HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

skue

1,445 karma · joined February 28, 2011

submissionscomments
skue··on Why Microsoft Word must die
This is an interesting article and has generated some good discussion, but blaming Word for mixing style sheets and control codes seems off to me.

> Arguments raged internally: should it use control codes, or hierarchical style sheets? In the end, the decree went out: Word should implement both formatting paradigms. Even though they're fundamentally incompatible and you can get into a horrible mess by applying simple character formatting to a style-driven document, or vice versa. Word was in fact broken by design, from the outset -- and it only got worse from there.

Back in the 80s and early 90s, WordPerfect was the market leader - not MS Word. And WordPerfect 5.0 supported style sheets when it was released in the 80s, alongside the existing control codes that were already a core feature of WP.[1] Even after it supported WYSIWYG editing, WP still enabled users to Reveal Codes - essentially toggling from WYSIWYG to the underlying markup.

I'm not defending MS Word as a program - I hate it too. I wish WordPerfect or something better had won. But I don't see how Microsoft alone can be blamed for deciding to support both control codes and style sheets.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WordPerfect#Styles_and_style_li...

skue··on Why Microsoft Word must die
I'm disappointed to see that MS Word has become the default for publishers. Back in 1999 I authored a web programming book for O'Reilly. At the time, their technical folks would begrudgingly accept Word files, but they strongly preferred FrameMaker.[1] Some of that probably had to do with the propensity for large Word files to become corrupted, but it's also because FrameMaker helped authors generate documents with much cleaner styling than Word. It's a shame that Adobe let FrameMaker languish.

FrameMaker allowed you to do ad hoc formatting, but it was designed for a stylesheet approach. The difference is analogous to creating a web page and declaring styles inline (how most folks use Word) vs. using a stylesheet (how most folks used FrameMaker). It is possible to pop open a style inspector in Word and use that instead, but it feels like an afterthought.

Pages also has a style inspector, which is my favorite feature (despite the old-school NeXT-style drawer). For a reason that I can't easily articulate, using styles in Pages feels cleaner than Word and more like using FrameMaker. So if I have to create a large Word document I will typically do so in Pages, then export to Word.

[1] I believe O'Reilly also accepted alternative open source formats such as DocBook and LaTeX. And though these might be great formats, I could never find an editor that I could stand using for more than a few minutes -- let alone the months needed to write a book.

skue··on New US $100 bill to debut Tuesday
It absolutely makes sense for the Treasury to generate new bills with technology/features that stays ahead of counterfeiters.

But changing bills every several years can also produce unintended consequences. If new bills are constantly arriving while multiple generations of older bills remain in circulation, it's hard to know what exactly what we should be looking for with each bill.

For counterfeiters, the best time to start generating old bills is probably right after the introduction of new ones. I'd like to think the government took this into account…

skue··on GCHQ report on 'Mullenize' program to 'stain' anonymous electronic traffic
It baffles me that the Post and Guardian decided to release this on a Friday.
skue··on Why can a scam company raise $40 Million Series C + $76 Million Series B?
Why am I not surprised that the Series A VC is with Matrix? They seem to go out of their way to earn a bad reputation:

http://www.boston.com/business/technology/innoeco/2009/11/th...

(Far more details on TheFunded for those who are members.)

skue··on JSFuck – Write any JavaScript with 6 Characters: []()!+
> While funny looking, what is the ingenuity behind it?

Is there a requirement that HN articles be ingenious? It's a novelty, that's all. And sometimes that's enough.

skue··on List of Wall Street CEOs prosecuted for the financial crisis
It certainly didn't help that Eliot Spitzer's political career imploded months before the financial crisis hit. It's impossible to know what he might have done -- either as governor or in some investigatory/prosecutorial role after his term. But it's also hard to imagine him remaining on the sidelines on this issue if his own dumb hubris hadn't taken him out of the game.

Edit: if any of you have seen Enron: The Smartest Guys in the Room, the same filmmaker also made a documentary to explore Spitzer's downfall with regard to the financial crisis:

http://www.theguardian.com/world/2011/feb/27/eliot-spitzer-w...

skue··on NSA disguised itself as Google to spy, say reports
Here's a direct link to the NSA slide explaining the MITM attack (originally published by Fantastico in Brazil):

http://www.techdirt.com/articles/20130910/10470024468/flying...

skue··on NSA shares raw intelligence including Americans' data with Israel
Sadly, the largest American media sources are still ignoring the story almost a day later. I searched CNN, NBC News, and Fox News - nothing.

