HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

slr555

737 karma · joined November 18, 2013

submissionscomments
slr555··on Most violence in the world is motivated by moral sentiments
When I was a theatre student a thousand years ago my teachers used to say every character you play feels like they have the gods on their side. Bad guys (with the possible exception of Iago) generally don't go around thinking "today I'm going to be particularly evil". They think what they are doing is right and will make the world better in some way. That is the challenge with moral relativism, people are very good at rationalizing their violence.
slr555··on Doctors want ban on prescription drug, device advertisements
Doctors are very good at keeping tabs on earnings of others but have no limits on the estimates of their own value. We in turned are conditioned to respect doctors as the vessels which carry the whole of healthcare. Nothing could be further from the truth. Talk to a very large percentage of doctors outside the office and you find that money is there bottom line. They're all for tort reform so you can't recover a large settlement when they are negligent. They grouse endlessly about how much they have to pay for malpractice insurance. I recently saw a doctor get into a private chauffeured limousine with a vanity plate outside a major NY hospital. I don't know too many pharma execs that live that high on the hog. Did I mention the chauffeur was armed. I guess you can make people angry when you flaunt wealth like that. My own doctor lamented not making as much money as "those wallstreet guys" just before he forgot I was in the hospital for a week. Oops.
slr555··on Theranos didn’t work with the huge drug company it supposedly made money from
I seem to detect the familiar odor of negative PR wafting over this entire series of articles. The New Yorker has one of the most famously rigorous fact checking policies in journalism. Things rarely ever slip past them. Companies like Quest Diagnostics and Labcorp have immense amounts of revenue to lose to a new, more efficient entrant like Theranos. No surprise they would go negative to undermine a new competitor. As far as the company ferreting out journalistic mistakes and correcting them, the onus should be on the media to get the story right.
slr555··on Uber Is Taking Millions of Manhattan Rides Away from Taxis
I take cabs and cars everyday in Manhattan. It is as hard or harder to get a yellow cab than it has been in the 25 years I have lived in the city. My routine goes like this; if I can't get a cab in 10 minutes, I get an Uber. I end up taking Uber a lot more than I would like but that is just how it is. I am not only trying during rush hour and rain storms. Even in "light" volume hours getting a medallion cab is not easy. The providers that have been hurt the most by Uber are the old gypsy cab companies. These were TLC "black cars", usually beat up old town cars that were dispatched by radio. Their system of radios and dispatchers has been decimated by Uber. The drivers of those cars have in large part become Uber drivers.
slr555··on Ask HN: How can you tell if you are insane?
Insane is probably not a useful word in this context. Is it possible that you are suffering from an illness? Of course it is. The internet is not the place to seek a diagnosis. Make an appointment with your primary care provider or a qualified mental health professional. There are a number of illnesses that can manifest themselves in ways archaically referred to as mental. Just keep in mind that everything that happens in your brain is chemical and electrical. If you are having a psychotic break, and believe me I do not mean that as a pejorative but simply as a medical term then you need qualified medical care. When asked, a schizophrenic patient will say when they began to hear voices they were as real to them as their friend talking from the next room. I wish you the best of luck. Get help. If you need treatment, get healthy. These are tough issues. Hang in there.
slr555··on Amazon Flex
Amazon can't even effectively manage their second tier delivery vendors like Lasership in NYC. They dump packages in unsecured areas (I had one stolen last week). They scan packages as delivered to make their SLA with Amazon and then deliver after 9pm. And now Amazon thinks some random folks with cars are going to do great delivering merchandise in one of the country's most congested urban areas. Maybe bricks and mortar aren't so bad after all.
slr555··on 14-Year-Old Boy Arrested for Bringing Homemade Clock to School
When they outlaw clocks only outlaws will be on time.
slr555··on Fibonacci Flim Flam
I was being a bit facetious but I was making the point that the distortions introduced by photo manipulation may not truly allow one to make the extrapolations about height the author alludes too. But as I say, my intended tone was tongue in cheek.
slr555··on Fibonacci Flim Flam
I am not much of a mathematician but I know a little about art and photography. Generally this piece was well written and I don't doubt a lot of it. Two comments though:

Using pictures of swimsuit models is a potentially deeply flawed methodology. Photoshop is of course liberally applied to these images and proportions of many aspects (leg length and waist length being perhaps the most germane here) are thus distorted.

