HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

singleshot_

1,617 karma · joined October 31, 2022

n/a
submissionscomments
singleshot_··on The madness of SaaS chargebacks
I am acutely aware that it constrains liquidated damages to a reasonable figure. Conveyance to a collector is, of course, customary in the trade.

The problem is that a “punitive” amount of liquidated damages is neither reasonable, nor would it typically be found to have been the product of an actual estimate of the damages. See, 356 cmt. a.

If you didn’t say “punitive” in the LD provision, you’d have the “reasonable estimate” conversation but GP straight up called it a punitive clause, which is not going to fly (in many jurisdictions, ianyl, etc. etc.)

singleshot_··on The madness of SaaS chargebacks
Restatement (Second) Contracts sec. 356 would seem directed squarely at this bad idea.
singleshot_··on iPhone Air
Why?
singleshot_··on iPhone Air
I’ve been a little concerned that the (non-transparent) back is “protected” by glass. I understand that Marketing has to work with what they’re given, but that’s a bit much.
singleshot_··on We hacked Burger King: How auth bypass led to drive-thru audio surveillance
I've had some challenges recording voices with video, but I salute your efforts.
singleshot_··on We already live in social credit, we just don't call it that
It is worth noting that the EOP OSC is investigating Jack Smith and the DOJ is investigating Letitia James.

This suggests the worst that could happen if you called the US President a criminal liar is that you would go to federal prison.

I suppose the conclusion is that the US is an autocracy.

singleshot_··on No place in children's hands: <16s in UK to be banned from buying energy drinks
> most anxious time in their lives, children?

Why assume the future won’t be even more stressful for this latest generation of young people?

singleshot_··on Mapping connections of anti-offshore wind groups and their lawyers
Respectfully, because I agree with you, I would like to suggest that you look up Mission Winnow next and let me know whether you believe “you couldn’t hope for a more tragically hilarious summation of the cynicism in this industry” held up as an accurate statement.
singleshot_··on Michigan Supreme Court: Unrestricted phone searches violate Fourth Amendment
> then that entire chain of evidence gets thrown out

exceptions: unless it would have gotten found anyway, regardless (inevitable discovery); or the cops, against whom the doctrine of poisonous tree is held in order to keep them honest, just made an honest mistake.

singleshot_··on Michigan Supreme Court: Unrestricted phone searches violate Fourth Amendment
> "mobile nature of our modern society and the fact that cell phones are everywhere and everyone has one."

An LEO citing to Carpenter for the opposite of its holding?

singleshot_··on Is 4chan the perfect Pirate Bay poster child to justify wider UK site-blocking?
Here’s a guy who doesn’t remember the Civil War.
singleshot_··on Scamlexity: When agentic AI browsers get scammed
If you were a lawyer, you’d think something slightly different when you heard the word agent than you would if you were a computer guy. The delta is the fact that under the law of agency, an agent has the power to bind the principal to a contract.

If the lawyers didn’t have this definition in their head there would be no drive to make the software agent a purchaser, because it’s a stupid idea.

singleshot_··on Mark Zuckerberg freezes AI hiring amid bubble fears
Call up TechCongress and offer to volunteer for a cycle.

Law school is the same as med school: if you can’t see yourself living life as something that requires a JD, skip it. Just do the thing you want to do; unless that’s “dispense legal advoce to paying clients and represent them in legal disputes” you can probably do it legally without a JD.

Also be aware you are a lawyer when you graduate law school and you don’t have to pass the bar unless that’s a requirement for your practice. For example, a general counsel of an internet startup might not have to be a member of the bar, but someone going into trial court to represent clients does. I would think you could be a staffer for a congressperson with a JD and without bar membership prettt easily.

singleshot_··on CEO pay and stock buybacks have soared at the largest low-wage corporations
> Legally the CEO has a fiduciary duty to the shareholders

The CEO has two fiduciary duties:

1) To act with appropriate information; 2) To avoid usurping corporate opportunities

The duty to make money for the shareholders is distinctly not a thing.

singleshot_··on How we exploited CodeRabbit: From simple PR to RCE and write access on 1M repos
> Unless there was any breach of customer information (and that can be often verified), there are typically no legal requirements.

