HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

smashah

1,114 karma · joined December 10, 2016

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/smashah; my proof: https://keybase.io/smashah/sigs/bREd6ydhJtwPxJlDyxa5M6TwQFAj_hVXZ9lqRA9kaR8 ]

Building http://openwa.dev/

https://twitter.com/smashah

submissionscomments
smashah··on Please don't use Discord for FOSS projects
We rightly shut down the sense of entitlement that some users have to project maintainers' time and effort. I believe this whole recurring "open source + discord = bad" talking point comes from the same sense of entitlement.

As an open source maintainer, I use discord (along with email, issues, discussions, PRs, Twitter, site chat etc.) as another option for those wishing to use it. It's not forced upon anyone. A small groups' esoteric (sometimes self-imposed) handicaps doesn't constitute a change in course for everyone else.

smashah··on Show HN: Long Range E-Bike
Differentiating between pedal assist & throttled e-bike serves no great purpose.

There should be no distinction, legally, between a normal bicycle and an electric bike of any kind (throttle or otherwise).

Personal Electric (micro) Mobility is the answer to many problems, let's not add any roadblocks to adoption. Other than keeping powers-that-be comfortable and sparing the feelings of cycling puritans, the distinction is useless, bordering on harmful to the environment.

smashah··on Chromium: Permit blocking of view-source: with URLBlocklist
Precisely!

I wonder what chain of events lead this PR being filed.

How did the kid(s) get caught? Did a teacher decide to tell the IT department head? Did the head of department then tell the IT maintenance team? Then the IT maintenance team told the test vendor?

Very odd chain of events to lead to such a dangerous change.

smashah··on Use forums rather than Slack/Discord to support developer community
Well I think you'd find that your first barrier would be the fact that most open source projects are run off of GitHub which is a company owned by Microsoft.
smashah··on Use forums rather than Slack/Discord to support developer community
> I'm not sure I got that from his, this needless insult did make me feel that way about yours though.

Just a little joke, didn't mean it in a bad way.

> No, it's not, but in my experience, about 50% of the people who contribute code I want to merge avoid proprietary garbage whenever they can. Why increase the friction for them?

PR critical discussions stay on PR. Would be silly to have that discussion off platform if it pertains to an open PR. My point was more aimed at the claim that the historical record should be of any concern to the maintainer.

> There are plenty of options that aren't actively user hostile if you're of the opinion that real time chat is that important.

Discord without verification and without overzealous rules is a good in between. I make sure to not require verification for my project's discord because verification is needless friction when somebody wants to ask a question/advice. The off-platform chat needs to be as frictionless as possible. Other than that I don't see how else a discord can be user hostile.

smashah··on RFC: Make NPM install scripts opt-in
Almost all npm packages are open and the code available in Github - so if npm package maintainers are not being policed then it's the community's fault for leeching and not looking into the code.

I run an install script for my package [0], this install script forces 2 lines in users' .gitignore files to prevent EXTREMELY sensitive data being committed into a public repo - despite me telling everyone in the community to not commit these files on god-knows how many occasions. I do this because I care about my users and I know if I tried some funny business then they would rightly call me out for it - NOT "because I'm allowed to".

[0] - https://github.com/open-wa/wa-automate-nodejs/blob/0ba7d6850...

smashah··on Use forums rather than Slack/Discord to support developer community
In reality the best solution is to mix all available tools in a way where individual interactions always have a specific place to be addressed effectively. For example, I encourage people to introduce issues in the discord. If it is fixable with the given context and I am available, I will fix it there and then + publish a new version of the package/patches within minutes. This way others don't even have the time to experience the problem in the first place.

If the problem seems more complex, I direct them to fill in an extensive issue template.

On boot of the library, I also log a link to an issue template with most of the context filled in.

If the issue has a few bits of information missing & there seems to be miscommunication, I direct them to message me on the discord.

Most projects are maintained by a single person, so the communication landscape of the project should be optimised for that person and how they deem effective to communicate. It's not for users/passers-by/etc.

smashah··on Use forums rather than Slack/Discord to support developer community
Discord makes sense for my project due to the dynamic nature of it. I agree it's probably redundant for stable projects with minimal updates
smashah··on Use forums rather than Slack/Discord to support developer community
Maintainers should do exactly what they determine is best for them and the project.

open-source puratism isn't a guiding principle for maintainers believe it or not.

Running a discord allows maintainers to foster somewhat friendly relationships with users instead of purely transactional & functional relationships.

Your comment comes off as entitled although I will concede that slack is not cool. Good day.

smashah··on RFC: Make NPM install scripts opt-in
Package maintainers implement install scripts for a reason. It should be opt-out, not opt-in.

There should be granualar control over which packages, and which scripts you want to block.

E.g in your package.json:

`"scriptblock": { "puppeteer" : "*" } ` or ` "scriptblock": { "puppeteer" : ["preinstall","postinstall"...] } `

etc.

smashah··on 1 Year of Coinbase as a mission focused company
"Don't bring politics to work" = "Don't bring your politics to work"

One person's every day life is considered by another to be "political".

smashah··on Facebook bans, sends C&D letter to developer of Unfollow Everything extension
I know about PDS2 which is why I specifically bring up the example of Teller. They literally use mobile clients and reverse engineer banking protocols manually then expose them as APIs to their customers.

https://www.producthunt.com/posts/teller-api?comment=483805

I support teller in this endeavour.

smashah··on Facebook bans, sends C&D letter to developer of Unfollow Everything extension
How come Teller API is (apparently) 100% legal and has massive VC backing but there is possibility of legal grounds for this blatant bullying?