In regards to painting and the arts in general, people talk about the rule of thirds or the golden spiral but artists are not so good about sticking to "rules". The general principle may apply but no one is measuring. Remember that engineers designed guitar amplifiers originally not to cause distortion. Everything changed when Link Wray put a pencil through the cone of his cabinet. ;)

slr555··on From Retail Palace to Zombie Mall: How Efficiency Killed the Department Store
I wonder why the flagship department stores seem to have perished in the USA but not as much in Europe. Of course Harrods comes to mind. KaDeWe in Berlin is an amazing store the recalls and even surpasses the main Marshall Fields in Chicago 50 years ago. KaDeWe is always packed with locals and tourists alike. The author of the article seems solely focused on the USA.
slr555··on How RED Cameras Changed the Game
I attended NAB (National Association of Broadcasters trade show) in 2006. The buzz about RED was incredible. They had a leadership team that included some heavy hitters in innovation. Jannard not only had money by he was driving a vision. Still, many of the engineers I spoke with at the conference were skeptical that a new entrant could overcome the barriers presented by the dominance of Sony, Ikegami, and to some extent JVC in the market.

Cameras are lot more than just the body which is the core of the system. Lenses, camera control units (CCUs), monitoring, media all have to work together. A producer/director/DP has to be convinced that the will save money or have a better product with the new system.

Red forced everyone to raise their game. ARRI's Alexa comes to mind. I have to applaud the RED team for shaking up a tough market to break into.

slr555··on Unbounded High Dynamic Range Photography Using a Modulo Camera
I am probably less technical than most of you but the upside of this technology (at the point it is real world ready) might be producing what I would call a RAW file that is RAW(ER). By that I mean the file would simply contain a wider range of scene information that could be accessed by Adobe Camera Raw or the like. For the class of photographers that have no interest in RAW the information would help the JPEG engine in the camera make a "better" informed JPEG (or whatever the standard is at that time). To me capturing more scene info is better than less assuming there are minimal penalties being paid elsewhere (file size, burst shooting etc).

As a side note, it seems to me that aperture and shutter speed would still be essential as they affect not only exposure but depth of field and subject motion. Perhaps a technique that allows proper exposure independent of fstop/shutter/ASA would allow exploration of extremely wide aperture with slow shutter but no need for ND filters.

In any event it will be interesting to see what happens.

slr555··on How many lives does a doctor save?
Check the Anger. This is an academic exchange of ideas. If you are angry go to the gym it's better for you.

A. You have debunked nothing.

B. There are no lies here.

C. Just because some random guy on the internet tells me to do something, I am no obligation to do that.

D. "Access to treatment", could mean the moon is made of green cheese but it is unlikely.

E. Since you are angry about it, cite specifically the the formulary content of the NHS and compare it to available treatments at Sloan Kettering. Since your so convinced it's true, prove it. (two can play at that)

F. Support you assertion that novel treatments only extend life by "a few months" with multiple citations from peer reviewed journals, oh and make sure their recent.

G. As far as the legal mandates. I am sure that everything in the UK is done exactly to the letter of the law in all cases and that deadlines are never missed.

H. You're assertion that closing the two week gap between when the GP starts testing and the specialist would start testing would close the mortality gap between the UK and Europe strains credulity and common sense.

Oh and just because you are dead bone wrong, http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/11788507/NHS-accused-of-sham...

"A cancer drug hailed as one of the biggest breakthroughs since chemotherapy will not be made available on the NHS, despite research showing it doubles survival"

Can you here me now.

slr555··on How many lives does a doctor save?
PS I don't know what documentary you are talking about? I have never created a documentary on the NHS. Certainly not any documentary that was "Anti-NHS" That is a patently falsehood.

I did work a documentary on Rheumatoid Arthritis patients across Europe, not just the UK and not focused on health systems. The patients experiences with their respective health service were out of scope and not on screen. I did however speak with them at length on the subject. Before you go casting about accusations please have some rudimentary idea of what you are talking about.

The NHS patients we met with each mentioned that in order to see a specialist on a timely basis they had to get private insurance after which their months longs waits dissolved to days. A close friend who was a staunch defender of the NHS after being diagnosed with MS has soured on the program and has also secured private insurance for specialist access. In another instance a young woman with a bowel perforation secondary to Crohn Disease has been waiting for at least two months to have surgery scheduled. Yes, yes I know anecdotal experience and all that but I guess it's just a poisson distribution that everyone I've ever known met or heard of that has needed specialty care from the NHS has gone the route of private insurance for access to specialists.

Take a close look at the quote from the article I posted with the prefix "Note:" and then sound it out. Use your vowels and note that it VERY CLEARLY states that one of the problems is "poorer access to treatment".

If you want to go on a formulary hunt to see which drugs are not paid for by the NHS that are recommended under NCCN guidelines or spend your night frothing over pubmed searches be my guest.

