers the source, endangers the truth from being revealed. These "rollbacks" of regulations make it orders of magnitude easier for any entity in a corporation or organization to track down people who attempt to expose their illegal actions / skirting of laws. Corporations have every incentive to suppress information that hurts their stock price. Corrupt local officials governments have every incentive to suppress individuals who threaten their "job security". Corrupt PACs have every incentive to drown out that one tiny voice that speaks the truth.

A government that endorses suppression cannot promote safety, stability, or prosperity of its people.

EDIT: Yes, I am also referring to the loss of Broadband Privacy rules as they have implications in the rollback of net neutrality: https://www.theverge.com/2017/3/29/15100620/congress-fcc-isp...

Loss of broadband privacy: Yes, your data can and will be sold

Loss of net neutrality: How much of it and for how much?

shawnee_··on America’s once-thriving middle class is slowly fading away
> a maddening lack of a definition for "disposable income".

Not really. The article goes into pretty good depth about its logic comparing them in pre-tax income (gross income) and after-tax (what it is calling "disposable income") across various countries.

http://www.pewglobal.org/2017/04/24/western-europe-middle-cl...

Thus, when gross income is used to define income tiers, the result is that higher shares of adults are estimated to be lower income or upper income, and smaller shares of adults are estimated to be middle income.

The chart here is telling, too: http://www.pewglobal.org/2017/04/24/western-europe-middle-cl...

shawnee_··on How Yahoo Killed Flickr (2012)
Recently heard a talk by Thomas Friedman about how the year 2007 was a really interesting "inflection" year wrt all kinds of technology.

The cost of making solar panels began to decline sharply in 2007. Airbnb was conceived in 2007 and change.org started in 2007. GitHub, now the world’s largest open-source software sharing library, was opened in 2007. And in 2007 Intel for the first time introduced non-Silicon materials into its microchip transistors, thus extending the duration of Moore’s Law — the expectation that the power of microchips would double roughly every two years. As a result, the exponential growth in computing power continues to this day.

His talk was basically a rehash of everything he talks about here: https://www.nytimes.com/2016/11/20/opinion/sunday/dancing-in...

Yahoo was an awesome company in 2007. Back when developer conferences were more or less free (for attendees), it hosted the first conference I attended as a newly transplanted person to SF... the "Open Source CMS Summit"... I think I still have some of the stickers it handed out to promote some of its then-recent acquisitions the original article discusses. Yahoo! was kind of one of the first companies to really actively engage and enable external developers (those not employed by Yahoo) as collaborative partners who probably could have helped Yahoo keep its then competitive advantage. Mozilla did this a bit earlier, yes... but not as a publicly-traded company. So part of its demise was due to impatient investors, for sure; however, I think the article makes a good argument for the implications of ignorance when it comes to fostering community.

It's now ten years after this inflection point that Friedman talks about; and according to him, it's just getting started.

shawnee_··on Republicans didn’t just strip away Internet privacy rights
Pai's logic is flawed in so many ways.

But in 2015, the FCC decided to treat the Internet like a public utility, taking away the FTC’s ability to police the privacy practices of broadband providers.

The decision to treat it like a public utility had almost nothing to do with privacy or "policing the privacy practices of broadband providers" and almost everything to do with rekindling the war on Net Neutrality.[1].

This move -- like pretty much everything else this administration is doing -- was done to appease and strengthen oligopoly power. It will ultimately hurt small upstarts in the "ISP /broadband delivery" category[2] (who vehemently opposed the stripping of this legislation), and it will make it orders of magnitude harder for small upstarts whose business may only benefit or scale with "neutral" access to the internet.

In oligopoly situations there are few, if any, choices available to switch to when said provider oversteps is bounds and decides to just start charging everybody more based on the kind of traffic they request... "because it can". Everything to do with everything on the Internet is going to get astoundingly more expensive very soon.

Pai does not understand small business. And it's worth noting that this is probably because he worked for Verizon as an attorney. Though despite his government appointment, he does not seem to have switched his mindset away from that to the best interests of the American people in mind with his policy agendas.

