HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

siliconviking

336 karma · joined January 24, 2013

submissionscomments
siliconviking··on Show HN: noteZilla - Interactive sheet music
Pleased to hear that! Thanks :)
siliconviking··on Show HN: noteZilla - Interactive sheet music
It's mostly manual work at this point, although it's not too bad because of some javascript that I wrote that makes it really straightforward to partition a score into time intervals...

And yes, I might actually write a blog post about this so make sure you have signed up on the site :)

siliconviking··on Show HN: noteZilla - Interactive sheet music
I use LilyPond when creating the sheet music, and it can take MusicXML as well as MIDI (I'm assuming that MuseScore can output at least one of them).

Alternately, it would be possible to just upload the pictures of the score directly in .png format onto noteZilla.

siliconviking··on Show HN: noteZilla - Interactive sheet music
Yes!

I'm actually using LilyPond already to create the sheet music, so if I do add the possibility for users to upload their own scores, it would most likely be with LilyPond...

Although the user would still need to partition the score (ie indicate at what time a certain note occurs) if the music was to be synced up to it.

It isn't terribly labor intensive but still requires a little bit of work... so maybe, if that's what people want!

siliconviking··on Show HN: noteZilla - Interactive sheet music
Still down? I made yet another upgrade after that first upgrade... Is it working now for you?
siliconviking··on Show HN: noteZilla - Interactive sheet music
Thanks! Makes me happy to hear that :)

I will definitely work on getting that line synced up. On my computer (Mac OS X / Chrome), it's perfectly synced, but it seems that that isn't the case for some people.

Thanks for the feedback.

siliconviking··on Show HN: noteZilla - Interactive sheet music
Most likely that will be very hard to do, at least for orchestral pieces, which are typically recorded using overhead microphones (ie, not with separate tracks for each instrument).

For pop music, it's definitely doable as long as I can get access to the individual tracks. It's actually something I have been wanting to do, so thanks for the suggestion.

siliconviking··on Show HN: noteZilla - Interactive sheet music
Thanks! :)
siliconviking··on Show HN: noteZilla - Interactive sheet music
I have considered that, actually. There are certain advantages with it - although, one thing that I like in particular with hosting the audio myself is that for example, I can slow it down to 25% speed and still have it sound great! Not possible with Youtube at the moment (if you slow down their videos, the results are deplorable).

Interesting demo! I definitely like the hiding of the instruments not playing.... also, lots of people seem to prefer a flowing score.

As for fetching more quickly, yup, also worth addressing.

More music? You can be sure about that ;)

Thanks.

siliconviking··on Show HN: noteZilla - Interactive sheet music
Just upgraded to a paid database in Heroku, took about 3 minutes all in all ;) Hopefully it will handle the traffic better.

Kudos to Heroku!

siliconviking··on Show HN: noteZilla - Interactive sheet music
Thanks. Looks like the database is not keeping up with all the connections. Will look into that....
siliconviking··on Show HN: noteZilla - Interactive sheet music
Oops! I forgot to change the definition of the keyboard controls... it's actually meant to turn a whole page so I just need to change the definition.

(just moving by one measure is more easily done by clicking in the score...)

Thanks for correcting that :)

As for Beethoven's 5th, it should self-correct, but I have noticed that in some browsers it doesn't quite work... What browser and hardware are you using? I will look into this further.

I have heard from several others that the current way of moving the cursor isn't optimal. Your solution could work. I'm going to explore a few ways and probably offer some new choices to the user. Your suggested solution would be very easy to implement, so most likely I will add that.

Thanks again!

siliconviking··on Show HN: noteZilla - Interactive sheet music
Thanks!

Well it seems that consensus is that the current page turning is not optimal... Perhaps scrolling is the solution. I will definitely invest some time in that to improve it.

Also, regarding the time and key signatures, I very much agree with you, they need to "stick"...

As for color coding, is the purpose to make it easier to follow a certain instrument?

siliconviking··on Show HN: noteZilla - Interactive sheet music
I think having the key / time signature "stick" makes a lot of sense... I will work on that. The only thing to look out for is key signature / time signature changes, and make sure those get captured too and that they stick...

As for scrolling, it seems like that is a feature that some people might prefer. I will most likely add that as a feature to it.

Thanks!

siliconviking··on Show HN: noteZilla - Interactive sheet music
Agreed! Coming up!
siliconviking··on Show HN: noteZilla - Interactive sheet music
Thanks very much!

Yup, I can do the highlighting fairly easily, that's a good idea!

Scrolling is easily doable too, but I'm not sure that's the best way for all situations. I might provide it though, and then let the user choose depending on their situation.

About me: a wannabe classical composer / tech geek ;)

(and in the event people are actually interested in this idea becoming more than just a concept, I would be very happy to provide a more elaborate About section)

siliconviking··on Death in Singapore
But what exactly would stop the FBI from sending agents to Singapore and conducting their own investigation, with or without consent? Need it be covert, it could certainly be covert.

I'm currently operating under the assumption (which seemed likely to me) that the Singaporean government / police had a motive for not wanting to involve the FBI. Hence the more reason for the FBI to be there.

siliconviking··on Death in Singapore
“The United States has offered FBI assistance to the Government of Singapore on the Shane Todd case" (but Singaporean authorities have not accepted the assistance) - what is the jurisdiction for the FBI to pursue this investigation without Singaporean consent? Doing that sounds like an appropriate measure at this stage (a little surprised that it hasn't already happened).
siliconviking··on Docracy Terms of Service Tracker
Awesome idea!! Any chance someone could curate it and highlight the changes that were meaningful? For example, Geico just took out the following:

"We do not save this data nor disclose it to any third parties."

(anything but comforting...)

siliconviking··on Show HN: CompareThings - Measure the popularity of pretty much anything
Gracias!!
siliconviking··on Show HN: CompareThings - Measure the popularity of pretty much anything
Thanks Juca! Hope things are well!
siliconviking··on Show HN: CompareThings - Measure the popularity of pretty much anything
Thanks! Meant to be fun, simple and useful, that's it ;)

Which mobile device were you using, out of curiosity?

siliconviking··on Google search mystery
Good suggestion - but I did the searches with quotes originally, so I don't think that's the case...
← PreviousPage 4 of 4