HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sillyfleece

-1 karma · joined July 23, 2022

submissionscomments
sillyfleece··on Stop saying “They shouldn't have invested more than they could afford to lose”
If you think lay people are going to be able to stomach being in the red year after year for 3-5 years without desperately looking for an out, I think you may need to reconsider your understanding of human psychology.
sillyfleece··on Stop saying “They shouldn't have invested more than they could afford to lose”
Not at all. The first post I replied to was saying index funds are safe for lay people to invest in. I'm saying index funds may not be safe for lay people to invest in in these extraordinary times. Crypto is way riskier than index funds, I agree.
sillyfleece··on Stop saying “They shouldn't have invested more than they could afford to lose”
>probably to make it back within a few years

"probably"? Are you willing to be held criminally liable when the elderly take your advice and the S&P does not bend to your will for the next year or two due to say -- oh I don't know -- unforeseen world events?

edit: I was alluding to the possibility of c): not investing in the S&P or crypto for the duration and suffering inflation. which would have been better than a) and b) since inflation is added on top of both those losses.

sillyfleece··on Stop saying “They shouldn't have invested more than they could afford to lose”
Is this really the line you are going to use to convince people to avoid scams?

I'd like you to meet Sam the Scammer: "If you would have bought bitcoin on this date in 2019 you would have been up 200% by now. You would have doubled your money in 3 years. literally."

sillyfleece··on Stop saying “They shouldn't have invested more than they could afford to lose”
What am I missing? S&P is down 10% yearly, 17% YTD, no? When "safe" investments are looking worse than keeping your money in the bank getting hit with inflation, rational people start getting desperate and scams explode.

Anyone who has lived in emerging markets knows the sentence soon becomes "Don't invest in <previous safe investment> more than you can afford to lose."

And the last stage in such countries ends up being: "Don't put more dollars in your bank than you can afford to lose" (because your failing bank or country will confiscate it).

Until you reach this stage the number of scams increases exponentially.