[1] [https://www.techdirt.com/blog/netneutrality/articles/2015021... [2] http://bgr.com/2017/04/03/twc-charter-merger-fcc-rules-ajit-...]

shawnee_··on Disapproval of FCC regulations a significant blow against privacy protection
However, this headline is patently false, right? Congress didn't sell anything. They removed protections that were put into place late last year and hadn't gone into effect as far as I know.

It's nearly impossible to find even one constituent who wrote to their Congresspeople asking for this law to be axed. It was a handful of lawmakers in Congress who accepted bribes, payments[1], and other kinds of lobbying from telecoms to push this through... that is the definition of "selling". And yes, the votes did happen almost exactly down party lines.

The headline was taken directly from the NYT article, and it is indeed accurate. That HN changed it to appease ??? is really disconcerting.

[1]http://www.vocativ.com/415350/house-rep-pushing-to-set-back-...

shawnee_··on House Schedules Vote on Eliminating Consumer Online Privacy Rights Next Week
The "next week" referred to in this article happens today.

https://amp.theguardian.com/technology/2017/mar/28/internet-...

For this to get through the Senate the way it did makes it pretty clear to me that the Senate is way beyond corrupt. Especially considering the piece of this legislation that goes way too far in prohibiting future privacy rules from enacted if, for some reason, this did end up going through and being a total disaster.

shawnee_··on Netflix expected to spend over $6B on original and acquired programming in 2017
This sentiment seems fairly common in various comment threads I've seen. The dancing aspect seems to evoke in some people... discomfort or something hard to pin down, and I wonder why. At the end of the day, electricity is still electricity whether it's being delivered through power lines or pulsed through fiber optics or pulled and stored in someone as static electricity as they dance. Most science fiction dealing with time travel or teleportation seems to rely on a machine or a suit or a phone booth or some mysterious futuristic means of energy. Yet tribal dancing is one of the oldest human traditions of energy expenditure, done ritualistically. It doesn't seem entirely outlandish to me that a certain configuration of certain energy expenditures by humans could create some sort of ripple or warp or whatever in time space.
shawnee_··on Medium asks $5 a month for nothing
I'm a former journalist who had to leave the industry not because I didn't care for journalism anymore, but because newspapers lost their business model, and the industry remains a shadow of its former self.

Whenever people ask me how I got into the technology industry (as a non-CS person), my short answer is something like this: when I saw what the Internet was doing to print media, I knew I had to learn how to code. Which led to having to learn how to design (CSS & JS). Which led to having to learn how to create servers for hosting and zero-downtime deploy. And also needing to understand machine capabilities and OSes and network loads and... etc.

Journalism was what I loved in middle and high school: darkroom photography and developing pictures from literal film in stop bath. Cropping shots with razor blades before gluing them on mockups. Soliciting local businesses for ads sold by the square inch. Writing and editing and editing and editing because hey... once that hits the press there is no edit button.

The process of traditional journalism is kind of dead, yes; though I don't think the industry itself has lost its business model... more like it fractured in a way that made national and world news dissemination way more powerful than the local yokel beat. That was what initially happened, anyway: small newspapers simply could not compete, and those that could were slurped up by massive parent companies that may or may not be entirely neutral or unbiased, politically, due to their size.

However, I think the tides are starting to shift and the trend is back toward localization. My initial grand design plan for Ecosteader, for example, was big and national.. like a magazine. I realized that the kind of advertising I'd need to be able to sell in this niche would actually do best locally. And indeed, this is why I keep the site live (despite the fact that I have sold only one book and received zero dollars from Adsense). I am pretty sure that going forward the next "big" disruptive thing in will be in hyper-localization ... ecological and efficient when it comes to physical goods and labor.

Anyway... slight digression, but I think it's indicative of what matters WRT to what people are willing to pay for when it comes to advertising delivered alongside content. Advertising works when people are looking for specific content relevant to them and they notice a good deal or a sale or a new store opening or something interesting about a place they see IRL.

This is getting too long. I will stop now.

shawnee_··on GitHub lets staff own IP developed for personal projects using company resources
The result is that contract forms have become a sort of IP-free zone.

