HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

silkodyssey

1,516 karma · joined March 17, 2009

Founder of Safyah Solutions http://www.safyah.com kelvin.pompey@gmail.com
submissionscomments
silkodyssey··on World's Largest Social Network - The Open Web
The open web is a network of information while facebook is a network of people. Social is about interaction between people so I disagree that the open web is more social. The open web may be more connected but facebook is more social because the connections are mainly between people. And while facebook is in many ways a closed system it is weaving itself seamlessly into the fabric of the web with the open graph initiative. Search engines may not be able to crawl facebook directly but through it's graph api website developers can access that information.
silkodyssey··on [dead]
If these are the reasons people have for hating django then I would have to conclude that the django developers are doing great work!
silkodyssey··on Ask HN: Free Programming eBooks
http://diveintohtml5.org/ http://book.realworldhaskell.org/read/
silkodyssey··on Pain. Or, Why Learning to Code is like Learning Chinese.
I don't remember going through this phase when I was learning to program! I got started with C many years ago and I remember savoring every moment. :) I think what may account for the difference is that in my case the interest in programming stemmed from wanting to learn how the computer worked and C's low level nature facilitated this very well. With regard to the author it seems she's more anxious to start creating real useful applications. I get the impression she's more interested in the end product of the programming than the actual programming process.

Currently I do most of my development for the linux platform but I was considering moving to windows to take advantage of some opportunities in that area but I am facing some of the same challenges as the author of the article. The C# language and .NET platform are a whole new world and it feels like I am starting from scratch. It's hard to justify as I can do everything I need to do on the linux platform.

silkodyssey··on Writing is Thinking
I think the assertion has some merit in as far as writing allows us to communicate our thoughts with a higher level of precision.

It's relatively easy to have a vague idea about something but it's a different matter to explain it with well reasoned arguments.

With programming it is the same. It is sometimes easy to conceptualize the steps required to solve a particular problem or implement a particular algorithm but when the time comes to translate it to program code it can be more difficult as we have to think about all the little details.

silkodyssey··on Can Java Be Saved?
I think that both sides of the argument are valid but I am more inclined to believe that keeping the language stable at least over the short term may be the better strategy.

Java thrives in environments where stability is a prime concern and Sun's commitment to maintaining backwards compatibility would inspire confidence.

The new languages that are being developed to run on the jvm reduces the need for Java to evolve as rapidly as some would like. If it is proven that these new languages solve problems better than java then it's only a matter of time before developers make the switch.

At this point when it's obvious what features are really desired then it Sun/Oracle may decide that adding those features to the Java language are appropriate.

In this way the new jvm languages sort of act like a research lab to test out new ideas to see which work better.

silkodyssey··on Does math have big scary teeth or something?
I think all jobs require problem solving to some degree just that some jobs are easier than others and others while not necessarily easy are sufficiently well defined to enable a worker to develop expertise in that area. And with expertise in a field problems are often solved intuitively without going through all the "problem solving mechanics".

Getting to this point where problems can be solved intuitively can sometimes take years of study and practice. We can look at this as an investment. A person invests time and energy in wiring his or her brain to solve a particular set of problems and after achieving this goal the person is left with little desire to repeat the process for another problem domain. A doctor may apply problem solving skills to diagnose and treat a rare disease but may not be able muster the effort required to learn photoshop. It's not due to a lack of problem solving abilities but more of a desire to step not out of their problem solving comfort zone.

silkodyssey··on Lost in Translation or Why GWT Isn’t the Future of Web Development
Whether or not GWT is the future of (client side) web development is left to be seen but I think its very existence frameworks like it suggest that there is a need that needs to be filled.

