HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sjy

1,545 karma · joined March 14, 2013

submissionscomments
sjy··on No new locally-acquired coronavirus cases in Australia yesterday
> Restricting movement in Europe between countries is more comparable to restricting movement within a country.

Which is another significant policy that was implemented in Australia, both this year and during the Spanish flu pandemic. https://www.abc.net.au/news/2020-03-24/coronavirus-border-cl...

sjy··on No new locally-acquired coronavirus cases in Australia yesterday
The population of South America is more than 15 times larger.
sjy··on I No Longer Tell My Friends about Anki/SuperMemo
The “Feynman technique” is all about writing your own notes, reviewing them to identify gaps in your knowledge, and organising them. That is basically how you are supposed to use spaced repetition software. In this context, Feynman’s criticism of rote memorisation just means “avoid downloading premade decks.”
sjy··on I No Longer Tell My Friends about Anki/SuperMemo
I baulked at the $25 price as much as anyone else would, so I used the free desktop app, and web app which works on mobile (ankiweb.net), for a month. After that, I was happy to pay $25 to support the developer and get the ability to edit cards on mobile and work offline.
sjy··on I No Longer Tell My Friends about Anki/SuperMemo
I have no formal training in history, but Anki has got me much more interested in it. Before Anki, I tended to collapse centuries of history into ‘the distant past,’ which made it hard to appreciate how events related to each other, or distinguish between events separated by years and events separated by decades or centuries. I discovered, by using Anki for an exam, that it’s relatively easy for me to remember 4-digit numbers, and relatively difficult for me to remember sequences of events. So, memorising the years of events has been a great way for me to learn more history. Arbitrary dates with no understanding of the context are harder to remember, so the cards that come up the most are the topics to read more about (or delete, if they really are useless factoids). It’s a bit like using the number line as a memory palace.
sjy··on I No Longer Tell My Friends about Anki/SuperMemo
I put all kinds of things in my Anki deck, mostly unrelated to software development, but I have created cards for things like the definitions of CRDT, ACID and monad, what link-local IPv6 addresses look like, and some useful flags in grep and parallel. Ever get annoyed by the realisation that you learned something a few months ago, but have forgotten it by the time you need it? Anki can fix this.
sjy··on The story of the PDF (2018)
I don’t think any of that is possible with the JavaScript APIs exposed (if any) by common PDF readers. I’ve tried to do useful things with JavaScript in a PDF and failed utterly. https://stackoverflow.com/questions/32597283/can-javascript-...
sjy··on 2020's fastest-rising tech jobs? Programming language PHP leads the way
Analogous to the ‘serverless’ platforms, there are many companies selling shared PHP hosting, so you can just upload your code and expect it to work without worrying about security updates, service management, configuring TLS, etc.
sjy··on Woman allegedly impersonated prosecutor, dropped charges against herself
A similar process exists in Australia. It is a bit strange that the burden is on the recipient to object to an unlawful subpoena. I understand that it’s pretty common for vexatious litigants to issue subpoenas requiring politicians, governors and other public figures to attend court for cross-examination about a perceived injustice, and there is a bit of work involved in arranging for these to be set aside so that nobody ends up formally in contempt of court.
sjy··on On Abandoning the X Server
The issues can’t be ‘fixed’ in the Wayland protocol, but have been addressed by individual compositors and libraries like wlroots. The difficulty is not in building a decent Wayland desktop from scratch (GNOME, Sway and ChromeOS have all done this), but in rewriting X11 window managers, screen sharing apps and automation tools that perform functions that are the compositor’s responsibility under Wayland.
sjy··on On Abandoning the X Server
The GNOME Settings app allows you to assign global hotkeys under Wayland using the normal GUI [1]. Not sure about configuring those hotkeys in a config file like i3/sway, I assume it’s some dconf thing.

[1] https://help.gnome.org/users/gnome-help/stable/keyboard-shor...

sjy··on On Abandoning the X Server
I tried a bunch of tiling window managers over the last two years, and found that the choice of X11 or Wayland does not make much of a difference with regard to the “second class citizen” effect you described. What finally solved it for me was switching to GNOME (ie. mutter on Wayland) with the PaperWM extension. Fundamentally, I’m running a conventional desktop with no tearing and standard, widely used solutions for keyboard shortcuts, the clipboard, screenshots, and floating windows, so graphical applications look and feel correct even if they are a bad fit for the tiling model. Tiling is then implemented by PaperWM at a higher level, in JavaScript, leaving the complexities of hardware accelerated, animated compositing to GNOME. It’s a good combination – I’d like to see more tiling window managers designed to take advantage of hardware-accelerated compositing.
sjy··on The RIAA’s attack on YouTube-dl is not a DMCA 512 infringement
It is based on the weaker premise that youtube-dl is “primarily designed or produced“ or “marketed” for the purpose of circumventing copyright protection.
sjy··on The RIAA’s attack on YouTube-dl is not a DMCA 512 infringement
> Are only gui based webbrowsers with large market share the only legal way to access multimedia content?

I believe they are the only supported way to access content on YouTube. As for whether the unofficial ways to access YouTube are legal, that depends on whether they circumvent a “technological measure that effectively controls access” [1] to copyrighted works. That’s not so clear, but YouTube does obfuscate its code to make the task of tools like youtube-dl harder.

[1] https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/1201

sjy··on Washington crews destroy first U.S. “murder hornet” nest
I recommend Steffen et al, Trajectories of the Earth System in the Anthropocene (2018) [1]. You can’t read the whole thing in 5 minutes, but you can read the three figures and their captions, which say a lot, and it’s open access, peer reviewed and recent. Maybe your point is that the Earth system is too complicated to explain in 5 minutes, and that’s fair enough, but I do think the climate change policy debate would be a little more sensible if you were expected to spend at least 5 minutes reading this kind of literature before participating.