Exactly. One of the sleaziest tricks used by Realtors (most Realtors are not lawyers) is getting clients to sign their forms: their terms usually have the word "percent" hard-coded into the contract. Rather than opening the door to hourly or fixed dollar amounts, they insist that their forms are the "standard". I heard one recently say in a public forum that banks "require" these specific forms that only Realtors have... this is a total lie, and anybody that tells you that you can't negotiate to create your own contract for a deal should be prosecuted for coercion.

I've been trying for a long time to alter the common perception that Realtors add value; they don't. They take value out of transactions -- equity that's taken literal years to build up -- gone in one (fell) swoop. People need to be way more aggressive in their negotiations with real estate salespeople, and it all starts with the contract.

This is still a small, WIP, side project (free, open-source contract templates); however, you can get the idea: http://ecosteader.com/docs

shawnee_··on The Intel Edison: Linux Maker Machine in a Matchbox
Despite being "x86" it's near impossible to add custom drivers or rebuild the OS. What's the point of being "x86" if you can't make use of the ecosystem?

Edison isn't supposed to be a hub; it's a lightweight and specialized piece of hardware that can be customized to travel and explore and communicate high-load (poll-heavy) data gathering situations to a hub. Having x86 in octopus tentacles that can efficiently communicate with the x86 hub brain (which is where your heavy OS/custom driver code should be stationed) means you actually can make pretty good use of the ecosystem, and create projects that can get real-time data online quickly.

shawnee_··on Information Avoidance: How People Select Their Own Reality
If we are talking Fox News, I'd say Tucker Carlson's show is pretty good. Bret Baier and Chris Wallace are also decent. Most everyone else is a clown putting on a show for ratings. I won't talk about the liberal-leaning stations because I would imagine you know who's serious and who's a ratings clown, for example, I would imagine you might categorize Rachel Maddow (MSNBC) as a member of the latter.

The problem with your assessment here is that "clowning" is not actually a part of journalism. Fact-finding however, is part of journalism. The OP is making the case that people will actively ignore facts they are receiving when they can't parse the information to match up with their world view. They will dismiss facts as things like conspiracy or what you're calling "clowning for ratings" when they don't like what they are hearing.

Information dissemination that is based on verifiable facts garnered from multiple independent sources... this is the job of journalists. From what I've seen of Fox News, it does not subscribe to the verifiable facts method of journalism and relies instead upon the echo chamber method of repeating something enough times in attempts to make it seem truthful.

shawnee_··on World’s richest doctor gave away millions, then steered the cash to his company
The University of Utah deal — laid out in contracts obtained by STAT through a public records request ...

Four tax experts who reviewed the contracts at STAT’s request all agreed that the Utah deal was suspicious. Two said it appeared to violate federal tax rules governing certain charitable donations, amounting to indirect self-dealing by Soon-Shiong and his foundations.

This story highlights the imperative need for public-benefit institutions (especially those that use taxpayer dollars) to have their tax records be public. The clampdown on FOIA requests (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13586952) and the refusal of a certain whitehouse-dweller to make his own dealings public make me think this scheme might be more pervasive that just this instance. Yeah, it's a high-profile doctor who got busted; however, the people who craft these kinds of schemes tend to replicate their successes across many high-profile clients.

shawnee_··on I am an Uber survivor
Rock the boat, people. You are a part of your company's culture: not an observer of it, not a victim of it.

From an article I wrote a couple years ago:

"My two cents for the conversation is pretty simple: there are only two different kinds of humans in the world: Those who actively exploit women, and those who actively speak out against the exploitation of women. Keeping your mouth shut for fear of rocking the boat -- this is a form of apathy all its own." http://ink.hackeress.com/2015/01/why-im-boat-rocker.html

shawnee_··on USPS confirms Byuu’s PAL SNES package has been lost
Interesting to read this today. A couple weeks ago, I sent my nephew a new Rasp Pi, custom wood case, book, breadboard kit package for his birthday... and am just in the process of filing a claim on it.

Problem is, I was kind of coerced by the employee into using this specific shipping that gave me only $50 insurance on the package. I didn't realize I was so under-insured until after the package was confirmed as "lost".

I wonder if x-ray or something is making it easier for employees on the inside to target expensive electronics packages.

shawnee_··on Falling Home Prices Could Be a Good Thing
The article is going over a paper[0] that asks what would happen to house prices if houses were treated as disposable consumer goods instead of a means of storing wealth.