PS I have no axe to grind. I'm not the one bringing profanity and personal accusations into this. You don't know me. You clearly have no clue about my politics but are clearly incensed that someone deigns to take issue with the NHS. The bottom line is that patients are dying sooner in the UK than elsewhere. If that is okay with you then great, I'm just saying as a personal opinion informed by my reading and personal experiences that it is not a system I would choose to live under or advocate the adoption of in my country.

If you are happy with the health care system in your country that's great.

slr555··on How many lives does a doctor save?
http://www.bbc.com/news/health-33772892

Note: They suggest some of the reasons behind this could include cancers being diagnosed later, poorer access to treatment and less investment in health systems.

PS Rapid referral to a specialist is an oxymoron in the NHS.

slr555··on How many lives does a doctor save?
Sure about that?

Look at the five year survival rates for innovative treatments. Granted not all of them and not every time, but to generalize to "months" is a gross mis-characterization not borne out by a thorough review of the literature.

slr555··on How many lives does a doctor save?
Consider the following individual when you think about this question:

http://www.wwltv.com/videos/news/health/2015/07/28/trauma-su...

Norman McSwain was one man but through his work developing PHTLS (Pre-Hospital Trauma Life Support) and introducing modern EMS practices to numerous countries around the globe he truly did save countless lives. He has been credited for doing more to reduce the homicide in New Orleans than any mayor or police commissioner because he taught the trauma surgeons that increased survival from penetrating wounds and was an incredibly skilled surgeon himself. His work with the Tactical Combat Casualty Care Committee helped reduce battlefield fatality rates to historic lows.

The statistics don't take into account the kind of doctor you choose to be. If you choose to join a posh private practice and treat little old ladies who "just don't feel quite right" you may not save a lot of lives. But if you choose to be on the front lines, for instance one of the last doctors out of Charity hospital after Katrina, and spread knowledge far and wide you may just save more than "ninety lives".

We all get the same 24 hours in each day. Norman just used them better than most of us.

slr555··on How many lives does a doctor save?
Beating up pharma seems to be easy sport but consider this.

Have you ever had serious case of bronchitis, or a high fever, or needed any kind of surgery?

Guess what? No anesthesia (yes it's a drug not just a machine), no antibiotics, very likely no you.

Now take a look at the recent articles on the UK's much hyped NHS and how they are laggards in cancer survival because they do not take advantage of pharma innovations.

Know anyone anyone with hypertension or diabetes? Ask them whether they were well controlled and side effect free on the first drug they were prescribed . That's the big reason there are a lot of "me too" drugs that sell. (and while you're asking see if they fully compiled with their doctor's diet and exercise advice)

One size does not fit all.

slr555··on Tinder and the Dawn of the “Dating Apocalypse”
The "dating apocalypse" began not with the internet but the pharmacist. Effective long term contraception and anti-infectives that worked against a wide variety of venereal diseases removed the tangible consequences of promiscuous sex. Those milestones are the real articulation in the history of dating.

In the 60's there were the "happenings" where people metaphorically swiped right and left. In the 70's it was discos, the 80's had pick-up bars. I'm pretty sure Vanity Fair had long features on each of those phenomena as well. Each generation starts to mature and are pretty sure that they are the first to discover sex, which of course their parents never had, and the older generation sees "little precious" out doing their thing and the end of the world is nigh. 20 years on the youngsters are bouncing the kids on their knees and the old ones are pushing up grass and so it goes. As the Thorton Wilder said, "Once in a thousand times it's interesting".

slr555··on Show HN: Spot the Drowning Child
In general drowning is a poorly understood phenomenon among the general population. Portrayals in film and TV contribute much to many misconceptions. While there has been considerable attention paid to the fact that the act of drowning doesn't "look" like the film/TV stereotype, less focus has been placed on the sequalae of a drowning event. The alveoli, which are the functional units of our lungs where gas exchange occurs are quite delicate. Natural surfactants facilitate the work of the alveoli. Water and the contaminants it may hold disrupt these surfactants and can lead to short to intermediate term post "resuscitation" morbidity and mortality. Victims do not leap to their feet and return to saving the world as they do in the movies. Any drowning victim should be seen in the emergency department even if they are revived on scene.
slr555··on Digital colours and digital photography
I can't argue with any of the technical data in this article which is clearly well researched. There is however some important nuance that is missing. Color theory is a fractal and the deeper you go the more convolutions you find. Motion picture and video artists are typically a lot deeper in the weeds of color than photographers. One phenomenon relates to the psychological perception of color. One reason the picture of the flower is never the same as the flower is that you remember it differently (and yes I realize you may look at the lcd on your camera right after shooting). People in general carry certain "memory colors" grass green, brick red, that do not correspond to the metered color of these things. Grass is deeper green and bricks more saturated in memory.