More and more advanced applications are being built in the browser and Javascript doesn't provide the tools to build applications of that scale. Java has been proven for these type of applications in the enterprise and it's not surprising to see efforts being made to apply it to rich ajax applications.

silkodyssey··on The Making of ReoCities, 600K accounts recovered already and counting
You never know! This may be a good opportunity to launch a startup. Some users may be interested in maintaining their sites so maybe tools can offered to help them in that regard. The work done so far is commendable and there is more work yet to be done. It would be a shame if all the work goes unrewarded!
silkodyssey··on SICP in Clojure (In Progress)
Rich Hickey has some interesting things to say about learning clojure via SICP. http://groups.google.com/group/clojure/browse_thread/thread/...
silkodyssey··on PG: The hundred-year language
It is interesting that Rich Hickey shares this opinion as well (he considers OOP spaghetti code) and both of them are developing new lisp dialects!
silkodyssey··on Barack Obama gets Nobel's Peace Prize
I agree with the general sentiments that the award is probably premature but I think the general nature of the award lends itself to situations such as these.

An award has to be given out every year and the world does not produce ghandis at that rate so the people who have made profound achievements will have to share the award with those who've done less.

This does diminish the achievements of the greats in a sense but that's just how the system works and the fact that we can't really point to anyone else who obviously deserved the award more than Obama suggests that he may have been the best choice after all.

silkodyssey··on What I've Earned (And Learned) From Writing a Ruby Programming Book
You mention that apress lets other authors release open version of their books. Did these authors release their books for free initially or have they been with apress since the beginning?
silkodyssey··on Shark Eats Entrepreneur Alive
Would there be any legal recourse for the technical co-founder in this case?
silkodyssey··on Django 1.2 roadmap and schedule
I like the idea of a smarter template if tag but after having looked at the snippets page it doesn't look quite like what I was hoping for. I was looking for something more the tornado framework's implementation.

I prefer tornado's template system in general. It's much closer to actual python in terms of syntax and the ability to pass functions from a request handler to the template is sweet!

silkodyssey··on Introducing Atlas: A Visual Development Tool for Creating Web Apps
I was wondering whether it supported just the mac platform so thanks for the answer!
silkodyssey··on Pyjamas - port of Google Web Toolkit to Python
This is a promising project. I would much prefer to write my apps in python than java! However I don't think it's ready for prime time. The last time I tried it I couldn't get version 0.6 to work and there were some issues with some of the widgets with version 0.5.
silkodyssey··on Announcing GWT 2.0 Milestone 1
I think I remember reading somewhere that the Google Wave team gave up on supporting ie6 so this suggests that GWT doesn't eliminate all cross browser issues.

I don't use it though. I have looked at it and I don't see the point of compiling java to javascript. I like the output it produces but I don't like the workflow. I am not fond of java's verbosity and I would have preferred an approach similar to the one taken by YUI in implementing rich widgets in javascript.

silkodyssey··on C−−: a portable assembly language designed by Simon Peyton Jones et al.
http://homepage.mac.com/randyhyde/webster.cs.ucr.edu/HighLev...

Another attempt at a "portable high level assembly language". It's being developed by Randall Hyde author of "the Art of Assembly Language". It supports the ia32 architecture (64 bit support is coming in the future) and you can write applications using pure assembly language mnemonics or mix these instructions with high level control structures, high level data types (has support for OOP). It also includes a standard library with functions for concurrency, network programming, pattern matching etc. It's a really interesting project. It's both more low level and high level than C at the same time!

silkodyssey··on The Facebook Exodus
Could it be the times has an issue with facebook? As has been pointed out by other commenters there is no real evidence to suggest a facebook exodus but could this be a subtle message to readers that a facebook exodus is a desirable outcome?
silkodyssey··on [dead]
Well the article was published on Thursday, July 17, 2008 so I think that's unlikely.
silkodyssey··on Ask HN: Where do you live?
Kingstown, Saint Vincent and the Grenadines.:)
silkodyssey··on Ask HN: Please, review wordoid.com, a smart naming webapp
A feature I would like is to be able to filter out words according to whether they're scarce, rare, unique or common.
silkodyssey··on Why Facebook has never listened and why it definitely won’t start now
Facebook is just trying to prevent itself from becoming irrelevant. It realizes that the service it offers it not unique in any significant way and it can get left by the way side when the next big thing comes along.

It's still a young company and without an established business model we can't really hold them to too much. You won't expect an application in beta to be a beacon of stability and usability. This is the stage facebook is in and it should be allowed to evolve until they find a sustainable business model.

← PreviousPage 3 of 3