We kind of already know the answer to this: "Rental cars get trashed." The same applies to housing: neighborhoods with mostly renters as opposed to owners are rarely as well-kept, clean, or as safe as those with primarily owner-occupied units.

Treating housing as disposable also creates a significantly heavier environmental burden which isn't entirely obvious at first:

- Cheap, short-term repairs and cosmetic fixes create more landfill waste. Estimations are 45 percent of landfill waste comes from "Construction & Demolition" or as the industry calls it: "C&D". When it comes to diverting C&D waste, it's usually only the older high-quality material that can be diverted and/or reused; the rest goes in landfills[1]

- Disposable housing neighborhoods targeted as toxic sludge waste-grounds[2].

More disturbing is that a nationwide trend to start treating housing as a "disposable consumer good" already seems to be underway. REITs got their own sector in the stock market late last year[3]. Invitation Homes (bankrolled by Blackstone) has recently unveiled a Ponzi-type scheme to buy up dilapidated houses, smack on cheap cosmetic fixes, rent them out at top-of-the-market prices... all in the name of creating "stock wealth". Invitation Homes IPOed last week. For more on what we can come to expect, see this[4].

In other words, we can expect continual upward pressure on rent not for the quality of the housing being rented, but for the landlords charging tenants more for their liability insurance.

No... it's not the supply of housing that needs to be optimized; it's environmental stewardship resultant from even the tiniest bit of unencumbered land ownership that we should be solving for. My theories around how to do this have been evolving on ecosteader.com.

  [1]http://www.ecy.wa.gov/beyondwaste/bwprogGBCandD.html
  [2]http://www.alternet.org/books/how-corporations-dump-their-toxic-sludge-areas-filled-poor-people
  [3]https://secure.marketwatch.com/story/stock-markets-new-real-estate-sector-gives-reits-a-home-2016-05-11
  [4]http://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-blackstone-lawsuit-20140506-story.html
shawnee_··on FBI will no longer accept FOIA requests by email
Previously-accumulated USDA data (that has already been paid for and is technically a public good) has been blacked out also. Source: https://sunlightfoundation.com/tracking-u-s-government-data-...

The USDA announced that public access to that information would now be mediated through Freedom of Information Act requests.

There was a dog food poisoning reported [earlier this week](http://patch.com/illinois/hydepark/s/g0ven/illinois-company-...) The "supplier" of the poison dog food is probably pretty happy the public can't figure out which other pet food manufacturers (Besides Evanger's) they vendor.

This move was likely designed to hide facts from the public and to make investigative journalism a lot more difficult. Public health and safety data needs to be public and squelching it is akin to public endangerment.

[edit: thx for grammar correction.]

shawnee_··on A Response to Paul Graham's “How to Make Wealth” (2012)
It's a really good analysis. Even moreso through the postmortem lens of where we are today (relative to where we were when Paul Graham originally published his essay ~2004).

As you noted, the section about "Wealth and Power" seemed to have been tacked on almost as an afterthought. So it isn't until the end of your piece that you get to this point:

Graham concludes: “The same recipe that makes individuals rich makes countries powerful. Let the nerds keep their lunch money, and you rule the world.” Sadly, the bottom line is that unless you are among a tiny handful of the elite, a laissez-faire economic system would enslave you, not liberate you. The only people who will enjoy the fruits of a truly free society are those with the power to keep you in line. Given more freedom, those in power will first cut off the access to power, to prevent anyone from challenging them. They will immediately go for the jugular. There is no compromise with power and no means to share it. Thus, the power elite will readily command vast armies of people and resources to ensure that you stay down. This will be their first priority. Their second priority will be to extract labor from you in the manner that serves them best. In a perfectly libertarian society, the bullies would not only take your lunch money, they would murder your family, burn your house, and leave you for dead by the side of the road.

If you were to re-write / edit your piece today, my recommendation would be to start off with this as your premise. We have sooooooo much evidence today from many, many people who followed this path recommended by Graham thirteen years ago. Sure, maybe a few of the nerds got to keep their lunch money. However: catapulting a reserve of lunch money into the kind of wealth that matters (the kind of wealth that buys power) just doesn't happen for your average nerd. There's one more layer needed on the recipe.

