What is our modern understanding of this? Are there kinds of local clusters you could detect with the naked eye?
1,819 karma · joined June 15, 2021
What is our modern understanding of this? Are there kinds of local clusters you could detect with the naked eye?
I think one issue we have is that authors of a paper shouldn’t be forced to provide “tech support” for life under the sword of retraction. I try to reimplement analysis and algorithms in the literature all the time, and it’s hard to get it right. I don’t want to write to the authors for help without trying my best first. And I don’t get to write to the editors complaining about no response unless I’m thoroughly convinced of an error.
That’s why I think the comment article triggering a real investigation is the right process. It showed that Mur put enough effort into his replication effort by thoroughly describing the process.
The final exchange with the authors was confusing to me, I don’t get what happened. But I do think Mur was right to be frustrated at that moment.
> Consider that the SARS-CoV-2 Omicron variant and its one-amino-acid reversion mutants were artificially and systematically generated. In that case, we should suspect that the other variants (Alpha to Delta) were also artificially generated viruses. Indeed, the lack of findings to date that many of the various mutations seen, especially in the early variants, are indeed associated with increased viral infection (31) supports the hypothesis that each variant was artificially synthesized to identify the amino acids of the S protein responsible for infectivity and pathogenicity. The possibility that the set of mutants was artificially generated to identify amino acids of the S protein involved in the infectivity and virulence is supported.
Though I appreciate the novelty, it would be fun to see more discussion. But, I think something has gone wrong with your analysis is everywhere you look you think it’s unnatural evolution.
Hand grinders are getting better and better too, so if longevity is a concern you’re in luck.
> Compared to other mammals, humans have a long life.
Being a social animal is irrelevant.
I really want journals to have two way links in a paper. I get google scholar alerts about certain papers being cited, and I want to skip to “why did they cite this? Did they use it, improve it, it just mention it?”
He literally linked you to a lecture by a professor teaching his history course at Yale. Disagreeing is interesting, but “uneducated”?
When I was growing up on the internet, everyone understood the value of pseudo anonymity. But then Facebook came along and everyone is shocked that attaching your name and face to your random thoughts is a bad idea.
And while a burner account is vulnerable to doxing, at least that’s universally viewed as going over the line. And maybe as an owner of a social media platform, Musk could prevent doxing with better privacy tools.