Alexis Van Hurkman wrote an amazing book called Color Correction which is about digital color grading for motion pictures and TV. The issues pomax discusses exist at every step of the process: Capture, Editing, DI, Projection. The engineering standards work around the practicalities of the physics. Canon and Nikon won't address this issue. Their markets are dying as it is. Red might. Arri might. Panovision might. Black Magic might.

I suggest that pomax spend more time hanging out with cinematographers and DI artists and less time with photographers and coders to unravel more of this.

Last comment on the flower picture. Many people fail to get the shot they want not due to camera inadequacy but because to light something for the camera, direction, quality, temperature of light cost money and takes a lot of skill. Point and shoot isn't.

PS Mapplethorpe managed to get some flowers that look pretty good. And that was in the stone age.

slr555··on Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief
I think the take away may be that Ellen Pao is not the executive that someone's hype machine purports her to be.
slr555··on Inside the $499 aluminum NES that’s crafted like a Leica
Not such a great analogy. Yes, Leica's can be a vanity item or a status symbol but the fact is that their optics achieve things in a significantly smaller package at an amazing level of quality that is often unequaled by even top of the line Japanese systems. I don't own one and probably will never give my Nikons to get one but to compare it to a console that plays a couple of games is like apples to gyroscopes.
slr555··on The Cartel Gunsmiths
It is true that in the military, much shooting is done in semi-auto mode. That said there is a huge difference in the volume of fire that can be generated in full auto vs. semi-auto. Companies like Surefire are now building 100 round magazines that are far more reliable than the Beta mags which weren't much more than a gimmick.
slr555··on The Cartel Gunsmiths
While it is true that there are legal M16 series rifles out there, I would be stunned if you could find an unfired full auto M16 variant for 10K. Full auto M16's in decent shape will fetch 20K plus. Additionally, I think it was only in the last few years that a legally owned NFA full auto was used in a crime. For decades there was not a single crime committed with a legally owned full auto post NFA.
slr555··on The Cartel Gunsmiths
Many firearms, Glocks by way of example have serialized barrels. The issue is, sticking with the Glock example, that the polymer lower carries the serial plate and is considered to be "the firearm" since barrels are interchangeable and their sale is not regulated. It is straightforward to get a replacement barrel. Barrels do not have an infinite service life and barrel replacement is not uncommon.
slr555··on The Cartel Gunsmiths
Filing serial number off is generally unsuccessful as a means of rendering a firearm untraceable. Law enforcement can use a variety of methods to reveal the serial number due to the changes that the original stamping makes in the metal underneath the actual surface impression. While in theory using an impact tool or a milling type tool could work to remove the underlying metal there is a risk that the integrity of the part (in this case the lower receiver) could be compromised.

I would take exception to the author's statement that the lower receiver is the primary firing mechanism. While it does contain the trigger and sear the upper receiver contains the full bolt assembly, firing pin, and gas system (or piston if you feel like getting fancy).

My biggest question is that if they are creating lowers from billet and other parts as well, why they just don't equip these weapons with auto sears and make them full auto. Go big or go home, right?

slr555··on The Killing of Osama Bin Laden
Reporting like this is so unconvincing because all the sources are anonymous and there is no way to corroborate the assertions of the reporter. It's as though he asking us to accept a story told by the Easter Bunny and confirmed by the Tooth Fairy. The explanation of why all the subterfuge is necessary is quite unconvincing. If you consider each of the reasons separately they make little sense. Given that the US SpecOps community is nearly completely Republican in its sympathies it makes no sense that this story would go unleaked by those elements. This version of the events also requires a vast conspiracy within the journalist community that has widely reported on the story from the perspective of numerous SEALs. Finally, what of all the injured SEALs on the crashed helo. No medevac, no casevac, no reportage. The US would definitely sacrifice a dozen lives to keep advanced stealth technology out of the hands of other governments. Fails Occam's Razor miserably.
slr555··on Worse
It is definitely worth noting that Amazon has a shareholder problem. Yes, they have devoured everything large and small but profit margins are razor thin. One of the most brilliant things that Jeff Bezos did was telling his early investors not to see a return for several years, but the market does and will demand returns. Given that Costco makes most of its profit on membership fees it will be interesting to see if the Prime increase is sufficient to both sustain or improve service levels and increase profitability.
slr555··on Installing VLC Media Player voids your speaker warranty
While it is likely true that most laptop speakers are crap, overdriving the power amp or any condition that causes clipping even at lower volumes can lead to cracked voicecoils which in turn produce distorted sound. In the old days we just used to push in on a driver and you could easily feel the broken voicecoil. clipping = death
← PreviousPage 4 of 5Next →