HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

slownews45

2,904 karma · joined May 14, 2021

submissionscomments
slownews45··on Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will investigate
Then don't drive with other drivers - NON-autopilot drivers eating, texting (constantly!), seeming to look up directions and much more (falling asleep).

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cs0iwz3NEC0&t=2s

The fact that you promote this absolute recklessness and demand users turn off safety features that may, net net save lives is depressing.

Finally, folks get very confused between things like autopilot and other features (autosteer beta with FSD visualization) etc. I think some teslas now even show a message warning that cruise control will not brake in some cases? Anyone have that.

I've been following the unintended acceleration claims around tesla's as well. Most seem pretty bogus.

For what its worth here is data we currently have from Tesla:

"In the 2nd quarter, we recorded one crash for every 4.41 million miles driven in which drivers were using Autopilot technology (Autosteer and active safety features). For drivers who were not using Autopilot technology (no Autosteer and active safety features), we recorded one crash for every 1.2 million miles driven. By comparison, NHTSA’s most recent data shows that in the United States there is an automobile crash every 484,000 miles."

So you want to go to a 10x increase in crashes. (1 per 484 vs 1 per 4M). I realize this is nt one to one, but even outside of this we are seeing maybe a 2x improvement (if your normalize for road conditions etc).

Nission Maxima had something like 68 deaths per million registered vehicle years. Will be interesting to see how this comes out for Teslas.

slownews45··on Architect Resigns in Protest over UCSB Mega-Dorm
What does a building with 10 emergency exists, lots of individually lockable suites and rooms have to do with guns?

Santa Barbara has strict anti-gun laws already. CA has a lot of anti-gun laws already. The UCSB system has anti gun laws already.

Santa Barbara issues something like 50 permits a DECADE for concealed carry. It's a "may" issue jurisdiction, and they don't issue.

And if metal detectors are implemented, I'm not sure students will care. They already exist for large sporting events and other areas of concern, so if there was a concern you'd want fewer main entrances so you could staff them.

Bigger issue is normally non-students in student housing, so security can be good in terms of setup. This means the newer buildings often do things like keycard access to suites only for suite holders, and some even do keycards for your room separate from suite, again, all logged and tracked. I visited a friend at a school where I had to sign in my car with a guard, had to be escorted to their room by a front desk staffer etc. That's extreme - no way UC is going that (this was a small elite place).

The major student issues in terms of safety are stranger access to dorms / bathrooms at night, theft issues (bikes / bags etc), and nuisance issues (noise, weed smoke, parties etc).

slownews45··on Meta
One big difference - a lot of these billionaires are willing to try out ideas and ignore folks who say they won't work.

If you try out a few ideas, some will pan out.

And brain implants are certainly coming. Parkinsons and other diseases are already being treated with them.

slownews45··on Architect Resigns in Protest over UCSB Mega-Dorm
Sure.

One issue is that for tall buildings a fair bit of thought goes into things like aerodynamics of overall building, ventilation / HVAC control, and internal pressures.

A tall building has an issue with its core / utilities usually, the taller the go generally the worse the ratio of non-livable space to livable. So things that mess with for example HVAC efficiency may be seen as a negative.

If everyone opens a window on one side of a building, over building surface areas and wind speeds at heights, you can get pretty crazy pressure issues. You can also get aero issues. You an also run into HVAC issues (ie, volume of air from 3 open large windows on the 40th floor may overwhelm HVAC system capacity).

Let me ask you, you are building a skyscraper to rent.

If you allow folks to open their windows and the wind blows something out that kills someone on the street - who will be sued? If someone drops something out (trying to put a plant in window or stick a telescope out) and kills someone - who pays. If someone falls out that window, who will be sued (see a cruise line that had a stupid idiot hold a kid through the window and drop them).

Other issues are around maintenance and weather proofing etc etc. Again, environment at height can often be harsh, and now you may have to have someone on side of building to replace a window or related mechanisms. Easy in a house at ground level, a pain at height.

BTW - I like windows that open and would NOT live in a tall res condo. My key point was that all the folks talking about how window exists are required - it's so weird seeing people speak with such certainty on something so easily disprovable.

I think up to 30 floors or so and older places it was common for windows to open (they were also built differently, more open space / daylighting / shallower footprints (ie, H shape buildings vs full block buildings).

slownews45··on Architect Resigns in Protest over UCSB Mega-Dorm
This building is being built in an area with some of the STRICTEST fire codes in America - just in case folks reading get the wrong idea. In fact, condo skyscrappers are in my view much more risky (the time to exit a 50 foot skyscrapper can be very long).