At least most of the tech news sites picked up the story.

skue··on New iPad browser from Opera
I know. You can tap on a button to reveal a button to show three more buttons to get some details. But there's a reason I didn't bother to mention that in my post: No one will ever do this.

Edit: changed 'click' to 'tap' (old habits die hard)

skue··on New iPad browser from Opera
This browser is a web security joke.

1. Unless you prefix URLs with http or https, you are relying on Opera and/or Google's algorithms to point you to the correct page. Some might say that's a feature, except...

2. You cannot see the URL of recommended pages before you select them or while you are browsing them.

3. There no indication whether you accessed a page via HTTP or HTTPS.

This browser teaches users to ignore security. It assumes that no one ever enters a typo, that Google's search results can never be gamed, and that any anti-phishing functionality they have included (one would hope) is fully up to date.

All the respect that I had for Opera as a company just vanished.

skue··on New iPad browser from Opera
That TechCrunch article includes this quote:

> Kleinhout also noted that the team looked at how to keep users safe without having them evaluate lots of icons in the browser’s URL bar (which Coast doesn’t have). Instead of having to know what HTTPS is and how certificates work, Coast puts a very clear safety warning on the screen when it recognizes that the user is trying to access an unsafe site.

I'm very curious to know how that works. I sure hope they don't simply show certificate errors but otherwise treat pages the same whether they are secure or not.

skue··on 0 to 60 in One Second: Fusing WebGL, CSS 3D and HTML
Recreating a logo is not the same as reusing a logo, especially when we are talking about music. What you are describing would be akin to recreating a song by using different sounds, instruments, algorithms, etc. In other words, a new performance or "cover." That's very different than reusing the original, unedited work wholesale.
skue··on Just Delete Me
I canceled my account a week ago, and it wasn't nearly that simple. They paid an agent almost an hour's wage to make it as difficult as possible to delete my account.

The agent kept asking me for personal data such as my birthdate and half the digits of my credit card number. I refused repeatedly (I never recall giving Skype my birthdate in the first place).

Eventually after 55 minutes of discussion, the agent agreed to delete my account if I could provide them 5 of my contacts, the amount of my last bill, and my contact email. Even though you have to be logged in to speak to an agent, and all of these things are fully visible on their website once you are logged in.

skue··on 0 to 60 in One Second: Fusing WebGL, CSS 3D and HTML
> I realized it would make a pretty neat demo just by itself, so I built that in too, to the dulcet tones of Selah Sue—whose last name I hope is not indicative.

The demo and technology are amazing, and he should be proud of his hard work. But I was a bit surprised by his appropriation of someone else's work to add a soundtrack. Why not try to reach out to the artist and ask permission first?

Now before you hit the downvote icon, here's a thought exercise: What do you think HN's reaction would be if a random musician used this web visualization in a music video without asking permission first? How often do we get irate about design theft, and why is doing the reverse in this case okay?

> The songs are used here entirely for educational purposes of course. Not that it matters, since they're all on YouTube anyway.

This is simply untrue. Although the blog entry has educational value, the music itself serves no purpose other than to provide a soundtrack. It's being used for entertainment value, and if the developer does professional web design and references this work on a resume or contract offerings, then it arguably serves a commercial marketing purpose as well.

And saying that the video is available elsewhere? That's again no different than appropriating images or artwork from elsewhere on the web and reusing them for other purposes.

It's good that he credited the music, and I'm glad he thought about reuse issues. But again, why not ask permission first? And if it can't be obtained, why not find a musician who needs the exposure and would be happy to have their music included?

skue··on Microsoft CEO Steve Ballmer to retire within 12 months
> Windows 7 and 8 were the first mobile OS that didn't completely rip off Apple

Is everyone here too young to remember Palm, Windows CE, Pocket PC, et al?

We need new terminology for describing the transition that occurred once we had pervasive smartphones with built-in app stores, because it's nonsensical to claim that "mobile" didn't exist before that.

skue··on Microsoft CEO Steve Ballmer to retire within 12 months
> He will be remembered for missing mobile.

Wait, what? That's like saying RIM missed mobile. Microsoft was doing mobile years before Apple or Google ever entered the market[1].

My guess is that Microsoft and Ballmer's real-world experience in mobile actually constrained their imaginations. Their failure to see how mobile could be reinvented was due more to hubris than naivete.