Graham rightly points out that wealth is not a zero-sum game. Power, on the other hand, is most definitely a zero-sum proposition, and those who have it will stop at nothing to retain it and quash any perceptible threat. Power is a black hole—it consumes everything and yet remains a perpetual void. We see instances of this even with the meager controls in place in our society today. Loosen or remove those controls and power, unchecked, will accumulate until nothing remains. Anyone or anything in its path will be destroyed.

It's hard not to think about the political implications of how this relates to just about everything these days.

shawnee_··on Secret docs reveal: an FBI with vast hidden powers
When it comes to civil liberties, smaller government is always a good thing but literally no party supports that

Perhaps you should try to re-frame your statement in the context of local vs state vs federal government.

In reality, a government does not have to be big to be corrupt enough to willfully harm or infringe upon the civil liberties of its citizens. The "enforcement" piece of a local government doesn't have to be large to harass or detain or jail people. Or protesters. Or anybody they dislike for being ___________ or having voted __________.

The terrifying thing about Trump's administration is that he's fueling this delusion of an America that doesn't exist any more, empowering corruption at the local level (Martial Law) while simultaneously removing options for citizens to redress where grievances about their civil liberties matter -- at the federal level.

shawnee_··on Resilient cooperators stabilize long-run cooperation in Prisoner’s Dilemma
I wonder if a better one sentence conclusion might be something like "Predictably nice players consistently distribute their gains to the group". After all, the interesting variable here is repeatability; that is, as certain players learn which players are consistently "nice" through repeated trials, they get iteratively better at gaming them to forfeit their (potential) gains.

In other words, over time, the "compound interest" on the gains the nice individuals lose gets rewarded to the group. Any individual in the group who can game "niceness" benefits the group at the expense of the nice individual. "Good guys finish last," or something of that nature?

Stabilized long-running cooperation seems like a very bad desired(?) outcome, by the way; is that what you're saying is a good thing? Pareto improvements are usually realized / discovered / gained by individuals who eschew tradition and playing nice.

shawnee_··on Don't Give Silicon Valley More H1B Visas
The fairly recent landmark decision in Browning-Ferris[1] should take a few steps toward curbing the abuses of this practice. Not only for H1B workers, but also for many of the kinds of people that tend to get -- in this commenter's words -- "scammed" by agencies. The problem is many workers coming in know little to nothing about current US employment law.

If you are building or working on something that is going on the "asset" side of a company's balance sheet, you are probably in a joint employer situation. And if you are in a joint employer situation, you need to be loud and clear about disparities. Which obviously exist when the middleman temp/outsource agency is shaving 35, 40, 50, X percent of your wages, benefits, whatever.

The theory here is that the company that was trying to save a few bucks by hiring "cheap" foreign help now has to account for the liabilities of being a joint employer: now legally defined to include the welfare of any workers being treated like slave labor by the firms they hire. So... maybe it's not really "cheaper" after all.

Makes a lot of sense.

[1] http://www.acc.com/legalresources/quickcounsel/joint-employe...

shawnee_··on Quantifying the Cost of Sprawl (2013)
And compact development produces on average about 10 times more tax revenue per acre.

So the author of this article is trying to sell this approach based on the "benefit" of tax revenue per acre? Is that (should that be) the primary goal of a city's design... to squeeze out as many tax dollars as possible from every square inch of space?

The main problem with compact development (my observation) is the HOA fees that tend to be baked into owning in one of these "compact" developments. These fees are very often ostentatious and do not map out to actual costs of building or maintaining shared infrastructure "compactly". And let's not even get into the pitfalls of CCRs that disallow pet ownership, fine members for paint colors, etc.

shawnee_··on GoDaddy Acquires Host Europe Group
Still the lousiest of the lousiest. After its IPO, GDDY became one of those companies that tweaks its numbers in such a way that it siphons off all the wealth created by its employees up into management salaries and executive compensation. You can spot companies that use this as their "strategy" by really high Debt:Equity ratios, and a few other metrics... a few interesting ones here:

