HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

shmatt

3,785 karma · joined August 27, 2014

webstertix a-t gmail
submissionscomments
shmatt··on Reddit App – Suspicious high number of recent 5 star, one word reviews
But he sold is original shares in 2006. All of them, and for cheap. Any shares he has now are part of his CEO compensation package which is minuscule compared to the investors

Even though he’s a cofounder, his current position is like the one of a non founder ceo in a post-exit company

shmatt··on Reddit App – Suspicious high number of recent 5 star, one word reviews
He’s (at this point) a non large shareholder CEO. His income is highly dependent on the board not firing him every single day. It’s not a great situation to be in
shmatt··on Reddit App – Suspicious high number of recent 5 star, one word reviews
It’s a dinosaur company with a dinosaur board. Other than the CEO of YC every other single member of the board is some aging boomer who has probably never used Reddit 2 days in a row

I feel bad for spez at this point. We obviously are seeing what he deems as the boards request of him. We have no idea what he really feels about everything going on

shmatt··on Reddit App – Suspicious high number of recent 5 star, one word reviews
I would question the monetization value of a user visiting reddit to read a 4 year old post about the best water pump, vs. "normie" users just flipping through their front page

These investors are trying to make back 1.3 BILLION dollars sunk into a social network in the top 10 websites visited in the US that can't make money, they're rightfully trying to go full facebook/instagram/normie. What if I told you old.reddit only accounts for 10% or less of web users. That people are actually able to browse new reddit (I personally can't).

tl;dr: For the content they're looking for, no they dont need someone like you who's deleting old posts they don't care about

shmatt··on Reddit appears to be restoring edited/deleted comments
> But if they are smart, they’d rate limit free API access

They are, up to 100 requests per minute is still free post change

Someone could make a lot of money by building a paid Reddit app with everything people want, and a BYO API key, similar to what people are doing with OpenAI keys

shmatt··on Reddit CEO Says Mods Too Powerful, Plans to Weaken After Blackout
except you don't need to be born a chosen one to become a mod. its not rocket science, and plenty of people want the power

have you every thought to yourself, wow, /r/pics is so much better since /u/DM_ME_BOOGERS joined the mod team, I really feel like there was a pre-2019 /r/pics and a post-2019 /r/pics

People don't even notice that mod teams could have completely rotated out this year and they didn't feel a thing

edit: ill add an example, /u/Cyxie up until a couple years ago, moderated 20% of the top 500 subreddits, their user is now deleted

Has anyone felt reddit is worse these days since they left? Is the day they left widely known as the day Reddit became bad?

Heres your answer: no one cares about Cyxie, Reddit was fine before them, during their tenure, and after they deleted their account

shmatt··on What Reddit Got Wrong
then resigning would have been the way to go. shutting off access to the knowledge base others contributed to is a power play

if you volunteer at a dog shelter, and find you don't agree with some of their practices anymore. do you stop volunteering? or do you just set all the dogs free

shmatt··on What Reddit Got Wrong
My bet is that investors like Andreessen Horowitz and Sequoia Capital are pulling their hairs out, seeing Reddit lose money at the end of the month, after Open AI and others are raising trillions by scraping their data
shmatt··on What Reddit Got Wrong
I never understand why Reddit is credited to the "free community based moderation" idea

Facebook does this at much larger scale (2B users active in FB Groups), with way more spam, and some FB groups are much larger than most big subreddits

Its not about Facebook or Reddit, its about people being so power hungry they do these things for free. When subreddits post about bringing in more mods, thousands apply, maybe 2 get in. If Reddit deems locked subreddits abandoned, there is already a system to give the abandoned subreddit to anyone else that wants it (within reason). Subreddits also split pretty often due to mod infighting

The last thing that bugs me is peoples claims the new mods (if chosen by reddit employees) wont be as high quality as the previous ones. No one has ever proven the current moderation teams are any good. The infighting is because some mods love adding arbitrary rules like "no relationship posts" in AITA. Does everyone agree with that? Is that a perfect rule? Why? A new moderation team could be just as good or just as bad as the previous one

shmatt··on 33-46% of workers on MTurk used LLMs in a text production task
This is more like cousins having a baby with 3 nostrils
shmatt··on France’s Mistral AI raises a $113M seed round to take on OpenAI
by the time any average series E IPOs, they're all diluted like crazy anyways
shmatt··on Killing Community
People (for obvious reasons) like to compare Digg to whats going on at Reddit. It seems a lot closer to Facebook

