HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

skosuri

1,031 karma · joined December 16, 2010

Cofounder/CEO Octant || Associate Professor, UCLA (on leave) || https://www.octant.bio/biosri || http://www.kosurilab.org/
submissionscomments
skosuri··on MSU Vice President of research & innovation Steve Hsu has been forced to resign
First. I’d say read the blog post I linked to above. To answer your question on the “well-known” differences; they definitely are real and genetic. It’s just that IQ and most measures of intelligence look nothing like those traits. The common variants that are tagged in GWAS for IQ are also not different from a variant distribution standpoint. Again, the blog lays this out. There are thousands of papers on this topic. Good books to read are David Reich’s book (which does enter this more touchy territory) and ‘She has her mothers laugh’ for a more general reading. Ewan’s blog in general is also really good as well. In terms of papers, there are a bunch of recent ones that are quite good. Will need more time to post but they tend to be covered by Ewan.
skosuri··on MSU Vice President of research & innovation Steve Hsu has been forced to resign
I wasn't being sarcastic. I was saying that if you are actually sincere, and I was hopeful you were, I said to to take the time to read the blog post (knowing it was long); they go through great lengths to explain to people not in the field what the issues with work like Hsu's. It wasn't meant to be mean. You dismissed it, failed to try to understand it, and were incredibly inconsiderate calling it long and rambling. This is when my tone changed, and in my opinion deservedly so. It indicated to me you were being insincere about spending the time to learn more. Considering how many racist trolls I deal with that do this kind of thing often, your dismissiveness made me think you weren't actually interested in learning more. I gave my information, pointed to the things that you were misunderstanding in that blog, and offered if you have scientific questions, I am happy to take more time to try to answer them. That offer still stands.
skosuri··on MSU Vice President of research & innovation Steve Hsu has been forced to resign
Sorry, didn't actually see any scientific criticisms or questions in any of your replies; just your "sincere" request for more information, which I gave you. You just don't seem interested in learning more.
skosuri··on MSU Vice President of research & innovation Steve Hsu has been forced to resign
So again, you have no substantive questions/comments on the criticisms brought up in the blog post other than to call it long and rambling. Nothing on how common variants associated with intelligence don't segregate substantially across populations. Nothing on the poor accounting for population stratification; nothing on lack of replication on populations outside the regressions; nothing on effect sizes; nothing on IQ test score changes over time that are too short for genetic changes...

anyways, the flex is because you now know who I am and what I research. If you have serious questions about the above topics... the same topics for why most people don't take Hsu seriously, feel free to email them to me. In the meantime, I am laughing because you were anything but sincere.

skosuri··on MSU Vice President of research & innovation Steve Hsu has been forced to resign
Agreed and of course. He can and should continue his research as a well paid full professor at MSU, which I assume he will. He gets a lot of attention for doing so. Otherwise he’d just be a random really bad quantitative geneticist you’ve never heard of that thinks that no one else but him understands L2 regression.
skosuri··on MSU Vice President of research & innovation Steve Hsu has been forced to resign
Lol; what I thought. Do you just make up things you put in quotes? That’s not what those characters are meant for.

The “long, rambling blog post” outlines a number of pieces of evidence that say it’s highly unlikely there are meaningful differences, and because of population stratification, stuff like GWAS (that Hsu uses) can’t give us a lot of info. Look, if you have questions or doubts about these criticisms, you can ask and people will take those questions seriously. Ewan Birney is a world class geneticist that leads Europe’s leading institute on the subject. He’s writing a blog post for lay people to help them understand the complexities. What you wrote in response just shows how blinded you are in just discounting other arguments.