[1] https://www.pnas.org/content/115/33/8252

sjy··on Reverse-engineering the problematic tail behavior of Fivethirtyeight forecast
> what is the die that is being rolled in these election statistics?

A program which randomly generates outcomes for each state, based on probability distributions inferred from the polls, and calculates who wins the election given those outcomes. They run the program repeatedly and report the proportion of simulated wins as the probability of winning. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monte_Carlo_method

sjy··on Delete Facebook and You'll Lose All Oculus Games for Good
It’s odd that this question which specifically refers to “legal obligations” appears on skeptics.stackexchange.com and not law.stackexchange.com. But the accepted answer hints at the true position when quoting another source that says “the business judgment rule ensures that, contrary to popular belief, the managers of public companies have no enforceable legal duty to maximize shareholder value.” That is, as pointed out in a less-upvoted answer [1], there is indeed a legal duty to act in the (financial) interest of the company and its shareholders, but courts allows for some risk-taking and for value to be realised over a long period, so you can’t prove a breach of the duty solely by reference to share prices.

[1] https://skeptics.stackexchange.com/a/25118/19389

sjy··on I am an Uighur who faced China’s concentration camps
“I want to make it clear that this Uighur genocide is not just [about] religion ... it’s a test for humanity, for the whole world.”
sjy··on YouTube-dl has received a DMCA takedown from RIAA
The RIAA says the technological measure at issue is YouTube’s “rolling cipher,” which is more than the conspicuous lack of a download button.
sjy··on YouTube-dl has received a DMCA takedown from RIAA
In that analogy, the RIAA is saying “hunting knives are illegal, because they’re primarily designed or marketed for hunting, which is illegal” and you are saying “that’s unfair because I use my hunting knife to cut pizza.” The analogy breaks down because hunting knives aren’t illegal, but copyright circumvention devices are.
sjy··on YouTube-dl has received a DMCA takedown from RIAA
You seem to be reading “the purpose of this source code is to circumvent technological protection measures” as though it means “this source code can be used to circumvent technological protection measures.” There is a difference.
sjy··on YouTube-dl has received a DMCA takedown from RIAA
> Meh, we're only going to throw anecdotes back and forth.

That’s a big problem with this whole debate. I think we’d be better off without copyright and that creators would find new, better ways to make a living. But it’s pretty difficult to see how this could be convincingly proved or disproved, so I guess we’re stuck with the status quo forever.

sjy··on YouTube-dl has received a DMCA takedown from RIAA
You could make the argument that the technological measures are not effective (the RIAA says this was rejected by a court in Hamburg), but not in that extreme form. If the existence of a working circumvention tool implied that the technical measures were not “effective,” then all circumvention tools would be legal and the law would have no effect. “Effective” must mean something more than “so ineffective that it can be circumvented with common sense,” and something less than “so effective that there’s no need to make its circumvention illegal.”
sjy··on YouTube-dl has received a DMCA takedown from RIAA
There may be significant differences between US and EU copyright laws, but the anti-circumvention laws in question here are pretty consistent, as they implement the WIPO Copyright Treaty ratified by both the US and the EU: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-circumvention
sjy··on YouTube-dl has received a DMCA takedown from RIAA
(A) seems applicable to me. It is obvious that the primary purpose of youtube-dl is to download videos from YouTube. It is also obvious that most videos on YouTube are copyrighted, and the absence of a ‘download’ button protects the copyright holder’s right to prevent viewers from redistributing the videos. The contentious part is whether not YouTube has “effective” anti-downloading controls that youtube-dl “circumvents.” The fact that it needs to be continually updated to defeat attempts at blocking it suggests that this is a fair characterisation.
sjy··on YouTube-dl has received a DMCA takedown from RIAA
Are they lying when they say ‘YouTube’s “rolling cipher” is an effective technical measure within the meaning of EU and German law, which is materially identical to Title 17 U.S.C. §1201 of the United States Code’? That seems quite plausible to me. Executing Google’s code in a regular web browser doesn’t give you a way to save an .mp4 file on your computer.
sjy··on YouTube-dl has received a DMCA takedown from RIAA
The issue here isn’t that youtube-dl infringes copyright, it’s that (according to the RIAA claim) its purpose is to “circumvent the technological protection measures used by authorized streaming services.” Even if youtube-dl was tested exclusively on public domain videos, so that the developers never infringe copyright, it could violate 17 U.S.C. 1201 [1] if the RIAA succeeds in proving that it was “primarily designed” or “marketed” for circumventing technological protection measures.

[1] https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/1201

sjy··on YouTube-dl has received a DMCA takedown from RIAA
youtube-dl needs to be regularly updated as streaming sites add new countermeasures to block it. If those updates can no longer be crowdsourced from a popular, reputable site like GitHub, the tool has a good chance of dying.
sjy··on YouTube-dl has received a DMCA takedown from RIAA
The logic behind the DMCA complaint is that youtube-dl is “marketed … for use in circumventing a technological measure that effectively controls access to a [copyrighted] work” [1], not that it “allows you to download potentially copyrighted material from youtube.”

[1] https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/1201

sjy··on Whose Computer Is It?
Rather than “network you attach it to,” would it be more precise to say “repository it can automatically install software from”? What I think of as “the network” has very little control over my devices, and some of them even work without network access.
← PreviousPage 6 of 30Next →