HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

slowpoke

1,598 karma · joined June 28, 2011

submissionscomments
slowpoke··on Secure Boot: Who will control your next computer?
You aren't getting downvoted for explaining, you're getting downvoted for the ridiculous assertion that we need to throw out basic Freedoms like the ability to do whatever the fuck with hardware we own (including running whatever the fuck we want on it) because there's a chance we might be compromised.

    Those who would give up essential liberty 
    to purchase a little temporary safety
    deserve neither liberty nor safety.
slowpoke··on Secure Boot: Who will control your next computer?
There is no good reason to deny anyone the four basic Freedoms. The world will eventually realize this, and get rid of proprietary software for good, in addition to all the other horrors RMS has accurately predicted and warned us about for over three decades.

Too bad people didn't listen, continue to trample everyone's Freedoms under their foots for their petty selfish greed while having the audacity to assert their actions to be perfectly ethical. We are currently seeing where this has lead us, and it is the duty of every good man or woman to do anything in their power to stop it, lest evil will triumph.

slowpoke··on 9-Year-Old Who Changed School Lunches Silenced By Politicians
I hate to be that guy but it's Streisand, not Strisand.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streisand_effect

slowpoke··on 9-Year-Old Who Changed School Lunches Silenced By Politicians
That would be even more ridiculous than forbidding her to photograph things and would probably increase the public outrage by at least two orders of magnitude.
slowpoke··on Kogan imposes a tax on IE7 shoppers
Entering a shop wearing spikes is a choice. Being disabled, in contrast, isn't.
slowpoke··on Linus Torvalds: Linux succeed thanks to selfishness and trust
I know the debate about altruism and I was implying that I'm on the side of people who reject the hypothesis that it doesn't exist.

I do agree about finding common ground and shared interests, but I don't think all of this is an end by itself - it's a means to achieve a fair world. This goes for the GPL, too, and indeed free software in general, and I think this is what Linus does not understand from his purely technical perspective.

slowpoke··on Linus Torvalds: Linux succeed thanks to selfishness and trust
I don't agree with Linus here. He first goes on about how "open source" is not about making the world a better place, but then states that the GPL is all about fairness. Well, that's the point - we want a fair world, where everyone's freedoms are respected. How is that not making the world a better place?

You could just as well start arguing that there is no such thing as altruism, and that everyone always acts out of selfish reasons, even if helping someone else. I must say I find this to be a quite misantropic attitude in general.

slowpoke··on IE10's 'Do-Not-Track' Default Dies Quick Death
>Suddenly you have to pay for everything.

False dichotomy. It's not "targeted ads vs no content on the internet". People will just have to use generic ads, not targeted ones. I don't think there will be any meaningful difference in profit, and even if there is, then so be it.

slowpoke··on Microsoft Bans Linux/Android Dual-Booting on Windows 8 ARM Devices
My point is that it's one and the same. You're making distinctions where there are none. Software which I run on my device is content, too. Denying me the right to change or modify that content is the very definition of DRM.
slowpoke··on Microsoft Bans Linux/Android Dual-Booting on Windows 8 ARM Devices
Secure Boot (on ARM) restricts my ability to run whatever the fuck I want on my device. I do not see how this is not Digital Restrictions Mismanagement.
slowpoke··on Why read books if we can’t remember what’s in them?
>My point is, that one of the -other- benefits of having a breadth of knowledge, is that it helps prevent unintentional derivativeness and mimicry.

I could not disagree more on the last part. Derivation and mimicry are the very foundation of creativity. Good artists copy. They take from whatever inspires them. In fact, there is no art that doesn't copy - you will not find art that exists in the void. Everyone stands on the shoulders of giants. And that's a good thing.

slowpoke··on Customizing the Mac to behave like Xmonad
First of all, they are closed.

Second, they do all sorts of stupid non-standard stuff, so you can't use KMS, a framebuffer or xrandr[1]. The GUI application for managing monitors sucks balls and isn't scriptable. I happen to use some older monitors, and that gives me all sorts of pains, too.

To be somewhat fair, it used to be even worse. But it's still nowhere near decent, and will never be unless they open the specs and release the source for the drivers.

In the future, I will exclusively use Intel Graphics. While they aren't perfect either (from what I could gather), at least the drivers are open, which already places them light-years ahead of nvidia and ATI. For the record, my netbook never had a single graphics-related problem, while I lost count of how often I cursed nvidia for their shitty drivers on my desktop.

[1] Support was apparently added to the current beta, but I haven't tried it yet.

slowpoke··on Oops Now You Can Track the Tweets Politicians Tried to Delete
Interestingly, I pretty much expected this answer. Yes, politicians are, in the end, humans, too. They make errors and we need to acknowledge that. However, being held accountable for what you do does not exclude that. The point is not to punish for every little error, it's to be able to differentiate the small errors from major fuck-ups, deliberate deception and corruption - which is of course, as I said, not in the interest of a lot of politicians.