Compounding this, historic building in CA was sometimes very poor by modern standards (all wood tinder boxes). So this may very well be a major upgrade in safety over existing housing stock.

slownews45··on Architect Resigns in Protest over UCSB Mega-Dorm
Multi unit buildings are REGULARLY build with ZERO window exits.

This idea that a 60 floor skyscraper is going to do opening window "exits" over 300 foot drops is insanity and disgusting.

Please look up condominium skyscrapers before talking about window exists being required from a housing code standpoint.

slownews45··on Architect Resigns in Protest over UCSB Mega-Dorm
Do you understand how how housing selection works ?

There is zero requirement to live in their housing. So what the hell are you going to sue them over?

There is a shortage of on-campus housing - do you understand that? That is what this project is trying to solve for in part.

If you live off campus - go for it! In fact, even if you WANT to live on campus you'll have to enter a lottery after year 1, they only usually can prioritize first year students. So trust me, if you don't like this housing, no one is going to make you pay for it, and they'll be happy to have you out.

This type of housing really works for folks who like working with others, getting along with others, making friends. And as someone who didn't get a single until senior year, being able to get it on without having folks walking through or in room will be seen as a MAJOR positive by students.

slownews45··on Architect Resigns in Protest over UCSB Mega-Dorm
I'm curious - reading this makes me depressed at how stupid HN and reactionary HN seems to have become.

Do people not realize that in California we build residential buildings that are MANY MANY stories tall.

The LACK of operable windows in a bedroom is generally a REQUIREMENT on a skyscraper / residential condo tower for safety reasons. They worry about kids falling out etc.

The safety plans involve other measures - including much better building codes around fire control (ie, sprinklers). Fire hardened emergency exists (ie, these students may be moving out of historic all wood tinderboxes if my old CA school is any indication).

slownews45··on Architect Resigns in Protest over UCSB Mega-Dorm
You are not a student at this school.

Where I went to school we got lots of strong opinions from outsiders. But some of the "worst" dorms were the most popular for reasons that are not always obvious to outsiders.

And yes, some students like to live close to others. UCSB may be doing double and triple bunking in rooms (my school did 4 to a room for a while, when the "crappy" new space opened it was first choice in the housing lottery).

Folks talking about sharing a bathroom meaning that people will be pooping out of windows are idiots who either went to some elite school where you are waited on by butlers. It would not be uncommon for a hall with 15 rooms to have two bathrooms.

Other things that offended folks that students gave no craps about. We had some coed bathrooms, was never an issue. I'm sure now they are called gender neutral.

slownews45··on Architect Resigns in Protest over UCSB Mega-Dorm
To be crystal clear, at least in California on-campus housing is generally where students want to live.

With berkeley on campus housing can rely on FA awards, much more flexible in terms of reasons to cancel (ie, you withdraw from school), big issue with group leases off campus when one person flakes.

What's interesting is that there is a view that we can't try out things like this in the US. There are so many critics, and so few doers.

Be worth seeing what students think of the housing. I realize that may not align with some of the NIMBYs and critics, but ultimately they should have voice as stakeholders.

And why not try something out?

For those not familiar, there is a big shortage of on campus housing, many schools are waiving requirements to live on campus in year 1

slownews45··on Cryptocurrency loan platform implodes in $130M hack
Actually, if you were familiar with how these things work, the attack was pretty carefully worked out. That said, since all this code was copycat crap by folks who didn't really understand it - not surprised. In other words, the code really was fine - the folks running the pool were just clueless in terms of what they let trade (ie, not suited to code).
slownews45··on IPv6 Progress Top Sites 2021
The latency comes because it seems services fall back to a server reroute for a media stream for example if you have a double nat situation they can't get through to route directly. It's not the NAT, its the approaches used to work around the NAT. This hits particularly hard with IPv6 (ie, the fallback will be a server that does next leg IPv4 if needed).

We hear that IPv6 has more IPs than people. Great. It should be easier, not harder, to get a block of these IPs.

ISPs don't want to hand out static blocks.

Static RIR allocations also poor and in some ways harder than it was to get IPv4 allocations early on (Have 13 end sites (offices, data centers, etc.) within one year or 2000 devices etc) or go to IPv6 multi-homing.

The limiting factor in some of this is not IP address quantity but routing complexity - I understand why they may want to limit things from that side, but it limits the utility of the space.