Look, I don’t know who you are; you can look me up (https://www.octant.bio/biosri).. but maybe when most experts in a field are saying one thing, and one person on the fringe is saying another... you at least owe it to yourself to understand the dominant viewpoint. It’s easy to find my email, or Ewan’s or many other researchers that take a lot of time answering questions. Quantitative genetics is complicated and in that blog post he’s trying to break down the major ways people get this stuff wrong; including Hsu. But in general, most on this site thus far have a viewpoint that is set in stone, hold their nose, and think an entire community is really stupid and politically correct. Anyways, if you are not a layperson I apologize and as a researcher, you can always just publish your findings, and the community and I can learn from them.

skosuri··on MSU Vice President of research & innovation Steve Hsu has been forced to resign
His genetics ideas are bad science. They are poorly thought out papers and overstate conclusions based on data that don’t properly account for the population and environmental effects. Hsu has been doing this for many many years. Then he goes around alt-right circles and acts like there is controversy; and starts companies offering embryo selection based on polygenic scores; again terrible science and he didn’t even state his conflict of interests on that. I disagree with all of those ideas and actions... and he still should be a professor. He just shouldn’t be a VP of research at MSU. He’s had several bad ethical lapses. The COI alone is grounds for firing... see the similar types of controversies surrounding the Harvard chemist who failed to disclose Chinese funding; that guy wasn’t even vp of research. Finally, all of this controversy makes it nearly impossible to do the work of vp of research effectively. He gets to go back now to maybe making his research and papers better (in a fully tenured job).
skosuri··on MSU Vice President of research & innovation Steve Hsu has been forced to resign
If you are actually sincere, take the time to read this: http://ewanbirney.com/2019/10/race-genetics-and-pseudoscienc...
skosuri··on MSU Vice President of research & innovation Steve Hsu has been forced to resign
Do you mean the hundreds of faculty at his university and the grad student union that called for his resignation from a position of power over them? Yeah, I think it’s reasonable. He’s still payed quite well and welcome to his crappy research ideas.
skosuri··on MSU Vice President of research & innovation Steve Hsu has been forced to resign
Disqualify him from being a professor? He’s still a tenured full professor with a nice salary. He’s just no longer in charge of all research at the university.
skosuri··on MSU Vice President of research & innovation Steve Hsu has been forced to resign
Amongst geneticists. If you want to learn more you can read here: http://ewanbirney.com/2019/10/race-genetics-and-pseudoscienc...
skosuri··on MSU Vice President of research & innovation Steve Hsu has been forced to resign
This is definitely the case of the dam finally bursting. For example, a famous geneticist who left said this: https://twitter.com/ctitusbrown/status/1271082397656735746?s...

I also have friends on the faculty. This is the dam bursting and should have happened a long time ago.

skosuri··on MSU Vice President of research & innovation Steve Hsu has been forced to resign
Nope. He has a very fringe view on the state of the science. His conclusions from his work have been widely considered wrong.
skosuri··on MSU Vice President of research & innovation Steve Hsu has been forced to resign
No. I’m faculty though and some of my best friends and colleagues are or were faculty there. I also research quantitative genetics. Been hearing the back story for years; many fear him and he threatened retaliation against some of my friends who were junior faculty.
skosuri··on MSU Vice President of research & innovation Steve Hsu has been forced to resign
He’s still a fully tenured professor at MSU; free to research whatever he wants.
skosuri··on MSU Vice President of research & innovation Steve Hsu has been forced to resign
Up until today? You have no idea what you are talking about. I have colleagues at the university that have been trying to have him removed for years; several have left in part because of him.
skosuri··on MSU Vice President of research & innovation Steve Hsu has been forced to resign
He’s a hack. Most people in quantitative genetics think he’s a hack. He’s still a fully tenured professor making a lot of money & free to choose his research agenda. It’s just that he shouldn’t be head of research and really amazing faculty have left at least in part because of him.
skosuri··on MSU Vice President of research & innovation Steve Hsu has been forced to resign
I am very glad this happened and this decision was very supported by the faculty of MSU. He is still a full professor at MSU making hundreds of thousands of dollars a year. He’s just no longer in charge of the research agenda. His own research on quantitative genetics is terrible and widely ridiculed. It’s great that he’s tenured and is allowed to have his poor scholarship justify his racist and sexist conclusions; but it doesn’t mean he gets to automatically lead a research agenda for a whole university.
skosuri··on Researchers and Founders
Being an academic researcher (kosurilab.org) and a founder (octant.bio), while I do think there are some similarities (working hard, etc), I think there are some really big differences too. Some of these might be more particular to academic research than research more broadly, but some quick thoughts:

