HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

skue

1,445 karma · joined February 28, 2011

submissionscomments
skue··on Heart Surgery in India for $1,583 Costs $106,385 in U.S.
The next phase, going from validated new procedure/approach to broader adoption, has its own ethical issues. During my medical training I scrubbed into three surgeries that should have been routine, but where an experienced surgeon decided to try a new approach that he had heard about. All three cases went wrong, and one was near-fatal. Fortunately, there were no long term consequences.

Learning new techniques in a field that requires hands on training with real patients who are entrusting their lives to the experience of the surgeon is a constant balancing act. It's the same with training new surgical residents -- which Atul Gawande also discusses in one of his earlier books, Complications.

skue··on Hacker News Folks Get Long Overdue Thanks
Absolutely. It's called lead time bias, and there's a great illustration on Wikipedia:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lead_time_bias

Gil Welch at Dartmouth is one of the experts in unnecessary medical screening and lead time bias. He's written numerous academic and media articles, especially regarding lung, breast, and prostate cancer screening. Also an amazing public speaker:

http://tdi.dartmouth.edu/faculty/h-gilbert-welch-md-mph

skue··on Ask HN: How do you apply for a tech job?
> "Excellent question!" to any experienced interviewer means...

That's an very broad statement.

This phrase can come across as gratuitous or stalling, but it really depends on how you phrase it, the enthusiasm you project, and whether you use it sparingly and appropriately.

skue··on The SEC Just Voted To Lift The Ban On General Solicitation
> If you look at the way YC demo day works, its a pretty reasonable way for potential investors to find startups which are compatible with their investment goals. I think it addresses the challenge of the general solicitation rule...

Sure, YC demo day addresses this problem, but there are many startups out there who will never attend YC. And because these startups still need validation and a network, this has fueled an accelerator bubble as more and more accelerators throw open their doors.

I don't believe having all these accelerators is a good thing. Many are run by folks who have very little experience, and in some cases they offer little value other than a demo day stage.

So although I'm also unsure whether this rule change is good public policy, I do hope it helps pop the accelerator bubble and forces the remaining accelerators to focus more on building value and less on playing matchmaker.

skue··on YouCompleteMe - A code-completion engine for Vim
I already have the latest version of cmake installed via homebrew.

The problem appeared to be that YCM's install.sh script goes out of its way to determine the active version of python and link against its libraries[1].

For anyone with python installed via homebrew, that means it links to 2.7.3. Unfortunately, both MacVim and the homebrew version of vim link against the system python (2.7.2). As a result, loading YCM triggers an error resolving urandom and crashes vim.

[1] https://github.com/Valloric/YouCompleteMe/blob/master/instal...

skue··on YouCompleteMe - A code-completion engine for Vim
Thanks, that's good to know. I have been using XVim for a while now. It can be quirky, but it's amazing what JugglerShu has been able to pull off.

Have you used both Xvim and ViEmu? How does ViEmu compare?

skue··on YouCompleteMe - A code-completion engine for Vim
Ditto. Here was my "super-quick installation" experience on OS X:

1. Read through the full page of installation instructions.

2. Update to latest version of MacVim.

3. Go research Vundle because up until now, I've been happily using Pathogen. Install Vundle.

4. Update vimrc file for Vundle, add YCM.

5. Launch vim, note error saying YCM needs installation.

6. Run :BundleInstall, which tells me I should compile and impolitely adding "Read the docs!" (Which docs? The GitHub docs, which tell me I should only need to recompile in rare cases? Or the bundle's vim docs, which didn't exist on my system prior to running this command?)

7. Back to terminal, launch ./install.sh --clang-completer in the YCM directory.

8. Go fix breakfast, return. Compilation eventually completes, no errors.

9. Launch vim, which immediately crashes with error: Vim: Caught deadly signal ABRT

10. Give up and delete any trace of YCM.

In a perfect world maybe I would have an extra hour or two to debug this, run through some regressions but right now I don't. Sounds like a nice plugin, maybe I'll try again in the future.

skue··on A Disease Without a Cure Spreads Quietly in the West
In med school I learned about a mailing list primarily for infectious disease specialists tracking potential outbreaks worldwide. After a few months I stopped reading it -- it was too terrifying.