[1] https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/6/61/Windows_...

skue··on TextSecure: Forward secrecy for asynchronous messages
Mobile networking is imperfect. An app capable of waking in response to a push notification may still fail to create a network connection with the sender.
skue··on Tesla Gets Carried Away Hyping Crash Test Results, Has Hand Slapped By Feds
HN isn't just about software/engineering, it's also about entrepreneurship.

Tesla is a startup with cool technology. They're taking on a market where startups never succeed and are navigating significant challenges regarding new technology, consumer bias, competitors, regulatory issues, business model, press relations, and more. Some of us find it fascinating and enlightening to watch them take this journey.

Edit: Reworded.

skue··on Tesla Gets Carried Away Hyping Crash Test Results, Has Hand Slapped By Feds
It was easy to see that coming once the media story took off the way it did. But this just generates more coverage of Tesla's results.

I doubt that anyone at Tesla is feeling the least bit chastised. Musk is certainly not the type of person who is afraid to generate a little controversy.

skue··on US doesn't know what Snowden took, sources say
I genuinely wonder what other sysadmins working at/with the NSA think about Snowden.

His actions have probably made their jobs more difficult, but they also work with these same systems, have a sense of their scope, and know the extent to which internal controls are (apparently) more procedural than technical. I wonder how many secretly feel vindicated for some concern they have felt or expressed in the past.

skue··on US doesn't know what Snowden took, sources say
> Remember, there is a difference between not auditing access to their internal fileservers that they keep their PowerPoints on, and not auditing access to their wiretap data.

This will clearly be NSA's response -- whether it's true or not -- but Snowden didn't just take random PowerPoints and internal training docs. If I'm not mistaken, he also took copies of FISA court documents and other highly classified materials that were never intended to be shared among NSA staff.

I truly believe the lack of audits for these materials has destroyed NSA's credibility across the board:

1. We know that NSA hires/contracts incredibly smart and technically talented individuals who are experts at breaking into systems and avoiding detection.

2. The only way for NSA to provide reasonable controls in this environment is to create a culture of monitoring and accountability, and design all their systems from the ground up with auditing and security in mind.

3. But apparently they didn't do #2 (or never figured out how to enforce this for sysadmins), because Snowden repeatedly accessed restricted and highly classified material without an audit trail.

I don't see how they can credibly admit a Snowden sized failure but still ask us to trust them with our personal data.

skue··on US doesn't know what Snowden took, sources say
> Another [official] said that the NSA has a poor audit capability, which is frustrating efforts to complete a damage assessment.

Wow. The NSA spent untold billions building advanced tech to snoop others but never bothered to set up proper internal controls for their own systems?

Of course this also raises the question, how can they continue to insist that there are reasonable controls in place to prevent abuse when they can't even determine what Snowden accessed, after he collected thousands of documents over a span of years?

skue··on Cyberscare: Ex-NSA chief calls transparency groups, hackers next terrorists
Only on HN would you get a bunch of hackers going off on a tangent about the proper use of tl;dr right in the middle of a discussion about whether hackers and activists should be considered potential terrorists. :-)
skue··on Cyberscare: Ex-NSA chief calls transparency groups, hackers next terrorists
So Hayden is playing bad cop, while Alexander plays god cop?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6135833

skue··on Cyberscare: Ex-NSA chief calls transparency groups, hackers next terrorists
One wacko on Reddit and a few hyperbolic calls for protest hardly warrants a heavy handed response.

What about the constant over-reaction you hear from gun rights activists? You hear far louder and more violent statements directly from national TV pundits anytime the topic of gun reform comes up.

I don't understand why as a country we are okay with heavily armed, self-appointed militias spouting paranoid delusions about "the Feds," but somehow challenging the NSA in discussions on Internet forums is being considered dangerously close to terrorism.

skue··on Ask HN: I'm a chronic procrastinator – how do I break it?
Before I went to med school, I was similarly skeptical about the med/pharma industry. But like the global warming debate, once you understand the science, you begin to realize how facile the conspiracy theories are.

Here's the science behind ADHD: Functional MRI allows us to image actual brain activity. And there are clear differences between the brains of those diagnosed with ADHD and those diagnosed without (and yes, they do these studies blind, so researchers can't be biased).

And more recently they have found that stimulants such as methylphenidate (aka Ritalin) and others actually reverse these changes. Here is a recent study, plus a metareview (which compared several such studies):

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23247506 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23660970

Of course, we could still have an interesting philosophical discussion about what we label a medical condition and what are variations of normal that nevertheless have a biological basis. Clearly, ADHD is not on par with debilitating psychiatric conditions such as schizophrenia or a bipolar manic episode.