I don't think this is creepy, either. If you decide to become a politician, this should just be part of what you sign up for - either accept that you will be held fully accountable for everything you do and say, or don't become a politician.

slowpoke··on Oops Now You Can Track the Tweets Politicians Tried to Delete
The most important thing in politics is transparency, which many politicians vehemently oppose for their own selfish reasons. But, as the representatives of the people, they have to be held accountable for everything they do. Little steps such as this wonderful project go a long way towards this goal.
slowpoke··on Implementing UEFI Secure Boot in Fedora
>I don't get it. My reading is that MS will sign Linux distros for a lifetime fee of $100 per vendor.

That's besides the point. It's that Microsoft - a software vendor - is suddenly the authority over distributing and signing keys for what amounts to a hardware lock mechanism that prevents you from doing whatever the fuck you want with your computer, all in the name of a false pretext of security. This is insanity.

>Also, as far as I can tell a user (or an OEM) can just go into their UEFI settings and turn off secure boot, then install and boot completely unsigned anything.

The problem is with what you've conveniently placed into parentheses - if the OEM decides to not give you the ability to turn it off, you're fucked. A hardware vendor should not have the ability to tell me what the fuck I can run off it. I'll admit that this is getting into slippery slope territory, but I can see a lot of OEMs using this "feature" because, hey, it worked for Apple - it can't be that bad⸮

slowpoke··on How to Read Mathematics
>You're completely ignoring the working memory argument I'm making.

I'm not ignoring it. I said I don't buy it. I generally don't believe that you need visual compactness to to point of being cryptic to make use of pattern matching. I'm not saying this is necessarily easy. Neither is choosing good variable names in programming, especially at high abstraction levels. But that's no excuse for not doing it.

The other thing is that mathematicians will finally have to accept that they aren't the only ones who need math. It's not, for the most part, a "field for experts" (to paraphrase you) which only those who are willing to become experts at it are allowed to understand. It's a beautiful science with lots of appliance in almost every other field. But it's inaccessible as hell in large parts due to mathematicians with your attitude.

I strongly believe that math can be made more accessible and more "user-friendly" for people who aren't experts at it. It will be hard to do that without sacrificing its tremendous power and flexibility (which I am totally against in software, as well). But it must (and will) eventually be done.

Take note, by the way, that the accessibility problem is less and less important the more specialized the math you are doing becomes. I don't really care if some hyper-abstract field of math that a few dozen people in the world are even able to grasp the basics of is arcane and cryptic. That's something only experts will care for and if they are fine with their niche field being overly cryptic, so be it. What I'm concerned about is math in general.

I firmly agree with the position that math should not be taught as an appliance, because that is missing the point. However, it's downright fatuous to ignore the fact that math has appliances, and that therefore, a lot of people will have to learn a subset of it. To excuse bad practices which have survived by virtue of no one questioning them with nothing but "it's optimized for edge cases (experts)" is a cop-out. It ignores the problem.

I also find it funny that I already met with such vehement opposition for just proposing meaningful variable and function names. That was just an example. There are a lot more problems to be solved. Stuff like "this is trivial" or "left as an exercise" as a way to avoid writing out cumbersome, but nonetheless important (for non-experts) parts, the general terseness of mathematical texts, including the parts in plain English. I could probably find more.

Let me conclude with this: Math as a whole has accessibility problems, just like a lot of CS and computer stuff. Flat out ignoring them or even asserting "it must be this way" is incredibly ignorant. And we need dialogue to do this - not condescending "there is no problem" rebuttals.

slowpoke··on Screw the power users
Not the parent, but for Chrome, probably the horribly limited extension API. I could not even begin to imagine how I would use a browser without Pentadactyl. Or Tree Style Tabs. Both of which are flat out impossible in Chrome. As are tons of other extensions.
slowpoke··on All you need is e-mail, e-mail. E-mail is all you need.
You're thinking of this in the completely wrong way. Why should email - the protocol - offer you all of this? It's nonsense, and goes against basic UNIX philosophy (do one thing). It does another part of the UNIX philosophy very well, though: it's a universal interface. Email can be used to communicate between all sorts of applications, and those applications can give you the features you want easily. Which brings us back to what you're complaints amount to: client problems.
slowpoke··on How to Read Mathematics
Sorry, if all you have left is the (very typical) argument of "if you think that way you just don't understand it", then I'll consider this discussion over. I have no interest in hearing endless appeals to tradition. I'm sure people made similar arguments for GOTO back in the day. Good thing we moved on.
slowpoke··on All you need is e-mail, e-mail. E-mail is all you need.
>just like static web pages have been fixed to do asynchronous JavaScript to provide dynamic web experiences

If by that you are trying to imply that email needs more awful HTML junk and other "features", stop. Now. That would finally destroy email, not fix it.

slowpoke··on All you need is e-mail, e-mail. E-mail is all you need.
>It's the fact that the server stores no archive of content.

And that's still not a problem of email. That's a problem of your employer's competence. They should have an archive. Everything else you mention are client problems.

slowpoke··on How to Read Mathematics
>The benefit in single letter variable names in math is that you're able to write the information in a more compact, digestible manner.

You missed my point entirely. I said that you should not optimize for writing math, you should optimize for reading math. And that's where the same argument as for code holds true as well: It doesn't matter if it takes longer to write, it will be read magnitudes more often, and that is what matters most.