Update: It was probably ProMED-mail[1]. The WHO also posts disease a outbreak news[2].

[1] http://www.promedmail.org/

[2] http://www.who.int/csr/don/en/index.html

skue··on The state of democratic control over surveillance in France
Please stop calling it "offensive" when people have a strong reaction your views.
skue··on The state of democratic control over surveillance in France
When you're young, it's easy to have a knee-jerk reaction to authority. But go spend any significant time in a developing nation that lacks basic infrastructure, get close to the people living there, learn about their struggles and their dreams, and then come back and tell me that the solution is to abolish government.
skue··on I'd like to invest my time in your startup
Instead of thinking of it as an ongoing subscription model, it could be structured as equity in lieu of cash for whatever services are rendered. Lawyers and advisors will sometimes do this.

This should be reviewed with a lawyer, because I believe it adds tax/accounting complexity for both sides (but maybe not in UK?). Also, if we're talking common stock, this would force an early startup to balance keeping their share price low and thus paying a lot more stock for the value provided, or raising the share price (possibly too high, too soon) in order to pay less.

Edit: Saw your reply to the OP, below. I do agree that an experienced, rational entrepreneur would likely steer clear of any arrangement like this, to have a clean cap table and to avoid dilution. But of course "the right way" to do things changes over time, and there is a real shortage of technical talent. So I don't think it's crazy to see something like this become a trend.

skue··on I'd like to invest my time in your startup
You're 5 hours ahead of the east coast, 8 hours ahead of the west coast. Being available 1-6/7pm for the east coast seems fine.

And as others have said - it's a great idea, especially given the shortage of technical talent. The biggest challenge I could see would be whether you can provide enough hours (value) for each startup, while simultaneously working with enough startups to give you the multiple pies you mentioned, and all this on top of a full time job. In any case good luck, and let us know how it goes!

skue··on Motorola cell phones are regularly phoning home
Not true. The article has been updated to clarify that this model does not use the MotoBlur interface. Apparently the code is still there, and still active.
skue··on Motorola cell phones are regularly phoning home
The article has been updated to point out that this model does not use to MotoBlur interface. Apparently having (what looked like) a mostly stock Android interface was an important buying consideration.
skue··on The Rise Of The Million Dollar, One-Person Business
Interesting breakdown, though the title is a bit misleading. The numbers do show a 5% annual increase in single person companies making $1MM+ in 2011, but it's difficult to know whether that reflects a true rise without comparing against historical data.
skue··on NSA slides explain the PRISM data-collection program
I'm sorry this has devolved into a back and forth. I was trying to offer the perspective of someone who believes passionately about this issue and is looking for ways to get more active, but who cannot get excited about these protests in my area. I do hope there are bigger protests in other cities and they make some impact.

I believe we are both frustrated that more is not happening, and unfortunately that frustration is being directed at each other instead of the real issue. I do applaud your enthusiasm and stepping forward to help advertise this.

skue··on NSA slides explain the PRISM data-collection program
No, the predicted attendance is low because no one has heard about this.

Only organizing among Redditors, not bothering to reach out to people with more experience organizing protests, and not partnering with affiliated organizations (Tea Party, Occupy, various student groups) who might all come together to rally around this is why predicted attendance is so low.

Update: Added first sentence to emphasize point.

skue··on NSA slides explain the PRISM data-collection program
These protests have not been well organized. From the outside it looks like a handful of Redditors who are thinking of hanging out together - and there seems to have been no PR or outreach to folks beyond Reddit. Most of the nation does not use Reddit.

My page for my New England city has nothing except a link to a conversation with half a dozen folks planning a preliminary meeting, with no follow up info posted. I could drive to Boston, but what's the point: the Boston group is only predicting an attendance of 40. I doubt it will get media coverage, and at that size I honestly hope it doesn't.

skue··on Productizing A Freelancing / Consulting Business
I disagree that it's off topic. Patrick's email/article gave an example of how easy and valuable it can be to automate something within a doctor's office, then added this:

"Many things are easy for software companies in a way that they just aren't for non-software companies... doctor's offices don't think of APIs for the same reason that developers think that free soda is a wonderful thing to treat your employees to."

