HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

shoham

88 karma · joined March 24, 2011

Co-Founder of FeedForward: http://feed-forward.net
submissionscomments
shoham··on Reddit becomes reddit Inc.
Their ad system has great potential, but right now it's under-developed...
shoham··on Facebook First Half Revenue Hits $1.6 Billion
We're a start-up with a limited ad budget, but I found Facebook to be a good launching pad for our first several hundred registered users.

With Reddit we really get a good combination on by networking directly with artists (I'm a co-founder of this site: http://www.feed-forward.net the focus of which is to help improve communication between artists) by posting our own works on specific communities on Reddit (I'm a musician, and the other co-founder is a photographer), and when others posting their work from our site to Reddit in conjunction with our paid ads.

With Reddit, my feeling is that you really do have to keep it fresh for people not to tune it out.

PlentyofFish? Interesting.

shoham··on Facebook First Half Revenue Hits $1.6 Billion
TV ads work because, and only if they grab the attention of the viewer. I've bought tens of millions of FB impressions this year myself. The results have been fine, but I've moved on. It's really easy to ignore Facebook ads, and the point of Facebook isn't to help you get off of Facebook, so I don't know how good that is in the long run for any business to buy postage stamp sized display ads on.

Personally, I think that the Reddit model has some potential. Have you checked out/used their system? I think that it's imperfect, as I stated here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2968162 but there are some good aspects, and we've been more successful there than anywhere else.

shoham··on Facebook First Half Revenue Hits $1.6 Billion
"I agree completely. The "Like" phenomenon feels very much like something you would see on VH1's "Remember the 80's?"

Wow. Harsh, but spot-on.

shoham··on Are jobs obsolete?
I think that his argument is flawed, but there's some merit to the idea that what a job means will, should and has shifted.
shoham··on Facebook First Half Revenue Hits $1.6 Billion
could-- more likely, I think that it won't. What's Facebook do? It helps you connect, and reconnect with friends and family -- what's that have to do with buying and selling goods? Why do I need to watch shows on Facebook, and not somewhere else?
shoham··on Are jobs obsolete?
Well, like The New York Post. What do you expect from CNN!?!
shoham··on Jack Welch: China losing competitiveness. Must Create '10,000 Apples'
Those machines still cost money to make, and run...
shoham··on Are jobs obsolete?
I think that the title was just to grab your attention. I don't agree with everything in the article, especially the idealization of the Middle (or 'Dark') Ages, but the idea that what kind of work people will do 30-50 years from now, I think will be as great of a shift as from the farm to the factory, or the factory to the office (though probably not as big of a shift as the agricultural revolution!)

I think that the author is making a case that more people will work for themselves since the Renaissance, and perhaps from home since the Industrial Revolution began.

In Rushkoff's defense, he's distinguishing between work and jobs.

shoham··on Jack Welch: China losing competitiveness. Must Create '10,000 Apples'
"Even if the only expense was food, absent government help one person would have a hard time staving off malnutrition on that much money here in the US. That's living under a bridge and wearing trash bags to work."

Exactly.

"I don't really understand why that's the case, either." I'm not sure I understand the question. If you mean, "Why do these other countries cost less to live in?" it is the case that some things cost the same in both 1st world and developing countries. Some of it goes back to Brenton Woods, and some of it goes back further. It's a really good question, but it seems that the more 'developed' a country the higher the wages, AND the higher the cost of living, which in a lot of areas leads to equillbirum, but certainly not in every area.

One example would be the family car, which might cost 20K new in the US, and about the same in Vietnam, so only very rich people in Vietnam can afford a new car. One of the reasons the U.S. got out ahead on this industry is because a lot of the inventors in the field were, and have been American, and because of trade deals, and tariffs that used to protect the industry.

It's still the case that people want their cars to come more highly trained workers than say their shoes (not life or death if they're junk). And those workers end up costing more to train and keep, thus the high price on this kind of good.

shoham··on Facebook First Half Revenue Hits $1.6 Billion
Alexa.com has LinkdIn @ 13, Amazon @ 15, and ebay @ 21 globally.
shoham··on Facebook First Half Revenue Hits $1.6 Billion
Even at 1 Billion users, that's only $10 Million -- less than 1% of what they made in the last 6 mos.
shoham··on Facebook First Half Revenue Hits $1.6 Billion
I agree with just about everything but your last sentence.
shoham··on Facebook First Half Revenue Hits $1.6 Billion
Well, there's no pay-per like option right now, so technically I'd say that this doesn't count.

As to your point re: linking to brand page on Facebook, I feel as if this goes to the point that unless and until you let businesses sell on Facebook, and somehow capitalize on that (through a commission fee, or just more ad revenue for clicks to their Facebook store,) I'm not convinced that either Facebook or these businesses are really better off in the long run.

Don't get me wrong, it pays for businesses to have some kind of a Facebook strategy, unless and until Facebook goes the way of AOL. I agree, the Like game isn't free, but I question its long-term sustainability -- do I really want Doritos' posts next to ones from friends and family?

