HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

slr555

737 karma · joined November 18, 2013

submissionscomments
slr555··on A silent epidemic of male suicide (2011)
There are several sources for comparable US data. Examining page 6 of the PDF below demonstrates that the suicide rates for middle aged to elderly Caucasian males in the US is higher in 2014 by a factor of ~3 or in cases more compared to women and other ethnicities. Despite the prevalence of suicide in this group the issue is seldom covered by the media or addressed in public policy debates.

http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/hestat/suicide/rates_1999_2014....

slr555··on Flying Car Dreams May Soon Be a Reality
I have to agree with Sokoloff below. The problem with flying cars is, well....they fly. Which means dealing with an object in 3 dimensions, pitch, yaw, roll and all that in a product that's supposed to replace a Prius. Even in highly sophisticated jets landing and take off requires a high degree of skill. Rotary wings are easier in some regards but if they stop you sort of drop like a stone. People can't handle driving on a three lane road. I have little confidence they could navigate a 4 or 7 layer stack of lane sets.

Sadly, George Jetson is still a man of the future.

slr555··on 4WD vs. AWD. What's the Difference?
All this talk of traction and moving forward is great but one of the most important things to remember about 4WD or AWD especially in snow and ice is that is doesn't enhance your ability to brake. It is easy to feel fearless being able to accelerate on a slippery road but a bummer to discover you can't stop (yes, I get that engine braking plays a role...).
slr555··on Rudy Van Gelder, Audio Engineer Who Helped Define Sound of Jazz, Has Died
A Love Supreme. Blue Note recordings. I marvel at them today. Yes, a major loss.
slr555··on Cognitive behavioural therapy is falling out of favour
Your point is a good one but in medicine the issue tends to be that a lot of studies with varying controls and endpoints are being lumped together and presented as a coherent whole. In reality the distortions (and in some cases biases of the researcher) that are introduced leave the data often untenable. You are absolutely right that powering medical studies correctly is a critical issue. It is also critical that when making pronouncements about important treatment modalities that the research be of the highest quality.

Meta-analyses are often used in so creating so called evidence based medicine standards which are sometimes cost cutting efforts dressed up like research.

As a trauma surgeon recently said to me recently, "They said they designed it using evidence based medicine. They didn't say whose evidence".

slr555··on Cognitive behavioural therapy is falling out of favour
Meta-analysis: the non-study, study that says, well, anything you want it to say.

I am so tired of second rate journals running rehashes of other researcher's work and pawning it off as a "ground breaking examination of the data". Anyone in the field of medicine will tell you that meta-analysis is the least credible form of "research".

I find the Guardian author's first hypothesis most credible. There are a lot of bad therapists out there. It is well established in surgical studies that results for a procedure will be less positive in study sites that are not centers of excellence as the surgeons are less practiced and less skilled. Surgeons and therapists are not stamped from a machine. As the commercial says, "your mileage may vary". Put another way, what do they call the person who graduates last in their class in med school? Doctor.

For any medical ailment of any consequence you might face you will be well served to find the best and most experienced provider available to you.

slr555··on I don't think the Port Authority would like it if you looked at this photo
In the US virtually all public places and people are fair game for photographs. One has no legal expectation of privacy in public place in the US.

That said, I am more qualified to be on commenting on petapixel than Hacker News. On photo web sites there are endless stories of overreach by individuals and institutions that attempt to limit a photographers right to take photographs in public. The situation in the USA is different than many other countries where photographing anyone associated with the military, any military installation and a great amount of "infrastructure" sites are off limits to photographers.

So while the Port Authority probably has no legal standing to limit photography it is interesting to ask if they have any logical standing for doing so. In numerous texts on the topic of physical security this issue is addressed. Security experts typically say that persons taking video or photos of secured locations with particular regard to photos of perimeter security, lighting security and cameras might be viewed as suspicious actors.

That common sense advice is taken to an absurd extreme here as it is highly unlikely that a threat actor would utilize a 4x5 camera, which is cumbersome, obvious and reliant on labor intensive film processing, on a tripod to take surveillance photos.

I experienced a similarly absurd episode when taking a photo of the weathered hopper control levers of a NYC garbage truck. A sanitation worker informed me that it was not allowed to take photographs of NYC vehicles. While I was tempted to inquire what the strategic import of the garbage control levers was, I held my tongue, finished my pictures and left.