I read that as encouraging developers to look at doctor offices as a valuable market without warning them about the importance of HIPAA/HITECH compliance. And I believe that can get folks into trouble if they aren't careful.

Perhaps I should have simply phrased it that way instead. Thanks for the feedback. I deleted my prior message and I'll email Patrick with my concern.

skue··on Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs to links
That is an excellent point about micropayments. Creating a system that pays sites without a middleman that tracks visits would be challenging (though I imagine it's technically feasible).
skue··on Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs to links
Sure, I was always intrigued by the micro payments idea. Heck, if that we're the norm I wonder if it wouldn't promote better web content. I'd be more likely to spend more time on sites I wanted to support than the sensational sites I may feel guilty about having clicked through to.

But I don't think most folks think this way, so practically speaking I don't see micropayments ever working. Would love to be proven wrong.

skue··on Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs to links
You mention the privacy implications of "Like" buttons but neglect to mention the privacy implications of the ad networks.

Remember when Double Click started building a database of every Internet user and their preferences (and were foolish enough to mention it publicly)? Your employer now owns that database.

skue··on Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs to links
Not all of us block ads because they are annoying to look at. They are also a very real threat to privacy because ad companies track us across multiple websites (yes, I block Google Analytics and other trackers as well).

OTOH, I also feel tremendous sympathy towards websites trying to survive on ad revenue. I'm actually the type of person who still buys music to support artists.

I don't know what the solution is. We are forced to choose between being watched as we browse the web, staying completely offline, or blocking ads but not supporting the websites we visit.

skue··on The New Mac Pro
Wait, Guy English is very ignorant and doesn't know what he is talking about? That's a hilariously ironic comment.
skue··on Live: Head of NSA meets with House Intelligence Committee
And THIS is the ultimate answer to the question: If I have nothing to hide, why should this bother me?

It's not whether each of us individually have something to hide: it's whether our politicians, our activists, our reporters, our lawyers, our doctors, our military, our police, our courts, our spies, our business leaders, our celebrities, our friends & family have something to hide.

Because if any of them can be manipulated by the data that is being gathered, then all of us lose.

skue··on Estimated Cost to Store All US Phone Calls Made in a Year
OTOH, the estimated bytes per call truly is conservative. The 8KB/s estimate is based on G.711, and using G.726 or G.729 would yield a 2-8x reduction in storage. So this is definitely within an order of magnitude: even if the minutes of talk time are off by a factor of 10, you could offset most of that with better codecs.

(Credit: commenter petrilli on Schneier's recent post about this.)

skue··on Choosing Hong Kong Is a Brilliant Move by Edward Snowden
There is another big reason why Snowden may have chosen HK. A few months ago the HK high court ruled that the process for applying for asylum needs overhaul, and until that happens all extradition proceedings for asylum seekers are on hold. So Snowden simply needs to apply for asylum in HK to significantly delay things:

http://www.globalpost.com/dispatch/news/regions/asia-pacific...

I haven't seen much coverage of this in the US press, aside from Slate & CSM. The rest of the media seems more interested in Snowden's girlfriend and scholastic record instead (sigh).

skue··on Encrypted e-mail: How much annoyance will you tolerate to keep the NSA away?
> Quantum computers do not allow you to break all public key cryptography, they only allow you to break the common forms in use today.

True, but it's the public key cryptography in use today that I'm concerned with!

skue··on Encrypted e-mail: How much annoyance will you tolerate to keep the NSA away?
He was referring to the possibility that the NSA can already crack the underlying encryption algorithms via quantum computing, etc. If that's the case, being open source and correctly implementing the encryption algorithms is moot.
skue··on The day Steve Jobs dissed me in a keynote (2010)
There's a great expression that is especially useful when dealing with big companies: "Never ascribe to malice that which is adequately described by incompetency." [1]

While it's tempting to think that Jobs was pulling all the strings, the reality is that Apple is a large company where legal departments take forever, internal debate occur, and communication is slow.

It sucks that Jobs made that $40 statement without someone vetting (or caring) that they were negotiating with CDBaby and that's their price. It sucks that Apple did not communicate better about the reason for the delay. But doing enterprise deals is nothing like working with an individual, and in that context I wouldn't simply assume that Apple/Jobs was being spiteful.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hanlon's_razor

← PreviousPage 9 of 12Next →