But ADHD can cause functional impairment in school, jobs, and personal relationships; it can lead to decreased happiness and satisfaction in life (and not only for the person affected, but also their families, partners, and colleagues); there are clear neurophysiological differences underlying it; and we have treatments that can make an important difference. So why not use them?

And as for the big drug companies? Most of the ADHD drugs are generic these days, so they don't profit.

skue··on Ask HN: I'm a chronic procrastinator – how do I break it?
The meds are not magical at all: they just help you be less distracted.

If you have been procrastinating for years and have a regular routine and numerous personal habits built around procrastination, those don't go away when you take a pill. All the meds do is make you more present, which would understandably make you more conscious of those routines and habits. That might not be fun -- but it is the first step in changing the habits.

Have you talked to anyone besides the school psych? If it is ADHD (and sorry to hear they half-assed your assessment), then meds are only part of the solution. Regular exercise, a more structured routine, eliminating distractions, finding a partner who supports you, etc. are also important.

You can learn more on your own via books or trial-and-error, or by finding a clinician who can be like a coach to help you figure out what works best for you. The book I listed above talks about all the non-med things you could be doing: one of the authors has ADHD but doesn't find meds helpful for him, so he uses a number of lifestyle changes and natural alternatives instead. Also, the authors have a specialized clinic outside of Boston, and there are other centers like this around, with people far more competent than the school psych who can spend the time to help figure this out.

skue··on Ask HN: I'm a chronic procrastinator – how do I break it?
It depends on the degree. I think the more compelling factors for the OP are that (a) this has been going on for years, (b) he has a very strong feeling that this is holding him back, and (c) his dad is the same way.

It's possible that he's so incredibly smart that he finds many things boring, and that's not ADHD. ADHD tends to lead to a lot of disorganization (across different settings: home, work, school), plus attempts at compensation (self-medication, self-stimulation, etc.)

But just to be clear: This is a random list, it's not meant to be diagnostic. If these resonate with the OP or someone similar then it might be worth learning more about ADHD and talking with a professional. Please don't assume you have ADHD just because these things hold true.

skue··on Ask HN: I'm a chronic procrastinator – how do I break it?
The fact that this has been going on for years, and that you feel the procrastination is holding you back from your full potential does sound like it could be ADHD, as others have mentioned. Also, ADHD tends to run in families. So if your dad is the same way...

Most people associate ADHD with kids who struggle in school. But highly intelligent people can have it too. It still holds them back from reaching their potential, it's just that their potential is much greater.

Here are some things to ask yourself:

* Do you also procrastinate non-work things such as buying gifts, paying bills, calling people back?

* What is your home like: Do you have a lot of half-finished projects, "piles", or chores that never get finished?

* Are you always running late because you are busy doing other things, or underestimate what you need to do to get out the door and get to your destination?

* Do people tell you that you frequently interrupt others when they are talking?

* Would you describe yourself as a risk taker and more prone to high adrenaline activities? How the friends you keep?

* Are you only able to focus with the help of caffeine, guarana (eg, Vitamin Water Energy), or other energy drinks?

* Do you use nicotine to relax or be more focused? (If so, please stop and see a doctor.)

* Do you use alcohol, not to get drunk or for the drink itself, but as a way to unwind or slow down at the end of the day?

This is a good book: http://www.amazon.com/Driven-Distraction-Revised-Recognizing..., which reminds me of another question:

* Do you buy/start a lot of books, but rarely seem to finish them?

Read enough of the book to see if this resonates with you. If it does, the next step would be to talk to (a) your doctor if you have one, or (b) find a psychiatrist in your area who specializes in ADHD. The book can help you find resources.

Edit: Just to be clear, this list is NOT meant to be diagnostic. Although I happen to have an MD, I am NOT a practicing physician no one should assume they have ADHD based on any list like this. I would only say that if many of these things hold overwhelmingly true for the OP, then it might be worth learning more about ADHD and finding a professional to begin a conversation.

Yes, ADHD and meds sparks a lot of cynicism in some people. However, one reason I recommended that book is that the authors present a balanced approach to meds. One of the authors has ADHD, but doesn't find that meds make much of a difference for him (they reportedly are ineffective for 25% of adults with ADHD). But they have helped many of his patients and his own son.

← PreviousPage 8 of 12Next →