As an example of how crazy people get at photographers check out: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=97hfxth3aas

slr555··on Cloud and Field: On the resurgence of “field guides” in a networked age
I am reminded of Foucault's referencing of Borges' fictional Chinese encyclopedia, Celestial Emporium of Benevolent Knowledge. Which divides animals into 14 categories:

    Those that belong to the emperor
    Embalmed ones
    Those that are trained
    Sucking pigs
    Mermaids (or Sirens)
    Fabulous ones
    Stray dogs
    Those that are included in this classification
    Those that tremble as if they were mad
    Innumerable ones
    Those drawn with a very fine camel hair brush 
    Et cetera
    Those that have just broken the flower vase
    Those that, at a distance, resemble flies
I think people have realized for some time that all efforts at cataloging carry the baggage of ethnocentrism and cultural biases.

PS I am agreeing with danielvf.

slr555··on Apple should stop selling four-year-old computers
The dearth of Macbook Pro releases may not represent an obstacle or even a nuisance for everyone but for devotees of the Mac such as myself whose work falls under the general rubric of "creative", it presents real challenges. The Mac issue is not necessarily speed (which could mean processor, bus, GPU etc) but isolation. The platform is burdened by I/O options that are not mature or well supported. Things became really challenging when Apple bet on Thunderbolt, which from my non-techie perspective seems to have never gained great acceptance by peripheral makers. By stripping out Firewire and and providing somewhat limited USB 3.0 support Apple really narrowed the universe of mass storage and other peripherals that were viable.

Everything that formerly lived happily in the enclosure of a Mac Pro now had to live in a stack near a laptop or new Mac Pro cylinder. The more compact Mac Pro exacerbated workplace sprawl rather than helping it. Macbook Pro models faced the many of the same issues.

I have been nursing along an early 2009 Mac Pro, praying is does not have a major component failure because apple has left me as a photographer/videographer out in the cold. While I realize the Intel processor road map has created challenges for Apple, they need to get updated machines into the market or face defection from people like me who have been Mac Zealots since the mid-80's.

slr555··on How foreign governments spy using PowerPoint and Twitter
The malware known as PowerPoint has infected millions of systems worldwide and has cost businesses, NGO’s and governments untold billions in lost productivity. PowerPoint files seem to be self-spawning and capable of infinite replication in the wild. Small variations in the PowerPoint files forces administrators to keep endless permutations of these highly virulent files.

PowerPoint is often introduced into an organization by highly sophisticated threat actors using deeply customized versions of the software. McKinsey, BCG, and Bain deploy the PowerPoint malware to a multiplicity of customers whose human capital and infrastructure become mired in endless recursive loops known as PowerPoint cycles.

The actual introduction of PowerPoint is typically merely incidental to these threat actors ambitions. Most often they derive substantial portions of their income by reselling organizations intellectual property which they already own.

Once the organizations systems become bogged in ever more bloated PowerPoint files productivity plummets. Morale drops among employees and management often re-engages the threat actors to attempt to right the ship.

The PowerPoint Malware is seemingly unstoppable at this point. Any computers that contain it should be air gapped and protected by highly restricted physical access.

slr555··on The Spanish cooking oil scandal (2001)
It is interesting that that within the last few days the NY Post has published an article on the food supply that continues to promulgate this myth. The book author they cite is also blaming olive oil for the tragedy in Spain. It is unfortunate that even with better data available publishers continue to quote myth as fact.

http://nypost.com/2016/07/10/the-truth-behind-how-were-scamm...

slr555··on When everything else fails, amateur radio will still be there and thriving
For me the best thing about HAM is that it makes you learn before you can play. For a non-engineer such as myself, having to learn the electronics, physics, antenna design, FCC rules etc. forced me to acquire knowledge I probably wouldn't have otherwise gone out of my way for as an adult. I got my General class license a few years ago and keep trying to get myself motivated to go for my Amateur Extra license but doing HAM in NYC is hard. Unless you are lucky enough to have someplace you can put up some kind of antenna you are largely limited to a 5 watt HT. There is so much that is exciting happening in HAM today. SDR systems are very exciting as is all the internet hybrid. It is super fun and I do hope a new generation gets psyched about it and drives innovation.
slr555··on AI produces realistic sounds that fool humans
I have so much respect for foley artists. Artist being the operative word. People don't appreciate the hard work and creativity that goes into making the perfect sound.
slr555··on AI produces realistic sounds that fool humans
AI that produces sound through analysis of a source video is impressive. Fooling humans is not. Since most of us have grown up on a steady diet of film and television many of the sounds we have in our memories are the work of foley artists that add sound effects to sequences in post. The sound of horse hoofs on cobblestones is likely created from a percussive technique that has no equine participation. The sounds of people being punched may be the sound of a large piece of meat being struck with a club. Similarly crunching snow likely is not the sound of a person walking through actual snow.