Just shows that tech is more scared of Facebook than massive established institutions.

smashah··on Elite MBAs are no Longer Relevant
Few years ago, when I was more in the scene, I met one of these guys and he told me he was pitching "Uber for Umbrellas" to VCs. Then I got into antler... Let's just say I've become cynical.
smashah··on Elite MBAs are no Longer Relevant
In an ideal world you're right. However, points 4 & 5 are the limiting factors.

The reason why elite MBAs make sure to ensure the success of each other is to make sure they're also given the leg up when looking for opportunities.

If a Oxbridge MBA judges a compatriot solely on merits and doesn't extend an opportunity then it cheapens their own value.

Perpetuating the privilege is the point. It's the only reason why I would do an MBA - for the blatant, proud and culturally accepted nepotistic advantage.

smashah··on Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids and democracy
WhatsApp needs to be taken away from WhatsApp. It is more important to worldwide communication than SMS
smashah··on Facebook-owned sites were down
Good, now I can go for lunch.
smashah··on EU plans to force OEMs to use a common charger for all phones
This concern does not translate well to anybody wanting to switch platforms. This level of sunk cost fallacy would not fly as an excuse for any other technology, let alone on HN.
smashah··on Three ex-US intelligence officers admit hacking for UAE
While being federal agents they try to spread democracy with bombs. Once they leave, the pretence is dropped and squash any organic calls for democracy and dissent with hacking.

Outraged when these countries are hacking individuals? Then also be outraged when you sell them F35s

smashah··on Apple blocked the FlickType Watch keyboard then announced a clone of it
You think they lowballed him?
smashah··on A cross-platform GUI for YouTube-dl
This would require some sort of open-api type spec but for CLIs. I like this idea. Good luck to anyone taking it up.
smashah··on Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighborhoods
One day an intergalactic 5th dimension demon investor will buy earth and rent it back to us for 1 Billion souls per year. What madness.
smashah··on Launch HN: Evidence (YC S21) – Web framework for data analysts
Wow that's cool. Now of I can create these snippets to output as SVG then I can add it to my GitHub readme!
smashah··on Miller CLI – Like Awk, sed, cut, join, and sort for CSV, TSV and JSON
Nice. Any reason why installation section is not prominent and on the top of the readme?

It's even in an non-intuitive place in the documentation.

smashah··on Netflix intensifies VPN ban and targets residential IP addresses
As a Brit living in the middle East for most of the year, I resolved these issues by setting up Home Assistant in my house on UK with the wireguard add-on and upping my bandwidth so my local download speed matches the UK upload speed.

This allows me to use all UK services perfectly. Including iPlayer.

Good thing about wireguard is I can use it with my android TV also, making UK media consumption a breeze.

smashah··on Yarn 3.0
Wasn't able to get over some of the decisions made on yarn 2. Hopefully yarn 3 is more compatible to a usual npm flow.
smashah··on Facebook Wanted NSO Spyware to Monitor Users, NSO CEO Claims (2020)
Recent NSO story isn't new. The leaked numbers are new.
smashah··on Huge data leak shatters the lie that the innocent need not fear surveillance
It is not equally reductive because one reduction serves to perpetuate oppression, apartheid and empowers regimes that are the architects of roadblocks to progress. And the other reduction aims to remove the obstacles to dismantling all the above.

The only way the contextualisation is relevent to the original comment is if there's some value in appending this racist myth that "if those Arabs had their say then women would be on leashes and gays would be made into smoothies on-sight". Ironically, the contextualisation is the status quo. The contextualisation is a direct result of, among other things, Israel and it's complicit export of cyber oppression weapons.

And before someone claims that this is separate from the state, just consider that the export license would not be granted for a sale which would be detrimental to Israel's interests as a state. The base deduction is that it's in the interest of the state to keep its neighbours citizens in-check and for Israel to be known worldwide to be an exporter of these exact tools.

smashah··on Huge data leak shatters the lie that the innocent need not fear surveillance
This tactic of dipping your true intentions in the aesthetics of progress is new and designed to trick people with a north-star cause to sympathize with the oppressor.

Unfortunately it only takes a few brain cycles for even the simplest of persons to realise that upholding apartheid because #girlpower is a sad stretch and a half.

It's relevant because the goal is to delegitimize criticism of apartheid and it's export of oppression to its neighbours.

There is no other point of relevance to my original comment and, in all honesty, it amounts to blatant propogandising. I'll just leave it at that.

smashah··on Huge data leak shatters the lie that the innocent need not fear surveillance
Hopefully some will ask themselves why the "beacon of democracy" in the region is so ready and open to sell tools used almost solely to prevent the spread of true democracy to their neighbours? And then maybe we should all have a long hard think about how this translates to our own disgusting arms industries as a whole.
← PreviousPage 16 of 23Next →