1. Bias towards action & clear eyed => I think that's right, but there is another part of this too, that is more important as a founder – making decisions even under massive uncertainty. In a company, it's not just uncertain technical decisions, but also market decisions, cultural decisions, people decisions, etc. This is stomach churning, and most researchers can focus on the technical challenges in ways that founders can't. You have to do this in research decisions too; but as a founder it feels like it happens way, way more often with broader and broader sets of decisiosn.

2. One of the thing that I feel very different about founders is you have be honest about what the actual problems you have to solve are, and not turn your nose at the seemingly mundane and important tasks like managing a company. Great researchers are focused on their scientific problems over decades - founders are focused on building a lasting organization. These have pretty different consequences on what one chooses to spend their time on.

3. In academia at least, there are some really big differences in running a company versus running a lab. In a lab, my main mission is training people, while working on problems I find interesting... slowly moving towards my long-term scientific/technical goals. In a company, it's building a product that people will buy, and slowly moving towards those same goals. Again, this has pretty big consequences on what one spends their time doing and the types of problems you get to solve. There are positives and negatives to both approaches, some of which are quite subtle. For example, reputation games are far more important in academia than industry - I also find authority becomes a lot more pernicious in academia than industry. Anyways, lots here that are very different (but again this might be academia rather than research itself).

skosuri··on The US already has the technology to test millions of people a day
Hey all; wrote this with Feng Zhang, Jason Kelly, and Jay Shendure. The argument largely is already technology in place that will scale for mass screenings for bringing people back to work. To make it happen, we believe it will require separating clinical testing from mass screenings, allowing us to clear many of the logistical and regulatory barriers standing in the way.
skosuri··on A Third Solution
Oh, nvmd. I just saw you wanted a $1/run. Something ONT based perhaps.
skosuri··on A Third Solution
We've developed something NGS-based we call SwabSeq. You can find out more here: https://www.notion.so/Octant-SwabSeq-Testing-9eb80e793d7e463...

You can get to $1/sample; but need >1000 samples/run at least to get to that cost level. Could run 10k/day without automation; likely a lot more (100k-1MM) with automation.

skosuri··on CalTech wins $1.1B jury verdict in patent case against Apple, Broadcom
They do. Most universities also rely on other sources to supplement research including donations, endowment spending, ip, and even tuition.
skosuri··on Ebola Is Now Curable
To be fair, and when it comes to health and biology, Twitter >> HN. The comments on most bio-related posts here make me cringe.
skosuri··on Benefit of Microbiota Transfer Therapy on autism symptoms and gut microbiota
Scientific reports is a nature family journal somewhat akin to Plos One (very little importance review). It should set some warning lights on.
skosuri··on Five Corrections to The New York Times
To be clear, the link you posted is a discussion on the previous letter sent to a more general audience.
skosuri··on ReSeq: Repurposing HiSeq DNA Sequencers
Ooh. I got a HiSeq 2000 for a six pack of beer. Can’t wait to try to hack it!
skosuri··on UCLA asked faculty to consider declining to review for Elsevier journals
Honestly nothing really. It’s more that there are papers that I am often the best person to review them (because of particular expertise). I often just don’t pay attention to where it’s coming from.
skosuri··on UCLA asked faculty to consider declining to review for Elsevier journals
Email discussion started yesterday; amongst 20 or so faculty half a dozen agreed to not review. We'll probably discuss at the next faculty meeting or the holiday party that's about to start.
skosuri··on UCLA asked faculty to consider declining to review for Elsevier journals
Well I'm on the UCLA faculty and it's definitely being discussed pretty widely amongst my department.
← PreviousPage 2 of 9Next →