Again, if you're just doing quick calculations on paper or hacking something into your shell/REPL, I really don't care if you use cryptic variable names. I do, too. But I don't want to ever see this in a good program, and I think that it doesn't belong into a good math text, either.

>The reason this latter point is important is for the same reason short, compact programming languages are a boon to comprehension.

And again you missed what I explicitly stated: it's good to write in a concise way, but only as long as it doesn't become cryptic. And I disagree with your belief about information processing. It's better to build semantic relations by having meaningful names than it is to process a lot of information in a short time. It really doesn't matter how fast you are able read something - if it doesn't make sense, you won't understand it.

slowpoke··on How to Read Mathematics
>The same can be said about code: you assume your reader has a certain level of understanding of the domain that you're modelling through code.

No, this is not at all the same. Code can be read without understanding everything if it is well documented. Yes, code should be short and simple, too. But not terse and cryptic - and that's what so many math texts do. So yea, cool, you can compress half a page of written English into half a line of mumbo-jumbo. Great. You have gained nothing.

I'm not saying that the half page of written English is better. Not at all. But there's something somewhere between those two where math should be. And not at the cryptic end of the scale.

Take just simple things such as meaningful variable naming. There are tons of good reasons why we do this in programming. I can't count the number of times I've tried to decipher math texts and had to look up over and over and over again what some x or f or lambda or phi is actually supposed to represent. It gets worse when they start making distinctions based on the bloody way a symbol is typeset (x vs x).

It's perfectly fine to do this in quick calculations on paper (just as it is fine to use one character variables in quick one-off scripts). But if you are writing a prolonged mathematical text, then take the time to give variables meaningful names. It's not that hard, and would go a long way for improving readability.

slowpoke··on How to Read Mathematics
Except that (good) code is written to be read, and to be understood - and not be terse and cryptic, just so that people writing it have less to do. That's essentially what most math texts do. I don't want math to be prose, but often, a little more verbosity or communication of intent would be nice. Just like good comments and documentation. In CS, this is universally accepted as good style, and for very good reasons - and for the same reasons, it should be in math, as well.
slowpoke··on Protecting My Copyright
The GPL is trying to keep code free in an environment where it's unfree by default. You are conflating what free software is doing right now with what it is trying to eventually accomplish - being a step towards a post-scarcity society. Yes, you could modify code and never share back etc without copyright, but it would at the same time be pointless to do so. Nobody, including yourself, would gain anything from it.
slowpoke··on Protecting My Copyright
You're misunderstanding the "it's not nice" part. For example, it's not against the law to be (somewhat) rude, either - but it's not nice. As I pointed out, the whole attribution thing is something that needs to be addressed on a social level, not enforced by law.

And in general, I don't think it's an unreasonable world-view to dislike something, but be against regulating it. For example, I'm vehemently against right-wing ideology and fascism, but I still would not want laws restricting nazis to voice their misguided opinions, because everybody is entitled to free speech. That's not being unreasonable, that's being consistent.

slowpoke··on Protecting My Copyright
>And remember that the copyright law is what make GPL possible...

It's funny you say that, because RMS has cited the creation of a post-scarcity society has one of the explicit goals of free software. In such a society, copyright would not exist, because everything would be free (as in both speech and beer). The GPL is but a means to an end, not an end unto itself, and it just so happens to use the current system of copyright to progress towards that end.

So yes, without copyright, there would be no GPL. But without copyright, we would not have most of the problems the GPL is trying to solve.

slowpoke··on Protecting My Copyright
>I'll just go ahead and post it wherever I want without giving you any attribution

Actually, I use the WTFPL[1] for a lot of code I produce, so yes, you could do that, though it wouldn't be nice to do that.

My opinion is that copyright should not exist. While I can't demand copies from anyone, I don't think anyone has a right to stop me from sharing anything that I have access to, either. Putting things on the internet counts as giving me access. I simply reject the notion that people should be able to control the distribution of digital data. It's both illogical to assert ownership of something abstract and harmful to society at large.

On the other hand, I think people should be credited for their work (if they want). But that's a social issue and not one that can be solved by laws. Look at the scientific community: plagiarism is highly frowned upon and proper attribution is required. And that's mostly by social pressure, not by laws.

So in short, my believe is "Give credit where credit is due, but don't try to tell others what they can or can't do.".

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WTFPL

slowpoke··on Protecting My Copyright
This is ridiculous, and I don't mean the response of that site owner. While yes, that woman is at least slightly nuts, the problem in the first place was "oh the horror, people are using my image, let's throw around DMCA takedowns". Yes, it's not nice to not give attribution, but I don't see a fundamental problem here. What was the loss involved? Nothing. People liked the image, so they used it. Where's there any theft? Nobody stole anything. Just another example of why the DMCA is a very bad law and needs to go away. Ideally along with copyright as a whole.
slowpoke··on GitHub for Windows
These aren't misnomers, they are intentional. Please read a bit into git before you accuse it of "misnaming" things.
← PreviousPage 4 of 20Next →