Facebook has always lead the fight to monetize users to the max. If its sudden API changes or shutdowns, or suing 3rd party app developers. Yet they still generate Billions and people are fine using them, instagram, or Whatsapp, even though they fully understand the enshitification the timeline has gone through throughout the years, and how aggressively they monetize their user base

I also see Reddit as extremely similar to Facebook groups, which can also have millions of users, and are moderated for free by volunteers

shmatt··on Show HN: Non.io, a Reddit-like platform Ive been working on for the last 4 years
You think Facebook would let a large percentage of users use a 3rd party app that blocks all advertisements, tracking, and other monetization? Look at how Meta treated the whole Apple tracking ordeal

If a lone dev would have made an app like Apollo for FB, they would be under 10,000 pages of litigation the next day

People don't use the FB app because its great. They would love a non-tracking version of the same service. It's just not allowed

shmatt··on Show HN: Non.io, a Reddit-like platform Ive been working on for the last 4 years
I swear, the current protests have shined a very odd light on the average commenting Redditor, they want

* The website to be free

* The API to be cheap

* The ability to use a 3rd party app that does not track, advertise, or monetize you in any way

* VCs to continue to pour hundreds of millions of dollars to run the site and never ask for an ROI

Good luck kids

shmatt··on Ask HN: Alternatives to Reddit
To me Reddit is FB groups with voting. So does that make Usenet similar to FB groups?
shmatt··on Did Reddit just destroy mobile browser access?
FB is highly profitable, Reddit loses money.

The outrage from users that Reddit is trying to do what everyone in the tech industry does makes no sense

And furthermore, if they give up the IPO focus, let’s say they don’t do the obvious and sell to Meta

What do they do? Layoff 80% of employees? Cut down the servers? Obviously if they are going to screw over the investors, no one will give a penny to another funding round

If, theoretically, the investors really don’t have a majority of votes, like someone here mentioned, the 2021 funding round was the last one, Reddit just burns it’s cash until it shuts down

shmatt··on Did Reddit just destroy mobile browser access?
I find it funny people have been going on this anti Reddit turning profit crusade, but ignore the fact Reddit is pretty similar to Facebook groups, just has much better ui and indexability

And everyone I know in real life who uses Reddit on a daily basis is also in at least 2-3 FB groups. Be it a local mom/dad group, Costco group, the car they own, or something more niche

They’re not big Zuckerberg fans but they’re much more accepting of him making billions than the Reddit shareholders

FB groups also utilize mods who work lots of hours for free. So those who say Reddit cannot IPO because of the free labor are wrong

shmatt··on Did Reddit just destroy mobile browser access?
They need to create a username and password to ask that question? If they already have a Reddit account that wins
shmatt··on Reddit CEO doubles down on attack on Apollo developer in drama-filled AMA
But in the startup world it’s make profit, sell, or shut down

Do people really prefer Reddit shut down or be owned by Meta, just because of an app made by a single dev, that someone could buy and keep alive, or 10 companies could recreate tomorrow?

Reddit isn’t going to be turned into a foundation

shmatt··on Reddit CEO doubles down on attack on Apollo developer in drama-filled AMA
The Reddit board of directors don’t represent the founders, who have probably been long ago diluted to less than 10%

They represent investors who sunk 1.3 billion dollars into a company who was spending millions providing 3rd party apps a free api where users can’t be monetized. And is not currently profitable

If my previous experience means anything, the board wanted the price to be 100x higher or to shut down the api completely, and were talked down by spez

shmatt··on Reddit CEO doubles down on attack on Apollo developer in drama-filled AMA
You’re asking why do CEOs speak out? Do q&as? Fireside chats? Of course they all speak corporate speak

Most of the top questions were childish and useless, asking to get rid of the ads, go back to the original spirit of Reddit. Comparing the pressure and decision making process of a CEO who raised 1.3 BILLION dollars to some basement dweller who’s shutting down their app out of spite (pretty sure they could sell the app for $5M today no questions asked)