And all of it is harder to configure and operate for most folks. Sure, Google was maybe all in on IPv6 for google cloud from the start, but they have crazy money - and even for them I'm sure it was a pain and a big lift to offer that as a service to their GCP customers 15 years ago.

For the average person -> it's still not that good.

Note: I'm kidding about google and their rockstars delivering IPv6 early on. It was as painful for them with all their experts as everyone else - which tells you something.

One clear pain point, ISPs not giving out static IP's (v6). So what's point of huge space?

Att IPv4 info

https://www.att.com/support/article/u-verse-high-speed-inter...

Comcast Static is $25/month for 5 (business connection)

etc

slownews45··on IPv6 Progress Top Sites 2021
I am asking, under IPv4 I can trivially get a static block of IPs.

I can then trivially

* put some devices on a VLAN (ie, a VOIP phone) and it will have a public IP, globally routable.

This works well in my experience, latency is super annoying on VoIP and for some reason behind a NAT sometimes it seems to route media through a third party server!

For a small business you can put a PBX on the VLAN and folks can remote register to it trivially (ie, phone.companyZ.com) - with COVID this is great.

You can VPN terminate more easily with a static ip block.

At home I can do a game server on the static IP block or I can host some of the simultaneous music composition stuff (trivially).

My question is simple - how do I get a static IPv6 block so I can do all this if I want to on IPv6.

I get IPv4 is outdated, but how do I do some of this stuff in the fancy IPv6?

You are telling me IPv6 means I don't need any public static IPs and can use some private IPv6 space (10.x was already plenty for that for me in ipv4) with a dynamic public IPv6.

Fine, how does this work. Seriously, what VPN endpoint am I configuring? How does my VOIP / SIP play with this? Do I need to go back to poking weird holes in a NAT? My OWN experience was this all doesn't play well together. Firewalls seem not to play well with dynamic prefixes - and that's just the start. Devices pick up the wrong IP's internally (SIP etc).

In short - 20 years into this, when I try to do something simple -> stick my VoIP phone on a static public IP and VLAN -> its a total pain.

At a small biz, if I try and put a PBX on a static public IPv6 - it's a total pain (and BTW - the SIP IPv6 support in most hardware and softphones is terrible).

This should be the winning use case. Phone calls / person to person audio would benefit TREMENDOUSLY from direct peering connections without any NAT!

But despite an insane number if IPv6 addresses at least in the US they won't assign you a block of even 20.

slownews45··on IPv6 Progress Top Sites 2021
Awesome! I'm in the US.

I gave up on some SIP/VOIP stuff because this (and other protocols) generate lag etc when you are going device > NAT > server > NAT > device route, vs device to device.

I just need ONE prefix, but a group of 5 or 8 would be amazing (then you could use the default IPv6 scheme for addressing things).

Maybe there is hope, the US lags in some of this a fair bit. There should be enough space it would seem.

slownews45··on IPv6 Progress Top Sites 2021
I tried this. It doesn't work. First, which ISPs give you the static IPv6 blocks? Its pretty easy (for $10/month) to get a block of IPv4, but I had a hard time getting anyone to find any free IPv6 addresses (oddly).
slownews45··on IPv6 Progress Top Sites 2021
How did you get your ISP to give you a static IP block or prefix? I can get an IPv4 block, but despite the yelling of the IPv6 fanatics regarding how many IPv6 addresses are available, I can't get anyone to allocate me even 20 or so (much less a prefix!).

Is there something in the spec that makes this hard to do. It's been 20 years.

slownews45··on IPv6 Progress Top Sites 2021
My current setup is comcast and att to the net. Internally I've got a DHCP server, with reservations for key equipment (ie do a certificate issuance for these as well) - think proxmox / esxi web interfaces). A few items x.x.x.20 and less static IP (ie, gateway etc).

This system works great. Comcast down? No worries, failover to ATT (and visa versa). Everything works through the NAT, failover is seamless.

I've spent a bit of time naively trying to get ipv6 to work as smoothly. The way IPv6 addresses are handed out, auto-change, are typed etc. It's just no where near as smooth.

We needed IPv5 - I basic extension to address range - that's it. Just add another 0-255 at the beginning or end of things and be done.

My other complaint. Desite supposedly having more ipv6 addresses, my ISP WILL NOT give me a static block / prefix etc.

In other words, there are enough IPv4 addresses that I can get a block of 5 static IPv4 addresses, but CANNOT pay for a static IPv6 block. What's the limit / issue with giving me a static IP prefix if I'm willing to pay? Seriously...