Our perceptions of sound within a video/film source is already deeply skewed and therefore the notion that this AI is a Turing test of sorts is a weak analogy.

slr555··on What If PTSD Is More Physical Than Psychological? Evidence from new study
The title of this article extremely poorly chosen. The DSM-5 criteria for PTSD defines this condition in terms such that a great number of patients meet the criteria who have never been exposed to blasts of any kind. Yes, there may be significant numbers of patients like those the article describes who suffer from a previously uncategorized blast injury phenomenon that has sometimes been attributed to PTSD but the author is drawing the wrong Venn diagram for the reader. The new entity does not begin to subsume the entire PTSD population. This matters because too many patients whose symptoms have been stigmatized anyway will now be left with the impression that "real" PTSD is only associated with a history of blast exposure.
slr555··on ‘2001: A Space Odyssey’ rendered in the style of Picasso
I am much more of an artist than a technology person and the rendering inconsistency the author refers to is one of the coolest aspects of the video. This is the kind of happy accident that gives work originality and makes it more than a slavish copy. Reminds me of Link Wray putting a pencil through the speaker cone of his amplifier.
slr555··on 407,000 Workers Stunned as Pension Fund Proposes 60% Cuts
I'm not much of a finance guy so please tell me how this is different than a Ponzi scheme.
slr555··on Campaign demands telecoms unlock the FM radio found in many smartphones
This will be awesome. We will have a whole new generation with real life experience with intermodulation distortion, picket fence noise and host of other quirky radio anomalies.
slr555··on Why Suburbia Sucks
Perhaps Mr. Balashov is thinking of the great urban centers of Europe like Moscow. Where it can take 2.5 hours to go 20 blocks and where the mass transit system embraces multi-culturalism and internationalism by only having signs in Cyrillic.

I am sorry that Mr. Balashov has chosen to live in Atlanta, but I suspect he has little knowledge of Omaha. Growing up in such a place is quite idyllic. The creeks, the parks, the forest and the fields encourage children to play sports, have pets, picnic and stare up at the sky from amidst fields of boundless green listening to the sound of insects and birds instead of sirens.

As Oscar Wilde said, "For heaven's sake, don't try to be cynical. It's perfectly easy to be cynical." It is easy to be cynical about suburbs and wax poetic about cities. Well I grew up in Kansas and have lived for 25 years in NYC (Manhattan). Also known as the capital of the world.

I've been to Paris, Moscow, London, Dubai, Cairo, Buenos Aires, Brussels, Prague, Budapest, Stockholm, Amsterdam, Berlin, Munich, etc. And guess what I still love Kansas and Nebraska.

Loathing suburbia is snobbery and a failure of imagination.

My favorite Tarkovsky film is Nostalghia. The title refers to a very specific feeling that Russians experience when the miss their homeland.

slr555··on Medical error is third biggest cause of death in the US, experts say
This statistic gets bandied about every now and then and is completely indefensible. Extrapolation is hardly proof and the CDC statistics don't begin to validate this nonsense.

If it were true it would mean that for essentially every person you had ever heard of dying from any type of accident or pneumonia there would be one resulting from medical error.

Every fatal car wreck you ever read about. Every drowning. Every fatal accidental shooting or fall AND every person you had ever heard of dying from lower respiratory tract infection would have an approximately equal number of deaths CAUSED by medical errors.

In other words people who would have lived instead died because a medical professional made a mistake.

If you believe that's true I have a wonderful bridge here in Brooklyn I would be happy to sell you for a very reasonable price.

slr555··on Chinese state media discourages April Fools' Day
The Chinese characters for the word gullible have also been removed from all Chinese dictionaries and public documents.
slr555··on Fun Photoshop File Format Facts
What is interesting to me is the intersection of all these perspectives about code and the user experience. I have taken quite a few photoshop classes through the years from the perspective of a photographer (as opposed to designer) and what always makes me smile are all the functions you are told never to use. The most basic of these is the menu choice under Image>Black & White. When asked why we should not use it the instructor invariably says, "Photoshop is a monolith of code and Adobe is terrified to remove anything for fear it will all come crashing down. So even though no one uses Black & White it will be there forever."