After so many rounds of raising, I’m being generous if I guess that spez owns 5% of Reddit stock. Reddit is being run right now by the biggest investment firms in SV. Rigjtfully looking for ROI. It would literally make them more money to shut down Reddit than to do what everyone in the AMA is asking them to do

In terms of accessibility, I understand they have a roadmap. I don’t understand how they don’t have 400 ADA lawsuits on court right now. Every corporation I worked for had been flooded by copy paste ADA lawsuits, and an app or 3rd party apps aren’t enough, the website has to be fully accessible

shmatt··on Shreddit is a Python program to remove all your Reddit comments
The thing that will surprise me most is if the mods - who spends tens of hours a week working for free just for their status symbol, will actually remove their accounts and/or shut down subreddits for good, instead of 1 or 2 days

Reddit moderation is not a democracy, there is a very small group of people who control a large number of the 1 million+ subscriber subreddits. They work so hard just for the respect/props, maybe they figured out a way to make money off it buy promoting corporate posts, who knows

If that happens, it really will be a re-creation of Digg, where the power users ending up killing the website by manipulating it

Without subreddits in their full control, what else do they have?

shmatt··on ArchiveTeam has saved over 11.2B Reddit links
Facebook and Instagram have historically shut down API with 0 days heads up. Breaking apps that depended on them. This is pretty normal for a social network trying to commercialize
shmatt··on r/ProgrammerHumor will be shutting down to protest Reddit's API changes
The mods only power in life is on Reddit. If they give that up they lose everything. Once in a while some crazy stats like 5 mods control 20% of the top 500 subreddits pop up, I’ve never tried to validate but there is definitely a small group with a lot of power among mods

Their entire purpose in life is being a Reddit mod, they’re the ones people expect to kill Reddit?

shmatt··on Apollo will close down on June 30th
His app icon was showcased front and center at the WWDC keynote, something I always thought was bought with money, for (I assume) free. It has tons of users including paying users. I have a very hard time imagining being able to sell the app right now for less than 10 figures. All this fight has shown me is that people will gladly pay for this app monthly

If he's leaving all that on the table out of spite, well thats his money to lose. But he shouldn't call the world unfair

shmatt··on HashiCorp just let go 8%
I don't say this pretty much about any person, but I can't stand Gergely Orosz. He was a line manager at Uber EU, and makes notes of his time there like he was SVP in Silicon Valley

He speaks of broad terms of "how things worked", like - there are thousands of EMs and Directors right here on HN with triple his experience who can only speak to their team/group/division, would never act like they know what happens on other engineering teams outside their org.

Other than his "expertise" his newsletter is pretty much the same as browsing Blind. Getting DMs from people with their personal opinions about their employer (im sure he doesnt even verify that) and reposts them

shmatt··on HashiCorp just let go 8%
In many cases it’s “non tech in tech” being fired. They are still recruiting engineers, they probably won’t recruit more non tech this year

When the Twitter drama started yesterday I searched LinkedIn for posts from hashicorp employees announcing they have been cut. In the first hours it was recruiters, project managers, and customer success people

My guess is they will also freeze hiring more recruiters

Another point is there used to be natural attrition in tech, during the great resignation it was even higher than normal. You plan ahead assuming some people will leave, and when things get bad and no one leaves, you’re stuck with more people than you budgeted for

shmatt··on HashiCorp just let go 8%
This just means a lot of these people wouldn’t have a job to begin with.

Not saying one is better than the other, but if it took months to fire people, lots of US tech companies wouldn’t have grown 30% without thinking twice. Leaving many of then people let go today without an entry ticket to tech to begin with

shmatt··on Reddit's Recently Announced API Changes, and the future of /r/blind
No way these apps actually shut down

An app like Apollo - which is so important Apple is featuring front and center at their biggest announcement of the decade, won't attempt to add some caching, poll less for push notifications, and/or charge $5/month, before shutting things down for good?

All of these app developers are fear mongering, and hiding their true plans, im 100% sure of this

At the minimum they could sell to someone else for many millions of dollars, and they'll do the things I described

shmatt··on Apple’s Vision Pro Is a $3,500 Ticket to Nowhere
Now lets hear the writers opinion on an iPhone with no App Store, no copy - paste, no video recording, and no front facing camera. Kind of like the original one, which we now can't imagine a world without
← PreviousPage 9 of 20Next →