Frankly, I'd rather just see Reddit or Google style ads that look like, and function like the content I came to see in the first place (and as an advertiser I'd pay well for them, but I find Facebook's current ad set-up to be lacking -- as someone who has spent a considerable amount of my own money on Facebook ads).

shoham··on Facebook First Half Revenue Hits $1.6 Billion
"Smart people with that much attention flowing through their systems will figure out the details". As an investor, I'm uninspired here -- the details are all that matter to me-- not who the smartest guy in the room is, not at these prices. Think about Enron, or AOL. I'm not seeing what Facebook makes -- this is all very reminiscent of the 1998-2001 tech boom. I know what Apple makes (consumer electronics and software), and what Microsoft makes (consumer software). I know what Google makes (software to help me find the information I want). I know what AOL sold: dial-up internet access. And Enron: natural gas

What does Facebook make? How will they help businesses make more sales and connections using their ad network? Will people get tired of 'liking' businesses, and having their posts appear next to pictures and posts of friends and family?

shoham··on Feed-Forward helps artists communicate better.
Congratulations!
shoham··on Jack Welch: China losing competitiveness. Must Create '10,000 Apples'
Rhetorical question, I suppose, but I 'lived' in Vietnam (backpacking) for about a month and spent less than ten dollars a day (significantly more than I would have if I lived there for say a year and cooked my own meals, and had rent instead of staying in guest houses). Probably around $3 a day for a middle class person would suffice, or $4,000 a year for a middle class family of four. Hard to compete with that!
shoham··on Facebook First Half Revenue Hits $1.6 Billion
Well, anything's possible, and I'd even say that they might do something else that neither us nor them nor anyone else has figured out yet, but I can't speculate there. I see Facebook as a potential AOL without the dial-up service, but with more user loyalty, and a potentially unbreakable monopoly on IM. If they can focus on what they doing best -- helping people stay connected with their friends, and not get lost in the hype of dollar valuations they'll be fine.

As an investor, I'm short Facebook at an $80 Billion valuation.

shoham··on Are jobs obsolete?
Thanks for sharing! Great article, reminded me of a great speech I read recently that Paul Graham gave in 2005:

http://www.paulgraham.com/opensource.html

The jist is the same as Rushkoff's, and Lanier's conclusion-- that people perform better when they do something they care about enough to do it for free. The paradox with the digital age is that consumers have grown accustomed to not paying for digital goods -- and artists have grown accustomed to settling for any attention they can get, which means marketing gimmicks, and settling for the lowest common denominator far too often for authors of original content. Lanier covers this well, for sure:

http://edge.org/conversation/the-local-global-flip

shoham··on What happened to common decency in the hiring process?
This is true with Rite Aids in Pittsburgh as well!
shoham··on Facebook First Half Revenue Hits $1.6 Billion
My question is "Where is that revenue supposed to come from?". Let's assume Facebook's userbase doubles in the next year, and tops out/ holds steady at at 1.5 Billion people for the foreseeable future, and that their revenue per user doubles from $4/year to $8/per year -- there's a reasonable $80 Billion valuation for you, but where to from there? Investors buy stock they think will rise in value. Will FB offer a dividend?

Here is the rub with/for FB: The best ads are no ads-- playing the 'Like' game is cheaper, and more authentic for advertisers. Better than Google's search results your posts are more social, cost nothing, and show up in between pictures and posts by friends.

shoham··on Facebook First Half Revenue Hits $1.6 Billion
Interesting points, ig. When it comes to revenue, I ask myself "Why do people come to your site". The magic for Google/Yahoo is that you come to their site to leave their site, to find answers to questions like "Where can I find a diamond engagement ring?" and then they get the answers, and some highly relevant, highly lucrative ads.

For eBay, and Amazon, you come specifically with the intent to spend money on their site.

For Facebook, the name of the game is to get you on their site, keep you there, and to bring you back tomorrow to chat with your friends, something like AIM was 10 years ago, but with a better ad network. So far, with all of the businesses that want me to like them on Facebook, none of them have asked me to buy anything on Facebook, just spread their ads -- paid and earned.

Could Facebook be the next ebay or Amazon? Sure, if they want to let every business on their site use their "Pay with Facebook" feature to sell anything. For me, this would justify the current valuation not display ads.

Here's a link to LinkedIn's Q2 revenue (120 Million: http://mashable.com/2011/08/04/linkedin-q2-beats-street/), which again shows that display ads (plus premium membership fees) don't add up to what search ads, or commission fees do. Even for a site like LinkdIn which is more popular than either Amazon (30 Billion in annual revenue) or eBay (8 Billion in annual revenue).