If the company is regulated by the SEC I believe you will find that any “material” breach is reportable after the determination of materiality is reached, since at least 2023.

singleshot_··on When DEF CON partners with the U.S. Army
I think you may have a need to create a sense of humor. Perhaps you have heard about the Meshtastic talk at defcon by now.
singleshot_··on Thai Air Force seals deal for Swedish Gripen jets
That was the old legal, too.

Source: lawyer who understands the core element of law is enforceability, but who is not himself a criminal due to quality upbringing

singleshot_··on Thai Air Force seals deal for Swedish Gripen jets
My limited understanding is that this is going to be an offset against the applicable import tariff, not an export tariff.
singleshot_··on When DEF CON partners with the U.S. Army
Could use Meshtastic maybe
singleshot_··on Illinois limits the use of AI in therapy and psychotherapy
> Define “AI therapy”

They did, in the proposed law.

singleshot_··on Vanishing from Hyundai’s data network
That’s not correct: both the objective and subjective reasonable expectation are implicated. If the objective standard was not relevant, why would it matter if the manufacturer made the disclosure you mentioned?
singleshot_··on Vanishing from Hyundai’s data network
They don’t have a reasonable expectation of buying a surveillance-safe new car because one does not exist.

Other than that I hear you. You’re talking about the reasonable expectation in someone’s head but I’m talking about the possibility even existing in the marketplace. I guess you could argue maybe the reality of the market is trumped by the opinion of a person as to the reality of the market. I’m not sure that makes sense (or that ut doesn’t).

I guess you’re saying “they do have that expectation” while I’m saying “regardless of anyone’s expectation, car manufacturers have all addressed the market in a way that makes the expectation false and therefore unreasonable.”

singleshot_··on Vanishing from Hyundai’s data network
Further:

Safer roads and more convenient travel comport with public policy; and,

No one in 2025 has a reasonable expectation they are not being surveilled by their new car.

(FWIW, I’m against surveillance transport but there is no reasonable way to say these contracts of adhesion are unconscionable under US law).

singleshot_··on The dead need right to delete their data so they can't be AI-ified, lawyer says
> It would probably be worth having a law that says that your likeness is part of your estate, and then it can be covered by estate law.

Varies state to state, but you might google "postmortem right of likeness" to determine whether it would truly be worth it to have such a law.

singleshot_··on Tech does not deserve special legal treatment
(The first person to mention the Uniform Electronic Transactions Act is going to get a very stern look because this was just an example).
singleshot_··on Tech does not deserve special legal treatment
I don’t think we were talking about equal application of the law. We were talking about the unwise approach of creating new law for new situations when the old law would work just fine.

For example, when you ask Uber to quote a price for a trip, and they quote the price, and you click “ok,” that’s pretty similar to a paper contract, but it’s not exactly the same.

Should we make up a new set of laws for contracts that you form over your phone? Or should we do our best to apply the old law to the new situation?

The law takes the latter approach. Benefits include: we already have a ton of experience dealing with the old corner cases. To the extent the new corner cases have some similarity to the old ones, we can use the old precedents to establish a greater degree of certainty about future events and how the law will consider them.

Obviously the law will never be equally applied to everyone, but we would greatly simplify our legal lives if we avoid coming up with a new set of laws for every slightly different new technology.

singleshot_··on Tech does not deserve special legal treatment
This is not the position the law takes on this issue. Relevant search terms to learn why include “law of the horse.”
singleshot_··on What's Not to Like?
If I had a nickel for every time I heard a comparison that nonsensical…

Hey, wait a minute-

singleshot_··on U.S. fires statistics chief after soft jobs report
> I don’t know

The root of the problem. With a functioning due process regime, we would.

singleshot_··on Tesla must pay portion of $329M damages after fatal Autopilot crash, jury says
> I'm not necessarily sure the victim(s) should get all of the punitive damages.

I have some great news for you, then: the attorney probably took a third (more if they win an appeal).

> But is there an even better possible place to disburse the funds from these types of fines?

Oh, my mistake: I thought you meant way worse.

← PreviousPage 8 of 34Next →