  				GoDaddy		Industry	Sector
  				=======		=========       ======
 
  Revenue/Employee (TTM) 	375,425 	7,814,598 	62,334,654
  Net Income/Employee (TTM) 	-4,537 		793,185 	1,346,909
  Receivable Turnover (TTM) 	210.28 		5.11 		10.76
  LT Debt to Equity (MRQ) 	205.65 		8.56 		12.85
  Total Debt to Equity (MRQ) 	206.47 		14.86 		21.44
  Interest Coverage (TTM) 	0.09 		37.70 		15.70

* source: http://www.reuters.com/finance/stocks/financialHighlights?sy...
shawnee_··on How Elizabeth Warren Took Down the CEO of Wells Fargo, and Why It Matters

  "mandatory binding arbitration clause"
Wells Fargo hay have put an arbitration clause somewhere buried in their fine print; however, "binding" is what would be questioned by the courts. Probably pretty easy to refute its bind-ability, given that WF has negated and demonstrated incompetence on its side of the contract duty: safeguarding the consumer's info.

(Binding contracts require competent parties on both sides).

http://www.nytimes.com/2015/11/01/business/dealbook/arbitrat...

shawnee_··on Vancouver plans to tax empty properties 1% of their assessed value
My landlord takes the risk of owning the property, and I pay a premium for that.

You pay a premium so your landlord can take risk to get the most lucrative profits? Why, you are a benevolent renter, aren't you?

By your logic, owning a small company with some employees is passive income and "bad",

That is not at all what I said; your reading comprehension needs work. Owning a company with employees[1] means you are responsible for allocating the income into business profits among your employees. Most people who scrub toilets and wash sheets for AirBNB rentals are NOT employees or the owners of the properties. Along the same lines: the right way to treat employees involves giving them part ownership of the company they are working for, and thus they are rightfully entitled to some of the income from business-generating assets. Landlords do not do this. They farm out the work required to manage or maintain the assets, and demand the lion's share of the profit.

[1] There is a definite legal definition of "employee", and you don't seem to understand what that is. See the IRS's definition. https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employe...

shawnee_··on I’m a Coastal Elite from the Midwest: The Real Bubble Is Rural America
the median Trump supporter had a higher income than the median Clinton supporter.

This is exactly it. Small-town America is a very different beast from suburban America. Most small town residents tend to pride themselves on their self-sufficiency ... which is, of course, contingent upon being able to gas up and drive to the nearest "city" (max population: 40,000) a couple times a month for necessary provisions from the big box stores.

Lisa Ling[1] did a great piece where she interviewed people in the largest Radio-Free Quiet Zone[2]. The high-schoolers she talked to spent more time talking about how different (and better) they were from "city people", a fact they were quite proud of.

.. _1: http://www.cnn.com/shows/this-is-life-with-lisa-ling

.. _2: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_National_Radio_Q...

shawnee_··on Vancouver plans to tax empty properties 1% of their assessed value
> * British Columbia punishes renters, as it taxes 'passive income' (i.e. rent), which discourages owners from renting out existing properties or building-to-rent.*

There are so many incorrect statements in this sentence, I don't even know where to begin.

Taxing vacant properties does not punish renters. It "punishes" people who buy properties for speculation, or (as the AirBNB trend is going) attempt to control a piece of limited supply.

The purpose of taxing passive income (lazy landlords, rent collecting) more aggressively is because it is not actually work. It is technically wealth extraction. As a renter, 100 percent of your rent is a "tax" (it's not going to offset any of your long-term assets); and when you pay 70-90 percent of your income in rent as a tax (as many minimum wage workers do), it is massively difficult, if not impossible, to save enough to acquire any assets that help you build wealth. On the landlords' side, it's even easier to use all that extracted wealth (from poor people) to acquire assets that build wealth.

No, collecting rent is not work or a job. Even if you have a whole fleet of illegal immigrants scrubbing the toilets, throwing down cheap carpet, and painting the walls of your units every few years. The moment you enter the territory of needing to pay somebody else to manage your asset (even if it is "just" scrubbing the toilets after your AirBNB tenants or renters leave), you're entering passive income territory.

shawnee_··on HN comments are underrated
Business startup ideas are essentially experiments in economic theory.

Yet HN comments are vastly inferior to Reddit's when regarding anything to do with economics.