I am told this is much of the reason that Lightroom was born. It was an effort to make a photographers tool that wasn't crushed under the weight of its own legacy code.

slr555··on Secret US flight flew over Scottish airspace to capture Snowden
That makes sense but there are so many transpacific routes that spend huge stretches of time over open water that I am not sure it is even feasible for all commercial flights. CIA SAD/SOG operations likely have a much broader risk envelope.
slr555··on Secret US flight flew over Scottish airspace to capture Snowden
The range of a Gulfstream V is about 6500 miles. Given that fact the jet could have easily flown without entering UK airspace at all. The Gulfstream V also has an initial cruising altitude of 41,000 feet with a max of 51,000 feet. 45,000 feet may be high for a commercial jet but the G5 cruises comfortably at that altitude. Given these facts I am not sure why the CIA would create the exposure flying over the UK would create. My guess is they have heard of flight aware and know a transponder does.
slr555··on CIA planned rendition operation to kidnap Edward Snowden
Not sure that this source is entirely credible. There is no link to the documents or to the original journalistic source. I also find it hard to believe that the CIA couldn't spoof a new tail number or just buy a new jet if they really wanted to keep this quiet. It doesn't really pass the common sense test. Unless the documents are produced and they are extremely compelling this seems more like conspiracy theory than good journalism.
slr555··on The problem of OS X hardware in 2016
Thanks for posting this. Perhaps I will have to screw up my courage and try to do the firmware upgrade and go to twelve cores. If anyone knows a really good source for a tray swap please post here.
slr555··on The problem of OS X hardware in 2016
This is a very real problem. I am still running an early 2009 Mac Pro that is slowly beginning to resemble the 1970 Mustang Mach 1 I drove in high school. I have replaced the original graphics cards with an upgraded unit to get GPU support in Photoshop. I have installed a couple of SSD's to get away from spinning iron. Hunted high and low to finally find a USB 3.0 card that would work. Have been thinking about a swap to move from an 8 core tray to a 12 core unit.

It's really hard to justify buying a "new" Mac Pro that is a 4 year old design at this point. I keep hoping that Apple will announce a revamp but the days since the last release keep climbing and best guesses have the inside date at mid to late 2016 at best.

Since my creative applications are mostly subscription based and cross platform, software costs aren't so much of an issue anymore....

I have been using the Mac since '85. I have not used Windows since XP (job required) but I still get hives when I am around an MS box. Still this may be the future.

Sad Mac. No happy gong.

slr555··on The Rise of Return-Anything Culture
Generous return policies in the US have historically been significantly more prevalent than the author states. Stores like Nordstrom have accepted anything a customer would return up to and including tires which the do not and have never sold. Mercantile stores had a similar policy. Same with LL Bean. REI until recently had unconditional returns. North Face has repaired 20 year old products for me. Returns for credit only were primarily only enforced in specialty retailers and independents.

Of course warranties and returns are figured in to the balance sheet of every company. It's not really free. The cost of such policies are baked into pricing decisions. Ultimately it is one component of a retailer's value proposition.

slr555··on “Gunslinger’s gait”: a new cause of unilaterally reduced arm swing
Really hard to say with Secret Service where and what they are carrying. Likely a handgun strong side carry on the waist but also perhaps a PDW like an MP5 or equivalent in its most concealable iteration under the arm on the weak side.

The hand position is pretty standard as a ready position for many fighting systems. Easy to go to a guard position or to initiate striking or pain compliance maneuvers from that stance. On a startle cue, from that position the hands will come up, at which point they can choose the appropriate response.

slr555··on “Gunslinger’s gait”: a new cause of unilaterally reduced arm swing
This is not a new phenomenon. In the law enforcement community it has been well recognized for many years that people who carried concealed weapons will often exhibit reduced arm swing on the gun side. The habit is driven by two issues. The first is training and a desire to keep the strong side arm indexed to the weapon for faster unholstering. The second is a reaction to the first and involves trying to unlearn the reduced arm swing, which more recently has been seen as a "tell" which may give warning to potential adversaries that one is armed and may be a potential threat. As a corollary people are now taught to be aware of reduced arm swing in others.
← PreviousPage 3 of 5Next →