I don't doubt the social utility (pardon the pun) of such networks (I am a founder of one myself), but I question just how much revenue these kind of peripheral ads can really generate.

shoham··on Bill Dietrich gives CMU $250,000,000
The music school could really use the money! Hail to Pitt :)
shoham··on Quotes From Bill Hewlett and David Packard
Thanks for sharing this, whether or not either of them actually said these things verbatim (which has been questioned elsewhere in this thread). These guys got what capitalism is all about: providing goods, services, and jobs that make people's lives better.
shoham··on Quotes From Bill Hewlett and David Packard
I think that these phrases and especially number 5 point to a different paradigm in business than we have today, unfortunately. Profits should really be there largely to help a company expand service, do R&D into new technologies, and keep the business afloat in hard times, not as the prime mover it all too often is.

To your question: "What is a business for", I like this answer:

#2: Set out to build a company and make a contribution, not an empire and a fortune.

Even the meanest Robber Barren on the Gilded Age got this, I think.

shoham··on Facebook First Half Revenue Hits $1.6 Billion
80-1 P/E valuation seems a bit steep to me. I still see this as a $25 Billion company in the long term, which isn't bad for a site that gets much of its revenue from display ads.

Here's a list of websites by 2010 revenue:

http://www.incomediary.com/top-earning-websites-in-the-world...

You'll notice that just about every site in the top 15 sell goods and services (physical: Amazon, eBay or digital: Netflix, iTunes) or search ads (Yahoo, and Google). Display ad based sites languish at the bottom for several reasons, including the fact that the content of those ads are not what you came to the site to engage with.

If the numbers are right, then Facebook is bringing in about 1/3 the revenue of eBay, but analysts on secondary markets and elsewhere are giving it a valuation twice that of eBay's: http://finance.yahoo.com/q?s=EBAY or five times that of Yahoo's which has twice the revenue: http://finance.yahoo.com/q?s=YHOO

Hopefully people can see through the hyperbole, and find a fair market value for this company.

shoham··on Feed-Forward helps artists communicate better.
My friend, and business partner William Klieber have developed a unique to too help artist communicate better. We host artists of several disciplines including visual artists, musicians, filmmakers, and writers. Artists can also sell their work commission free.

Our unique karma system encourages artists to give feedback for each others' work. The more high-quality feedback an artist gives for others' works on our homepage, the more often his/her work appears on our homepage.

shoham··on Reddit becomes reddit Inc.
Hi,

As a small business advertiser on Reddit, I feel as if this would be a good idea, especially for big businesses; however as I wrote before (http://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=shoham), there are a couple of little things that I think you guys could be doing to be more business friendly with self serve ads for small businesses like my own: http://www.feed-forward.net

The three main ideas are: (1) lower the cost per day for ads (for a small business, with less than 100K a year in revenue, Reddit ads don't scale well). Facebook, and Google have a $1/day minimum. (2) Let the OPss of self serve ads moderate their post. It defeats the purpose of spending money on an ad, and having such an awesome idea such as the SSA program if the comments section is hounded by trolls, and moderated by no one. I've been told by admins that Reddit has a long history of free speech adherence, which is great, but posts are removed from subreddits all the time for not complying with the subreddits' rules, at the mods discretion. My proposition is that you guys extend this courtesy to buyers of SSAs.

Third, allow advertisers who have been advertising for a while to focus their impressions on people who have already clicked on their ads. Again, this is a small business-friendly idea -- I've focused most of my ad buys on r/music , a huge subreddit of 150K people. If after a month or two I could focus my buys on those users I've already engaged with in that r/, that would help bolster two objectives: keep the ad conversational, and help advertisers create a community around their submission/business. Once a few thousand people have seen my ad every day for two or three months, I can maybe even invite them to a sponsored r/...

-Shoham

shoham··on Reddit becomes reddit Inc.
Buyer of Reddit self-serve ads here, and I think that their approach is interesting, even exciting, and in the long-term potentially very profitable. Some of the issues come down to the ad averse culture (as you pointed out), not just of the community at large but even of the staff on the back-end.

There are great little ideas that are not being managed effectively in my opinion. For instance, it costs more to target a particular subreddit than the whole website, which is not particularly good for the kinds of small businesses that could really benefit from the service (there's also a daily minimum -- $20/day for site-wide, and $30/day for subreddit buys -- compared to Google, and Facebook's $1/day minimum).

Secondly, the true genius of the Reddit ad system is that your ad looks a lot like a regular submission. Think about the power of Adwords -- your ad looks just like the content your potential buyers came to consume anyway.

Thirdly, and here is the double-edged sword -- in the comments, a conversation (actually, a long-term, multiparty conversation) can build around your company. The power of this is truly great; however the implementation has been spotty. Every post on Reddit is submitted via a community with rules, and moderators. The one exception to this is self serve ads. What you end up with is a lot of spam and trolling in your self-serve ad, which defeats the whole purpose of having the comments in the first place.

Unfortunately, in my experience, the admins aren't sure what to say and fallback on free speech adherence, etc. although many posts and comments are taken down in various subreddits due to a lack of observance on the part of the commentor or OP to that sub's rules.

TL;DR: Reddit's self-serve ad system is a billion dollar idea in the making, but only if the culture of the community and more importantly the admins allow it to be so.

← PreviousPage 3 of 3