It didn't used to be this way, and I kind of miss the HN of old... where logic and fearlessness were valued more than affiliation or keeping up of brand appearances. I've been finding it increasingly disconcerting that the incentive here lately has been to discredit or silence (bury) comments from anybody whose opinion points out something like: yeah -- Airbnb's "business model" might be creating way more more problems than it's claiming to solve. Or that collusion in and among YC-funded companies might (or maybe should) yield some Antitrust issues. The tech commentary can be pretty good, and there are plenty of active HNers whose opinions I respect. However, it is leaning heavy on becoming selection-biased and just plain mean to anybody with an original idea.

shawnee_··on A New Real-Estate War in Silicon Valley
In all, the proposals' opponents have raised more than $1.8 million against the measures in the five cities, according to campaign finance records, largely from groups like the National Association of Realtors and an array of landlords including apartment giant Equity Residential. That far outstrips the roughly $200,000 reported raised by various groups supporting rent control.

Real estate is a broken industry. Moreso in the Bay area, but the negative effects there ripple outward. See: http://ecosteader.com/alternative

In the Airbnb story yesterday, my comment (which was maliciously downvoted), was this:

"Landlords and Realtors get their cut every time there's a turnover in occupancy. Interestingly, this is the root problem at both ends -- from people living in poverty (Portland's sidewalk tent campers who get shuffled around), those suburbanites affected by the housing "crisis", and those who can afford to own in any upscale hip-n-trendy neighborhoods where Airbnb rentals are desperately sought. Those rooting for turnover are usually those who profit the most from it.

Sure, people travel and need to rent rooms once in a while. People like to rent while they're young and mobile, but the two use cases need very serious and separate delineation from each other. Airbnb is pushing them more into "overlap" territory. Airbnb's expansion into "subletting" was the kicker.

So, long story made short: it's an interesting economics problem I've been working on solving in my spare time, as a very long and iterated side project with Ecosteader (ecosteader.com). Some of the details emerging need a better format for communication; however, the most clear thing to come from my research is that people need to _own_, and they need to be able to transact with each other directly. Middlemen (Airbnb is the middleman here) taking significant commissions is part of the problem.

But the middlemen problem has sort of an obvious solution: to tax rental income so aggressively that it's just not an appealing source of investment to people who invest in rentals. Use the tax generated from over-inflated rents to build properties for sale, and/or figure out a way to use that money to grant-deed land on which people can build. This last option seems the more fun opportunity to me, and is what I originally had in mind building an eco- site.

The homesteading movement needs to come back, adapted a bit for the 21st century."

Disagree if you want... but explain how the problem can be solved better any other way.

shawnee_··on Cuomo signs bill prohibiting Airbnb listings in NYC
Airbnb profits from high volume and turnover, just as landlords and Realtors get their cut every time there's a turnover in occupancy. Interestingly, this is the root problem at both ends -- from people living in poverty (Portland's sidewalk tent campers who get shuffled around), those suburbanites affected by the housing "crisis", and those who can afford to own in any upscale hip-n-trendy neighborhoods where Airbnb rentals are desperately sought. Those rooting for turnover are usually those who profit the most from it.

Sure, people travel and need to rent rooms once in a while. People like to rent while they're young and mobile, but the two use cases need very serious and separate delineation from each other. Airbnb is pushing them more into "overlap" territory. Airbnb's expansion into "subletting" was the kicker.

So, long story made short: it's an interesting economics problem I've been working on solving in my spare time, as a very long and iterated side project with Ecosteader (ecosteader.com). Some of the details emerging need a better format for communication; however, the most clear thing to come from my research is that people need to _own_, and they need to be able to transact with each other directly. Middlemen (Airbnb is the middleman here) taking significant commissions is part of the problem.

But the middlemen problem has sort of an obvious solution: to tax rental income so aggressively that it's just not an appealing source of investment to people who invest in rentals. Use the tax generated from over-inflated rents to build properties for sale, and/or figure out a way to use that money to grant-deed land on which people can build. This last option seems the more fun opportunity to me, and is what I originally had in mind building an eco- site.

The homesteading movement needs to come back, adapted a bit for the 21st century.

← PreviousPage 3 of 11Next →