I feel like proponents of Ipv6 have not actually tried to use it at the consumer / prosumer / small business level.

slownews45··on Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf]
Quick summary.

Revenue up 41%!! Incredible for an already very large company.

Op Margin also up to 32%?

When you realize how hard walmart and friends works for every point of margin and growth - these guys are literally printing millions.

slownews45··on Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf]
Umm, intel flatlined basically on chip development. Chip shortages also hit the sector. And the long tail has gotten to point where folks keep systems in workloads even if "better" solutions exist - because existing systems are working fine. 4 years is not unreasonable (now). Once chip shortages ease and development picks up again at intel useful life may decrease again.
slownews45··on Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf]
Don't advertise that way if you don't want to? I'm failing to see what the issue is. If you don't mind and advertiser saying, hey, look at me instead, then don't pay google to advertise.
slownews45··on Facebook Reports Third Quarter 2021 Results
right - and it assumes that a company like apple has given no thought to what might sell in the market when they come out with things like the "wildly overpriced" airpods.

Yes, when they came out, they cost a LOT more than the competitors (I used Jabra). But wow, did they WORK well. It was no comparison really and was a lot of little things (just fewer bugs I think rather than features, they ALWAYS paired with my phone, pretty quickly, and had good battery life).

For a lot of consumers, they don't care about features, they just trust apple more than they would for example govt run email or govt made phones.

slownews45··on Facebook Reports Third Quarter 2021 Results
Instagram and whatsapp have to be growing.

Facebook itself? I think its dying personally.

slownews45··on Facebook Reports Third Quarter 2021 Results
Is govt doing a good job with this stuff off of facebook? I know plenty of folks who really had trouble getting even govt action on all sorts of harm (revenge porn / various internet scams).

I really hope at least govt can deliver on this stuff reliably - the risk is folks will lose faith in govt rather than these big companies (google / apple / whatsapp / instagram etc).

slownews45··on Facebook Reports Third Quarter 2021 Results
Or iphone/apple have "sealed their fate" by not doing something like the headphone jack or a replaceable battery or whatever.
slownews45··on Jury hands victory to Facebook and Oculus VR founder in Rift ownership trial
I guess my question - given this lawsuit is so "boring" why do places like forbes go big into covering it early (facebook evil) but then when it is exposed as a sham, don't cover that outcome.

https://news.bloomberglaw.com/ip-law/ex-facebook-vr-founder-...

https://www.forbes.com/sites/joeparlock/2020/06/16/lawsuit-a...

They literally have tech journalists in courtroom for the outcome. But if it's not anti-facebook no coverage.

It is a bit weird.

slownews45··on Leaded fuel reduced IQ of children born before 1990
Exactly. The idea that you can't make an engine that runs on unleaded is rediculous. Airliners for example don't use leaded.

Yes, planes 50 years ago -> maybe those were designed for leaded. But the idea that we are selling new planes, today, that "only" run on leaded gas is a farce and goes to show how seriously aviation is taking the transition away from leaded gas (which has been delayed as I've said decades).

At some point you just lose patience.

slownews45··on Facebook documents offer a treasure trove for Washington’s antitrust war
This is so weird as a support for the FTC complaint.

My own read. Facebook is fighting for - and likely losing - the attention of younger users.

Tiktok and others are doing relatively well.

This is the problem with these networks, they become your parents network. Myspace gone, friendster gone.

The FTC claims of monopoly are laughable?

Tiktok seems to be crushing Facebook in downloads and in time in app, and now I heard was even crushing youtube (all of these folks are competing, youtube has youtube community and patreon style features now with chat etc as well).

is facebook huge? For sure. Is it a monopoly? Have folks not heard of things like tiktok.

Will be interesting if China goes after tiktok the way the US is going after facebook.

slownews45··on Eliminating gifted programs won’t make education fair
One positive of some of these programs might be that it's OK to be "nerdy" there or a "try hard". If you search for school fights on youtube it's kind of eye opening if you went to a try hard type program or school.
slownews45··on Eliminating gifted programs won’t make education fair
I think IQ testing is prohibited at least in California for African American's? Is this true? Does this extend to things like admissions exams for gifted programs?
slownews45··on Leaded fuel reduced IQ of children born before 1990
If the tax was substantial I'd support this.

Graduated approach ignores the decades that have ALREADY been provided as an exception to the lead fuel rules that apply everywhere else - it's already been graduated.

← PreviousPage 5 of 25Next →