And he probably cant quote Shakespeare as well ;)
201 karma · joined March 10, 2008
And he probably cant quote Shakespeare as well ;)
Take it or leave it :-)
In the case of NM we happened to have something that is often also computationally simple and efficient so we keep using it, but it is by no means a “correct theory”. just a useful model that is still useful.
i daresay it will continue to be useful for some things even if we eg discover that we are living in a simulation and manage to escape! As long as some part of us will continue to experience this reality it will be useful - the math is simple and gives good approximations in many cases.
Depending on your scales etc you may wish to group different things into the category of “object”, eg a car would likely be be selected as a valid grouping of atoms as an object by most people in conversation wheres it is mostly empty space at the micro level, and has a bunch of very different densities (many oom) at diff volumes even at the macro scale (eg the air in the trunk vs the engine block).
For objects where the gradient at the boundary is not great relative to our size we would subjectively experience no surface when coming close eg to a cloud.
Does a galaxy have a "surface"? We can often also "clearly see" the edge of it...
Thanks for sharing!
[edit]
Even more for making!
The specific infinite results you get depend on the representative you choose and if you want to calculate integrals which you have yet to define, you need to work harder. On the other hand, if you care about modeling specific infinities for applications you are very likely also someone who needs and wants the actual theory.
As someone with mathematical background indeed i repeat that i think this theory is interesting and worth studying. Just not that it simplifies anything.
No, they do not differ by an infinitesimal. You picked an arbitrary infinite N and found the derivative to be N/4. What if you picked N^2? or 2^N? or some upper limit set whose existence is stronger than choice? You get a different derivative every time and they all differ by an infinity between them. Good luck explaining that to high school students.
Moreover, working with equivalence relations is never a feature of any theory. Having to prove independence from representative at every step is not a feature, as you clearly demonstrate by making the mistake above.
> I've done a course in analysis that covered distributions, but your reply made me chuckle. You've told me that distributions are just as simple and then proceeded to dump paragraphs of jargon at me. L^infinity? Dual space? Support? Penrose defined? Inner product via integrals?
All concepts that are simple to define and understand. Majority of physicists likely understand well. Those that don’t, could.
Paragraphs of jargon? i’ve rigorously proven and justified my further assertions, at a similar level to OP and above what i’ve seen in some physics lectures.
I deliberately decided to avoid defining the above “jargon” terms after considering doing that to avoid extending the already long comment. I decided this because they are simple and a curious mind could quickly understand them by browsing wikipedia.
You’re welcome to ignore them and to go and compute derivatives and integrals just as mechanistically as in NSA (and I repeat, we haven’t even mentioned integrals in NSA. Good luck defining what are measurable functions on the hyperreals to your hypothetical AP high school students).
And to boot we never have to deal with any quantities that are not real measurable numbers. Anything we care about we can compute, more easily (integrals? integrals??) this way.
That is not to say that this isn’t an interesting theory that should be studied - just that it is quite the opposite of a “simplified” approach to general functions
I don’t know, this feels like a math “hold my beer” moment. Math is infinitely deep and interconnected, but you have to start somewhere, on solid ground.
I was not being facetious above - the issues that i mentioned above are actual problems when you make calculations. But let’s ignore those issues for a second.
So you found the “derivative” of a single, arbitrary chosen representative of an infinite family of functions. What if you chose (tanh(Nx)+1)/2? What if you chose Logistic(N^2 x) instead of Logistic(N x)? You’d get different derivatives. In fact any function (up to additive constant) whose integral of the neighborhood of 0 is 1 would work there. What use are the values you are calculating if they reflect your choice and not anything inherent to the problem?
As for distributions, i picked up and read a small 100 page penguin “leaflet” from the library during my undergrad that went through the subject rigorously (and with plenty of examples). It’s not that different from working rigorously with probability or real analysis. And at the end, in applications we indeed are usually interested in integrals, not derivatives which we have not even defined. At the end of the day, you have a [X=weak L^infinity(R)] function (heavyside). You look at the dual space and since we established don't really need the deep theory, believe me when i tell you that the correct space is the space of test function on R (X’=infinitely smooth, compact support, bounded integral). Each of those conditions is simple for our simple example of R. The inner product is via integral.
Formally speaking elements of X are equivalence classes of sequences of functions and are not really defined pointwise, but neither was the NSA example. There we had to choose an arbitrary representative hyperreal function and here we may identify pointwise defined functions with the classes of the constant sequences of those functions.
using integration by parts it is simple to show that <F,G’> = <F’,G> if F is continuously differentiable on G’s support. Let us formally define in this way the weak derivative for functions that are not traditionally differentiable, if such an element exists an is unique that satisfies all the integral relations. However note that differentiation is an linear isomorphism on the space of test functions and so weak derivative indeed exists and is unique. Furthermore
We can also define elements of X poinwise by identifying F(x) with the limit <Txn,F> as n grows if it exists and is independent of the sequence Txn where Txn is a sequence of functions with support tending to {x} and constant integral 1. It is a simple exercise to show that for “normal” functions this holds, and by above we can poinwise define derivatives this way as well.
What about our H(x)? it is an exercise to check that by pointwise we get what we should outside of 0. What about the derivative at 0? Well, do the exercise above with <T0n’,H> and we see that it is penrose undefined. Decidedly not even necessarily infinite, just undefined. However, integration by parts shows that <T,DH>=T(0) ie dirac delta at 0.
Aside from all the theory that i kinda gave handwavingly much like OP in the post, the mechanics are simple integration by parts to get the only stuff that’s “real” here, which are the integrals. in NSA we haven’t even defined those. How will knowing what infinity i will get at 0 given an arbitrarily chosen representative for H help me?
Do your results depend on ZFC? stronger axioms? At what level of infinity do we stop? You can brush aside the formalities but then what better is this approach than physicists?
For a simple example of difficulties consider comparing the volume of two distinct k-unit spheres embedded in R^n where n>k.
I guess the main difficulty might be in regards to how you store the file links and associated files.
Ill be waiting for your public domain repo with ios syncthing build instructions - no need to doxx yourself. ill happily build it for myself - i don’t have a dev account either.
FWIW that app works much better than icloud has ever worked for me. eg with icloud you never know when the device decides to remove a file from local cache until youre offline and need to use it.